
Karnataka's new misinformation bill can penalise social media users for honest mistakes
Time and again, the Indian government takes up the task of regulating the menace of misinformation, which includes any information that is incorrect, and in most cases spread without the intention to deceive. By no stretch of imagination is this easy, but most policy interventions have focused on requiring social media intermediaries to restrict the sharing of false and/or superstitious content.
You capture an image of a Myna bird perched on your window sill and immediately post it on your social media account with the caption 'One for bad luck'. Careful. Sharing this superstition online could land you in prison for up to seven years under the Karnataka Misinformation and Fake News (Prohibition) Bill 2025.
Structural infirmities
The bill attempts to distinguish between 'fake news' and 'misinformation' and assigns penalties that range from five years for misinformation to seven years for fake news. It claims to differentiate between these two types of false speech, but the definitions reveal no difference as each describes speech that can influence the public through false or exaggerated information.
Determining intent is a challenge when scrutinising online false speech. Legal scholars have repeatedly warned against using catch-all phrases like 'fake news' to describe any form of false speech, as this term is often used by politicians to delegitimise criticism levied at them in modern-day public squares. And it also remains too vague to accurately define under law. Social media users may end up being penalised for honest mistakes and trivialities and social media companies may themselves over-censor to avoid penalties.
The bill criminalises speech that is factually incorrect and imposes unusually harsh penalties. Spreading fake news could get you the same prison time as that for kidnapping.
Communication of misinformation to any user within Karnataka is prohibited under the bill. But geo-fencing online speech is technologically hard. Digital natives can easily circumvent detection using virtual private networks (VPNs) for instance, evading accurate geolocation via proxy servers distributed globally. This sets the stage for a digital cat-and-mouse game, with the Karnataka police chasing anonymous users across a geographically unbound internet.
Also read: Internet can't be regulated like TV. Look at how UK, Australia are doing it
Enforcement concerns
The definition of 'communication' in the bill is wide enough to capture any other forms of communication, possibly extending to in-person communications, which is excessive. A prohibition on communication of misinformation also raises concerns about applicability to past communications or to situations where the recipient moves into the state post communication. Instances where the sender has no knowledge of the receiver's location will make compliance impossible.
The bill also provides for a six-member social media regulatory authority to enforce provisions related to fake news under the proposed law. But the authority's enforcement powers stand on shaky ground. For instance, the authority has the power to trigger punitive action under the Bharatiya Nyaya Sanhita, 2023 (BNS), yet 'fake news' as defined in the bill does not map onto any specific offence in the BNS.
The authority's powers are confined to fake news, excluding misinformation, despite the significant conceptual overlap between the two. Penalties for misinformation can be enforced through a standard legal process of filing a First Information Report (FIR) and finally adjudication by a court, all without the involvement of the authority. This framework makes the identification of illegal content difficult in instances like when a piece of content qualifies both as fake news and misinformation. How will the authority keep itself from adjudicating on aspects of the content that is misinformation?
The regulatory authority is also given a sweeping mandate to police a wide range of speech based on subjective standards. For instance, the authority is to monitor and pre-emptively block content deemed disrespectful to Sanatan Dharma, and which promotes superstition or is unscientific in nature. Imagine the enforcement burden on the six-member body to apply these standards to a deluge of complaints, especially given the speed of content circulation.
Beyond its many conceptual issues, the drafting of the bill is inelegant in multiple places with key terms left undefined, scope of penalties unclear, and vague obligations for social media companies. Such drafting, in a legislation with criminal penalties, is unfortunately common in both central and state laws and complicates both compliance and enforcement efforts. The design challenges with the proposed law do not end at definitional and structural inconsistencies, but also extend to constitutional and philosophical problems which we will explore in the subsequent article.
The authors work at Koan Advisory Group, a technology policy consulting firm. Views are personal.
This article is part of ThePrint-Koan Advisory series that analyses emerging policies, laws and regulations in India's technology sector. Read all the articles here.
(Edited by Aamaan Alam Khan)

