logo
Universities everywhere are in crisis

Universities everywhere are in crisis

The Hindu2 days ago
On July 21, a federal judge challenged the U.S. administration's reasons for slashing billions of dollars in federal funding to Harvard University. The funding threats and cuts reflect a larger worldwide trend of right-wing governments forcing higher education institutions with their ideological agendas. Across the world, universities, once imagined as havens of free inquiry, are now being transformed into sites of political control.
Weaponised budgets
This pressure is particularly evident in the U.S., where Ivy League universities have become the centre of a cultural conflict. Portraying these institutions as havens for 'anti-Americanism', Mr. Trump tightened visas for overseas students and threatened funding cuts to colleges that defied his definition of 'free speech'. The U.S. Supreme Court's 2023 ruling ending affirmative action in college admissions gave right-wing activists even more confidence and spurred calls for broad changes in admissions rules. While Columbia University was pushed into adopting a strict definition of antisemitism, a measure critics say silences legitimate debate about Israel and Palestine, the 2024 congressional campaign forced Harvard's president, Claudine Gay, to resign. Major donors withdrew millions in funding from institutions that resisted these pressures, leaving faculty fearful that discussions on race, gender, or foreign policy might provoke similar reprisals.
The effects are felt globally. In Australia, using the nebulous concept of 'national interest', ministers have vetoed peer-reviewed humanities research proposals covering topics such as climate activism and Indigenous politics. Law faculties have faced criticism for deviating from 'black letter law' and incorporating decolonisation into their courses. Universities are also under pressure to pass anti-foreign interference audits to protect rich international student enrolment and engage in persuasive self-censorship on sensitive subjects, such as China, Palestine, and Australia's colonial past.
In India, populist leaders see public universities as elitist strongholds. Police visit campuses to quell dissent; budgets are cut; and vice-chancellors replaced. Jawaharlal Nehru University, once a hub of open debate, now frequently faces the label of 'anti-national'. In 2023, the University Grants Commission mandated compulsory courses in 'Indian knowledge systems'; this is seen as advancing Hindu nationalist narratives. The South Asian University, established by SAARC as an international institution, pressured a faculty member to leave after his PhD student cited Noam Chomsky's criticism of the Modi government.
From Budapest to Bahrain, the pattern is clear. Viktor Orbán forced Central European University out of Hungary. Turkey dismissed thousands of academics who supported a peace petition. Brazil and the Philippines drastically cut social sciences' funding, silencing studies on inequality. Gulf states impose tight restrictions on conversations about religion, gender, and labour rights. Independent research is now seen across continents as a threat to national security.
Along with these direct attacks is a quieter but equally destructive force: the neoliberal makeover of higher education. Rankings, patent creation, and the pursuit of student 'employability' are transforming universities into corporate entities. People discount feminist studies, sociology, history and other subjects which explore power dynamics as unnecessary extravagances. Students become paying customers, faculty members turn into disposable service providers, and trustees prioritise brand management above intellectual exploration. The far right exploits this market-driven logic, portraying universities as taxpayer-funded breeding grounds for sedition, while simultaneously cutting public funding essential for maintaining intellectual diversity.
Defending the commons
According to the Academic Freedom Index, produced by V-Dem and partner organisations, academic freedom declined in 34 countries between 2014 and 2024, not only in autocracies but in democracies as well. Indicators measuring institutional autonomy, freedom of research, and campus integrity dropped to their lowest levels since the early 1980s. Every erosion of academic freedom limits society's ability to tackle pressing global challenges such as climate change, the impacts of AI, and democratic deterioration.
Despite these challenges, hope remains. Networks of academics, students, and civil society groups around the world are resisting ideological pressure. Faculty groups and student coalitions in the U.S. actively promote inclusive education, which forces some colleges to rethink too rigid definitions of antisemitism. Legal collectives and independent academic platforms still guard areas for critical inquiry in India.
However, survival alone is insufficient. Universities must recover their public agenda. Governing boards should shield hiring, promotions, and funding decisions from political interference. Donors must support uncomfortable inquiry rather than dictate it. Alumni can fund independent academic chairs or legal defence efforts. Faculty members must engage in university governance instead of leaving it to bureaucrats, while students should remember that campuses are democratic commons, not merely credential factories. If fear, profit motives, or majoritarian arrogance dictate what can be taught or expressed, we risk inheriting not just weakened universities but diminished democracies.
Amrita Nambiar, Assistant Professor of Law, Vinayaka Mission's Law School, Vinayaka Mission's Research Foundation (DU); Amrithnath Sreedevi Babu, Sessional Academic and PhD candidate, Macquarie Law School, Macquarie University, Australia
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Asian stocks slip from highs, dollar gains ahead of crucial 'tariff' week
Asian stocks slip from highs, dollar gains ahead of crucial 'tariff' week

