Minister says AI ‘does lie' but defends Government amid copyright row
Peter Kyle acknowledged the technology was "not flawless" as he insisted the Government would "never sell downstream" the rights of artists in the UK
(Image: Wiktor Szymanowicz/Future Publishing via Getty Images )
The Technology Secretary has said that AI "does lie" but defended his rejection of attempts to strengthen copyright protections amid concerns about tech firms using creatives' material to train their models.
Peter Kyle acknowledged the technology was "not flawless" as he insisted the Government would "never sell downstream" the rights of artists in the UK.
He also said he had "mistakenly" said his preferred option on AI and copyright was requiring rights-holders to "opt out" of their material being used by tech companies, and had since "gone back to the drawing board".
Ministers have faced a backlash from major figures in the creative industries over their approach to copyright, with Sir Elton John this week describing the situation as an "existential issue."
The Government is locked in a standoff with the House of Lords, which has demanded artists to be offered immediate copyright protection as an amendment to the Data (Use and Access) Bill.
Peers have attempted to change the legislation by adding a commitment to introduce transparency requirements aimed at ensuring rights-holders are able to see when their work has been used and by whom.
Article continues below
Asked about the risk of AI producing unreliable information, Mr Kyle said "people need to understand that AI is not flawless, and that AI does lie because it's based on human characteristics".
"Now it is getting more precise as we move forward. It's getting more powerful as we move forward," he told Sky News's Sunday Morning With Trevor Phillips.
"But as with every single technology that comes into society, you can only safely use it and wisely use it by understanding how it works."
He added: "We are going to legislate for AI going forward and we're going to balance it with the same legislation that we'll bring in to modernise the copyright legislation as well."
The Government has said it will address copyright issues as a whole after the more than 11,500 responses to its consultation on the impact of AI have been reviewed, rather than in what it has branded "piecemeal" legislation.
Among the proposals had been a suggestion that tech companies could be given free access to British music, films, books in order to train AI models without permission or payment, with artists required to "opt-out" if they do not want their work to be used.
Article continues below
Asked about the prospect of an opt-out clause, Mr Kyle told the BBC's Sunday With Laura Kuenssberg programme: "I always had on the table from the outset an opt-out clause.
"But I mistakenly said this was my preferred option that had more prominence than perhaps some of the creatives wanted it to have, and I've now sort of gone back to the drawing board on that, because I am listening to what people want."
Last month hundreds of stars including Sir Elton, Sir Paul McCartney and Kate Bush signed a joint letter to Sir Keir Starmer urging the Prime Minister to introduce safeguards against work being plundered for free.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
South Wales Argus
5 minutes ago
- South Wales Argus
Two arrests after Palestine Action claims blocking Israeli defence firm UK site
It comes ahead of proposed legislation that will ban the group under anti-terror law. Avon and Somerset Police said a 30-year-old woman and a 36-year-old man, both from London, have been arrested on suspicion of criminal damage, unauthorised entry to a prohibited place and locking onto a person, object or land to cause serious disruption. Earlier on Tuesday, a Palestine Action spokesperson said activists had blocked the entrance to Elbit Systems in Bristol, and covered it in red paint 'to symbolise Palestinian bloodshed'. Avon and Somerset Police said officers were called to the site at around 6.30am. A spokeswoman said: 'Two people have been arrested following a small protest outside a premises at the Aztec West Business Park, in Almondsbury. 'They remain in police custody and inquiries are ongoing. 'We're committed to facilitating people's right to peaceful protest, but will not tolerate any criminal behaviour.' The incident comes as a draft order was laid before Parliament on Monday to amend the Terrorism Act 2000 to include Palestine Action as a proscribed organisation. If approved, it would become a criminal offence punishable by up to 14 years in prison to be a member of the direct action group or to support it. MPs and peers are expected to debate the legislation on Wednesday and Thursday and, if approved, the ban could come into force by Friday. A Palestine Action spokesperson said: 'While the Government is rushing through Parliament absurd legislation to proscribe Palestine Action, the real terrorism is being committed in Gaza. 'Palestine Action affirms that direct action is necessary in the face of Israel's ongoing crimes against humanity of genocide, apartheid, and occupation, and to end British facilitation of those crimes.' The group also occupied the rooftop of UK subcontractor Guardtech Group, the spokesperson added. Officers are also at the scene at the site in Brandon, Suffolk. A Suffolk Police spokesman said: 'Officers and specialist negotiators are currently at the location and our immediate priority is to bring this to a conclusion and to ensure the safety of everyone at the scene.' Palestine Action is seeking a legal challenge against the Government's bid to proscribe it, with a hearing expected on Friday to decide whether the ban can be temporarily blocked, pending further proceedings to decide whether a legal challenge can be brought. Commenting on the proscription on Monday, Home Secretary Yvette Cooper said: 'The right to protest and the right to free speech are the cornerstone of our democracy and there are countless campaign groups that freely exercise those rights. 'Violence and serious criminal damage has no place in legitimate protests.'
