Social protection minister takes legal action against Data Protection Commission
Papers were lodged in the High Court on Monday by the minister for social protection Dara Calleary for a miscellaneous common law application against the Data Protection Commission. The minister is represented by the Chief State Solicitor's Office.
It is understood the action relates directly to the Data Protection Commission order against the department confirmed last month, which was delivered along with a €550,000 fine.
It is not as yet known what the nature of the application is, given legal challenges to decisions by State agencies or bodies are typically delivered via an application for judicial review.
The department of social protection had not replied to a request for comment at the time of publication.
A spokesperson for the Data Protection Commission said that the regulator is not 'in a position to comment as the matter is now before the courts'.
Last month's decision related to an investigation into the alleged biometric nature of the public services card — the welfare-benefits card which can also be used to access separate State services, including the National Childcare Scheme and driver licence renewals.
Biometric data refers to any information that can identify a person by their physical characteristics — via a fingerprint for instance or, in this case, a photograph.
The commission found the card violated GDPR by failing to identify a legal basis for processing biometric data, retaining that data without justification, and not ensuring sufficient transparency about how the data would be used during registration.
The commission also ruled that the Government must discontinue processing such biometric data using the public services card within nine months of the decision unless it can identify a legal basis for doing so.
It is not the first time the department has taken the legal objection route with the Data Protection Commission in light of adverse decisions regarding the card.
In August 2019, the commission ruled that the State had no lawful basis for making the public services card — originally conceived in the 2000s as a welfare benefits card only by the department of social protection — mandatory for all public services.
That decision led to a prolonged legal battle between the State and one of its own regulators. The dispute ended in a December 2021 settlement, with the commission's findings left unchallenged but with the State continuing with the public services card project — albeit without mandatory requirements.
Read More
Microsoft faces lawsuit over allegations of unlawful data processing for advertising
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
RTÉ News
an hour ago
- RTÉ News
Opposition call on Government to scrap fees hike for students
Opposition parties have urged Government to scrap a potential €1,000 student fees hike, saying rise is creating "barriers" to third level education and could force people not to go to college. TDs from across the political spectrum called for a u-turn on the Government plan, despite Minister for Further and Higher Education James Lawless criticising the "hypocrisy" and "points scoring" of rival parties. Speaking during a private members motion in the Dáil tonight, Sinn Féin TD Donna McGettigan told Minister Lawless to "have a look up there" at students in the Dáil gallery, before telling him "these are the people you've turned your back on". Her party's finance spokesperson Pearse Doherty said the Government plan is creating "barriers" for students and "scared the bejaysus" out of families when it was announced last week, arguing fees should be going down not up. A number of other Sinn Féin TDs also criticised the move, including Donnchadh Ó Laoghaire who said, "There are cabinet ministers who think the cost of living crisis is over". Their views were echoed by Labour TD and party spokesperson on Education and Youth Eoghan Kenny, who said "I wouldn't have been able to achieve third level education if it wasn't for the support of the State" - support he said is now being taken away. Pointing out the planned student fee increase, Deputy Kenny said when students hear about fee increases "you realise how little valued you are by this State". Social Democrats TD Jen Cummins described the situation as an "omnishambles" taking place "while families are grappling with the thought of whether they will be able to send their child to college in the autumn", while Independent TD Seamus Healy said he believes Government is "throwing students under the bus". However, responding to the criticism, Minister for Further and Higher Education James Lawless said he understood some of the points raised he rejected the "hypocrisy" and "points scoring" taking place. Minister Lawless said he believes "Fianna Fáil is the party of education in Ireland" and that he disagreed with the "cheap populism" from some opposition TDs. He said any changes are "a policy decision" and "not a move to re-allocate moneys", saying "some parties want to make noise, I want to make progress". Responding to the Minister's comments, Green party leader Roderic O'Gorman said the student fees controversy is a "messy episode" and that it is "okay to recognise that and right and proper to correct it." "Please Minister, do the right thing," he added.
