logo
Karnataka's new misinformation bill can penalise social media users for honest mistakes

Karnataka's new misinformation bill can penalise social media users for honest mistakes

The Print27-06-2025
The Karnataka government now proposes to criminalise such false speech and create a parallel regime to central laws for the targeted blocking of online content. The bill will be sent to various departments for consultations before being presented before the state cabinet. In this piece, we will delve into the structural and enforcement infirmities of the bill.
Time and again, the Indian government takes up the task of regulating the menace of misinformation, which includes any information that is incorrect, and in most cases spread without the intention to deceive. By no stretch of imagination is this easy, but most policy interventions have focused on requiring social media intermediaries to restrict the sharing of false and/or superstitious content.
You capture an image of a Myna bird perched on your window sill and immediately post it on your social media account with the caption 'One for bad luck'. Careful. Sharing this superstition online could land you in prison for up to seven years under the Karnataka Misinformation and Fake News (Prohibition) Bill 2025.
Structural infirmities
The bill attempts to distinguish between 'fake news' and 'misinformation' and assigns penalties that range from five years for misinformation to seven years for fake news. It claims to differentiate between these two types of false speech, but the definitions reveal no difference as each describes speech that can influence the public through false or exaggerated information.
Determining intent is a challenge when scrutinising online false speech. Legal scholars have repeatedly warned against using catch-all phrases like 'fake news' to describe any form of false speech, as this term is often used by politicians to delegitimise criticism levied at them in modern-day public squares. And it also remains too vague to accurately define under law. Social media users may end up being penalised for honest mistakes and trivialities and social media companies may themselves over-censor to avoid penalties.
The bill criminalises speech that is factually incorrect and imposes unusually harsh penalties. Spreading fake news could get you the same prison time as that for kidnapping.
Communication of misinformation to any user within Karnataka is prohibited under the bill. But geo-fencing online speech is technologically hard. Digital natives can easily circumvent detection using virtual private networks (VPNs) for instance, evading accurate geolocation via proxy servers distributed globally. This sets the stage for a digital cat-and-mouse game, with the Karnataka police chasing anonymous users across a geographically unbound internet.
Also read: Internet can't be regulated like TV. Look at how UK, Australia are doing it
Enforcement concerns
The definition of 'communication' in the bill is wide enough to capture any other forms of communication, possibly extending to in-person communications, which is excessive. A prohibition on communication of misinformation also raises concerns about applicability to past communications or to situations where the recipient moves into the state post communication. Instances where the sender has no knowledge of the receiver's location will make compliance impossible.
The bill also provides for a six-member social media regulatory authority to enforce provisions related to fake news under the proposed law. But the authority's enforcement powers stand on shaky ground. For instance, the authority has the power to trigger punitive action under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS), yet 'fake news' as defined in the bill does not map onto any specific offence in the BNS.
The authority's powers are confined to fake news, excluding misinformation, despite the significant conceptual overlap between the two. Penalties for misinformation can be enforced through a standard legal process of filing a First Information Report (FIR) and finally adjudication by a court, all without the involvement of the authority. This framework makes the identification of illegal content difficult in instances like when a piece of content qualifies both as fake news and misinformation. How will the authority keep itself from adjudicating on aspects of the content that is misinformation?
The regulatory authority is also given a sweeping mandate to police a wide range of speech based on subjective standards. For instance, the authority is to monitor and pre-emptively block content deemed disrespectful to Sanatan Dharma, and which promotes superstition or is unscientific in nature. Imagine the enforcement burden on the six-member body to apply these standards to a deluge of complaints, especially given the speed of content circulation.
Beyond its many conceptual issues, the drafting of the bill is inelegant in multiple places with key terms left undefined, scope of penalties unclear, and vague obligations for social media companies. Such drafting, in a legislation with criminal penalties, is unfortunately common in both central and state laws and complicates both compliance and enforcement efforts. The design challenges with the proposed law do not end at definitional and structural inconsistencies, but also extend to constitutional and philosophical problems which we will explore in the subsequent article.
The authors work at Koan Advisory Group, a technology policy consulting firm. Views are personal.
This article is part of ThePrint-Koan Advisory series that analyses emerging policies, laws and regulations in India's technology sector. Read all the articles here.
(Edited by Aamaan Alam Khan)
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Punjab Cabinet approves Bill to make sale of spurious seeds non-bailable offence
Punjab Cabinet approves Bill to make sale of spurious seeds non-bailable offence

