Criminal Cases Review Commission boss steps down in wake of Andrew Malkinson case
Karen Kneller's resignation from the Criminal Cases Review Commission (CCRC) comes after former chairwoman Helen Pitcher stepped down in January, claiming she had been scapegoated over Mr Malkinson 's case.
He was wrongly convicted of rape and spent 17 years in jail in one of the worst miscarriages of justice in British legal history.
Last month, former victims Commissioner Dame Vera Baird became the interim chairwoman of the CCRC, having been asked by the Lord Chancellor to carry out a review of the organisation.
She said: "The CCRC has a vital role to play in the criminal justice system, but confidence in the organisation has been badly damaged. Confidence in our work must be restored.
"I thank Karen for her work at the CCRC over many years."
Amanda Pearce, who is CCRC casework operations director, has been appointed interim chief executive, a position that had been held by Ms Kneller since 2013.
The CCRC - an independent public body that reviews possible miscarriages of justice in the criminal courts of England, Wales and Northern Ireland and refers cases to the appeal courts - has had four critical reviews in the last 10 years.
Mr Malkinson was knocked back twice by the CCRC until his legal team carried out crucial DNA testing that was then repeated by the commission and led to his release.
A review found that he could have been released 10 years earlier if the CCRC had obtained new DNA evidence as early as 2009, and thousands of cases are being reviewed in the wake of the bungled handling of the case.
In May, the Commons Justice Committee also warned that the position of chief executive Ms Kneller was no longer tenable.
MPs said in a report that it followed "unpersuasive" evidence from her on the CCRC's challenges and response to public criticisms in April, and concerns on the performance of the review body.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
24 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Harvey Willgoose's best friend told police after schoolboy's death that his killer, 15, was 'always carrying a weapon' - including 'a little axe and knives', court told
The best friend of a pupil fatally stabbed in school claimed his killer was 'always carrying weapons' hidden in his trousers, including an axe, a court has heard. Harvey Willgoose, 15, suffered fatal injuries when another pupil stabbed him on their lunch break at All Saints Catholic High School in Sheffield on February 3. The teenage attacker, who cannot be named for legal reasons, has pleaded guilty to Harvey's manslaughter by reason of loss of control, but is facing trial at Sheffield Crown Court accused of murder. A boy who was best friends with the Sheffield United fan said that the defendant once told him to feel the outline of something in his trousers - where he found an axe concealed. The jury previously heard that the defendant's mother had contacted the school in December 2024 because she found an axe in his gym bag. The incident was reported to police. In a recorded police interview that was played to the jury today, the boy was asked about the defendant's history of carrying knives. 'I have known since he joined the school he used to carry them a lot,' he said. 'He carried a little axe, he carried knives - different types of knives. 'He would either show me or tell me to feel the outside of his trousers and there would be an imprint of the top of an axe or something. It was a few months ago.' But he admitted he had never actually seen the defendant carrying a knife before. The boy was in school on the day of the attack and recalled how he and other pupils barricaded themselves in a storage cupboard after a panicked student told them: 'Someone's been stabbed, there's blood all over.' It came less than an hour after Harvey and the defendant had squared up to each other in a science class which was also attended by the friend. The boy said he was in detention over lunch when a girl ran into the room to tell them that there had been a stabbing. 'I didn't even need her to say who it was, because [the defendant] was always carrying a weapon and Harvey was having a bit of an argument with him,' he said. The boy, who was 14 at the time, added: 'We ran into a storage cupboard in the detention hall so we were safe, locked ourselves in and barricaded the door.' He said he had spent quite a bit of the morning with Harvey that day, having been dropped off at his house so they could travel to school together. Hear developments from the trial of the boy accused of killing Harvey Willgoose on the Mail's award-winning The Trial podcast The boy was also present at the first school break when Harvey and the defendant began to push each other, but he said that it had seemed friendly and assumed it was 'banter'. Harvey and the defendant fell out on social media over the weekend before the attack, after Harvey supported a boy with whom the defendant had a disagreement the week before, the court previously heard. The disagreement had seen the school placed into lockdown and the police called, because the defendant claimed he had seen the other boy carrying a knife. But the witness said Harvey and the defendant that had previously been friends with no history of animosity. Recalling the science lesson where Harvey and the defendant squared up just minutes before the fatal attack, he said: 'Harvey walked into the lesson, sat down for a bit and [the defendant] walked in as Harvey was walking out to go on a time out and they squared up to each other. 'I sat near [the defendant] and said to him 'what's happened?' and he said 'it was just a bit of beef'.' The defendant is expected to argue that his actions were manslaughter due to a loss of control which was the 'end result of a long period of bullying'. The trial was previously shown shocking CCTV of the fatal attack on Harvey, which saw the two boys squaring up, before the defendant produced a knife and lunged at him, twice. Harvey quickly backed away and collapsed just 49 seconds later, the court previously heard. He died from a stab wound to the heart. The trial continues.
