Government urged to ‘get its act together' over third-level fees plan
Minister for Finance Paschal Donohoe became the latest minister to refuse to confirm Government plans over third-level fees.
Advertisement
The student contribution fee has been temporarily reduced for the past three years as part of cost-of-living packages accompanying the budget.
The fees had been €3,000 before being temporarily cut by €1,000, saving families with multiple children at third level thousands of euros per academic year.
Social Democrats TD Jennifer Whitmore told the Dail that students and families have been 'led down the garden path' by the Government and they are 'absolutely sick of its games'.
Earlier this week, Higher Education Minister James Lawless said that student contribution fees will increase as there is no cost-of-living package to pay for what were temporary reductions introduced amid an inflation crisis.
Advertisement
He said that fees will have to be reset, which means they will revert to the same level as previous years.
He added that 'all of us in any walk of life have to play the hands we're dealt'.
Ms Whitmore described these comments as 'utterly galling and incredibly tone deaf'.
'When will the Government get its act together and level with parents and students?' the Wicklow TD added.
Advertisement
'It has been five days since the higher education minister took to the airways and dropped the bombshell that parents and students will have to find another €1,000 to fund college before September.
'He did not try to sugarcoat that news – it was quite the opposite. A member of Government actively stacking the deck against students and families, essentially telling them to suck it up – that is what he said – and play the bum hand they have been dealt.'
Sinn Féin TD Matt Carthy said the minister 'clearly stated' that without a cost-of-living package in October's budget, college fees will rise by €1,000.
This, he said, was backed up by Taoiseach Micheál Martin.
Advertisement
'Let us clear up this mess today,' he urged Mr Donohoe.
'I have just one simple question for the minister and it is the same question that has been anxiously asked at kitchen tables all over the country.
'When students get their bill in September, how much will they be asked to pay? Will it be €2,000 or €3,000?
'Students and their families need an answer to that question today. It is the only question I have for the minister.'
Advertisement
Mr Donohoe answered by outlining the supports available to students.
He said that one in three students do not pay a student contribution.
He told the Dáil that half of students use the SUSI scheme, and that households with an income of up to 64,000 euro do not pay a student contribution.
The Fine Gael minister added: 'Budget by budget, we make changes we believe are affordable which recognise the challenges there.
'That is why we will do what we normally do in the approaching budget. We will put in place measures, including those to deal with the cost of becoming a student and the challenge many families face, we know are affordable, can be funded and can be built upon in the years ahead.
'The minister, deputy Lawless, myself and the Minister for Public Expenditure and Reform, deputy (Jack) Chambers, are clear on what that objective is.
'We are clear that temporary measures in place when inflation was high need to be looked at as well as how we can put in place other measures that can make a difference to something we know is an acute difficulty for many and those who are already receiving needed supports.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
6 hours ago
- BBC News
North Yorkshire voters' messages to new MPs year on from election
A year on from Labour's landslide General Election victory, we asked voters in two North Yorkshire seats that changed hands for the first time in years if they had seen any change and what their priorities were for their new Lee works as a waitress in Harrogate, a seat won by Liberal Democrat Tom Gordon from the Conservatives in the poll on 4 July said she left her home town after being asked for a combined £1,600 up front to rent a flat and went to live in nearby Leeds where tenancies are 31-year-old is now planning to move back, but will only be able to afford to if she moves in with her partner, and wants her local MP to push for cheaper housing. "There is nothing for a single person to afford," she said. Tourism and hospitality play a crucial part in Harrogate's economy, but Caitlin said a number of her friends who also worked in the sector could not afford to live in the town."It is really hard to find places to live that match our wages," she said. "If I had tried to move into somewhere on my own, the rent would have taken most of my salary. "I'm moving in with my partner so that situation is fine for me, but for a single person there is nothing." For husband and wife Paul and Rachel Flatters, who also live in Harrogate, the new government's first year has been one of worry about the cost of living - and plans for welfare said: "Everything is so expensive. We're trying to manage in the best way we can but all you can think about is paying the bills."Rachel said the couple both received personal independence payments (Pip) and