
For India's complex, growing economy, a lesson from China's Qing dynasty
By most staffing norms, we have an acute shortage of nurses, policemen, teachers and public development officers. The ideological belief that smaller governments are better for the growth and development of a nation stands in sharp contrast to the economic reality of market breakdowns, particularly in areas of health, education and safety. Human resource investments in areas of public health, public education and law and order are critical for long-term economic growth and improvement in basic quality of life for an average Indian.
Given the size and complexity of India, among the lessons from history, on the perils of evangelical allegiance to the ideology of a smaller government, the example of the pitiful demise of the Qing dynasty is worth recalling. In The Ideological Foundations of Qing Taxation, Taisu Zhang presents a compelling argument that the Qing dynasty's government size was notably small, primarily due to ideological constraints rather than structural limitations. Zhang posits that the Qing state's fiscal conservatism was deeply influenced by Confucian political ethics and the traumatic memory of the Ming dynasty's collapse, which was attributed to excessive taxation. This historical lesson led Qing rulers to adopt a cautious approach. Consequently, the government maintained a minimal presence in economic affairs, resulting in a grossly limited capacity to mobilise resources and people for state functions. The Qing state was small in actual personnel and ideologically committed to maintaining a light footprint. According to one estimate, the Qing state never employed more than 30,000 officials across the empire. In most counties, a magistrate and a few hundred local staff would administer populations of over 2 lakh.
When compared to other contemporary states, the Qing government was exceptionally small. Zhang highlights that while European and Japanese states had tax-to-GDP ratios ranging from 10 per cent to 20 per cent, the Qing's formal tax revenue constituted only about 1 per cent of GDP by the mid-19th century. This stark contrast underscores the Qing dynasty's limited fiscal capacity and its implications for governance and state development. The ideological commitment to small government led to institutional practices that further constrained the government's size. Zhang's analysis reveals that the Qing dynasty's small government size was not merely a result of economic or administrative limitations but was fundamentally shaped by ideological beliefs that prioritised small government and feared the social and economic consequences of fiscal expansion. This ideological framework not only defined the Qing state's fiscal policies but also had lasting effects on China's economic development trajectory for two centuries.
Within the context of India's current status, improving 'state capacity' for good governance is at the heart of most reforms — at the central as well as the state levels. The real economy of India is moving much faster than our traditional data are able to capture, hence our administrative capacity is constantly doing a catch-up. Technology is a great enabler and critical to modernisation, but not a complete substitute for human resources. There are limits, therefore, to development when merely based on technological and financial advancements. Shortage of human resources becomes a binding constraint to overall improvements in outcome. This is obvious in public health, public education and maintenance of law and order in particular – where no matter how much improvement occurs in infrastructure, budgets and technology – the feet on the ground remain a critical bottleneck. We need to recruit more people for public service in India, across different sectors and we need to do this urgently.
India is a talent-rich nation. We have to ensure that the most capable and hardworking people are brought into public service. This requires innovations in recruitment and parity with the rest of the fast-growing economy to avoid long-term distortions. Parity in terms of pay as well as performance. Most public debates are limited to the differences in the pay structure (hence, regular Pay Commission revisions, etc). The time-use survey data reveals that an average government employee works fewer hours daily and has more leisure hours than private sector employees. Keeping the government sector small and privileged has long-term economic and social costs for the nation. While we modernise the economy, we must also modernise the state – by strengthening quality as well as its numbers. This is a critical need to sustain India's growth and development today as well as to meet our aspirations for the next hundred years — as the fundamental ideological flaw of the Qing dynasty shows.
The writer is Member, EAC-PM
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


