
The emperor and the shogun: A power struggle across the centuries
The swordsmen 'tied up the monks on guard, then invaded the hall where the statues were enshrined. One man suggested that the statues' bodies be destroyed, but the others objected because they were carved in full court dress. Out of respect for the emperor they should remain unscathed. ... Having been fashioned from a separate block of wood, the heads were simply yanked out of the bodies. ... Clasping the heads ... the nine men departed as noisily as they had come. Once outside the temple, (one of their number) led them in a chorus of war cries, then they ran back through the city, pausing briefly to bow before a gate to the imperial palace.'
Historian Donald Keene, in 'Yoshimasa and the Silver Pavilion: The Creation of the Soul of Japan,' adds this detail: The swordsmen 'then exposed the heads on the banks of the Kamo River, following the common practice at the time of 'patriots' exposing for all to see the heads of men accused of being traitors. Beside the heads of the three shoguns, placards were set up enumerating the crimes of each.'
Mid-19th-century Japan was a seething cauldron. For 250 years, the country had been sealed shut against the outside world. Perhaps no other major culture in world history had developed in such splendid isolation, feeding only on itself, neither influenced nor influencing, not preyed upon and not preying. For two centuries, those who chose myth over reality faced no rude awakening from their conviction that theirs was 'the land of the gods,' its ancient divine inheritance inviolable and eternal.
Then came the rude awakening. The U.S. Navy's Black Ships are a familiar symbol of the force that opened Japan — a crack in 1853, then wider, then wider still. Foreign feet trod the sacred soil, their numbers growing, their rights and privileges expanding. Was this to be permitted? It was, declared the shogun ruling in Edo (present-day Tokyo) — if only because Japan was powerless to resist. It was not, said the emperor reigning politically impotent in Kyoto, divine guardian of the divine nation's divine myths.
Assassins roamed the land — in the emperor's service, they said — cutting down foreigners and Japanese deemed collaborators, traitors to Japan's sacred past, sacred present and sacred future. Imperial restoration was their aim. They scarcely foresaw the Meiji Restoration they themselves were hatching, neither its imminence — it lay a scant five years down the road at the time of the attack on the statues — nor the modernizing and Westernizing direction it ultimately took, scarcely less noxious in their nostrils than the shogunate it toppled. Those who propelled history forward were turned by history into such anachronisms that to modern eyes they seem as archaic as an earlier restoration they hoped to reproduce: the Kenmu Restoration of 1333-36.
Three ancient characters, larger than life for better or worse, were in spirit very much alive to the 19th-century avenging swordsmen who made life intolerable and ultimately impossible for the Edo shoguns helpless to stem the foreign incursion. The three are Emperor Go-Daigo (1288-1339), the guerrilla warrior Kusunoki Masashige (1294-1336) and shogun Ashikaga Takauji (1305-58).
Go-Daigo: living symbol of everything the 19th-century swordsmen fought for — an emperor not only reigning but ruling, no mere figurehead but a god ruling the land of the gods and its people of the gods.
Kusunoki: the ultimate loyalist hero, leading followers numbered in hundreds against shogunal armies numbered in tens of thousands, knowing his cause was doomed and fighting all the more fiercely, leading his men forward crying, 'Would we had seven lives to give that we may destroy the enemies of the Court!'
And Takauji, the villain of the drama — the ultimate traitor, 'enemy of the Court' number one, founder of the Ashikaga shogunate that ruled from 1336 to 1573 and (thus Keene's title) creator of 'the soul of Japan.' Takauji's greatness as warrior and statesman stand him in little stead in historical memory: his fate is sealed, he it was who betrayed Go-Daigo. Posterity judged him and wreaked its vengeance on his statue 500 years later; the two others were of his immediate successors, his son and grandson.
Go-Daigo's Kenmu uprising against the Kamakura shogunate (1185-1333), precursor of the Meiji uprising against the Edo shogunate (1603-1868), was a hopelessly muddled, comically bungled affair, doomed to certain and instant failure, yet, for a time, triumphant — how? Thanks to Takauji, whose first betrayal — not of Go-Daigo but of the shogun whose leading general he was — turned the tide. The contemporary anonymous court chronicle 'Masukagami' ('The Clear Mirror') says of him (in George Perkins' translation), 'Takauji had given the shogunate a solemn written pledge of unswerving loyalty when he left Kamakura, but his true intentions were said to be in doubt. ... It had been whispered that Takauji might try to use the present national crisis to elevate his own position, and the whispers proved to be well grounded.'
