Pay increases, worker safety top issues for Baltimore DPW workers after two deaths on the job
"We've had huge challenges with worker safety at DPW. We know that we've had workers die at DPW. We've had over 1,600 injuries in five years in the sanitation department at DPW," Baltimore City Council President Zeke Cohen said.
DPW workers voice union concerns
Conditions became so bad, some workers did not even have access to toilet paper or proper bathroom facilities.
ore
CBS News Baltimore
The unions have come under fire from some workers who claimed they were out of touch.
Several who spoke to the inspector general criticized AFSCME, saying their "presence has been non-existent, and the union has not advocated for the workers in the last few years. One worker opined that Local 44 is absent until something drastic happens, like when a worker dies…"
"They're lying to you all. We are tired of them. That's why we're here," said Stancil McNair, at a heated city council legislative oversight hearing on March 20. "More of us came to this hearing than we do to a union meeting. That's sad. And they're still playing games. Still playing games."
WJZ Investigator Mike Hellgren asked the unions about these concerns.
"Our goal is to protect all of you," said Antoinette Ryan-Johnson, President of City Union of Baltimore, which represents DPW supervisors. "If that means that I need to take the bow, I will do so, but we need you to be our eyes and ears."
Two DPW deaths raise alarm
After the deaths of Baltimore DPW employees Ronald Silver II and Timothy Cartwell in 2024, union leaders said Monday they will follow through on their promises to keep workers safe.
"Today, we mourn the dead, but mourning is not enough. We fight for the living—for every worker who has been ever told to suck it up instead of speak up," said Courtney Jenkins, the president of the Metropolitan Baltimore Council of AFL-CIO unions.
The city has not provided substantive updates in months on the death of Cartwell. He was crushed by a trash truck.
Silver died after repeatedly begging for help in the extreme heat.
"He was not replaceable," Faith Johnson, Silver's mother, said last month, her voice breaking. "He was not replaceable to us. I'm still trying to figure out how life looks without him."
New safeguards are already in place statewide. The city is also implementing new heat standards.
"This summer, Maryland will be only one of six states in the country that offers these protections" said Scott Schneider, the former director of occupational safety for the Laborers International Union. "It came too late for Ronald Silver, but we hope that as we remember him today on Workers' Memorial Day, his death helped prevent others from having to suffer or die of heat exposures."
Fighting for pay raises
Right now, union leaders and the city are negotiating pay raises.
The average sanitation worker earns just 15 cents an hour in hazard pay and a little more than $42,000 annually, which many said is not enough to feed their families.
Right now, union leaders and the city are negotiating pay raises.
CBS News Baltimore
"It is the expectation of this city council that those workers will get a raise, and it will be a meaningful raise," Cohen said.
Last week, the city council president joined sanitation workers on the job.
Several members of the Baltimore City Council and union leaders remembered two workers who died on the job in 2024 and vowed to improve safety and increase wages.
CBS News Baltimore
"It is hard work. It is backbreaking work, and they deserve more," Cohen said.
The negotiations are private, and union leaders declined to comment on specific progress Monday, but Cohen noted the DPW director has committed to providing a pay increase.
Just weeks ago, Baltimore City signed new contracts with top leaders, with several earning more than $250,000 a year.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBS News
3 days ago
- CBS News
Family of Ronald Silver II sues Baltimore over DPW worker's heat-related death
The family of Ronald Silver II, a Baltimore Department of Public Works employee who died while working in extreme heat last year, is suing the City of Baltimore, attorney Thiru Vignarajah announced Thursday. Travis Christian, a co-worker who was with Silver on the day of his death, is also a plaintiff in the lawsuit. The lawsuit accuses the city of violating civil rights laws and forcing employees to work in unsafe conditions. In a notice of litigation, Vignarajah said DPW employees were afraid to report poor working conditions due to fear of being fired, especially those working as a condition of probation. He also said the department failed to inform workers about the risks of heat exposure or how to respond to symptoms of illness. "For years, DPW has operated a system of labor that demands that its workers, many of whom have prior criminal convictions, perform grueling manual labor in dangerous, subhuman conditions for laughable wages," Vignarajah said in a statement Thursday. "The agency has perpetuated a system where workers cannot ask for assistance, complain about their plight, or even quit—because if they do, they face retaliation, termination, and jail time." Silver, 35, died of hyperthermia on Aug. 2, 2024, while on his trash route, according to a report by the Maryland Occupational Safety and Health agency (MOSH) released in April. In March 2025, the Baltimore Office of the Inspector General (OIG) issued a detailed report outlining the events of that day, including accounts from witnesses and video evidence. Christian told investigators that the truck's air conditioning system was not functioning. He said Silver began feeling unwell several hours into his shift, but declined to rest, fearing the truck driver might report him to management. Silver collapsed twice that day. The first time, Christian said he found him lying face down, with scrapes on his hands and elbows and going in and out of consciousness. Christian described Silver's body as "limp and lifeless" as he lifted him into the truck. Later, Silver collapsed again while approaching a home to seek help. A witness attempted to assist and called 911. Silver was transported to the hospital, where he died. The OIG report said DPW workers feared retaliation for stopping work due to illness and described a culture that discouraged breaks even in dangerous heat. It also noted a longstanding pattern of excessive route demands, poor vehicle conditions, and lack of rest periods. MOSH cited the department for a "serious" safety violation, stating DPW failed to provide a safe working environment free from known hazards, including extreme heat. The agency also found that DPW lacked any heat safety training before Silver's death. It cited 14 heat-related injuries between 2021 and 2024, although the OIG identified 29 such cases. In response, DPW said it began implementing a Heat Illness Prevention Plan and requested additional time to comply. Silver's family has repeatedly said his death was preventable. They claim DPW ignored years of internal reports warning of unsafe conditions. "Mr. Silver's death was absolutely preventable and was the direct, predictable result of a city agency that treats its workers like indentured laborers," Vignarajah said in a March statement. "DPW's practices were designed to lock in a culture of silence and subjugation, and Ronald Silver II paid the ultimate price." Silver's family spoke to WJZ in November 2024, as they were grieving his loss. "I just love my son, and I miss him. I just want the world to know that my son did mean something. He wasn't just a trash man," Silver's father said in part.
