Chinook 1994 helicopter crash families criticise MoD for ‘losing moral compass'
Relatives of the 29 victims who died on the aircraft have written to the Prime Minister to demand a full, independent, judge-led public inquiry to establish the truth into the disaster, accusing the MoD of 'losing its moral compass'.
RAF Chinook ZD576 crashed on the Mull of Kintyre on its way from RAF Aldergrove in Northern Ireland to Fort George in Scotland, and all 25 passengers and four crew members were killed in the incident.
A verdict of gross negligence against the pilots, flight lieutenants Richard Cook and Jonathan Tapper, from a review into the incident by two senior RAF officers in 1995 was overturned by the Government in 2011 after a 16-year campaign by the families.
Relatives have now written to the Prime Minister to intervene and are seeking a judicial review in the High Court.
Chris Cook, whose brother Richard was one of the pilots killed in the disaster, said: 'In the BBC documentary that was shown early last year, what came to light was that the official documents to do with the accident have been sealed for 100 years by the Ministry of Defence.
'We weren't aware of that. There was news to me when I watched the programme.
'And so it seems rather suspicious to us that the documents are going to be locked away for such a long time.'
He added: 'We campaigned for 16 years to clear the pilots' names and so many times we were given indications that information didn't exist.
'Based on the experience we had in our campaign, they wanted us to go away – simple as that.
'But my late father always said justice has no expiry dates.
'Sadly, he passed away before we cleared Rick's name.
'He never got to see that, he died six years beforehand.
'But those words mean an awful lot, it means don't give up.
'You know if you think that an injustice is being done, you keep fighting for it.'
Mr Cook says there are 47 individuals that lost their fathers in the crash, most of whom were children and some not yet born, who have lived their whole lives without answers.
Jenni Balmer Hornby, daughter of Anthony Hornby who was killed in the disaster, said: 'It was a week before my 10th birthday when the crash happened and so obviously I wasn't old enough to go to any of the earlier inquiries, but my mum went to those.
'For some time she felt that it was an accident because of these inquiries.
'But now we know that the full information wasn't given, so we know over time that these inquiries were completely ineffective.
'I think it's very clear to myself and everyone in the campaign that the MoD have lost their moral compass – I'm so certain now that the MoD is hiding something.
'I can't go another 31 years not knowing what happened to my father.
'Him and his colleagues risk their life for their country and in return, we have just been dismissed and fed lies for three decades and we all deserve a lot better.'
Andy Tobias, who was just eight when his father John Tobias went on board RAF Chinook ZD576, has branded the response from the MoD as a 'betrayal'.
He said: '(It's been) really tough.
'My brother and myself have not had a father, he's not been around to direct us through the challenges that you face in life.
'You never get over it but you learn to live with it.
'For us, the MoD have really let us down as families.
'It's been a complete betrayal to all of those men who boarded that flight and gave their life and service.
'If my father knew that his family were fighting so hard to get answers and to get the truth, he would be turning in his grave.
Sue Sparks, whose husband Gary was killed in the crash, said: 'I think it would give us closure.
'Over the 30 years, we were led to believe it was an accident, which it wasn't.
'It could have been prevented.
'The helicopter was declared unairworthy and they were made to fly in it.
'It makes us feel angry and not treated properly by the MoD.
