Scottish couple lose legal challenge of winter fuel payment cuts
A couple have lost a bid to sue the UK and Scottish governments over the decision to cut winter fuel payments.Pensioners Peter and Flo Fanning, from Coatbridge in North Lanarkshire, took their case to the Court of Session in Edinburgh in March, alleging that both governments failed to adequately consult with those of pension age and did not release an equality impact assessment on the changes.The Court of Session ruled to refuse the petition on Friday.The couple's lawyers have said they have no doubt the Fanning's litigation had been influential in securing U-turns by both governments.
A spokesperson from the Govan Law Centre told BBC Scotland News: "While our clients have lost their case at first instance, we have no doubt that this litigation has been influential in securing the partial U-turn made by the Scottish government last November and the major policy U-turn confirmed by the UK government earlier this week."We hope that the Scottish government will now follow suit and restore the winter fuel payment in full for people such as our clients."Earlier this week, the UK government abandoned plans to withdraw the payments from all but the poorest pensioners after the scheme drew widespread criticism.The Scottish government had already launched its own winter fuel benefit in response to the original cuts which included extra support for those less well-off, but also a universal payment which is unaffected by income.The Govan Law Centre added the legal challenge "was always one of process" and the fact the UK government has already reconsidered the cuts "vindicates" their clients.It said that an appeal would have "reasonable prospects of success" but added it is unlikely that legal aid would be provided for this.
What's happening with winter fuel payments?
About 10 million pensioners in England and Wales lost their allowance under new measures announced by chancellor Rachel Reeves in July last year.Those on pension credit or certain other means-tested benefits retained the annual payments, worth between £100 and £300.In Scotland, the payment was devolved to Holyrood in April 2024, but the Scottish government followed the actions of their counterparts in Westminster in terminating it in August 2024, arguing £160m had been taken from its budget.A new alternative, called the Pension Age Winter Heating Payment (PAWHP), was due to be introduced the following month, but that has since been pushed back to winter 2025.It will also be means-tested, despite ministers claiming it would not be.Social Justice Secretary Shirley-Anne Somerville recently said the universal approach of the devolved Scottish scheme was important - but that wealthier pensioners would be made aware that they could opt out.The current plan is for all pensioner households to receive at least £100 regardless of income, while those on pension credit will receive up to £305 depending on age.Meanwhile, the devolved government in Northern Ireland also followed suit, but affected pensioners were given a one-off £100 payment from Stormont in November.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BreakingNews.ie
an hour ago
- BreakingNews.ie
Rod Stewart says Britain should ‘give Farage a chance'
Sir Rod Stewart has called on Britain to 'give Nigel Farage a chance' as he revealed how close he came to pulling out of his Glastonbury appearance. The 80-year-old singer backed the Reform UK leader ahead of appearing in the festival's afternoon legends slot on Sunday, 23 years after he headlined the Pyramid Stage. Advertisement 'I've read about (Sir Keir) Starmer cutting off the fishing in Scotland and giving it back to the EU. That hasn't made him popular,' he told The Times. 'We're fed up with the Tories. We've got to give Farage a chance. He's coming across well. Nigel? What options have we got? Rod Stewart has called on Britain to give Reform UK leader Nigel Farage a chance (PA) 'Starmer's all about getting us out of Brexit and I don't know how he's going to do that. Still, the country will survive. It could be worse. We could be in the Gaza Strip.' Admitting his wealth ensures 'a lot of it doesn't really touch me', he insisted he is not out of touch and expressed his support for Ukraine – criticising US president Donald Trump and vice president JD Vance for their treatment of Ukrainian president Volodomyr Zelenskiy on his visit to the White House – and Gaza. Advertisement 'It's depressing, what's going on in the Gaza Strip,' he said. 'Netanyahu doesn't realise that this is what happened to his people under the Nazis: total annihilation. And Trump is going to turn the Gaza Strip into Miami?' Stewart said a prolonged bout of flu, which forced him to cancel five shows in the US, nearly forced him to withdraw from a Glastonbury appearance he described to ITV as his 'World Cup final'. 'This time last week I was thinking of cancelling,' he told The Sun, crediting his wife Penny Lancaster with nursing him back to health. 'I have had Influenza A. It's been so terrible. It's the worst thing anyone could possibly have, I wouldn't wish it on anyone. Advertisement 'Apart from (Vladimir) Putin. I'd wish it on him.' Stewart told The Sun he had negotiated an extra quarter of an hour on top of the allotted 75 minutes for his set. He confirmed he will be joined at Glastonbury by former Faces bandmate Ronnie Wood, Simply Red's Mick Hucknall and Lulu, as well as performing the song Powderfinger by Saturday headliner Neil Young.