Indian Express

time3 minutes ago

  • Indian Express

Punjab Cabinet approves Bill to make sale of spurious seeds non-bailable offence

The Punjab Cabinet Friday gave its nod to introduce The Seeds (Punjab Amendment) Bill 2025 to make sale of spurious seeds a non-bailable offence. The decision was taken by the council of ministers at its meeting chaired by Chief Minister Bhagwant Mann. As per an official statement, the Cabinet gave its nod to introduce The Seeds (Punjab Amendment) Bill 2025 to ensure supply of high-quality seeds to the farmers of the state. 'There has been no amendment to Section 19 of the Seeds Act 1966 since its inception due to which the fines and penalties have no deterrence. So the Cabinet gave its nod to amend and insert Section 19A for contravention of Section 7 of the Seeds Act (Regulation of sales of seeds of notified kinds or varieties), enhancing the fine and penalty, and making it cognizable and non-bailable,' the statement said. As per the provision, the first offence by a company will invite punishment of one to two years and fine of Rs 5-10 lakh, and punishment of two to three years and fine of Rs 10-50 lakh for repeated offence. 'Similar misdeed by a dealer/person will invite a punishment of six months to one year and fine of Rs 1-5 lakh for the first offence and a term of 1 to 2 years and fine of Rs 5-10 lakh for repeated offence,' the statement said. Currrently, the fine is Rs 500 for first offence and Rs 1,000 and prison term of up to six months for repeat offence. The Cabinet also cleared a mechanism to provide land parcels on sale or lease to boost industrial and business investment, featuring a bi-annual digital land pool, investor facilitation for projects above Rs 200 crore, and e-auction procedures. In another key decision, the Cabinet approved an amendment in Rules 5 (b) and 5 (d) of the Punjab State (Group D) Service Rules, 1963, thereby enhancing the upper age limit for Group D recruitment from existing 35 years to 37 years. The council approved a one-time settlement (OTS) scheme to clear old loans under various industrial support programmes, with complete waivers for loans under the Punjab State Aid to Industries Act, 1935, and the Integrated Rural Development Programme. Accordingly, there will be a complete waiver of principal and interest for loans under IRDP and Punjab State Aid to Industries Act, 1935. The eligible units will be required to avail of the scheme and clear their dues within 180 days of publication of notice in newspapers. The Cabinet also gave its nod to the 'The Punjab Foodgrains Transportation Policy 2025′ and 'The Punjab Labour and Cartage Policy 2025′ for the smooth and hassle-free transportation of foodgrains in the state. The Punjab government through its state procurement agencies and FCI procures foodgrains from various designated centres/mandis. According to the new policy, during the year 2025, foodgrain transportation works will be allotted through a competitive and transparent online tender system. Other approvals included revising District Mineral Foundation rules, extending services of 951 veterinary staff, and amending VAT rules and temple advisory committees. Will develop robust semiconductor ecosystem: CM CM Mann said that the state government will make every possible effort to develop a robust semiconductor ecosystem in the state. Chairing a meeting with representatives of the semiconductor industry, Mann assured them of full support and cooperation, including the establishment of a dedicated semiconductor park in and around Mohali. He said Punjab offers a conducive industrial environment, a skilled workforce, and ample resources, making it an ideal destination for semiconductor investments. The industry, he noted, will not only spur industrial growth but also create significant employment opportunities for the youth. Mann emphasised the vital role semiconductor chips play in modern technology, stating that they are essential components in virtually all electronic devices. He added that semiconductors enable a wide range of functionalities from basic computation to advanced technologies. Mann highlighted the vast potential of the semiconductor industry, noting that it is currently experiencing an impressive annual growth.