'As a war widow, I feel very, very let down by the Government and the MoD.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Telegraph
28 minutes ago
- Telegraph
Sione Tuipulotu interview: Private school saved me from life of crime
Sione Tuipulotu is talking about his childhood growing up in Frankston, a suburb of Melbourne. It is not some idyllic recall of golden days. The Scotland captain will happily talk all day, but he does not do cliched answers. He did not grow up dreaming of playing international rugby, whether for his native Australia or Scotland, for whom he qualifies via his grandmother, Anne Thompson, who in 1963 moved with her parents and siblings from Greenock, outside Glasgow, to within an hour of Melbourne. No, at the age of 13 Tuipulotu feared, in his own words, that he was 'going down the wrong path'. 'Gang violence was always around but I was more scared of my dad than any gang in our neighbourhood,' says Tuipulotu. 'There is not much opportunity for kids where I was from. Boredom gets the best of a lot of kids in my area. You are bored and looking for something to do and quite often that leads to trouble. I stopped going to school a lot and I was getting into trouble when I did go to school.' I ask what sort of things he got up to. 'Oh, to be honest, crime,' he says matter-of-factly. 'Not that I am going to sit here and admit to any crime that I have done,' he adds. 'But you get into little things, as young kids do, in terms of stealing, fighting and it was because all the kids in my environment were doing it. 'You get to that age, 13, 14 and 15 years old, when you get to the crossroads, you know? My parents did a really good job with me ever since I was a kid. I was probably more scared of my dad than I anything else that was going on outside. So that kept me relatively on the straight and narrow, but I was getting into trouble.' 'I had a chip on my shoulder at school' What happened next, according to Tuipulotu, is a story of redemption. Not for the first time – and hopefully not the last – rugby's intervention led to good life decisions. He played soccer at first, but his dad Fohe was a rugby man and encouraged his son to join Southern Districts rugby club. The days when he 'ran down the right wing' in football quickly came to an end. Despite the distractions as a pupil at the Elisabeth Murdoch College, he excelled at several sports, but his rugby prowess attracted the attention of a private school, St Kevin's College, which offered him a full scholarship. Yet this is only the first stage of his journey from the backstreets of Frankston to a place in the British and Irish Lions side to face Australia in the first Test on Saturday. He was a kid looking for a purpose, and more importantly, for someone to put their arm around him. Do that, and he would give you everything. That it was a Scottish arm changed his life. The early days at his new school, however, initially left him cold. 'At first, I wanted to make my parents proud because it was an opportunity they could never afford themselves. But for the first couple of years, I had a chip on my shoulder. I thought none of the kids were like me. I didn't have anything similar with them; their parents were wealthy. When I came back home on the train, I would take my blazer off because I was embarrassed. I didn't want to come back to Frankston and all the boys see me in this fancy blazer. 'At one stage they were at a crossroads to get rid of me, because I was still getting in trouble. But one teacher called Robert Windle, who went to school in Edinburgh, put his arm around me and drove me through school. He had been to Merchiston, and it was funny that I would later end up playing with a number of boys who went there. 'He was the first XV coach but was also more mentoring, not on my rugby side, because he knew that came easy to me, but for the school stuff. I played for the first XV as soon as I joined the school at 14, I was physically developed for my age although at that stage I was more of a finesse player. It was only when I got older that I fell in love with the collision aspect of the game. 'Bob's interest made me really competitive. Once someone showed they cared about me, I didn't want to let them down and that's when everything changed for me. 'School became so important because I would spend three hours every day on the train to get there and back, so by the time I got back after rugby training it was late. I started taking rugby really seriously then, too, and zoned in on what I wanted to do. 'Going into my last year in school, I would keep my blazer on when I got off the train. I had figured out in my brain that the school had saved me from a lot of things and rugby had kept me busy.' 'We were overlooked by Australian rugby' If those formative years proved critical, when he left knowing that he wanted to become a professional rugby player, the frustrations and disillusionment of the 13-year-old Tuipulotu soon returned as he felt players in Melbourne were not given a fair chance by the Australian system, even when the Rebels were established as a Super Rugby franchise. 'I can give you a list of the Melbourne boys who were let go by the Rebels, and it would surprise you,' he says. 'For example, I played with Emmanuel Meafou, who is at Toulouse now. He was told he was never going to be fit enough. Hunter Paisami was told he was too small and would never play Super Rugby. 