
Water review in England and Wales: seven key takeways
Sir John Cunliffe, the former Bank of England deputy governor who led the Independent Water Commission (IWC) review, has published a 465-page report to attempt to address an industry beset by underinvestment, rising pollution incidents, soaring customers bills and meaty shareholder payouts.
The report makes 88 recommendations to government with significant ramifications for the industry and consumers. Here are some of the key takeaways.
The report has said that a fundamental 'reset' of the water sector is needed with the proposed scrapping of existing regulators and replacing them with one body for England and one body for Wales.
In England, this would lead to Ofwat and the Drinking Water Inspectorate being scrapped, and the removal of the environmental regulation functions for the Environment Agency and Natural England.
Under the proposal a new combined, integrated regulator that would be 'less desk-based' would be set up.
In Wales, Ofwat's economic responsibilities would be integrated into Natural Resources Wales.
The government said on Monday it would adopt the plan.
The IWC recommends that meters should be made compulsory for a 'wide range of circumstances', in a drive to force consumers to reduce household water consumption. That includes installing them for households in areas where there is not 'water stress'.
It suggests that the water industry could look to the energy sector, where suppliers must install a smart meter if they are replacing a meter or installing a meter for the first time – unless there is a good reason not to.
Proponents of smart meters argue they encourage households to use less water. However, larger households with high water usage would be at risk of paying more than a standard flat rate tariff.
Water companies could be let off fines if the government accepts a recommendation to allow them 'regulatory forbearance'.
The report argues that a regulatory regime should be established to improve the performance of struggling water companies, including tightening oversight of ownership and governance.
However, as well as this 'enhanced power of direction' the regime should allow 'regulatory forbearance', which would see companies dodge some financial penalties potentially further enraging campaigners already furious about the rise in pollution incidents.
In March, the Guardian revealed that troubled Thames Water – which could collapse into a temporary nationalisation – was asking to be spared billions of pounds of costs and fines over the next five years, claiming that potential investors would be scared off otherwise.
The government will also adopt a recommendation to upgrade the existing Consumer Council for Water (CCW) to a fully fledged ombudsman for customers. It currently runs a voluntary ombudsman scheme.
The report suggests a nationwide social tariff to help consumers who cannot afford their bills, which the CCW has campaigned for.
The change would give customers a clearer route to resolving complaints, such as issues including sewage floods in their gardens and taps running dry because of burst pipes.
The report says that the new water regulator would need to be able to offer 'suitable' remuneration, which would mean it would not have to follow 'public sector pay controls'.
The argument runs that to be effective the regulator will need to be able to hire and develop 'high-calibre' engineers and staff with financial expertise to provide proper oversight of the infrastructure and funding operations of water companies.
'Attracting skilled staff will require the regulator to offer suitable remuneration, outside public sector pay controls,' the report says.
The high pay of water company executives has long been a source of anger among critics of the industry, most recently reignited by Southern Water's chief executive receiving a doubled pay package.
However, Cunliffe, said: 'We are not proposing the regulator should set pay scales for the industry. They do need to recruit, and you have to attract the best people. What really makes the public angry is when the pay is there but the performance is not.'
The report said that the current metrics Ofwat uses to measure infrastructure resilience, such as sewer collapses, mains repairs and leaky pipes, is short-termist and 'backward-looking'.
The report calls for new national resilience standards for infrastructure to help guarantee the maintenance of underground pipes and other water and water waste assets.
It also says that the requirements for companies to map their assets should be strengthened.
The commission suggests the new regulator should have the power to set minimum capital levels for water companies.
That system could mirror the regime in the banking industry, where financial cushions meant to shock-proof the banking system from another 2008-style crash were introduced.

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


The Independent
23 minutes ago
- The Independent
Liverpool secure signing of sought-after French forward
Liverpool have completed the signing of French forward Hugo Ekitike from Eintracht Frankfurt for an initial fee of £69m, potentially rising to £79m. The 23-year-old has signed a six-year contract at Anfield after successfully passing his medical. Liverpool secured Ekitike despite late interest from Manchester United and a rejected £70m bid from Newcastle United. The club views Ekitike as a multi-functional forward with the potential to become one of the world's best, comparing his talent to Erling Haaland and Kylian Mbappé. This transfer marks Liverpool's fourth major summer signing, bringing their total spending to £250m, with potential add-ons increasing it to £300m.


BreakingNews.ie
23 minutes ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Liverpool complete signing of striker Hugo Ekitike from Eintracht Frankfurt
Liverpool have completed the signing of striker Hugo Ekitike from Eintracht Frankfurt. A deal was reached between the two clubs on Monday for the 23-year-old to join Arne Slot's Premier League champions, which the PA news agency understands to be for a guaranteed £69million plus a potential £10million in add-ons. Advertisement The striker, who scored 22 goals for Frankfurt in all competitions last season, flew to England on Tuesday to undergo a medical ahead of the deal's completion and will now travel to Asia to join his new Liverpool team-mates on their pre-season tour. PA understands Newcastle and Manchester United had been interested in Ekitike, whose capture continues Liverpool's summer spending spree. Florian Wirtz arrived from Bayer Leverkusen in an initial £100m deal that could rise to £116m, while Jeremie Frimpong also joined from the German club in a £29.5m switch and Milos Kerkez left Bournemouth for £40m. Giorgi Mamardashvili has also linked up with Liverpool after agreeing a move from Valencia last August, along with fellow goalkeepers Armin Pecsi and Freddie Woodman. Advertisement


Reuters
an hour ago
- Reuters
Forward Ekitike joins Liverpool from Frankfurt
July 23 (Reuters) - Liverpool have signed French striker Hugo Ekitike from Eintracht Frankfurt, the Premier League side announced on Wednesday, with media reports saying the deal was worth 69 million pounds ($93.65 million) plus add-ons. Ekitike is Liverpool's second-most expensive recruit in the close season after the Premier League champions signed Germany midfielder Florian Wirtz, who can also play as winger or forward, in June for a club-record 100 million pounds plus add-ons. "The 23-year-old has successfully completed a medical and agreed personal terms with the Reds, allowing him to fly out to Hong Kong to join his new teammates on their pre-season tour of Asia later this week," Liverpool said in a statement. Former Paris St Germain player Ekitike had a breakout campaign in 2024-25, scoring 15 Bundesliga goals in 33 appearances. He also struck four times as Frankfurt reached the quarter-finals of the Europa League. Ekitike, who made his senior debut at Stade de Reims, joined PSG on loan in 2022, making 25 Ligue 1 appearances as they won the French top-flight. He went on loan to Frankfurt in 2023, before making the move permanent a year later. "It's a strong story for him and Eintracht Frankfurt that he's moving to one of Europe's top teams with the greatest ambitions and opportunities," Frankfurt Sporting Director Markus Kroesche said in a statement. "Hugo has earned this move, and it shows that we are capable of offering players a great prospect." Liverpool begin their Premier League title defence at home against Bournemouth on August 15. ($1 = 0.7368 pounds)