Border issues ‘should have been foreseen' as former NI Secretary Julian Smith hits out at Cameron's cavalier' approach to Brexit

Belfast Telegraph

a day ago

And Mr Smith, who lasted just over six months in the NI role before being sacked by Boris Johnson, said he was 'frustrated but not surprise' at being removed from the job despite his role in securing a return of Stormont in 2020.
Having been appointed as Secretary of State by Boris Johnson in 2019 Mr Smith, who remains MP for Skipton and Ripon in Yorkshire though called himself 100% Scottish, found himself in the midst of what he called 'an unforgivable decision' by former Prime Minister David Cameron to call the referendum on leaving the European Union.
'I joined the Conservative Party because of David Cameron, because he was dynamic, but it was unforgivable that this fundamental question was put to the British people when you have a whole range of issues, not least the border between Northern Ireland and Ireland,' he told the BBC's Red Lines podcast.
Now on the back benches, one of the few supporters of Theresa May's government to have survived, he's highly critical of Lord Cameron's approach, calling the former Prime Minister 'extremely cavalier' in his approach to Brexit.
'It (the referendum) was put to the British people as if it was some sort of Eton game,' he said, referencing the fact that Mr Cameron was one of several at the heart of the UK government who had been educated at the famous private school.
After losing the referendum vote, David Cameron resigned and left piecing it together to others, among them Mr Smith who was a key figure in Teresa May's doomed government, serving as chief whip under her leadership from 2016-19.
'There should have been a proposition which outlined how both answers, yes and no, would be addressed,' he said.
'Issues such as how to maintain an open border between Northern Ireland and the Republic of Ireland should have been foreseen. Instead the UK was led into years of contemplating an answer to that question.
'It was a pretty disastrous period. It has led to many of the challenges today where concerns over immigration are unaddressed and a polarisation of politics. That may have come anyway, but it was really accelerated by that period from 2017 onwards.'
Theresa May resigned in 2019 due to an inability to pass Brexit legislation - three times the votes went against her government in the Commons, During that time he had built up a relationship with the DUP, who had secured their 'confidence and supply' arrangement to prop up government.
'The DUP relationship was very helpful in one of the big factors - keeping Jeremy Corbyn out of power,' he said.
'They were positive to work with, but it was obviously a very difficult time when you had a very small party that was critical to the stability at Westminster and so influential. On a personal basis I found them straightforward to deal with.'
When Boris Johnson took over as Prime Minister Smith was appointed to his first Cabinet as Secretary of State for Northern Ireland and was instrumental in breaking three years of political inactivity as Stormont resumed in January 2020.
'I wasn't sure I would get a job,' he said, having been a key figure in supporting Teresa May.
'I was delighted to get the role,' he continued, admitting days in Northern Ireland was the first time he had dealt with Sinn Fein politicians.
'They don't take their seats at Westminster,' he said. 'Probably they could have had the votes to influence things (over Brexit)
'But I found Sinn Fein to be a very driven and organised party. I find what happened in the past abhorrent and I disagree with their goals, but I found their politicians straightforward to deal with and developed good working relationships with them.'
That led to Stormont returning in January 2020. A month later, Julian Smith was out of the job.
'It was quite frustrating,' he said. 'The restoration of Stormont was one of the first successes of the Boris Johnson government. I had pushed back in cabinet about the idea of a 'no deal' Brexit. Looking back, if I had been Boris, I'd have been irritated by that too.
'I felt I could have assisted him more as Prime Minister. But no, it wasn't unexpected he decided to get rid of me as I'd served Teresa May.'
Asked about the potential for a border poll, Smith said he did not think the conditions were 'right'.
'Look at all the other things that need to be done,' he said.
'Constitutional discussion is basically an excuse for not dealing with these priority issues. Don't let politicians in Northern Ireland off the hook on dealing with social mobility, dealing with the health service, revenue raising
'I cannot in any world see a border poll with interest from Ireland, acceptance from the UK. We're better focusing on making people's lives better.'