the government's plans for welfare reform were "frightening.""We want our MP to fight those cuts in parliament," Rachel said. Their new MP said he had challenged the government on its welfare reforms "multiple times" and voted against the changes in the big Commons confrontation earlier this week."The government's plans to cut Pip were ill-thought through and foolish," said Gordon. "Pip empowers many disabled people to live more independently, helping to cover the increased costs that come with a disability."He said his Harrogate and Knaresborough constituency "desperately needs" more high-standard affordable and social housing."We also need to see developers held to account to provide the badly-needed infrastructure to support new housing, whether that's improved public and active transport, GPs and NHS services or schools," Gordon added. Sixty miles east is the seat of Scarborough and Whitby, the scene of another Conservative loss last year, this time to Labour's Alison first voter we met there was Sheena O'Sullivan, who raised a long-running complaint, the lack of progress on improvements to the A64. There have been calls for decades for the stretch of road between York and Malton to be upgraded to a dual carriageway to ease congestion."We haven't seen any change on this at all," said Sheena, who lives in Scarborough. "I was hopeful Labour could deliver some change, but I didn't have much confidence, unfortunately."Last week I was in a traffic jam for two-and-a-half hours in the heat. It is so frustrating." Eighteen-year-old Lewis Fawthrop, who is also from the resort, said young people in his home town needed more things to do that they could afford. "We were going to do an escape room, but it was £88 for the four of us. That's not something everyone can afford to do," said the who moved to Scarborough from Bradford, said: "It was fun at first when I moved over, going to the beach every day, but it got boring after a while. There's not much else to do except for the arcades."He said that if the town had youth clubs, he and his friends "probably" would have gone."We would have looked at them, depending what they were doing," he added. Hume said: "The government has committed to a strategy for young people and, in March, a national listening exercise was launched to allow young people to feed into this. Our youth guarantee means every 18 to 21-year-old in England gets access to education, training, or help to find a job or an said improving the A64 was one of more than 30 schemes identified by National Highways and Department for Transport that is being considered for delivery from 2030 added: "Major projects such as this typically go through eight consultation stages and the National Highways have completed most of stage two. York and North Yorkshire CA has also been awarded a bus franchise pilot." Listen to highlights from North Yorkshire on BBC Sounds, catch up with the latest episode of Look North.
Daily Mail
14 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Families are £1,700 worse off only one year on from Labour's loveless landslide - as critics say it is the 'worst start to a government in living memory'
Families are up to £1,700 worse off after one year of a Labour Government, according to an analysis. The Conservatives said Britons were suffering under the 'worst start to a government in living memory' – but warned there is more to come. According to the Tories' analysis, Labour has left families paying an extra £1,761 a year, adding that further tax rises are 'inevitable' – and could see the sum reach almost £3,000 by the end of the year. The Tories calculated that energy bills have risen by £152 since the election, while council tax will rise by £109 on average this year. Water bills are set to rise by an average of £123 a year, car tax and TV licences have been hiked by £5 and the average phone bill has gone up by £46. Meanwhile groceries and takeaways are up by £210, nursery fees have jumped by £756 for a child under two in a part-time nursery, and broadband has risen by an average of £36. The Tories also included an £11 'Chagos surrender tax' and the employer national insurance 'jobs tax', which the party said would cost families £308. Shadow Chancellor Mel Stride said: 'In just 12 months, Labour has taken a wrecking ball to the economy – and it's working families who are left to pick up the bill. 'This is the worst start to a government in living memory but the pain isn't over. Autumn's tax hikes are now all but inevitable. This is chaos created in Downing Street.' It comes as new polling suggests Labour has seen a double-digit drop in support. Sir Keir Starmer's party has averaged 24 per cent in polls in the last month, down ten points from 34 per cent in the weeks following the so-called loveless landslide election victory a year ago. While a slide in the polls after taking power is common, a drop of this size in unusual. A Labour spokesman said: 'Just as they didn't in Liz Truss's mini-Budget, the Tories' sums still don't add up. 'Through Labour's Plan for Change, wages are rising faster than prices, mortgage rates have come down, three million of the lowest earners have had a pay boost, and Britain has the highest economic growth in the G7.