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


India.com
21 minutes ago
- India.com
'Unparalleled courage, valor displayed by...': PM Modi, Prez Murmu lead nation in paying tributes to Kargil bravehearts
File/Archival Kargil Vijay Diwas: President Droupadi Murmu and Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Saturday led the nation in paying tributes to military personnel who fought valiantly in harsh conditions to hand Pakistan a crushing defeat in the 1999 Kargil conflict. On July 26 that year, the Indian Army announced the successful culmination of 'Operation Vijay', declaring victory after a nearly three-month-long battle on the icy heights of Kargil in Ladakh. India observes the day as 'Kargil Vijay Diwas' every year. Over 500 soldiers made supreme sacrifice in the conflict. In her message, President Murmu, who is also the Supreme Commander of the military, said: 'This day symbolises the extraordinary valor, courage, and steadfast determination of our jawans.' Modi said Kargil Vijay Diwas reminds the country of unparalleled courage and valour of its soldiers who sacrificed their lives in defending the country's pride. Various events were organised across the country, including at the Kargil War Memorial in Drass, to mark the occasion. In the event at Drass, Army Chief Gen Upendra Dwivedi, highlighting the Army's 'unique victory' on the Kargil peaks 26 years ago, said the military achieved a 'decisive victory' during Operation Sindoor as well continuing that tradition. 'It was the time when India made it clear that no evil intention will be allowed inside its borders, no harm will be allowed to the unity and integrity of India,' he said, referring to victory in Kargil. 'Continuing this tradition, during Operation Sindoor too, Indian military with the same indomitable courage and firm resolve targeted Pakistan backed terrorist infrastructure and thwarted other aggressive actions of Pakistan with effective pretense and achieved a decisive victory,' he said. 'Operation Sindoor is our resolve, message and answer,' he said. The Army Chief further added: 'With the unwavering trust of the countrymen and the political freedom granted by the government, the Indian armed forces gave a determined, precise and decisive response.' In his message, Chief of Defence Staff Gen Anil Chauhan said the Kargil conflict remains a stark reminder of Pakistan's 'treachery' and that India's adversaries will continue to test its resolve. But the nation will always come out victorious over the enemy's 'deceit and aggression' as was evident in Operation Sindoor, he added. Defence Minister Rajnath Singh also paid glowing tributes to the military personnel who made supreme sacrifices in the conflict. 'On Kargil Vijay Diwas, I pay heartfelt tributes to our bravehearts who displayed extraordinary courage, grit and determination in defending our nation's honour in the toughest of terrains,' Singh said. 'Their supreme sacrifice during Kargil war is a timeless reminder of the unwavering resolve of our Armed Forces. India shall remain forever indebted to their service,' he said in a social media post. Singh and the top military brass also paid tributes to the fallen heroes at the National War Memorial. In his remarks, Chief of Defence Staff Gen Chauhan said Kargil Vijay Diwas is not only about remembering the past but also about drawing inspirations for the future. 'Our adversaries will continue to test our resolve, but the legacy of Kargil reminds us that our jointness, preparedness and unwavering courage — proven once again by the success of Operation Sindoor — will always triumph over the enemy's deceit and aggression,' he said. Gen Chauhan said Kargil Vijay Diwas reminds every Indian of the unparalleled bravery and patriotism of the valiant soldiers who fought fearlessly to safeguard India's territorial integrity as also, the 'bitter truth of Pakistan's betrayal'. 'Pakistan Army's ploy to extend the conflict beyond the Great Himalayan Range by sending regular troops disguised as Mujahideens, remains a stark reminder of their treachery,' he said. Chief of the Naval Staff Admiral Dinesh K Tripathi said the legacy of the Kargil 'bravehearts' stands as a testament to the unwavering devotion to the service of the nation. 'Your sacrifice will remain a beacon of inspiration, not only for future citizens of our country but also for those who choose to serve in the defence forces with 'Duty-Honour-Courage!',' he added. Chief of the Air Staff Air Chief Marshal A P Singh the Indian Air Force remains committed to defend the sovereignty of the nation and uphold the proud traditions of courage, honour and duty as exemplified by the bravehearts. (Only the headline has been reworked by staff. Copy comes from an agency feed)


India Today
33 minutes ago
- India Today
Sent Rs 3 lakh crore to Tamil Nadu: PM refutes MK Stalin's claim on central funds
Prime Minister Narendra Modi on Saturday refuted Tamil Nadu Chief Minister MK Stalin's claim that the state was denied its rightful share of funds by the Centre, and said that Rs 3 lakh crore was disbursed to the south Indian state in the last 10 years, which was thrice as much as the UPA government released from 2004 to 2014. The PM said that as many as 11 new medical colleges have also been set up in Tamil Nadu in the last 11 years with the Centre's help. Notably, DMK chief Stalin has been continuously complaining about the Modi government not releasing enough funds for Tamil Nadu. After the Niti Aayog meeting in New Delhi in May, Stalin said that due to a few states not signing the Memorandum of Understanding (MoU) with the Ministry of Education on the PM Shri scheme, the Samagra Shiksha Abhiyan funding was denied. He said that specifically, for the year 2024-2025, nearly Rs 2,200 crore in Union funding was withheld from Tamil Nadu. On Saturday, PM Modi addressed a public rally in Tamil Nadu's Thoothukudi, where he inaugurated infrastructural projects worth Rs 4,900 crore. PM Modi reached Thoothukudi directly from the Maldives where he completed a two-day state visit and signed a number of key agreements with President Mohamed Muizzu.


Time of India
36 minutes ago
- Time of India
2 B'deshi ‘smugglers' shot dead in Tripura
Agartala: Two suspected Bangladeshi smugglers were shot dead by the BSF at the international border in South Tripura, officials said on Saturday. They further said another Bangladeshi individual had been injured in the firing, while two Indian smugglers were arrested. "BSF personnel were keeping a vigil along the border area, when they spotted a major smuggling attempt. As they tried to intercept, the smugglers got violent. In self-defence, the security personnel opened fire," a senior BSF officer said. "Three smugglers received gunshot wounds and fell to the ground. While one of them died on the spot, two others were taken back to Bangladesh by their companions," he said. They were taken to a health centre in Bangladesh, where one of them died. The other person is undergoing treatment there, he added. PTI