Telegraph
2 hours ago
- Telegraph
‘Brown lumpy liquid splattered me in Sainsbury's – I want compensation'
Has a company treated you unfairly? Our Consumer Champion is available to help. For how to contact her click here. Dear Katie, I am a 22-year-old soon-to-be graduate from the University of Strathclyde, and I've recently moved into my first proper flat with my partner. To help with the move, I hired a car to collect some Ikea furniture and move it into our new flat. We drove from the centre of Glasgow to the Braehead retail park where Ikea is. We stopped to pick up some quick bits for lunch at a Sainsbury's on the retail park. While we were shopping, a pipe that was running inside the store above aisle seven started leaking brown liquid with clumps, and fell from the ceiling on to us. The majority of the clumps landed just in front of us, as my partner pulled me backwards to avoid getting hit directly. The splashback of the clumps landed in a puddle of what appeared to be sewage. It came into contact with our hair, our face, our skin and our clothes. I have complained to Sainsbury's about this, and it has informed me that if I wanted compensation for my items, then I would need to travel into their store with the affected articles for inspection. I have declined to do this because myself and my partner would need to travel at our own personal expense on public transport, while potentially putting other users of this transport at risk of contamination. I've been told it cannot proceed with my complaint unless we can return to the store. What do you think my next steps should be? – RO, via email Dear reader, I asked if you had the receipt for your shopping on the day, to which you replied that Sainsbury's had already let you have it for free, as well as giving you a £40 gift voucher. I didn't ask for it, but you supplied me with an itemised list of what you and your partner were both wearing on that day – down to the socks, sunglasses on both of your heads and a smartwatch each. You also supplied me with a picture of your socks which appeared to have been lightly splattered with brown liquid. Clearly, you were hoping to be compensated for all your 'contaminated' wearable items. However, the seriousness of the case and whether you were going to be owed anything at all really came down to what exactly this brown, lumpy liquid was. If your hunch was right and it was raw sewage, then this had been a very serious hygiene incident indeed for Sainsbury's indeed, and I'd need to seek reassurance that it had been properly dealt with at the time. However, when I asked the supermarket to investigate, it confirmed that the leak was in fact just rainwater which had collected in a pipe containing moss, explaining what the brown lumps were. This makes sense, as sewage pipes do usually run underground. Although I recognise that being splattered with brown water would have been unpleasant and certainly not what you expected while buying a quick lunch in Sainsbury's, since your clothes aren't seriously contaminated, I'm afraid that I'm not prepared to ask it to do anything further for you. All your clothes need is a good wash, and you can easily wipe down your smart watch and sunglasses. Moving into your first flat together is an exciting but expensive time, and therefore, my advice is this: don't waste your money on bus fare travelling to Sainsbury's to have your clothes inspected because you won't win this one. Just enjoy your £40 voucher and move on. A Sainsbury's spokesman said: 'We apologised to the customer and his partner, after a rainwater leak affected their shop at our Braehead store. 'We covered the cost of their shopping, as well as provided a goodwill gesture and a new T-shirt. We understand they would like further compensation and we've explained how they can apply for this.'
BBC News
3 hours ago
- BBC News
Cormack Park upgrades part of £8m Aberdeen investment
Aberdeen say they have secured investment of £8m, mainly to be used to improve the club's training ground, Cormack installation of a new full-sized indoor arena will be part of the project."The vision is for a new covered 4G facility to be situated on the current undeveloped Neale Cooper Pitch 6, to allow for all-year-round use for our men and women's teams, both academies, AFCCT programmes and other local junior and amateur teams," the club said."We will also be making some additional improvements to Pittodrie Stadium over the next two years, in line with our previously announced medium-term plan of remaining at our current home."And chairman Dave Cormack added: "Together with our investors, I remain committed to driving Aberdeen FC forward and continuing to make our supporters and the region proud of its football club."