Daily Mail
11 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
UK's world-leading creative industries boosted by web tool that stops AI firms 'stealing' work to train models
The UK's world-leading creative industries have been given a fresh boost in their fight to stop big tech firms 'stealing' their work. US-based computer services and cyber security company Cloudflare has introduced a new tool which blocks Silicon Valley firms from mining creative works for free. Titans of entertainment including Sir Elton John, Lord Lloyd Webber and Dua Lipa have been locked in a battle with the Government because artists wanted better protection from bots. The Government last month finally defeated an amendment to the Data (Use and Access) Bill by crossbench peer Baroness Kidron, director of Bridget Jones: The Edge Of Reason, after weeks of ping-pong between the Commons and Baroness Kidron's growing number of supporters in the Lords. But Cloudflare's latest innovation will give publishers and website owners greater control over their intellectual property, and publishers will be able to choose if they want AI companies to access their content. Stephanie Cohen, Cloudflare's chief strategy officer, said the goal of such tools was to give publishers greater control and ensure a sustainable ecosystem for online content creators and AI companies. 'The change in traffic patterns has been rapid, and something needed to change,' she said. 'This is just the beginning of a new model for the internet.' Pop star Dua Lipa, pictured last week performing in Liverpool, is one of the leading names backing the campaign to protect the creative industries Crossbench peer Baroness Kidron has tabled a series of amendments to the Data (Use and Access) Bill which sought to protect artists' work from being scraped by big tech Cloudflare will allow web domains signing up to its tool to state whether permission is granted for bots to mine what is on the screen, effectively allowing creators to block AI crawlers from scraping from that website. Simply, they will be able to choose if they want AI companies to access their content at all. Baroness Kidron said Cloudflare's innovation was 'great news'. She told the Mail: 'This is a radical departure from the current stand-off between the tech sector and copyright holders. 'Cloudflare sit at the heart of the digital world and it is exciting to see them take decisive action. 'It is an enormous contribution to ensuring a vibrant public sphere, now and into the future.' The Daily Mail joined the calls for Labour to drop its preference to give AI firms a copyright exemption. Rich Caccappolo, vice chairman of dmg media which publishes the Mail, said the innovation would 'help prevent the current epidemic of unauthorised scraping of websites by AI companies and their proxies, who are using copyrighted content for commercial purposes without paying for it'. He said: 'We support any innovation that creates a structured and transparent relationship between content creators and AI platforms, and respects fundamental property rights. 'It will require a concerted effort by regulators, politicians, legislators, technology providers and content creators to build a new economic model for the AI era. We commend every step taken in pursuit of that goal.'
