logo
Podcast: In Amrita Shah's book about the voyages of one family, a tale of migrating Indians

Podcast: In Amrita Shah's book about the voyages of one family, a tale of migrating Indians

Scroll.in02-05-2025
Across the Indian Ocean are traces of a million voyages. Starting at the dawn of civilisation, traders in Mesopotamia and India began navigating its coasts. Empires transported commodities, slaves, and – during the British Empire – indentured servants. And, at the height of Pax Britannica, a certain Mohandas Karamchand Gandhi launched his political career with a fateful voyage to South Africa.
In The Other Mohan in Britain's Indian Ocean Empire, Amrita Shah investigates the voyages of one of Gandhi's contemporaries: her great-grandfather, Mohanlal Killavala. In this episode of Past Imperfect, Shah explains how Indian Ocean travels left an indelible mark not only on her family, but also upon so many broader aspects of India and the Indian diaspora. She presents us with an account of the diaspora which is sometimes surprising, and sometimes unsettling.
Shah began her research many years ago with a handful of family stories. Her great-grandfather, an educated and Anglicised Gujarati from Bombay, had migrated to South Africa. Here, he joined Gandhi's satyagraha activities before returning to Bombay and living out the rest of his life in India. But Shah knew that there were layers of this story that remained unexplored.
Killavala left Bombay after marrying a Gujarati woman – yet he married again on his travels, and this union led to the birth of Shah's grandmother in South Africa. Who was Killavala's second wife? Where did they meet? How did all of this change her family's story?
Looking for answers, Shah plumbs Gujarat's centuries-long association with the sea. The Killavala family settled in Surat while it was the dazzling epicenter of Mughal oceanic commerce, a place where merchants from across Europe, the Middle East, and East Africa mingled, haggled, and became extraordinarily rich. Appropriately enough, the Killavalas lived in the Surat precinct of Nanavat, which means 'dealing with money'.
Surat's fortunes declined sharply as the Mughal Empire disintegrated. The Killavalas joined thousands of other Gujaratis in migrating to a new hub of global trade: Bombay. Bombay's imperial connections facilitated even lengthier migrations of Gujaratis to unfamiliar places like Mauritius, Durban, and Cape Town. As an educated man fond of wearing western suits and eating English porridge, Mohanlal Killavala stood apart from most of these migrants, who were escaping desperate poverty. So why did he go?
Shah looks for answers in archives in Mauritius and across South Africa but encounters new questions. Learning that her great-grandmother was from Mauritius, she wonders whether she might have been Creole, of part-African descent. Many Gujarati merchants on the island married Creole women, and some of them even took these wives back to Gujarat.
Another lingering question involves Killavala's participation in Gandhi's satyagraha against the 1906 Registration Act, where the government of Transvaal, in an attempt to stymie Indian immigration, forced all Indian settlers to carry identity passes. By this time, Killavala seemed to have established himself as a respectable member of the Indian community in Natal. He worked for a white lawyer, served as an interpreter of Indian languages at the courts, and had a wife and young daughter in tow. What convinced him to travel to another territory and court arrest?
An archival find in Pretoria adds a new twist.
Here, Shah discovers that Killavala might have been a 'permit agent,' someone involved in both legal and illegal immigration networks between India and South Africa. Then, like now, illegal immigration was a hot-button political issue, adding fuel to the fire of white antipathy towards Indian settlers.
For Shah, the archival find provides possible answers to so many of her questions. Perhaps Killavala set out for South Africa through a professional network for facilitating illegal immigration. And perhaps he joined Gandhi's satyagraha for the purpose of acquiring passes – valuable sheets of paper that could smooth the way for new migrants.
Shah never finds definitive answers. But along the way, she paints a vivid portrait of a diaspora, demonstrating how travel abroad both reinforced prejudices and weakened racial boundaries. Traveling through contemporary Mauritius and South Africa, she encounters so many reminders of India – and some now slightly less faint traces of her own ancestors.
Dinyar Patel is an assistant professor of history at the SP Jain Institute of Management and Researchin Mumbai. His award-winning biography of Dadabhai Naoroji, Naoroji: Pioneer of Indian Nationalism, was published by Harvard University Press in May 2020.
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Climbers aim for Mt Samgyal, Mt Dawa & Mt Meru's untouched path
Climbers aim for Mt Samgyal, Mt Dawa & Mt Meru's untouched path