Irish Daily Mirror
2 hours ago
- Irish Daily Mirror
Protest told students may be forced to drop out if college fees return to €3,000
Students are concerned they will have to drop out of college if student fees are returned to €3,000, a protest has heard. Students gathered outside Leinster House on Tuesday evening to protest against suggestions from Higher Education Minister James Lawless that the €1,000 reduction in college fees will not be repeated. The Government has insisted that it will honour its commitment to reduce fees but has ruled out reintroducing the cost of living package that saw the fees drop to €2,000 in recent years. The protest was organised by Labour Senator and former Union of Students in Ireland (USI) President Laura Harmon and addressed by members of the opposition. Alex Angland, President of the UCC Student Union, said that 'as the cost of living continues to increase, students are being pushed towards a breaking point'. He added: 'Education is a right, not a privilege. Yet the government continues to place undue financial burden on students and on their families. 'More and more students are forced to take on unsustainable debt, to work excessive hours, and in some cases, to abandon their dreams of third-level education due to financial hardship.' Matt Mion, Education Officer at UCD Students' Union, told the crowd that he had brought a copy of page 72 of the programme for government, which stated the Government would 'continue to reduce the student contribution fee over time'. He also read from the Fine Gael and Fianna Fáil manifestos and the promises that were made during the election regarding fees, He said: 'What are they doing now? They're reversing. 'I have it here. I have the paper it's written on and it's not worth sh*t.' Maeve Farrell, President of Maynooth Student Union, said any decision to return student fees to €3,000 would be a 'disgraceful and unjustifiable decision'. She added: 'Myself and my fellow officers in Maynooth Students Union have been contacted by students who are devastated and terrified that this will mean the end of their studies.' Sinn Féin's Pearse Doherty accused the Government of 'weasel words' and said they had made a promise to cut student fees in the Programme for Government. He said: 'The question I have to the Government is, what have the students of Ireland done on you? 'Just last month, you unleashed your Minister for Housing, which has unleashed the landlords and allowed them to jack up rent for students to whatever level they want. 'Now we have the Minister for Higher Education jacking up student fees by another €1,000 at a time when rents are up, prices are up and now they want to put student fees up. 'Enough is enough. Now is the time to fight back.' In the Dáil, Taoiseach Micheal Martin defended the Government's stance on student fees, saying there are 'lots of instruments' to help students make college more affordable. Mr Martin said: 'This time last year was exactly the same position because the previous year had not provided estimates for the reduction of €1,000 that happened last year. 'It was exactly the same position and actually Sinn Fein had a motion down this time last year as well doing the exact same thing. 'There is an estimates process and there will be a budget. We will look at the full range of supports, including fees. 'We will look at student supports and stronger supports for students with disabilities. 'We will look for stronger supports for children from economically disadvantaged backgrounds, and we will look at progression into third level from different areas, and into postgraduate and research. 'There is a significant menu, and lots of instruments with which we can help students, particularly those on middle and lower incomes to make college more affordable. 'It is across the full gamut of instruments we have or provisions we can make in the budget.'
Irish Times
3 hours ago
- Irish Times
The Irish Times view on apartments: standards must not be abandoned
As the Government parties survey the wreckage of their overconfident housing promises, they now find themselves scrambling to revive the most sluggish sector in the construction industry: apartment development. The dramatic fall in apartment completions was a major contributor to the overall housing shortfall last year, and the outlook for 2025 appears equally grim. A variety of factors are at play, not all of them within the Government's control. Shifting international investment dynamics, higher interest rates and weaker yields have changed the calculus for global funds that once financed large-scale, buy-to-let developments. Nonetheless, the Government is not without tools to influence the situation. Its recent actions suggest a growing willingness to use every one of them. The Cabinet has already approved the loosening of rent pressure zone rules, allowing landlords in new-build blocks to charge higher rents, in the hope that this will entice investors back into the market. Senior Ministers, including the Taoiseach, have also signalled an openness to introducing targeted tax breaks for apartment developers. Today, the Cabinet approved a set of changes to planning standards. These will make it easier to build smaller, more tightly packed and arguably less habitable apartment units. In effect, the standards for natural light, storage, and amenity space are being diluted. While the changes may please construction lobbyists – many of whom have long argued that strict planning rules have strangled supply – they raise important questions about the quality of future housing stock. READ MORE It is worth noting that this is the third significant downgrade in design standards since 2015, following similar moves under former housing ministers Alan Kelly and Eoghan Murphy. Whether those relaxations delivered a measurable uptick in development is far from clear. If anything, the current slump suggests they did not. Officials in James Browne's Department of Housing argue that the revised standards still compare favourably to those in other European countries. That claim demands scrutiny. Many Europeans who relocate to Ireland are struck not by the generosity of our apartment layouts, but by how expensive and constrained they are. The State's chronic failure to deliver compact, high-quality urban living has long-term implications. Continued sprawl into exurban areas undermines climate goals, strains infrastructure and erodes quality of life. But so too does the prospect of a generation forced into cramped flats while paying among the highest rents in Europe. If the housing crisis is truly a national emergency, as political leaders frequently assert, it demands bold action. But urgency must not be an excuse for abandoning standards entirely.
