Barring members under 5 years from polls could kill PKR, say analysts
PETALING JAYA : PKR runs the risk of losing capable new leaders if the party prohibits members of less than five years standing from contesting in its internal polls, say political analysts.
Mazlan Ali.
Mazlan Ali of Universiti Teknologi Malaysia and Universiti Malaysia Sabah's Syahruddin Awang Ahmad said PKR deputy president Rafizi Ramli's proposal would prevent younger Malaysians from using the party as a platform to bring meaningful change to the country.
They said the proposal could result in stagnation within PKR's leadership, hindering the party's ability to cultivate and advance fresh, talented leaders.
'Rafizi's idea could kill off PKR and prevent it from having a dynamic leadership in the future,' Mazlan told FMT.
Syahruddin said the proposed requirement would indirectly hinder the entry of fresh talent capable of bringing new ideas and perspectives to the party.
Syahruddin Awang Ahmad
'This risks causing a sort of 'brain drain', with talented individuals choosing to join other parties that offer a faster path (to leadership), undermining PKR's efforts to remain relevant and dynamic in the political landscape,' he said.
Rafizi had called for party rules to be amended to prevent candidates with less than five years' standing from contesting for positions, saying the move would improve party discipline and ensure loyalty.
The PKR deputy president said the current system allowed newcomers to jump straight into leadership roles, sometimes with the approval of the party president, when they should 'start from the bottom'.
Sungai Buloh MP R Ramanan, a former MIC treasurer-general, joined PKR in 2020 after quitting the Indian-based party six years earlier. Ramanan is vying for the post of vice-president at this year's party polls, scheduled to be held on Friday.
Mazlan said a two-year period would be generally sufficient to determine if a member was loyal and committed to the party, adding that there was no need to be too restrictive.
He said the requirement could vary according to the seniority of the position in the party, with a five-year prohibition proposed for those gunning to be vice-president for example.
'For posts at the grassroots level, there shouldn't be a requirement for a candidate to have been a member for five years. Maybe just a year or less to encourage the emergence of new leaders.
'But for the PKR president's post, perhaps a 10-year membership requirement followed by seven years for the deputy presidency, and so on.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Malay Mail
27 minutes ago
- Malay Mail
‘Bring it': Amanah lawmaker dares Opposition to table no-confidence vote against Anwar
KUALA LUMPUR, July 29 — A backbencher challenged the Opposition to to translate its street protests last week into parliamentary action today by tabling a vote of no confidence against Prime Minister Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim. Referring to the #TurunAnwar rally on Saturday, Mohd Sany Hamzan (PH - Hulu Langat) said the Opposition had suggested that it could table such a motion in Parliament, adding that Anwar has also said his political rivals were welcome to try. 'But it has already been two days since the parliamentary meeting began, and we have yet to see any such motion tabled. 'So now, we challenge them to bring that motion forward,' Mohd Sany said during Question Time today. Opposition Leader Datuk Seri Hamzah Zainudin reportedly said during the rally that Perikatan Nasional was considering submitting such a motion to Dewan Rakyat Speaker Tan Sri Johari Abdul "in the near future." Thousands reportedly attended the rally in Kuala Lumpur last weekend to demand Anwar's resignation as the prime minister. Anwar currently has supermajority support in the Dewan Rakyat, either directly from lawmakers in the National Unity Government coalition or indirectly from those informally aligned.
Malaysiakini
an hour ago
- Malaysiakini
Just join unity govt, at least you can get DPM post, Maszlee tells PAS
PAS would be better off joining the coalition government instead of sticking with Perikatan Nasional, said PKR central leadership member Maszlee Malik. He said the Islamist party clearly has no confidence in PN chairperson Muhyiddin Yassin and opposition chief Hamzah Zainudin.
Malay Mail
an hour ago
- Malay Mail
Thai army accuses Cambodia of violating truce hours after deal to end deadly border clashes
SURIN (Thailand), July 29 — Thailand's army accused Cambodia Tuesday of violating an hours-old truce, saying clashes continued despite a deal meant to end the bloody fighting that engulfed their jungle-clad frontier. Following peace talks in Malaysia on Monday, both sides agreed an unconditional ceasefire would start at midnight to end fighting over a smattering of ancient temples in disputed zones along their 800-kilometre border. 'At the time the agreement took effect, the Thai side detected that Cambodian forces had launched armed attacks into several areas within Thai territory,' said Thai army spokesman Winthai Suwaree. 'This constitutes a deliberate violation of the agreement and a clear attempt to undermine mutual trust, he added in a statement. 'Thailand is compelled to respond appropriately, exercising its legitimate right to self-defense.' Cambodia's defence ministry spokeswoman Maly Socheata insisted there had been 'no armed clashes against each other in any regions'. However, both sides said morning meetings scheduled between opposing regional commanders along the border as part of the truce pact had either begun or were still scheduled to start. In Cambodia's Samraong city — 20 kilometres from the border — an AFP journalist said the sound of blasts stopped in the 30 minutes leading up to midnight, with the lull continuing until dawn. 'The frontline has eased since the ceasefire at 12 midnight,' Cambodian Prime Minister Hun Manet said in a Tuesday morning message on Facebook. Jets, rockets and artillery have killed at least 38 people since last Thursday and displaced nearly 300,000 more — prompting intervention from US President Donald Trump over the weekend. The flare-up was the deadliest since violence raged sporadically from 2008-2011 over the territory, claimed by both because of a vague demarcation made by Cambodia's French colonial administrators in 1907. 'When I heard the news I was so happy because I miss my home and my belongings that I left behind,' Phean Neth told AFP on Monday evening at a sprawling camp for Cambodian evacuees on a temple site away from the fighting. 'I am so happy that I can't describe it,' said the 45-year-old. 'Good faith' A joint statement from both countries — as well as Malaysia which hosted the peace talks — said the ceasefire was 'a vital first step towards de-escalation and the restoration of peace and security'. A spokesman for UN Secretary General Antonio Guterres said in a statement Monday evening that 'he urges both countries to respect the agreement fully and to create an environment conducive to addressing long-standing issues and achieving lasting peace'. Both sides are courting Trump for trade deals to avert his threat of eye-watering tariffs, and the US State Department said its officials had been 'on the ground' to shepherd peace talks. The joint statement said China also had 'active participation' in the talks, hosted by Malaysian Prime Minister and Asean bloc chair Datuk Seri Anwar Ibrahim in his country's administrative capital Putrajaya. Hun Manet thanked Trump for his 'decisive' support, while his counterpart, Thai acting Prime Minister Phumtham Wechayachai, said it should be 'carried out in good faith by both sides'. 'If they say they'll stop firing, they must stop completely,' said 43-year-old Thai evacuee Prapakarn Samruamjit in the city of Surin. Post-truce tariff deals Thai King Maha Vajiralongkorn marked his 73rd birthday on Monday, but a notice in the country's Royal Gazette said public celebrations scheduled for Bangkok's Grand Palace had been cancelled amid the strife. Each side had already agreed to a truce in principle, while accusing the other of undermining peace efforts and trading allegations about the use of cluster bombs and targeting of hospitals. Thailand says 11 of its soldiers and 14 civilians have been killed, while Cambodia has confirmed only eight civilian and five military deaths. More than 138,000 people have fled Thailand's border regions, while around 140,000 have been driven from their homes in Cambodia. — AFP