'It was the same for Monty Ioane. These were all Melbourne kids who didn't get the opportunity to play for Melbourne. That's all we wanted to do at the time, represent our state. There's a tight-knit community down there in Victorian rugby, and we felt like we were always overlooked in the grand scheme of Australian rugby because we grew up in what was perceived as a non-rugby state. They used us for marketing purposes, because we were Melbourne kids, but we never ended up getting much of an opportunity. 'When I left Melbourne, I left angry, and I saw so many other kids miss out on opportunities. Later on in your career, you think that it was meant to happen, but I definitely still have that chip on my shoulder of being turned away. I will carry it for the rest of my career. 'It is something I'm really passionate about, even on this tour because at the end of the day, I still represent Melbourne kids. That's where I'm from. I know a lot of those kids are supporting the Wallabies as they should, but even if a couple of them support the Lions because I'm playing for them, then I will feel that I have won.' After seeing the Rebels squad recruit many Western Force players when it was originally cut from Super Rugby in 2017, he moved on to Japan before Scotland came calling, with an offer to join Glasgow Warriors. It felt like another arm around his shoulder, and once again he was prepared to give all that he had. Which brings us to his sense of identity. Some have criticised the number of players in the Lions squad who were not born or raised in Britain or Ireland. Tuipulotu does not shy away from the issue. 'I really understand the people that are angry,' he adds. 'I'm not angry that anyone feels like that, to be honest. If anything, I understand it. If I open my mouth and they don't hear a Scottish accent, I understand how that might upset people, but my accent is my accent. 'When I left Australia, I wasn't ready to play for the Wallabies. I have never said that. All I said was that my talent was mismanaged. Going to Scotland, my talent was managed correctly. The coaches had a massive [impact] on my career, first Danny Wilson, then Franco Smith and finally Gregor Townsend. 'I can't say enough about Gregor because when I got to Scotland, I wasn't the finished product – I'm still not the finished product, I know that – but I needed time in the saddle to learn and he gave me that. 'He stuck by me maybe because he could see my potential and the reason for my success is because he stuck by me. He put his arm around me and I never want to let him down because of that. 'It was the same with my mum and dad when they sent me to that school, it was the same with my teacher when he put his arm around me, I didn't want to let my coach down. I think that is my personality, I am driven by not wanting to let people down. 'I feel like I am where I am supposed to be. I've captained Scotland now. I've gained many, many new friends and my son was born in Glasgow.' 'Boys from back home told me to shut up' Tuipulotu's backstory means that the Scotland captain is ready to face his native Australia with arguably an extra edge compared to his team-mates. He is primed for any abuse from the Australian players or supporters. 'I am ready for it,' he adds with a chuckle. 'Like I said, I play my best rugby when there's a big chip on my shoulder. If they are going to add to the chip, it just helps me and I will get more emotionally invested so that will only be a good thing for me. 'It comes with the territory. There are going to be things said on both sides. That's why I love rugby, that's why I love sport. It is not the things that you say are necessarily going to get the job done. It is the things that you do. There is always going to be noise, it is the biggest tour in the world, but it is cool that you get to answer it.' There are still some answers to deliver after Australia's defeat by Scotland last November when Joseph Sua'ali'i lined up Tuipulotu at centre for a massive tackle, only to injure himself in the process. Tuipulotu gave him a send-off but Sua'ali'i delivered a pointed warning, 'I'll see you next time'. 'It was quite a noisy game,' the Lions 12 recalls. 'But that made the game so fun for me. I know a lot of those boys from back home and played rugby with them. They were telling me to shut up because I was so motivated, but it was all good fun.' Finally, I ask him about his tattoo and the answer should leave no one in any doubt about his commitment to the Lions' cause. It is from the cover of an album by Lauryn Hill, the American rapper. ' The Miseducation of Lauryn Hill is my mum's favourite album,' he adds. 'We grew up on Lauryn Hill's music. It was quite a spontaneous tattoo, to be honest, because I'm not covered in them. I got it because of my mum and the influence she had on me. The story of my upbringing is that I was pretty terrified of my dad, but my mum raised me and I know how excited she is to see me play for the Lions. All my family in Australia had the red merchandise even before I had! 'Me playing for the Lions is as big an achievement for them as it is for me. To get on this tour, you have to be lucky in your own life, but to be there, you have to be lucky to have parents to have put you in a position to do well. That's the story for me. Me playing in this tour is not just a representation of my own work but also theirs. And my granny is going to be there with her bells and whistles on, too. I am just desperate to contribute as much as I can.'