Yahoo
4 days ago
- Yahoo
Silver's hot streak gathers pace; market at highest since 2011
By Polina Devitt and Sherin Elizabeth Varghese (Reuters) -Silver prices surged to their highest in almost 14 years on Wednesday, aided by worries about U.S. tariff policy, signs of tightness in the spot market and growing investor interest in alternatives to gold. Spot silver was up 0.3% at $39.40 per troy ounce as of 1354 GMT, its highest level since September 2011. Silver, both a precious and industrial metal, is up 36% this year, outperforming gold's 31% growth and coming within a whisker of the key $40-per-ounce mark. The metal hit a record high of $49 in 2011. U.S. President Donald Trump's plan to impose 50% import tariffs on copper from August 1 and the U.S. import tariffs for Mexico widened the premium of the U.S. futures for silver and other metals against the London benchmarks in July, leading to a growth in lease rates in the spot market. Gold, silver, platinum and palladium were excluded from Trump's April reciprocal tariffs, but "the broader market isn't trading it that way and is taking a page out of Comex copper's handbook", Nicky Shiels, head of metals strategy at MKS PAMP. Spot silver prices may hit $42 per ounce this year, according to Shiels. Analysts also noted that industrial demand for silver, heading for the fifth year of structural market deficit, remains solid, while investment demand is gaining momentum as a more affordable alternative to gold. Silver's recent rally has improved its ratio with gold to the strongest level in seven months. It currently takes 87 ounces of silver to buy an ounce of gold, compared with 105 ounces in April. "It is the copper tariff that sent some spinning off at odd tangents that captured the other metals," said a precious metal trader based in London, adding that the lease rates in the spot market should fall once the borrowing activity caused by the U.S. tariff fears subside. The current momentum could be hot enough to take silver over $40/oz in the short term, said Nitesh Shah, commodity strategist at WisdomTree. "But with positioning stretched, we would not be surprised if it fell back to $35/oz, before it starts its march higher to $45/oz next year," Shah added. Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
Yahoo
5 days ago
- Yahoo
Calgary sees big decline in crime severity, now well below the national average
Alberta's crime severity index — a measure used by Statistics Canada to track the seriousness of crime across the country — fell sharply in 2024, while Calgary's index reached a near-historic low. "Crime was nine-per-cent less severe in Alberta in 2024 than it was in 2023," said Warren Silver, an analyst with StatsCan, which released the new figures Tuesday. He attributes the drop to fewer break-and-enters, thefts and sexual assaults across the province. "And additionally there were 19 fewer homicides in Alberta than the previous year," Silver said. The crime severity index for Calgary, specifically, fell by 14 per cent to 62.3. That's now well below the national average of 77.9, which marks a notable turnaround from five years earlier, when the city was well above the national average. Calgary's index is also near its lowest point ever recorded, which was 61.1 in 2014. Insp. Travis Juska with the Calgary Police Service says those numbers are encouraging, but he recognizes not all Calgarians necessarily feel safer. "Just because we've seen a decrease in certain amounts of property crime or violent crime, doesn't mean that a Calgarian might feel safe or unsafe in a setting that they are somewhere in the city," he said. The StatsCan data shows crime rates (measured in terms of incidents per 100,000 people) are generally down across most types of offences in Calgary. But the rate of violent crime, while down from 2023, remains significantly higher than it was at its low point in 2013. Crime severity also dropped significantly in Lethbridge, falling 19 per cent year-over-year to an index score of 105.5. Mayor Blaine Hyggen attributed the downward trend to recent investments in the city's police service, including 26 new police officers and four new peace officers who were sworn in last year. Lethbridge Police Service Deputy Chief Gerald Grobmeier said the city saw reductions in break and enters, mischief, and car theft, in particular. Red Deer also saw a big drop in its crime severity index, which was down 20 per cent year-over-year to 118.7. Edmonton, meanwhile, was down 5 per cent to 101.1. Despite these decreases, Red Deer, Lethbridge and Edmonton remained on the higher end of crime severity across the 40 cities that Statistics Canada tracks. The overall crime severity index for Alberta remained the third-highest of all the provinces, at 95.6. Only Manitoba, at 141.2, and Saskatchewan, at 153.9, were higher. StatsCan calculates the index by assigning all police-reported crimes a weight based on their seriousness, which is determined by actual sentences handed down by courts. More serious crimes are assigned higher weights, less serious offences are assigned lower weights. The year 2006 is taken as a baseline and assigned a national index score of 100.