BBC News
28 minutes ago
- BBC News
Grandmother accused of toddler's murder regrets not doing more
The grandmother of a two-year-old boy who died from a severe head injury regrets every day not doing more for the "babby", a court has Ives-Griffiths collapsed at his grandparents' home in Garden City, Flintshire, in 2021 and later died from a serious head Ives, 47, and Kerry Ives, 46, deny his murder. They, along with their daughter Shannon Ives, 28, from Mold, also deny causing or allowing his death, and child evidence at Mold Crown Court on Friday, Kerry Ives said she had not previously spoken about Ethan's collapse because she "didn't want anyone to get in trouble". She was asked by prosecution barrister Caroline Rees if she regretted that she and Shannon did nothing to protect Ethan from Michael, and replied: "Every day", adding: "I regret I didn't do more for the babby".On Wednesday, Mrs Ives denied that either she or her husband hit Ethan, but said her daughter "used to smack his hand and smack his bum", and she had seen her "hit him up the back of the head"."If he'd laugh at her, she'd lose her temper," she described Ethan as a "chubby and "bubbly little child" who acted differently when his mum was around, "biting his lip" until it bled or shoving food into his mouth until he choked. On Friday, Mrs Ives was being cross-examined by the prosecution barrister Ms Rees about her failure to act after Ethan had a brief collapse on Friday 13 August - the day before his fatal Ives said she had not witnessed the incident herself but was told about it by her husband Michael and daughter Shannon, and was reassured Ethan had come told the court that had she been awake at the time, she would have suggested calling an asked why she did not tell anyone outside the family what had happened, she said: "I didn't want to get anyone in trouble."Ms Rees challenged her: "Why were Michael and Shannon more important than little Ethan?""They wasn't," she replied. Mrs Ives said Shannon had hit Ethan on 14 August but claimed the toddler "never cried or whinged".Ms Rees suggested Ethan had "learned not to" because "bad things were always happening to poor Ethan all the time".Mrs Ives denied being asked by Michael to keep quiet about the assault, but admitted she waited 18 minutes before calling an ambulance on 14 August because she had "panicked".Ms Rees asked her: "Were you hoping he'd come round like he did on Friday. Nobody would need to know?"Kerry Ives said "No".The trial continues.
The Independent
33 minutes ago
- The Independent
William and Kate to join King and Queen for Macron's Windsor carriage ride
The Prince and Princess of Wales are to join the King and Queen and their guests French president Emmanuel Macron and his wife Brigitte for a carriage ride through Windsor next week. Kate, who has opened up about her 'rollercoaster' cancer recovery, its life-changing impact and putting on a 'brave face', will carry out royal duties as part of the French leader's state visit on Tuesday. Kensington Palace has yet to confirm whether or not the princess will attend the banquet in Windsor Castle's St George's Hall in the evening. The princess, who was diagnosed with cancer in 2024 and confirmed she was free from the disease at the start of this year, last made an appearance at a grand royal dinner 20 months ago in November 2023 in honour of the South Korean president. Mr Macron's state visit to the UK, from July 8-10, is the first to be hosted at Windsor Castle, rather than Buckingham Palace, in a more than a decade since that of the Irish president Michael D Higgins in 2014. In a personal touch, the King and Queen will, on Wednesday, take the Macrons to see Fabuleu de Maucour, a 10-year-old grey gelding which Mr Macron gifted to known horse-lover the late Queen Elizabeth II in 2022 in celebration of her Platinum Jubilee. Fabuleu de Maucour belonged to the largely ceremonial French Republican Guard and was trained to carry the standard-bearer. They will also view an elegant Charabanc carriage from the Royal Mews, which was a present to Queen Victoria from King Louis-Philippe of France in 1844. And the Macrons will privately pay their respects at the late Queen's tomb in St George's Chapel by laying flowers in tribute. Charles, Ranger of Windsor Great Park, will also invite the president to tour the Windsor Castle Gardens, including areas of nature restoration and biodiversity and the wider Great Park. State visits, which capitalise on the royals' soft power to strengthen diplomatic ties overseas, have moved from Buckingham Palace to Windsor for the next few years while reservicing work continues at the London royal residence and starts to affect the state rooms. The arrangements are likely to form the template for US president Donald Trump's high-profile state visit in September, but much will depend on security considerations for the US leader, who survived an assassination attempt last year. William and Kate will meet Mr and Mrs Macron at RAF Northolt on Tuesday morning on behalf of the King and travel with them to Windsor. Charles and Camilla will formerly greet their guests on a Royal Dais constructed on Datchet Road in Windsor town centre, with the castle in the backdrop as gun salutes sound in nearby Home Park. The King, the Queen, the Waleses and Mr and Mrs Macron will then take a carriage procession through the Berkshire town and along part of the Long Walk which leads to the castle, just like President Sarkozy did. A ceremonial welcome will be staged in the castle's quadrangle with Camilla, William, Kate and Mrs Macron watching as the King and Mr Macron inspect the Guard of Honour. Lunch will be hosted in the State Dining Room, after which the president and his wife, the King and Queen and members of the royal family will view a special exhibition of items relating to France from the Royal Collection in the Green Drawing Room. Mr and Mrs Macron will also travel to London on Tuesday afternoon to see the Grave of the Unknown Warrior at Westminster Abbey, visit the Palace of Westminster where the French leader will address parliamentarians in the Royal Gallery, and meet opposition leaders at Lancaster House. The King and president will both deliver speeches at the banquet on Tuesday evening. Wednesday will see the president and Mrs Macron join Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer and Lady Starmer for lunch at Downing Street, ahead of a UK-France summit at Number 10 on Thursday. The King and Queen paid a state visit to France in September 2023 and enjoy a warm rapport with Mr and Mrs Macron, who will stay in the castle during their trip. The last state visit to the UK from France was in March 2008 when the now-disgraced president Nicolas Sarkozy, since convicted of corruption and influence peddling, and his wife Carla Bruni, were the guests of Elizabeth II at Windsor. The King, who is still being treated for cancer, has had a busy recent run of engagements, carrying out a host of visits in Scotland for Royal Week. Kate, who spoke about the challenges of her recovery during a visit to the RHS's Wellbeing Garden at Colchester Hospital on Wednesday, took part in the Qatari state visit last December, accompanying the Emir to Horse Guards Parade with William, attending the ceremonial welcome, the lunch and the Picture Gallery exhibition.
