Luxury or loot? American store sells Rs 100 Indian jholas for a whopping Rs 4200!
The humble Indian Jhola, no frills, no fancy leather, is a simple, all-purpose cotton bag long associated with Indian households, college students, and activists, of course. Now, suddenly, this Indian jhola has found itself in the global fashion spotlight and not without any controversy.
What typically costs in India around 100 rupees or even at times is free with purchases at Indian local markets, is now being sold for jaw-dropping prices by an American luxury retailer,
Nordstrom
, for approximately $48 (4,228 Indian Rupees).
The bag in question is being marketed as an 'Indian Souvenir Bag' by Japanese lifestyle brand Puebco. Made of cotton and emblazoned with Hindi script that resembles the kind of packaging found on lentils and masalas, the jhola is nearly identical to those casual bags slung across India, except for one striking difference: the price!
Social media erupted in disbelief as images of the listing went viral.
Many indians could not help but laugh over the fact that the bags they used to carry vegetables and groceries are now being sold as popular bags among high fashion enthusiasts. This is a case of classic western repackaging and rebranding.
Memes across social media are comparing that jhola to global luxury bags that surfaced instantly. Others expressed outrage at how an everyday cultural object, often associated with frugality and function, had been transformed into a high-priced 'exotic' item for western consumers.
by Taboola
by Taboola
Sponsored Links
Sponsored Links
Promoted Links
Promoted Links
You May Like
Trade Bitcoin & Ethereum – No Wallet Needed!
IC Markets
Start Now
Undo
How are people reacting all over social media?
Image credit: Puebco/Indian souvenir bag
The internet, as usual, was quick to erupt; many users expressed a mix of amusement and outrage at what they saw as a blatant case of cultural appropriation and commercial exploitation.'It is not about the bag; it is about the blatant repacking of our culture without context or credit,' one user posted.
Another reply, sarcastically quipped, 'Should we start exporting tiffin boxes next as artisanal lunchware?' A user on X commented, 'For $48, I'll throw in an extra jhola, a steel dabba, and a packet of Maggi.'
A Delhi-based artist wrote, 'This isn't just tone-deaf, it's bizarre. You can buy these for ₹60 outside Daryaganj Metro Station.'
What else will Americanization steal from us?
The controversy surrounding American. Rebranding Indian staples into high-fashion items is not new. Major fashion houses have faced similar criticism for selling items like lungi-styled skirts, kurta-like tunics, and even rubber slippers that were sold at exorbitant rates, marketed as exotic or avant-garde fashion in the West.
While some argue that global recognition of Indian design should be celebrated, others insist that it must come with context, respect, and fair acknowledgment of cultural origins. In the case of the Indian Jhola, what was once a symbol of sustainability and street-smart sensibility has now become a case study in how globalization and luxury branding can sometimes distort cultural narratives for profit.
As one viral tweet can sum it up, 'Call it what you want; to us, it will always be the bag you forget in the back of your dad's scooter.'
One step to a healthier you—join Times Health+ Yoga and feel the change
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
9 minutes ago
- Time of India
When design speaks louder than logos
It has been a busy week for Namrata Karad, founder and creative director of Ahikoza by Brahm, after former journalist Lauren Sanchez was spotted carrying a black clutch from the brand ahead of her wedding to Amazon founder Jeff Bezos in image quickly found its way into the global fashion spotlight—not just for the celebrity moment, but for the absence of any visible branding as well. 'For them to be carrying a brand without a logo? I humbly believe it says something about the brand,' Karad told part of a growing group of Indian and Indian-origin designers gaining global acclaim for 'quiet luxury'—a fashion movement defined by unique and subtle designs with a focus on craftsmanship. Labels like 11.11/eleven eleven, Dhruv Kapoor, and behno New York are leading this trend. Hollywood actor Brad Pitt, for instance, was seen wearing a shirt from 11.11/eleven eleven in a scene in his latest film, F1. Karad said her luxury handbags and accessories brand was born out of passion nine years ago, and not with the intention of celebrities endorsing it on red carpet. 'I saw a gap in the market, and I wanted to design handbags that would not have to announce themselves with a loud logo. Rather, be recognised by design.' All global brands have key features—a DNA. Think of Bottega Veneta that is known for its weave, or Judith Leiber famous for its crystal studded handbags. The thing that stands out for Ahikoza by Brahm handbags is the geometric patterns. 