NDTV
5 minutes ago
- NDTV
PM Modi Lands In UK, Long-Awaited Free Trade Deal Expected Today: 10 Points
The free trade agreement is India's first major bilateral trade agreement with a developed economy in over a decade. A 10-point cheat sheet on the free trade agreement to be signed by India and the UK The free trade agreement between India and the UK will be signed during Prime Minister Narendra Modi's visit to London on July 24. Commerce and Industry Minister Piyush Goyal will accompany the prime minister. The two countries announced the conclusion of the negotiations for the trade agreement on May 6, after three years of negotiations. The trade agreement proposes to remove taxes on the export of labour-intensive products such as leather, footwear and clothing, while making imports of whisky and cars from Britain cheaper, in an effort to double trade between the two economies to USD 120 billion by 2030. After the free trade agreement is signed by the commerce ministers from both countries, it will require approval from the British Parliament before coming into effect, as the Indian cabinet has already given its consent to the deal. Britain is the sixth-largest investor in India with investments of around $36 billion. There are 1,000 Indian companies in the country, with 1,00,000 employees, with a total of $2 billion investment. 99% of Indian products will receive duty-free access to the UK market, covering nearly all of India's current trade value. Apart from the free trade agreement, the biggest the UK has done since leaving the European Union, the two sides also sealed a double contribution convention. It provides for exemption for employers of Indian workers from paying social security contributions in the UK. India's exports to the U.K. rose by 12.6% to $14.5 billion, while imports grew by 2.3% to $8.6 billion in 2024-25. The bilateral trade between India and the U.K. increased to $21.34 billion in 2023-24 from $20.36 billion in 2022-23. From London, PM Modi will travel to the Maldives at the invitation of President Mohamed Muizzu in what is being seen as a breakthrough in the ties between the two countries following a spell of frostiness under Mr Muizzu.


Hindustan Times
5 minutes ago
- Hindustan Times
'If someone is...': What Smriti Irani said on Bollywood's 'silence' on Op Sindoor
Former Union Minister Smriti Irani has advised people to "not watch" actors if they are offended at their "lack of support" to Operation Sindoor, India's military operation against terror infrastructure in Pakistan and POK, launched on May 7. BJP leader Smriti Irani (ANI) In a TV interview, the politician was asked about chatter around Bollywood's muffled response to the operation that India launched a fortnight after 26 civilians were killed in a deadly terrorist attack in Jammu and Kashmir's Pahalgam. 'If someone is not with the country, and their lack of support offends you, then don't watch them,' she was quoted as saying by an India Today report. 'How can you express your anger (against their silence) as an ordinary citizen? By tunning off," the publication further quoted Irani. The former MP also asserted that if an actor did not support the Army, it did not mean that no one else did. She said the entire country stood with its forces. She also said that India no longer waits for an actor to break silence on an issue and say 'Bharat Mata ki Jai'. "The country has been made aware of these realities," she asserted. Her interview came ahead of her return to television screens again after years in the reboot of popular show 'Kyunki Saas Bhi Kabhi Bahu Thi', in which she will be playing the character of Tulsi Virani. Smriti Irani's remarks came over two months after India and Pakistan got engaged in a military conflict, triggered by Pakistan's targeting of air bases in India. The Indian armed forces said that Pakistan incurred heavy losses, with significant damage to its military infrastructure, including land and air assets. While some actors did heap praise on Operation Sindoor, there was chatter online that Bollywood remained largely silent on the issue, or gave a delayed reaction.


Time of India
24 minutes ago
- Time of India
UNGA list of speakers suggests Modi might be visiting US in September
PM Modi (File Photo) NEW DELHI: PM Narendra Modi has been listed as one of the speakers at the upcoming UNGA session, suggesting that he might visit the US in Sept. According to the GA-80th session general debate provisional list of speakers, the Indian head of govt is slated to address the assembly on Sept 26. While names of speakers are inscribed after consultations with the country concerned, the leaders retain the option of withdrawing at a later date and nominating someone else to deliver the national statement. External affairs minister S Jaishankar had addressed the 79th UNGA general debate last year. Modi also travelled to the UN last year and addressed the GA's Summit of the Future. In the recent past, he has addressed the general debate in 2019, 2020 and 2021. Modi has a busy schedule in the next few months, with visits to China and Japan coming up late next month and early Sept. He is also expected to host Russian President Vladimir Putin this year for the annual summit and Quad leaders in Nov. As of now though, no incoming or outgoing meeting is scheduled in late Sept.