BreakingNews.ie
16 hours ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Harris says Ireland and US should work ‘every hour' on tariff deal
Ireland and the US should 'use every hour' to reach a zero-for-zero tariff settlement in as many areas as possible, the Tánaiste has told the new US ambassador. On the eve of US Independence Day on Friday, new ambassador to Ireland Edward Walsh hosted Fourth of July celebrations on the lawn of the Deerfield Residence in Phoenix Park. Advertisement Simon Harris was among guests at Mr Walsh's first public appearance since presenting his credentials to President Michael D Higgins on Tuesday. Outside the star-spangled celebration, scores of protesters gathered outside the main entrance to the estate chanting: 'They feast, Gaza starves.' The demonstrators gathered to shout 'shame' at attendees over the US government's military support for Israel's war in Gaza. Protesters outside the US Ambassador Deerfield Residence in Phoenix Park (Brian Lawless/PA) Barriers erected as part of a heightened security presence around the residence were adorned with pro-Palestinian banners and posters calling for an end for US military use of Shannon Airport. Advertisement Inside, the US Embassy had invited 2,500 guests which included members of the Oireachtas, media figures, and business leaders. Shortly after 8pm, as a band played James Bond theme Live And Let Die, the ambassador walked out of the residence to the garden party with Riverdance creator Michael Flatley. Mr Harris shook hands with Mr Flatley outside a hotdog stand, having already met the ambassador inside the residence. All three took to the stage for renditions of the US and Irish national anthems, a colour guard, speeches and Flatley performing on a flute. Advertisement Mr Walsh told those gathered: 'I have been told that this is the best job in the entire world — and having been here a week, and I feel like that's the truth.' Mr Walsh told the crowd that the gathering for the US's 249th Independence Day was an opportunity to deepen relationships between the two countries. He said he and his family were happy to make the residence his new home, although they were still figuring out the light switches. US Marines flag bearers as the new US Ambassador to Ireland Edward S Walsh hosts July 4 celebrations at Deerfield Residence in Phoenix Park (Brian Lawless/PA) Expressing gratitude to president Donald Trump for appointing him to the role, he said he would work to strengthen the relationships between the US and Ireland. Advertisement 'I stand before you as a businessman, a family man, and someone who deeply values the ties that bind communities together, from the boardroom to the golf course. 'As the new US ambassador to Ireland, I look forward to building lasting relationships, communicating openly, and embracing all that brings our peoples together.' He relayed an anecdote from his grandmother that: 'God made the Germans to be serious, the French sophisticated, the Italians passionate – but no one was having fun, so he created the Irishman.' To a muted response, he said: 'You can cheer for that one.' Advertisement Having received a more enthusiastic reaction, Mr Walsh concluded his speech by asking the audience to 'cheers' for the support of his family, Mr Trump, and Ireland. Mr Walsh introduced his wife Lynn; his daughter Maggie and her husband, Matthew Kelly; and his daughter Anna and her fiance, Pat Beljan. His daughter Rachel was at home in New Jersey with her husband, Joe McGrath, and their two children. Mr Harris said the US and Ireland have been 'intertwined in each other's stories' through a shared history and cultural exchange, adding that Americans had played an important role in the Northern Ireland peace process. He said the economic relationship between the two countries was of 'immense mutual benefit'. 'As I speak tonight, I am conscious that we are just days away from the deadline when the US pause on placing tariffs on EU goods, and therefore on Irish goods, will be reached.' He added: 'Let's use every hour between then to reach a deal.' The new US ambassador to Ireland Edward S Walsh (left), with Michael Flatley (Brian Lawless/PA) Mr Harris said Ireland wanted to see a 'zero-for-zero' tariff approach in as many areas as possible, adding that uncertainty and instability 'helps no one'. 'With some of the most important voices in the Irish and US business communities here tonight, let me say again loud and clear – we want and we need to see an agreement reached between the EU and the US.' Adding that 'true friendship is not measured by constant agreement', the Tánaiste changed direction in his speech to express Ireland's concerns about the 'ongoing situation in Gaza'. 'Ireland has always unreservedly condemned Hamas as a terrorist organisation. 'We stand for Israel's right to live in peace.' He added: 'But we also want the bombs to stop, the killing to stop and we, as I know you do, want to see a ceasefire where humanitarian aid can get to people suffering.' Mr Harris said Ireland would honour its history by putting its reputation on the line in the search for peace, adding that its concerns in Gaza reflect a 'heartfelt commitment to humanitarian principles'. He told the ambassador that Ireland and the US had the ability to engage honestly and respectively even when perspectives differ. 'When friends speak candidly to one another, it strengthen rather than weakens their bond.'
