CalMac bid to reclaim costs for fault-prone Arran ferry MV Caledonian Isles
The £10.8m repair bill for the vessel is equivalent to a quarter of last year's maintenance budget for the entire CalMac fleet.The publicly-owned ferry operator confirmed to BBC Scotland News that action was under way to recover some of those repair costs following an investigation into the cause of the hull deformity."As this is commercially sensitive and subject to legal proceedings, we cannot comment further," it said in a statement.
Problems with "Caley Isles", as the ship is known, began in January 2024 when annual maintenance inspections in Scotland revealed extensive steel corrosion. The 32-year-old ship was moved to the Cammell Laird shipyard in Birkenhead for a "highly complex" repair operation which required removal of the ship's engines. That meant the ferry had to spend months in a dry dock, a narrow basin which is drained, leaving the ship out of the water and supported by blocks. The work, said at the time to cost around £5m, was completed last September but when the ship sailed back to Scotland the crew noticed a gearbox problem and metal shards were discovered in a filter. Further investigation revealed that eight frames, the ribs of the ship's structural skeleton, were deformed and that more steel replacement was required. CalMac engaged a naval architect to report on the root cause of the deformation, while more repairs were carried out in Greenock, by a different ship repair firm. The ferry was due to resume sailing from Ardrossan last month, but a new fault affecting its variable pitch propellers, essential for manoeuvring in harbour, was identified during sea trials, and the ship is still out of service.
The prolonged absence of MV Caledonian Isles has added to pressures on the west coast ferry network, and had a major impact on Ardrossan where the new Arran ferry MV Glen Sannox is too big to berth safely.Glen Sannox operates instead from Troon, 15 miles down the Ayrshire coast, which involves a longer crossing to Arran and fewer daily sailings. Meanwhile, Ardrossan, normally the main gateway to Arran, has been left without ferry sailings for six months, with campaigners claiming the economy has suffered.Sailing from the port will finally resume later on Monday with the 41-year-old ferry MV Isle of Arran drafted to provide temporary cover during July while Caledonian Isles remains out of action.
Why are CalMac's ships breaking down so often?
The particular issues facing MV Caledonian Isles are part of a wider problem as CalMac tries to maintain services with an increasingly ageing and unreliable fleet. CalMac does not own its ships - instead it leases them from another government-owned company CMAL which is responsible for harbours and ferry procurement. But CalMac does have to pay for maintenance, which has proven costly due to delays in the provision of new vessels.The annual repair bill has nearly trebled over the past 10 years.
When MV Glen Sannox entered service in January, it was the first new large ship provided to the ferry operator by CMAL in nearly a decade. Half of CalMac's 10 major vessels have now reached or are beyond their 30-year expected service life. Aside from rust issues, there are difficulties replacing equipment which is often so old that spares have to be specially manufactured. To make up for a shortage of vessels CalMac has chartered a catamaran, MV Alfred, from Pentland Ferries at a cost of £1m per month since May 2023. By the time the charter ends in October, it will have paid out around double the £14.5m it cost Pentland Ferries to build the vessel. The pressures should begin to ease from next winter onwards as the first of five new major vessels currently under construction for CMAL start to arrive.