'This is our defined DNA. When people talk about the brand, they recognise it by design. That, to me, is true luxury,' Karad said. New Delhi headquartered 11.11/eleven eleven—cofounded by Shani Himanshu and Mia Morikawa more than 15 years ago—follows a 'seed to stitch' philosophy. Moving away from mainstream manufacturing, the label produces small batches of 'slow-made clothing' in collaboration with groups of artisans located all across India. For instance, for the Kala cotton indigenous to Kachchh in Gujarat, it works with local weavers who specialise in hand spinning. 'The neighbouring villages also participate in the process. This leaves a much lower carbon footprint,' Himanshu said. 'The reason why many people don't know of us till now is because we have been quietly building this entire ecosystem in keeping with our design ethos,' he said. 'The larger vision is to make all our products compostable. We have not achieved this in all our products yet.' 11.11/eleven eleven only uses plant-based dyes and 100% natural colours. It also has a showroom in New York, and retails through 100 stores across India, the US, Europe and Japan. Hollywood actor Dev Patel visited its New Delhi store last month. Dhruv Kapoor, founder and creative director of his eponymous label, said the term quiet luxury emerged simply as a contrast to overt, all-over monogramming. 'The brand name recedes, allowing quality, craftsmanship, and silhouette to lead,' he said. 'True quiet luxury—where branding is nearly untraceable—tends to attract a more mature, discerning audience,' Kapoor said. His approach is to strike a balance with most pieces carrying a small, refined logo. A select few, like casual jumpers, sport bold logos and they 'sell out within days,' he said. Kapoor will showcase his collection at the Milan Fashion Week for the seventh time in September. Behno—which retails wallets, small leather goods, mini bags, totes and sling bags—has its design studio headquartered in the West Village of Manhattan in New York City, but it is very much rooted in the Indian subcontinent for production, according to its founder and creative director Shivam Punjya. 'Over the last year, we've expanded our presence through select retail partners and pop-ups in key global markets, and we've been fortunate to receive recognition from international press and tastemakers,' Punjya said. The brand will open its first store in India in Mumbai later this year, 'marking an important step in building a physical flagship presence for the brand,' he said. behno (translating to sisters in Hindi) claims to be pioneering 'a new standard' for manufacturing in the global garment trade, focusing on the way garment workers and artisans are viewed, employed, and treated. The brand's products are handmade in facilities implementing a set of six guiding principles focusing on health, artisan growth, family planning, women's rights, workplace satisfaction, and eco consciousness. In 2019, behno won Fashion Group International's Rising Star Award in accessories. Previous winners include Tory Burch, Michael Kors and Jason Wu. For Punjya, quiet luxury is about intention over excess—a design philosophy where there is a deep consideration for craftsmanship, materiality, and design integrity. 'It's luxury that you feel intimately for yourself…something that makes you feel special or even empowered,' he said. 'It's a luxury where those who know, know.'
Time of India
12 minutes ago
- Time of India
Rock the bandana with effortless flair — just like these Bollywood actresses
Effortless ways to elevate your look with a bandana A bandana can bring youthful energy to your outfit. It adds a playful, boho twist and is perfect for daytime. Print on print: Go bold and bright. A cropped fitted choli adds the right amount of structure to the flowy, fun look. Tired of too many ads? go ad free now Match your bandana to your outfit. Keep make-up fresh and minimal: Let the outfit shine. Accessorise lightly - let the prints and texture do the talking. Recommended colours: Bright tones like mustard, rani pink and emerald pop beautifully on Indian skin tones. Dusky or deeper skin tones should go for jewel tones like wine, cobalt and olive. Fair to medium tones should opt for turmeric yellow, mint green or coral. Let the bandana do the talking: Skip the head jewellery and keep it clean. Wear playful studs or an ear cuff that looks cute without stealing the focus. Add a mix of bangles or a single bold cuff on one hand, let the other hand be empty and stack rings. Keep your hairstyle simple to let the bandana and outfit take centre stage. Going big on the potli, embroidered or mirror work works best. Wear comfy juttis or embroidered slides. Last but not least add tinted sunnies for an outdoor function. — Tips by Ankita Mane, stylist 'Bandana with lehenga is a fresh take on fashion' Bandanas have played a big role in fashion with western celebrities , and others teaming them up with casuals. Stylist Khyati Busa says, 'Bandanas are a versatile and stylish accessory that can add a pop of colour to any outfit, including traditional Indian wear. Embellishments like tassels, sequins, or embroidery can be added to the bandana for extra glamour and flair.' Katrina Kaif Katrina paired an orange shirt with swimwear and added a pop of colour with a necklace. She completed the breezy look with a printed bandana Alia opted for a multi-colour, multi-panel bandhani skirt paired with a vintage mirror embroidered crop choli. She completed the look with a tiered bandhani potli and a matching purple bandhani bandana Kiara Advani Kiara opted for a metallic crop top with beadwork and embellishments, and teamed it with a pair of abstract printed palazzo pants. She wore a bandana as the headgear in the same print as the palazzo pants Neha Dhupia Neha Dhupia's glittery bandana brought a touch of drama to her look, perfectly paired with a bold green faux fur coat A bandana can be used as a neckpiece with a kurta for a modern twist or as a headband with a lehenga or anarkali for a chic vibe. It can also be used as a hair accessory by tying a bandana around a bun or ponytail for a chic and elegant look - Khyati Busa, stylist