Daily Mail
2 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Police calendar's one day for women… two months for trans
Police officers are being encouraged to mark Pansexual Visibility Day and a host of other dates related to the force's equality agenda as part of a ' woke inclusion calendar'. The list of key days - which also includes Asexuality Day and Lesbian Visibility Day - was shared with officers and staff allowing them to 'seek further information on them if they wish'. Last Wednesday saw International Drag Day and Monday last week was Non-Binary People's Day – while International Pronouns Day is on October 20. Not all of the dates are 'marked nationally by the organisation' - but officers and civilian staff can request more detail about them, potentially allowing them to request permission to mark specific dates in the workplace. Last night Dr Kath Murray, of gender-critical think-tank Murray Blackburn Mackenzie, said: 'Police Scotland's 'inclusion' calendar celebrates just one day for women, compared to two months for transgender causes. 'The force also signposts days celebrating drag queens, pronouns, and fringe gender identities. 'It has no formal representation for women, nor does it recognise the [gender-critical] Police SEEN network.' The calendar opens with LGBT History Month in February, with Purple Friday marked as the last Friday in February, a day when people can show their solidarity with LGBTIQ+ people by wearing the colour purple. Transgender Day of Visibility is on March 31, with Asexuality Day on April 6 and Lesbian Visibility Day on April 26. International Day Against Homophobia, Biphobia and Transphobia is on May 17, while Pansexual Visibility Day is on May 24. Pansexuality is defined as a sexual orientation characterised by attraction to people regardless of their gender identity. Transgender Awareness Week runs from November 13-19, while Transgender Day of Remembrance is on November 20. The row follows Police Scotland's decision not to allow officers in uniform to take part in a Pride march in Glasgow on Saturday. It came after a High Court judgment south of the Border last week which found this was a breach of impartiality, following a judicial review. Last month Police Scotland was accused of promoting trans ideology by putting up virtue-signalling gender posters in a station. The placards explain the words and phrases by going through each letter of the alphabet - for example 'G' is for 'gender identity'. Police Scotland has also been criticised over delays in implementing a separate Supreme Court judgment in April which stated that the words 'woman' and 'sex' in the Equality Act 2010 refer to a biological woman and biological sex. Last year Chief Constable Jo Farrell said the public and MSPs should be 'assured' that a man who commits rape or serious sexual assault will always be recorded as male. In March, the Mail revealed that this stance, which campaigners said was a major policy U-turn, was not communicated to officers, sparking claims that police may have misled parliament. And last week the Mail revealed that no one will face action over a 'deeply offensive' police document which compared gender-critical feminists to Nazis. Police Scotland was at the centre of a row in May after staff were told the concept of 'gender binary' - the belief there are only two genders - was a 'key feature' of the Nazis' ideology. The document was posted on the force's intranet by a serving constable who did not need authorisation to do so at the time. Last night Scottish Tory equalities spokesman Tess White said: 'Hard-working Scots expect Police Scotland to be focused on tackling crime, not a woke inclusion calendar. 'It's just common sense that keeping people safe should be the top priority for the force.' Commenting further on the calendar row, Dr Murray said: 'There are serious questions here as to whether Police Scotland would pass the impartiality test set out in the judgment against the Chief Constable of Northumbria Police issued this week, in relation to its participation in a Pride march.' A Police Scotland spokesman said: 'These dates are part of Police Scotland's inclusion calendar and, while not all are marked nationally by the organisation, listing them allows colleagues to seek further information on them if they wish.'
Times
3 hours ago
- Times
Travelling tabby ‘catnapped and dumped across border as punishment'
Harvey has always been an intrepid cat, known to spend his week roaming around the farms and cottages of Cumbria before returning to the bed and breakfast he calls home. But when his tracking device suddenly placed him more than 50 miles away, in a different country, his owner started to suspect something was amiss. Anne Cornthwaite, 61, from Borrowdale, has reported a local man to police for alleged catnapping. She claims that Alan, a neighbour, confessed to taking Harvey over the border to Scotland because of the tabby cat's supposed violent tendencies and disregard for personal property. 'The police asked me, do you want to report it as theft or animal abuse. I said both,' Cornthwaite said. The neighbour did not respond to a request for comment. Cumbria Constabulary was contacted for comment.
