New report flags unusually high acquittal rates in Orleans Parish judge trials
According to the report, judges Nandi Campbell and Leon Roche not only presided over more judge only trials than any other judges in the parish, they also issued not-guilty verdicts at dramatically higher rates.
Slidell man arrested following house search, drug bust
From 2021 to 2023, 123 bench trials were held in the court. Campbell and Roche handled more than half, 51% of them.
Judge Campbell acquitted defendants in 79 percent of her judge trials.
In violent felony cases, that number climbed to 91%. That's 21 acquittals out of 23 trials.
Judge Roche, in his first full year on the bench, acquitted defendants in 88 percent of his judge trials.
Judge Roche, who began serving a full term in 2023, acquitted defendants in 88% of his judge trials in his first full year on the bench.
'These cases indicate that there is a strategic advantage for defendants to waive a jury before these two judges,' said Rafael Goyeneche, president of the Metropolitan Crime Commission. 'And these two judges should not be outliers to this extent.'
Suspect wanted in connection with Algiers shooting in custody following Terrytown standoff
For comparison, Orleans Parish juries returned not guilty verdicts just 43% of the time during the same period.
Louisiana law currently gives only defendants the right to waive a jury trial, a power not shared by prosecutors. That's something the MCC wants to change. The group is proposing a legal amendment that would require both the prosecution and defense to agree to a bench trial, mirroring the approach in federal court and 31 other states.
'Most judges have two or three judge trials a year. That's a busy year for most of the court,' Goyeneche said. 'These judges are doing 15-plus judge trials per year, and their acquittal rates are well outside the norms of juries and the other 10 judges of the court.'
While the MCC isn't accusing judges Campbell or Roche of wrongdoing, the report suggests their high acquittal rates may be symptomatic of a larger issue in the judicial system, one that may warrant further oversight or reform.Brennan Stuprich could shatter several Southeastern records in Southland Tournament opener
Calloway calls UNO baseball 'probably the most dangerous' No. 8 seed ever in Southland Tournament
Shreveport's Stage Center brings 'Mean Girls Jr.' to the stage
Golf legend's private jet makes emergency landing at LAX
Sheinbaum questions why US allowed in 17 relatives of 'El Chapo'
Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
3 days ago
- Yahoo
Rosie Roche: Cause of Death Revealed for Prince Harry, William Cousin
Originally appeared on E! Online More details have come to light surrounding 's untimely death. Just over a week after the granddaughter of 's uncle, who is also a cousin of and , died at her Norton home at 20 years old, a coroner confirmed to The Independent that the cause of death was a 'traumatic head injury.' As revealed during an inquest into Roche's death held on July 21 at Wiltshire and Swindon coroner's court, per The Times, the college student was found at the property by her mother and sister after she had been packing her bags to go away with friends. According to the outlet, a firearm was also found nearby. Area coroner Grant Davies added at the time, per The Times, that police 'have deemed the death as non-suspicious' and that 'there was no third-party involvement.' E! News has reached out to local police, the royal family and the coroner's office for comment but has not heard back. More from E! Online Sharon Osbourne Reacts to Ozzy Osbourne Tribute After His Death Dylan Mortensen Confronts "Hollow Vessel" Bryan Kohberger at Idaho Murder Sentencing Chad Michael Murray's Kids Make Red Carpet Debut in Rare Family Photo With Wife Sarah Roemer The case has reportedly been adjourned until October 25. 'This relates to the sudden death of a woman in her 20s,' Wilshire police told the outlet. 'There are no suspicious circumstances and our thoughts are with her family.' 'We would ask,' authorities continued, 'that their privacy is respected at this terrible time.' The news surrounding Roche's passing broke two days prior to the inquest when The Yorkshire Post announced in a notice that 'Roche, Rosie Jeanne Burke died on Monday 14th July 2025.' 'Darling daughter of Hugh and Pippa,' the obituary read, 'incredible sister to Archie and Agatha, Granddaughter to Derek and Rae Long.' The announcement also noted that a private family funeral and memorial service would be held at a later date. Roche was a first-year student studying English literature at Durham University, per The Times, and following her passing, the principal of the school's University College Wendy Powers shared that staff and students alike were 'extremely saddened' by her sudden passing. 'Rosie had settled into the university and college beautifully and had lots of friends,' she told the outlet. 'She was loved for her creativity, energy, her love of books, poetry and travel among many other talents. She will be sorely missed.' Before going to university, Roche had attended St Mary's Calne, a girls' independent boarding and day school in Wiltshire. 'Rosie was a cherished member of our community,' the school wrote in a statement, per The Times, 'and she will be remembered with great affection by all who had the privilege of knowing her.' 'When we return for the new term,' the statement continued, 'we will hold a time of reflection in her memory to honour her life and the wonderful impact she had on those around her.' For more updates on the royal family, keep reading. Queen Camilla Makes History with New Royal TitleKate Middleton Pulls Out of Royal AscotPrince Harry Loses Appeal to Dismiss Decision in His Security Protection CasePrince Harry and King Charles III Are Not SpeakingKing Charles III Shares Insight Into His Cancer DiagnosisPrince William and Kate Middleton's Family Skips Royal Family's Easter ServiceRoyal Aide Who Accused Meghan Markle Of Bullying Receives a PromotionPrince George Makes His First Public Appearance of 2025Former Bodyguard to Prince Harry and Prince William DiesThe Duke and Duchess of Westminster Expecting Their First BabyLuxembourg's Prince Fredrik Dies at 22Prince Harry Reaches Settlement in U.K. Tabloids LawsuitKate Middleton Is in Remission After Finishing Chemotherapy for CancerMeghan Markle's Longtime Dog Guy DiesPrince William Mourns Death of Former Nanny's StepsonMeghan Markle Rejoins Instagram to Reveal New Netflix Show For the latest breaking news updates, click here to download the E! News App