India Today
an hour ago
- India Today
Wearing confidence: How a simple idea became a youth movement
In the crowded hallways of Indian colleges, where identity is often shaped through last-minute assignments, shared hostel rooms, and budgeted fashion choices, the idea of personal style might seem like a luxury. Yet for some, it becomes a quiet form of rebellion — a way to stand out, express, and be Bhola and Aarush Bhola didn't grow up with access to overflowing wardrobes or designer labels. Like most students, they learned to do more with less — styling the same shirt differently for multiple occasions, stretching every rupee, and sometimes borrowing pieces from each other to pull off a fresh what started as everyday problem-solving — trying to look good on a tight budget — began evolving into something larger. A question started to linger: Why should looking good feel like a privilege? And what if the solution to that question could be worn, shared, and scaled? India Today sat down with the brothers behind Allstag — a fashion label born not out of boardroom strategy, but out of lived experience — to trace the journey from casual college styling to a fast-growing youth movement rooted in STYLE STARTED FROM NECESSITY'A good outfit could change the way you felt about your entire day,' says Aarush Bhola. 'But back then, money was tight. We used to save up for that one good piece and wear it in different ways. People still noticed — they'd ask, 'Where did you get that?''What began as a creative solution to a tight budget turned into an idea: what if style could be accessible without compromise?A NAME THAT BEGAN AS A COLLEGE JOKE'The name wasn't even serious at first,' says Sahil Bhola. All of us were single, so 'stag' became a running joke. And 'all' came from wanting to include everyone.'Later, the two realised that this accidental name captured what they believed in — inclusivity and individuality with a raw, unfiltered STATEMENTS THROUGH SIMPLICITYAarush Bhola explains that they never tried to chase trends or loud branding. 'Every piece had something to say, even if it was quiet. Whether it was a quote, colour, or cut — it reflected a mood or a mindset.'For their wearers, the clothes often felt like an extension of their personality, not just a wardrobe choice.'We've had people tell us they wore one of our tees on a college date or a farewell,' says Sahil Bhola. 'These weren't just purchases. They became memories.'That emotional value — of feeling confident or seen in a particular moment — became a surprising and meaningful part of their journey.A JOURNEY WITHOUT BLUEPRINTSNeither of the brothers had formal training in fashion or business. 'We learned everything on the go,' shares Aarush Bhola. 'From what print suits what fabric to how a small change in fit can change how something feels — it was all trial and feedback.'advertisementMistakes were part of the process, but so was learning. GROWING THROUGH COMMUNITY, NOT CAMPAIGNSUnlike typical marketing-led growth stories, theirs was quiet and organic. 'People just started tagging us,' says Sahil Bhola. 'Students wearing the clothes their way, sharing their looks. That's how it spread.'Their inboxes are still filled with first-time buyers sharing stories, selfies, and FORWARD WITHOUT LOSING BALANCEThe brothers are expanding slowly — exploring new categories, testing ideas — but staying grounded.'We're cautious about what we take on,' says Aarush Bhola. 'We want people to still feel like what they wear from us reflects who they are, not just what's trending.'In the end, it's not just about clothes. It's about what those clothes make people feel.'It's not about the logo,' says Sahil Bhola. It's about how you feel when you wear it — confident, expressive, like yourself. That's what people come back for.'advertisementIn a world of fleeting trends, their story stands out for its simplicity — two brothers building something honest, one shirt and one story at a no glossy playbook guiding Sahil Bhola and Aarush Bhola. Their choices are shaped less by trend forecasts and more by instinct, trial, and feedback. They're not in a rush to scale for the sake of it. What drives them is something quieter — a commitment to keep making clothes that feel personal, wearable, and story isn't a blueprint for success, but a reflection of how small ideas can take shape over time — through lived experience, mistakes, and a willingness to keep listening. The result is still evolving. And that's the point.- Ends