Suddenly he was an imperial loyalist. An ambitious man thwarted in his ambitions, he sought their fulfillment elsewhere — in the imperial camp. Turning against his former masters, he freed Go-Daigo from wretched and ignominious exile on a remote island and stormed Kamakura. 'The attackers' battle cry was like a thunderclap, a noise loud enough to shake the earth. ... Emperor Kogon (the shogun's puppet, installed in the exiled Go-Daigo's stead), and (other courtiers) were utterly distraught. Accustomed only to the strains of musical instruments, they were stupefied by a sound so extraordinary and sinister.'
The Kamakura Period was over. Go-Daigo enthroned and ruling not only in name but in fact would give our story a happy ending. It was not to be. The Kenmu Restoration 'was an unmitigated fiasco,' writes historian Ivan Morris in 'The Nobility of Failure: Tragic Heroes in the History of Japan.' Go-Daigo's tragic flaw was his inability to come down from his divine clouds and understand human beings. Takauji he grievously misjudged, according him to whom he owned his otherwise impossible triumph scant honor. Cut to the quick, Takauji turned again, seizing the shogunate in open defiance of the imperial will. Japan was at war.
'The Battle of Minato River,' Morris writes, 'was fought on a sweltering summer day in 1336 and lasted from ten o'clock in the morning until about five in the evening': the loyalist guerrilla warrior Kusunoki versus Takauji the rebel shogun. The loyalists had no chance and knew it. Our story opened with a display of heads and now closes with one. 'Masashige's head,' we read in the contemporary chronicle 'Taiheiki' ('Chronicle of Great Peace,' translated by Helen McCullough), 'was exposed in the river bed at Rokujo. ... Subsequently Lord Takauji sent for the head and despatched it to Masashige's home with a message saying, 'It really grieves me when I think how long he and I were close associates' — as enemies, but what does that matter? In Japanese history, the 'association' of enmity is as dear and intimate as the association of friendship.
And Emperor Go-Daigo? He fled the capital and set up a 'Southern Court' in the mountains of Yoshino, where the cherries bloom. Takauji ignored it as Go-Daigo ignored him, Takauji giving his sanction to the 'Northern Court' in Kyoto and being sanctioned by it in turn; it confirmed his appointment as shogun, in which office he died in 1358.
The two courts remained divided until 1392.
Michael Hoffman is the author of 'Arimasen.'
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Japan Times
2 hours ago
- Japan Times
Governors urge central government to address Japan's shrinking population
Prefectural governors urged the central government on Wednesday to give top priority to measures against escalating population decline. The National Governors' Association called on the government to launch a national campaign involving private companies to promote comprehensive measures for addressing the shrinking population. In a set of proposals compiled on the first day of the association's two-day meeting in Aomori Prefecture, the governors called for the establishment of a government agency-level control tower to coordinate related policies. The association also called on the government to promote multicultural coexistence, regarding policy measures to deal with foreign nationals. In the proposals to deal with the population issue, the association underlined the need to create an environment in which it is easy to work and raise children, taking into account the opinions of women and young people. The governors also called on the government to promote the decentralization of companies and universities through tax reforms and other measures. The association confirmed its policy of considering marriage support measures by involving the business community. Regarding measures relating to foreign nationals, Shizuoka Gov. Yasutomo Suzuki said, "The central government only sees foreigners as a labor force, but local governments are accepting them as residents." In the proposals, the association urged the government to be accountable on improving the related environment, including education on accepting foreign nationals. Governors from across the country gather for a two-day meeting through Thursday in the city of Aomori. | Jiji Regarding this week's Japan-U.S. tariff agreement, Toyama Gov. Hachiro Nitta said: "I believe there would be a certain impact, but the central and local governments need to work together on challenges including an expansion of export destinations." Amid political uncertainty in the wake of Sunday's House of Councilors election, Yoshihiro Murai, head of the association and governor of Miyagi Prefecture, said at the beginning of the meeting, "We must unite and work together to overcome this difficult situation." Governors expressed worry over possible declines in their prefectures' tax revenues following a strong showing in the election by the opposition parties, which had called for various tax cuts. Regarding a possible consumption tax cut, Miyazaki Gov. Shunji Kono urged the central government to thoroughly consider the impact on regional economies. "We urge (the central government) to engage in comprehensive and responsible discussions over the effect (of a consumption tax cut) on regional economies, which may put a financial burden on future generations," Kono said. Seiichiro Murakami, the internal affairs minister who participated in the governors' meeting online, said the central government considers it inappropriate to cut the consumption tax. However, given that the ruling coalition of the Liberal Democratic Party and Komeito lacks a majority in both chambers of parliament, governors called on both the ruling and opposition parties to engage in discussions to secure financial resources for regional economies.