The first of four ships being built in Turkey, MV Isle of Islay, is on track for delivery by the end of September, about a year later than originally planned.The second Turkish ship, MV Loch Indaal, should arrive in the spring of 2026, with the other two following on at six monthly intervals.The long- delayed MV Glen Rosa is expected to be ready by the end of June next year, and is earmarked to join its sister ship MV Glen Sannox on the Arran route.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
4 hours ago
- The Independent
Business confidence at highest level in eight months, RBS finds
Business confidence has risen to its highest level in eight months, according to a Royal Bank of Scotland (RBS) survey. The private sector also saw its strongest rise in activity since November, the bank's growth tracker found. Overall, the combined output of Scotland's manufacturing and service sectors rose from a score of 50.5 in May to 50.9 in June. It marks the second consecutive monthly rise in business activity. RBS said that while the uptick was modest overall, it was the strongest since November 2024. The growth was driven entirely by the services sector with new project funding and a rise in demand underscoring the uptick. Manufacturing continued to fall sharply, the tracker found. Overall, business confidence improved to its highest level of optimism in eight months. Judith Cruickshank, chair of the One Bank Scotland Board, said: 'Scotland's private sector recorded a sustained uptick in activity at the end of the second quarter, with growth predominantly driven by service providers. 'In contrast, the manufacturing sector faced a challenging demand environment, leading to overall declines in new business and production. 'Despite these sectoral differences, firms exhibited increased optimism about the future, with manufacturers reporting positive growth forecasts for the first time in three months. 'In June, private sector firms encountered sharply rising operating costs, but selling price inflation slowed notably. This suggests a willingness among businesses to absorb some costs to bolster sales. 'The employment landscape remained broadly stable compared to the previous month, with sector data continuing to highlight diverging trends between manufacturers and service providers.' The UK as a whole saw output growth rise to a nine-month high, the tracker found, driven by expansions in business activity across eight of the 12 nations and regions monitored by the survey. Companies in Scotland recorded a ninth successive monthly fall in incoming new orders during June. The reduction in new work was centred on the manufacturing sector as services firms reported another expansion. UK-wide, new business rose for the first time in seven months. In Scotland, private sector companies remained optimistic about the year-ahead for activity in June. The degree of positive sentiment rose for a third straight month to the highest since October but was weaker than that recorded for the UK as a whole. Confidence across Scotland was supported by plans to introduce new product lines, improved operational performance, and strategic marketing efforts, the survey found. And after a slight rise in employment in May, Scotland's workforce numbers were broadly unchanged in June. Services firms reported increases in staffing levels amid upturns in new business and activity. However, this was offset by another month of job shedding at manufacturers. A near universal fall in headcounts was also recorded across the 12 monitored UK regions and nations, with Northern Ireland being the sole exception. Among the remaining areas, Scotland experienced the least pronounced drop in employment and one that was only 'fractional', RBS said. Since mid-2024, Scottish firms have continued to record a drop in backlogs of work, although June's rate of depletion was the weakest in eight months. RBS said that the fall is driven by a lack of orders in manufacturing which has allowed firms to complete outstanding orders. According to the survey, Scottish firms signalled another marked increase in average input costs during June. It found the rate of inflation quickened from May and was 'historically elevated'. Survey respondents often reported higher costs for materials, labour and energy, as well as rising supplier prices. However, the rise was less pronounced in Scotland compared to the UK as a whole. Firms north of the order also raised their output prices at a reduced rate in June. RBS described said the latest increase in charges was 'solid' but still amounted to the slowest rate in 11 months and was similar to the UK-wide average. Where higher charges were recorded, they were primarily attributed to the pass-through of increased operating expenses to customers.
BBC News
5 hours ago
- BBC News
Plan launched to tackle Fort William congestion problems