Business Standard

time9 minutes ago

  • Business Standard

Asian stocks slip from highs, dollar gains ahead of crucial 'tariff' week

Asian shares eased from highs on Friday, with Japanese markets retreating from a record peak, as investors locked in profits ahead of a crucial week that includes US President Donald Trump's tariff deadline and a host of central bank meetings. The dollar gained against the yen after bouncing off a two-week low on Thursday, helped by some firm US economic data, while Japan's currency was weighed down by political uncertainty amid media reports Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba will step down. Benchmark Japanese government bond yields hovered just below the highest since 2008. Japan's broad Topix index, which had jumped more than 5 per cent over the previous two sessions to reach an all-time high, pulled back 0.7 per cent. The Nikkei slipped 0.5 per cent from Thursday's one-year high. Hong Kong's Hang Seng lost 0.5 per cent and mainland Chinese blue chips declined 0.2 per cent. Australia's equity benchmark declined 0.5 per cent. At the same time, US S&P 500 futures added 0.2 per cent, after the cash index edged up slightly to a new record closing high overnight, buoyed by robust earnings from Google parent Alphabet. The tech-heavy Nasdaq also marked a record high. MSCI's gauge of stocks across the globe edged down 0.1 per cent, but remained just below an all-time peak from Thursday. The index is on course for a 1.3 per cent weekly advance, buoyed in large part by optimism for US trade deals with the European Union and China, following an agreement with Japan this week. Next week, in the US alone, investors need to contend with Trump's August 1 deadline for trade deals, a Federal Reserve policy meeting, the closely watched monthly payrolls report, and earnings from the likes of Amazon, Apple, Meta and Microsoft. The Bank of Japan has its own policy announcement on Thursday, and Prime Minister Ishiba's Liberal Democratic Party holds a meeting the same day. That's after the European Central Bank held rates steady on Thursday, pausing its easing campaign as it waits to assess any impact from US tariffs. The euro ended the session down 0.2 per cent against a buoyant dollar, and was little changed on Friday at $1.1743. The US currency advanced 0.3 per cent to 147.37 yen, adding to Thursday's 0.4 per cent gain. Trump kept the pressure on Fed Chair Jerome Powell to cut rates after a rare presidential visit to the central bank on Thursday, although he said he did not intend to fire Powell, as he has frequently suggested he would. US 10-year Treasury yields edged down to 4.39 per cent on Friday, effectively erasing an advance on Thursday. [US/] Equivalent Japanese government bond yields eased 0.5 basis point to 1.595 per cent, just off this week's high of 1.6 per cent, a level last seen in October 2008. JGB yields have been rising on concerns the political scale is tilting more towards fiscal stimulus, after big gains for opposition parties backing consumption tax cuts in Sunday's upper house election. Pressure is building on the more fiscally hawkish Ishiba to quit after his coalition lost its majority in the vote, after doing the same in lower house elections last October. Gold was flat at around $3,368 per ounce, keeping it on course for a 0.5 per cent rise this week. Brent crude futures gained 0.3 per cent to $69.35 a barrel, while US West Texas Intermediate crude futures added 0.2 per cent to $66.18 per barrel. [O/R] (Only the headline and picture of this report may have been reworked by the Business Standard staff; the rest of the content is auto-generated from a syndicated feed.)

‘Benchmark deal…trade will double by 2030'
‘Benchmark deal…trade will double by 2030'

Time of India

time9 minutes ago

  • Time of India

‘Benchmark deal…trade will double by 2030'

Piyush Goyal is the minister of commerce & industry, consumer affairs, food & public distribution and textiles, Government of India The landmark India-UK Comprehensive Economic and Trade Agreement (CETA) will make Indian farmers, fishermen, artisans, and small businesses shine globally, create numerous jobs, and help the common man get high-quality goods at competitive rates in line with the PM's vision. Read full article on TOI+ Facebook Twitter Linkedin Email Disclaimer Views expressed above are the author's own.

Why Donald Trump doesn't want Google, Microsoft to hire Indians
Why Donald Trump doesn't want Google, Microsoft to hire Indians

India Today

time9 minutes ago

  • India Today

Why Donald Trump doesn't want Google, Microsoft to hire Indians

US President Donald Trump has told major tech companies like Google, Microsoft and Apple to stop hiring foreign workers, including from India, and focus instead on creating jobs in the United at an AI Summit in Washington on Wednesday, Trump said American companies must now put national interest first, especially in the fast-growing field of artificial said that top US technology firms have made huge profits while setting up operations in countries like China and hiring large numbers of employees in argued that this has come at the cost of American workers. 'Many of our largest tech companies have reaped the blessings of American freedom while building their factories in China, hiring workers in India and stashing profits in Ireland,' Trump said during the event. 'Under President Trump, those days are over.'He said the mindset of these firms had become too global and called for a new 'spirit of patriotism and national loyalty' in Silicon Valley and across the American tech industry. 'We want you to put America first. That's all we ask,' he also used the event to announce three new executive orders aimed at boosting the US's AI industry. One of the orders lays out a national plan to fast-track AI development by easing regulations and encouraging companies to build data centres and other key infrastructure inside the US. The strategy is called 'Winning the Race' and is focused on helping the US lead in AI second order puts new rules on companies that receive federal funds to build AI tools. These companies must now ensure that the tools they develop are politically neutral. Trump said his administration would not support what he called 'woke' AI systems and blamed previous policies that focused on diversity and inclusion for slowing down progress in technology.'We are getting rid of woke,' he said. 'AI must be accurate and not influenced by ideology.' The new rules will also apply to government agencies that use AI tools, and these systems must not be biased or driven by political also questioned the use of the term 'artificial intelligence,' saying he prefers a term that better reflects its power. 'It's not artificial, it's genius,' he third executive order focuses on helping US-built AI products compete globally. It includes steps to support exports and ensure full development of AI technology within the Trump's comments have sparked concern among tech workers in countries like India, no official steps have been announced yet to limit hiring from abroad. However, industry watchers say such remarks from the President could affect the hiring plans of major tech firms, especially those that rely heavily on skilled engineers from India and Indian tech professionals, many of whom are employed in roles related to software development, data science, and AI in the US, Trump's message may create recent years, several US companies have increased their hiring in India to cut costs and tap into the country's large pool of skilled engineers. The latest statement from Trump could put pressure on firms to re-evaluate their hiring strategies, especially if new rules or limitations are the global race for AI dominance continues, the push for more national control and local jobs in the US could have effects on tech ecosystems in countries like India, which play a key role in supporting American firms through outsourcing, engineering services, and back-end operations.- Ends advertisement

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store