Yahoo
4 days ago
- Yahoo
What to Know About Prince William and Prince Harry's Cousin Rosie Roche, Who Was Found Dead with Gun Nearby
Prince William and Prince Harry's cousin Rosie Roche was a 20-year-old student when she died on July 14 Rosie Roche, who was a cousin of Prince William and Prince Harry, tragically died on July 14. She was 20 years old. Roche died at her family's home in Norton, Wiltshire, with a firearm allegedly close by inside the property. One week after her death, the Wiltshire and Swindon coroner determined that her cause of death was a "traumatic head injury," per the autopsy reviewed by The Independent. Roche was a student at Durham University in England and was studying English literature. She was connected to the royal family through her grandfather, Edmund Roche, 5th Baron Fermoy, who was Princess Diana's uncle. The royal family has not publicly commented on her death. Here's everything to know about Prince William and Prince Harry's late cousin, Rosie Roche, and her sudden death. She was Prince William and Prince Harry's cousin Rosie Jeanne Burke Roche, born on June 21, 2005, was Prince William and Prince Harry's cousin. She was the granddaughter of Princess Diana's uncle Edmund Roche, 5th Baron Fermoy, who died in 1984 of a self-inflicted gunshot wound, per The New York Times. Roche's grandfather had four children, including her father, the Honourable Edmund Hugh Burke Roche. He married Phillipa Katie Victoria Long in 2004, and they welcomed three children. Roche was the oldest of the kids and had siblings Archie (born in 2007) and Agatha (born in 2009). In an obituary published by the Yorkshire Post on July 19, Roche was described as a "darling daughter of Hugh and Pippa, incredible sister to Archie and Agatha, Granddaughter to Derek and Rae Long." The statement added that there would be a "private family funeral" planned later. The British royal family did not immediately issue an official statement, nor have Prince William or Prince Harry publicly spoken out about their cousin's death. She died from a 'traumatic head injury' Roche's official cause of death was listed as a "traumatic head injury," the Wiltshire and Swindon coroner told several outlets, including The Independent and Gazette and Herald. A spokesperson for Coroner Grant Davies said that authorities investigated the death and "have deemed the death as non-suspicious and there was no third-party involvement," per The Sun. The police also clarified that "there are no suspicious circumstances" surrounding the death, per The Independent. They added, 'Our thoughts are with her family. We would ask that their privacy is respected at this terrible time.' Roche's mother and sister reportedly found her deceased at their home in Norton, Wiltshire, on July 14. The two allegedly checked in on her after she began packing for a vacation with her friends. A spokesperson for the coroner's office confirmed to the Gazette and Herald that a "firearm was located nearby." She was studying English literature at Durham University At the time of her death, Roche was studying English literature at Durham University in Durham, England. Professor Wendy Powers, the Principal of Durham's University College, said in a statement after Roche's death, per The Independent, "Rosie had settled into the University and College beautifully and had lots of friends." She was known for her 'creativity' and 'energy' After Roche's tragic death, Professor Powers reflected on her impact at Durham University and how she will be remembered. "University College staff and students are extremely saddened by the tragic death of Rosie Roche," Powers said in a statement, obtained by The Independent. 'She was loved for her creativity, energy, her love of books, poetry and travel among many other talents. She will be sorely missed." Powers added in her statement that she was sending "thoughts and condolences" to the Roche family and her friends. "We are offering support to those affected at this extremely difficult time," she concluded. If you or someone you know is considering suicide, please contact the National Suicide Prevention Lifeline at 1-800-273-TALK (8255), text "STRENGTH" to the Crisis Text Line at 741-741 or go to Read the original article on People Solve the daily Crossword
Yahoo
5 days ago
- Yahoo
Prince William's Cousin Found Dead With Gun Nearby
Rosie Roche was a cousin of Prince William and Prince Harry on their mother's side. The 20-year-old cousin was the granddaughter of Princess Diana's uncle. She was found dead at the family home on July 14, according to the Sun, and a firearm was nearby. Now an inquest is being conducted. According to the Sun, the coroner, Grant Davies, said that police "have deemed the death as non-suspicious and there was no third-party involvement." Roche's mother and sister found her, the publication noted. It's the second tragedy to strike the extended family of the princes since 2024. Thomas Kingston, the husband of their cousin Lady Gabrielle Kingston, died by suicide at the age of 45 in February 2024, according to People. His parents "made an emotional plea to raise awareness of the potential side effects of antidepressants," People reported after that death. Roche was in college; according to the Mirror, she was studying English literature at Durham University. The Mirror explained that Rosie Jeanne Burke Roche was the granddaughter of the late Edmund Roche, who was the 5th Baron Fermoy and the uncle of Princess Diana. Thus, she had "strong ties to the British aristocracy," per the Mirror. Her parents were Edmund (Hugh) Burke Roche and Pippa Long, the Mirror reported. She was getting ready to go on a trip with friends when she was discovered dead, according to the Sun. The Yorkshire Post ran an obituary for Roche that read, "Roche, Rosie Jeanne Burke. Died on Monday 14th July 2025. Darling daughter of Hugh and Pippa, incredible sister to Archie and Agatha, Granddaughter to Derek and Rae Long. Private family funeral. A memorial service will be held at a later date.' According to the New York Daily News, the Royal Family has not made any comment on Roche's William's Cousin Found Dead With Gun Nearby first appeared on Men's Journal on Jul 22, 2025 Solve the daily Crossword