Time of India

timean hour ago

  • Time of India

Climbers aim for Mt Samgyal, Mt Dawa & Mt Meru's untouched path

Pune: A team of mountaineers from the city is preparing for two daring expeditions in the Himalayas in August—one to the twin peaks of Mount Samgyal (5,814 m) and Mount Dawa (5,900 m) in Ladakh's Nubra Valley, and the other to Mount Meru (6,310 m), one of India's most technically challenging peaks located in the Gangotri Glacier region. Led by Everest summiteer Krishna Dhokale, the Mount Samgyal and Mount Dawa expedition comprises a group of young climbers who will climb without Sherpa assistance beyond base camp. The team will carry out all logistical responsibilities, including ferrying loads, fixing routes, and making summit decisions independently. Supported by veteran Everest climbers Ganesh More and Ashish Mane, this expedition is designed to develop leadership, endurance, and alpine self-sufficiency among India's new generation of mountaineers. Simultaneously, a separate group of experienced climbers will attempt an unprecedented ascent of Mount Meru via the East Ridge, a route that has never been successfully climbed. Both expeditions are being organised by Giripremi mountaineering club. You Can Also Check: Pune AQI | Weather in Pune | Bank Holidays in Pune | Public Holidays in Pune The flag-off ceremony for both expeditions was held this evening at New English School, Tilak Road on Friday. The ceremonial flags were presented to the teams by Sheetal Teli-Ugale, Commissioner, Maharashtra Sports and Youth Services Department. The Mount Samgyal and Mount Dawa expedition will be led by Everest summiteer Mr Krishna Dhokale, with guidance and support from experienced climbers Ganesh More and Ashish Mane, also Everest summiteers from Giripremi. Simultaneously, Umesh Zirpe of Giripremi will lead the expedition to Mount Meru in the Gangotri Glacier region. This attempt will be made via the extremely challenging East Ridge, a route that has never been climbed before. Zirpe said, "Mount Meru, located in the Garhwal Himalayas, is considered one of the most sacred and technically difficult peaks in India, frequently mentioned in ancient Indian scriptures. The East Ridge ascent demands extreme high-altitude rock climbing, negotiating falling rocks, vertical cliffs, deep gorges, and a treacherous approach to base camp. The Indian Army has also taken special note of this challenging endeavour. "

New Zealand kayakers steal the show at 11th edition of Malabar River Festival finale
New Zealand kayakers steal the show at 11th edition of Malabar River Festival finale

The Hindu

time3 hours ago

  • The Hindu

New Zealand kayakers steal the show at 11th edition of Malabar River Festival finale

Two New Zealanders grabbed the titles of 'Rapid Raja' and 'Rapid Rani' at the 11th edition of the Malabar River Festival, which concluded at Elanthukkadavu near Pulloorampara on Sunday (July 27, 2025). Ryan O'Conner and Rata Lowell-Smith recorded the best times in their respective categories in the Downriver Race, the final event of the festival, which was shifted to Pulikkayam due to high water levels in the Iruvazhinjipuzha at Pulloorampara, where it was originally scheduled to be held. Kilian Ivelic of Chile and Arjun Singh Rawat of Uttarakhand secured the second and third positions in the men's category, while Millie Chamberlain and Dayla Ward, both from New Zealand, finished second and third in the women's category. The top three finishers in both categories were awarded prize money of ₹1.2 lakh, ₹60,000, and ₹30,000, respectively. Among the Indian kayakers, Arjun Singh Rawat secured the top position, followed by Amar Singh Ankit and Kuldeep Singh in second and third place, respectively. Meanwhile, Akshay Ashok, Adam Mathew Sibi, Nikhil Das, Sudhakar Jena, Ryan Varghese, Dona Marcella, and E. Swaliha were selected as the best kayakers from Kerala and awarded ₹10,000 each. Anak, Adam Mathew Sibi, and Karishma Diwan received special awards for being the best kayakers in the under-18 category. Minister for Tourism P.A. Mohamed Riyas gave away the prizes to the winners at the valedictory event held at Elanthukkadavu on Sunday evening. 'Malabar River Festival is garnering international attention and is being considered one of the five biggest kayaking festivals in the world,' he said, adding that the tourism sector in Kerala is evolving with the times and adopting newer trends that the rest of the world could follow. Linto Joseph, MLA, presided over the valedictory function, while Tourism Director Shikha Surendran, Joint Director D. Gireesh Kumar, Chief Executive Officer of the Kerala Adventure Tourism Promotion Society (KATPS) Binu Kuriakose, representatives of the Indian Kayaking and Canoeing Association (IKCA), and presidents of various upland grama panchayats in Kozhikode were present. The festival was organised by the KATPS and the Kozhikode District Tourism Promotion Council, under the aegis of the Department of Tourism and with technical support from the IKCA.

Maratha forts, Khudiram Bose & Shubhanshu Shukla—highlights of PM Modi's latest ‘Mann ki Baat'
Maratha forts, Khudiram Bose & Shubhanshu Shukla—highlights of PM Modi's latest ‘Mann ki Baat'

The Print

time7 hours ago

  • The Print

Maratha forts, Khudiram Bose & Shubhanshu Shukla—highlights of PM Modi's latest ‘Mann ki Baat'