Daily Mail
12 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
The Wave reopens to surfers with Boardmasters founder in charge after financial dispute
Ground-breaking British inland surfing centre The Wave reopened on Tuesday after abruptly closing last week. The wave pool surf complex, near Bristol, reopened at 6.30am on Tuesday morning, with all sessions due to run as scheduled. The sudden closure came amid a financial dispute, where its majority former owners Sullivan Street Partners claimed the site had been grabbed at a low value. But The Wave's founder, Nick Hounsfield, who had resigned from the board in late April, posted a video on Instagram and Facebook yesterday backing the new owners and calling on surfers to get behind them. The Wave Group has, according to its website, been acquired as a part of a 'financial restructure' by a group of investors who asked Surfing England chairman Julian Topham to step into the role of chief executive. Topham, who founded and runs the Boardmasters festival, said there would be a 'short period of transition' as the firm changes hands. When The Wave opened under Hounsfield in 2019, it was at the forefront of the emergence of wave pools offering world-class surfing on mechanically generated waves to the public. The Wave's website is up and running but no new bookings can be made by customers. The firm said it will 'get in touch' with people who had their bookings cancelled last week 'as soon as we possibly can.' Topham asked for patience while a new team get together to fully reopen The Wave and restart online bookings. He said in a statement online: 'We appreciate there has been huge uncertainty in the last week, for so many people, especially our wonderful Wavemaker staff, customers, and partners, so a big thank you for your understanding.' He added: 'There will be a short period of transition as a company changes hands and we get up to speed, but we are doing everything we can to make this as smooth and as fast as possible, and get The Wave open again.' In a video on social media from the Bristol site, The Wave's founder, Nick Hounsfield said Topham had 'high ethics and is an exceptional leader.' In his Instagram post, Hounsfield said: 'Just reflecting upon the last couple of days. It's been a storm. The Wave has so much of my heart and soul in it and it's been so distressing to see something close to me go through so much turmoil. 'I've just come in to The Wave to check in on the team. They are working hard to get The Wave open ASAP. As ever, they have stepped up to the task and there is a lot of positivity and excitement. A lot to do… but working hard. 'I've had a chance to catch up with the new CEO Julian Topham and his team. He has been asked to step in as CEO to get The Wave back to where it deserves to be, the heart of a vibrant and inclusive surf community and a force for good. 'I've known Julian for over 15 years. He has high ethics, is an exceptional leader and operator, and has enormous respect both in the surf community and in building epic events across the UK. He also recently took over from me as Chairman of Surfing England. 'I ask everybody who loves The Wave to really get behind Julian and his team as they look to get The Wave back to where it deserves to be. It feels like a fresh start.' Allegations from former majority owner Last week, former owners of The Wave alleged that the business, under the entity Surf Bristol Limited, was sold on the cheap. In a statement, former majority owners Sullivan Street Partners claimed the Bristol-based enterprise was 'sold by Administrator BTG' on 27 June, having been placed into a technical insolvency the previous day. Sullivan Street Partners alleged: 'A previous minority shareholder and individuals associated with the shareholder chose to pursue financial returns, significantly acting out of step with their moral fiduciary duties.' Elsewhere in the statement, Sullivan Street Partners claimed the process had been undertaken with the objective of 'grabbing the business at an undervalue and prejudicing other creditors in the process.' The statement also alleged that certain assets had been 'appropriated illegally with systems being hacked and frozen.' Sullivan Street Partners claimed that The Wave Group had 'simultaneously been the victim of a cyber attack with all data having been stolen.' The former majority owners noted that it was not clear whether the 'cyber attack' was connected to the other 'assaults on the company.' Sullivan Street Partners said that until 5.55pm on 27 June, The Wave Group had been preparing to open on 28 June, but that this had became 'impossible.' The statement added that The Wave Group still planned to open a new surf complex in London in 2027 and 'has several other opportunities under development.' Sullivan Street Partners said they were 'sorry for the upset the actions of others have caused.' An earlier statement from Sullivan Street Partners this week, said The Wave Group had 'lined up a refinancing alongside its exciting London developments, which would see all creditors repaid in full within a week and is offering to continue to operate the park.' This is Money contacted administrators at BTG for comment. What happened at The Wave? Last week, The Wave, abruptly closed. The closure came with no warning, with surfers and users of the site booked in arriving to closed doors and an apology written on a sign. Highlighting how suddenly the saga deteriorated, on Wednesday The Wave was posting on social media about an upcoming surf festival being held at the centre next month. The Wave opened in 2019 and cost £26million to build. The unique complex could generate up to 1,000 waves per hour. Since opening, the site provided surfing facilities for all abilities, catering for disabled visitors, total beginners and veteran surfers. The Wave's power supply stems from solar and battery storage and since 2019 the complex has welcomed 400,000 people. The Wave was brainchild of Hounsfield, a British entrepreneur who wanted to build a unique business that had a positive social impact. Hounsfield did not come from a background in property or business, but was an osteopath, who said he started with £500 in his bank account and managed to raise the money to build his dream. Since 5 May, The Wave's founder, Hounsfield, has not been a director of the business.