PM Modi Becomes India's 2nd-Longest Serving PM, Felicitated in Maldives
PM Modi Becomes India's 2nd-Longest Serving PM, Felicitated in Maldives

NDTV

time3 minutes ago

  • NDTV

PM Modi Becomes India's 2nd-Longest Serving PM, Felicitated in Maldives

Male: In a moment infused with diplomatic grace and historical resonance, Maldives President Mohamed Muizzu on Friday extended heartfelt congratulations to the visiting Indian Prime Minister Narendra Modi, lauding his achievement as India's second-longest-serving PM in consecutive terms. Addressing a formal banquet in honour of Prime Minister Modi at Male, President Muizzu hailed the milestone of 4,078 consecutive days in office as emblematic of his "unwavering commitment to public service and dedication to the progress and prosperity of the Indian people". The ceremony reflected a warm reciprocation of bilateral goodwill. "Tonight we are delighted to reciprocate that friendship and goodwill in the spirit of the closed ties between the two nations. First of all let me convey my heartiest congratulation to your excellency on becoming second longest serving prime minister of India today. This remarkable milestone 4,078 consecutive days in the office is a testament to your unwavering commitment public service and dedication to the progress and prosperity of the Indian people," President Muizzu said. Prime Minister Modi arrived earlier in the day at Velana International Airport following his landmark visit to the UK. In a notable gesture, President Muizzu personally received him at the airport, accompanied by senior members of his Cabinet including the Foreign Minister, Defence Minister, Finance Minister and Minister of Homeland Security. PM Modi's visit is at the gracious invitation of President Muizzu, in the context of Maldives' 60th Independence Day celebrations, where he is participating as the Guest of Honour. The occasion is not only symbolic of the enduring ties between the two nations, but also a reminder of India's early recognition of Maldivian independence in 1965. The diplomatic encounter is seen as an opportunity to reframe bilateral relations and reaffirm mutual interests in the Indian Ocean region. The presence of Prime Minister Modi during such a landmark celebration signals India's continued support for regional stability, maritime cooperation, and cultural dialogue. Meanwhile, with the completion of 4,078 uninterrupted days in office, Prime Minister Modi surpasses the tenure of late former PM Indira Gandhi's unbroken stretch of 4,077 days between 1966 and 1977. This historic threshold consolidates PM Modi's place in India's political chronology and deepens the narrative of sustained leadership under his stewardship.

CISC Air Marshal Dixit to visit Australia to witness Exercise Talisman Sabre
CISC Air Marshal Dixit to visit Australia to witness Exercise Talisman Sabre

The Print

time3 minutes ago

  • The Print

CISC Air Marshal Dixit to visit Australia to witness Exercise Talisman Sabre

Six officers from the Indian armed forces are participating in Exercise Talisman Sabre 2025 (TS25) as 'staff planners at various levels of joint operations planning, control, safety and logistics', it said. It is a premier multilateral training activity led by the Australian Defence Force (ADF) and the United States Armed Forces and likely to see the participation from 19 nations, representing a wide spectrum of regional and global partners, the Indian defence ministry said in a statement. New Delhi, Jul 25 (PTI) Chief of Integrated Defence Staff (CISC), Air Marshal Ashutosh Dixit will visit Australia on July 26–28 to witness the 11th edition of the ongoing Exercise Talisman Sabre, officials said on Friday. Indian officers have earlier participated in 2021 and 2023 as 'Observers'. The Indian armed forces' participation in Exercise Talisman Sabre is a 'testimony to India's growing role in multilateral defence diplomacy and its active contribution to a stable Indo-Pacific', the ministry said in a statement. The exercise presents an invaluable opportunity to deepen military-to-military ties, exchange strategic insights and bolster India's vision of collaborative security engagement. During his visit, the CISC is scheduled to engage with senior military leaders from armed forces of Australia and other participating nations, and witness various training activities planned under TS25, the officials said. The visit underscores India's commitment to enhancing defence cooperation and strengthening interoperability with friendly foreign nations. It also reflects the growing stature of the Indian armed forces as a trusted partner in fostering regional security and collective preparedness for future contingencies, it said. 'TS25 will showcase extensive interoperability and joint warfare capabilities across air, land, maritime, space and cyber domains. It will feature complex live-fire drills, amphibious operations, integrated field training and realistic testbed for modern multi-domain operations in support of a free, open and inclusive Indo-Pacific,' the ministry said. PTI KND NB This report is auto-generated from PTI news service. ThePrint holds no responsibility for its content.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store