Japan Times
3 hours ago
- Japan Times
Japanese groups make united call for abolition of nuclear weapons
Three Japanese organizations working for the abolition of nuclear weapons issued a joint appeal in Tokyo on Wednesday, calling for spreading awareness of the reality of atomic bombings across the country. It was the first time ever for the groups to come together for such a unified statement, which was unveiled ahead of next month's 80th anniversary of the 1945 U.S. atomic bombings of Hiroshima and Nagasaki in the closing days of World War II. The Japan Council against Atomic and Hydrogen Bombs (Gensuikyo) and the Japan Congress against Atomic and Hydrogen Bombs (Gensuikin) partnered with the Japan Confederation of A- and H-Bomb Sufferers Organizations (Nihon Hidankyo) to issue the appeal. The antinuclear movement gained momentum in 1954 after the 23-member crew of the Fukuryu Maru No. 5, a Japanese fishing boat, was exposed to radioactive fallout from a U.S. hydrogen bomb test. Gensuikyo and Nihon Hidankyo were founded in the wake of intensifying public sentiment. Gensuikin was established in 1965 after splitting from Gensuikyo. "I'm deeply moved by the cooperation of large organizations on the 80th anniversary of the atomic bombings," Terumi Tanaka, 93, co-chair of Nihon Hidankyo, said at a news conference. He expressed hopes that the collaboration will encourage hibakusha — atomic bomb survivors — who are yet to share their experiences to testify. "The task of spreading the reality of atomic bombings is a challenge for all humanity," Yayoi Tsuchida, 68, a senior Gensuikyo official, said. Masashi Tani, 45, secretary-general of Gensuikin, said, "We urge the government to take action, such as by ratifying the Treaty on the Prohibition of Nuclear Weapons," noting that "the international community is watching how Japan marks the 80th anniversary." "As the danger of nuclear weapons use grows, Japan's role is becoming increasingly important," the joint appeal said. "It is important to appeal against the inhumanity of nuclear weapons in Japan and globally by transcending differences in position."

Japan Times
4 hours ago
- Japan Times
Trump says Tokyo agreed to buy U.S. defense gear, clashing with Japan's account
Did this week's U.S.-Japan trade deal also involve spending on defense? Donald Trump seems to think so. Japan, not so much. Touting the surprise trade agreement with Japan on social media, the U.S. president claimed Wednesday that Tokyo 'had agreed to buy BILLIONS OF DOLLARS WORTH OF MILITARY AND OTHER EQUIPMENT." His comments came a day after Japan's top tariff negotiator, Ryosei Akazawa, told reporters in Washington that the new trade deal "does not include anything related to defense spending." Media reports quoting sources close to the talks also said that security issues had not been part of the trade discussions. It was not immediately clear if Trump was referring to pending arms deals with Tokyo. The U.S. has over $20 billion in active government-to-government sales cases with Japan under its Foreign Military Sales system as of January, U.S. State Department data shows. These purchases include advanced F-35 stealth fighters and Tomahawk cruise missiles. Japan acquires more than 90% of its defense imports from the United States and has expressed growing interest in even more advanced and interoperable technology as part of its 2022 Defense Buildup Program. The U.S. president has long taken a transactional view of what he says are Washington's 'unfair' alliances, issuing demands and threats during his first term and into his second that allies Japan and South Korea shoulder a larger security burden — or risk his ire. Tokyo, however, had been largely successful in fending off calls by Trump and his team to link security issues — including defense spending and host-nation support for the 54,000 U.S. troops in Japan — to the tariff negotiations. Just hours ahead of the first round of U.S.-Japan tariff negotiations in April, Trump claimed that 'the cost of military support' would be part of the talks. Although the move spooked Tokyo, the issue was effectively shelved after Prime Minister Shigeru Ishiba and his team repeatedly emphasized that the two issues must be dealt with separately while pointing to Japan's own unprecedented defense spending hike — to 2% of gross domestic product (GDP) by 2027. But that didn't stop Trump's Pentagon from setting a 'global standard' for Japan and other U.S. allies to spend 5% of GDP on defense. Indeed, even if defense was not a part of the trade deal — implicit or otherwise — the issue is sure to become a focus of future bilateral talks. Foreign Minister Takeshi Iwaya said in April that Tokyo 'intends to continue discussions on an appropriate track starting next year' on a cost-sharing agreement for hosting U.S. troops in Japan before its expiration in 2027. Japanese defense planners, meanwhile, are already weighing the possibility of even further boosted defense spending. A Defense Ministry panel of experts has reportedly recommended that the government consider hiking defense spending beyond 2%, and Ishiba has said that future budgets "may top 2%, if needed,' depending on the security environment.