'Eleven forts in Maharashtra; one in Tamil Nadu. Each fort has a chapter of history attached to it. Every stone is a testimony to a historical event,' Prime Minister Modi asserted as he took listeners on a journey through India's rich cultural, historical, and ecological heritage. The forts, spread across Maharashtra and Tamil Nadu, collectively, can now be called 'Maratha Military Landscapes of India', as named by the Indian government in the nomination dossier submitted to UNESCO for World Heritage status in 2024-25. New Delhi: Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Sunday highlighted the recognition of 12 Maratha forts collectively as a UNESCO World Heritage Site in his address for the 124th edition of his radio programme, 'Mann Ki Baat'. His 'Mann Ki Baat' address highlighted several of India's recent achievements and milestones—from Shubhanshu Shukla's space mission to rare bird surveys. Besides, Prime Minister Modi also dived into the excitement surrounding the upcoming festive season. The UNESCO recognition, which came at the 47th Session of the World Heritage Committee held in Paris, made the 'Maratha Military Landscapes of India' the country's 44th property to receive such global recognition. The twelve forts included in the UNESCO listing are Salher, Shivneri, Lohagad, Khanderi, Raigad, Rajgad, Pratapgad, Suvarnadurg, Panhala, Vijaydurg, and Sindhudurg—all in Maharashtra—and Gingee in Tamil Nadu. Prime Minister Modi encouraged citizens to visit the historic forts and learn more about India's rich past. 'These forts are not just bricks and stones; they are symbols of our rich heritage. Values and self-respect still echo from the high walls of these forts. I urge the citizens to visit them, learn about their history, and take pride in it,' he added. Month of revolution Reflecting on the significance of the upcoming month in India's freedom struggle in his 'Mann Ki Baat' address, Prime Minister Narendra Modi reminded listeners that August is a month of sacrifice and revolution, leading to Independence. Modi highlighted freedom fighters, such as Khudiram Bose and the countless unnamed heroes, who laid down their lives for the nation. Paying tribute to Khudiram Bose—in particular—the Prime Minister said, 'Let us not merely remember them in textbooks, but live by their ideals.' Khudiram Bose was sentenced to death at the age of 18 during British rule over the Muzaffarpur Conspiracy Case—an attempted assassination of a British judge The Prime Minister also called on citizens to keep the legacy of Indian revolutionaries alive through acts of service, civic responsibility, and unwavering patriotism. 'When Khudiram Bose walked towards the gallows, there was a smile on his face,' he recalled during his 'Mann ki Baat' address. 'After such countless sacrifices, after centuries of penance, we attained Independence. The country's die-hard patriots nurtured the freedom movement with their blood.' Prime Minister Modi also reminded listeners of 7 August, the day the Swadeshi Movement began in 1905, breathing new life into the Indian handloom industry. Now celebrated as the 'National Handloom Day', 7 August inspired success stories in the handloom sector from Maharashtra to Bihar and Odisha, the Prime Minister stated. 'Just like Khadi strengthened the freedom movement, today our textile sector is a pillar of progress,' he added. Also Read: 'Mann Ki Baat' is the 'Mann Ki Baat' of millions of Indians: PM Modi in 100th episode Homecoming of Shubhanshu Shukla The 124th edition of 'Mann Ki Baat' started with Prime Minister Modi's celebration of the return of astronaut Shubhanshu Shukla—a proud moment for the nation as Shukla became the second Indian after Rakesh Sharma to go to space and the first Indian to board the International Space Station (ISS). Prime Minister Modi recalled how the country came together to honour the historic achievement, marking a significant milestone in the Indian space journey. He also recalled the successful landing of Chandrayaan-3 in August 2023, calling it another defining moment, which will inspire the youth and ignite a passion for space and science across the country.'The recent years have witnessed a surge in interest towards space, science, and innovation,' the Prime Minister added. Shubhanshu Shukla's participation in the Axiom 4 Mission made history at a time when the Indian space start-up ecosystem is growing rapidly—a fact the PM mentioned in his address. 'Just five years ago, the country had fewer than 50 companies in this sector. Today, that number has grown to over 200 space-focused start-ups, driving technological advancements, creating employment, and propelling India's ambitions in global space exploration,' he said. First-ever grassland bird census During his 'Mann ki Baat', Prime Minister Narendra Modi also turned his focus to wildlife and conservation at one time. He highlighted a groundbreaking initiative from Kaziranga National Park in Assam, which, for the first time, saw a dedicated Grassland Bird Census. The survey focused specifically on bird species that depend on Kaziranga's unique grassland ecosystem. 'This is a significant milestone in our conservation efforts,' PM Modi said. The survey, a collaboration among forest officials, scientists, and bird watchers, has deepened the understanding of grassland bird biodiversity in Kaziranga. In the census, more than 40 bird species, including several rare ones, were identified. Prime Minister Modi explained that the identification process became possible through a combination of expert knowledge and modern technology. The team installed sound recording devices in the fields, and the recorded bird calls were later analysed using Artificial Intelligence, allowing researchers to identify the bird species without disturbing them. 'When technology and sensitivity come together, understanding nature becomes so easy and deep,' he said. The Prime Minister also encouraged young naturalists and researchers to participate in such initiatives, emphasising the critical role of protecting and celebrating the country's rich biodiversity. (Edited by Madhurita Goswami) Also Read: Nelson Mandela was influenced by Gandhi. And was aware non-violence strategy had to evolve

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store