Consultants have been appointed to come up with a plan to ease congestion on Fort William's have been long-running complaints about gridlock, particularly on the A82, which runs through the town and is a major link connecting Inverness with engineering firms are expected to spend 18 months developing a package of priorities and potential funding sources for transport improvements.A previous study suggested emergency services staff faced delays getting to work and some teachers and pupils were late for school due to congested traffic. AECOM and Stantec have been tasked by Highland Council and regional transport body Hitrans to produce the integrated transport is part of a wider vision for Fort William and Lochaber area called Council's economy and infrastructure committee chairman Ken Gowans said the appointment of the consultants was a significant but long overdue said: "The appointment of AECOM and Stantec to take forward the integrated transport plan brings renewed momentum and a real opportunity to tackle the long-standing issues of congestion and connectivity that affect residents, businesses and emergency services alike."Mr Gowans added: "This plan is a key step in shaping a better future for Fort William and the wider Lochaber area."Transport Scotland the plan would explore measures to improve local connections, and journey times on the A82 through Fort William. 'Magic wand' Frazer Coupland, of West Highland Chamber of Commerce, welcomed the development describing it as a "lifetime opportunity" for Fort William and the wider Lochaber told BBC Scotland News: "We are a town of low resilience when it comes to our transport infrastructure."It only takes a small mistake to really congest the place up and gridlock us on occasions."A four to five-mile journey can take up to an hour if you go at the wrong times of day."Mr Coupland said everyone wished for a magic wand to sort out the traffic problems but added that it would take time to come up with solutions. In September, businesses warned that traffic congestion in and around Fort William was preventing them from Chamber of Commerce said getting through the town had been a problem for years but it was now at "crisis point".BSW Timber and fish farm company Mowi were among businesses which expressed frustration at delays at getting raw materials in and products Scottish government said at the time it had plans for improving travel through the town. Fort William is a popular Highland tourist destination as well as a base for industry, including an aluminium town has road and rail links to Inverness, Glasgow and Mallaig.A previous report, the Fort William Strategic Transport Study in 2018, set out some of the challenges to these reported congestion could get so bad through the town that emergency services staff and teachers could be prevented from getting to their work on firms said they had to put on extra vehicles at congested times to catch up with their timetable, while some residents avoided shopping in the town flow was highly seasonal with busiest months being May to August, according to the also told of their being only one way in or out of the town, which could present study said if there was an accident on the A82 just north or south of Fort William, motorists were faced with a 162-mile (261km) diversion via report also said improvements were constrained by the geography of the William has high mountains on one side, including Ben Nevis - the UK's highest mountain - and Loch Linnhe sea loch on the other.
Daily Mail
8 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Spend our £9bn windfall on fixing broken Scotland's problems, Swinney is urged
has been warned he must use a £9 billion boost from the UK Government to fix the problems created by his party. The First Minister came under intense pressure as the UK Government published details of the windfall from Chancellor Rachel Reeves 's spending review. The breakdown showed almost £6 billion extra for Holyrood thanks to higher UK spending on health and £2 billion from education. Opposition parties demanded the SNP spend the cash on the same priorities - not blow more millions on bureaucracy, waste and dead-end preparations for independence. Scottish Conservative finance spokesman Craig Hoy said: 'Hard-pressed Scots will be furious if the SNP squander the money they now have at their disposal. 'It should be spent on people's real priorities starting with our NHS which is in a state of permanent crisis under the SNP. 'Nationalist ministers have spent 18 years wasting money on their own pet projects and self-indulgent fringe obsessions, rather than what really impacts people's lives. 'Scots can ill-afford for that reckless approach to continue considering they are already paying more and getting less under the SNP.' The Chancellor's spending review on June 11 set out headline figures for day-to-day budgets until 2028/29 and for capital spending until 2029/30. Despite the £9.1 billion extra - which the SNP Government can spend as it chooses - on top of a record £50 billion a year grant, finance secretary Shona Robison said Westminster was 'treating Scotland as an afterthought and failing to provide us with the funding we need'. The 0.8 per cent real terms annual growth in Holyrood's funding meant Scotland had been 'short-changed' by £1.1 billion relative to the rest of the UK, she claimed. In a robust riposte, the Scotland Office yesterday set out how Treasury spending in devolved areas would give Holyrood the £9.1 billion extra through the Barnett funding formula. It showed that by 2030, health spending south of the Border will generate £5.8 billion of 'consequential' funding for Scotland, education £2.1 billion, justice £451 million, housing, communities and local government £380 million and transport £807 million. Scottish Secretary Ian Murray said: 'The UK Government has delivered the largest real terms settlement for the Scottish Government since devolution began in 1999, and ensured a definitive end to austerity in Scotland with £9.1billion more until the end of the decade. 'It is for the Scottish Government to determine how it spends this money. 'It is notable, however, that almost £6 billion of additional funding has been generated by health spending, and over £2billion by spending on education. Many Scots will expect to see better outcomes in their schools and hospitals given this record funding.' Mr Swinney and health secretary Neil Gray have vowed to 'renew' the NHS, but waiting lists, delayed discharges and cancelled operations remain stubbornly high. Around one in six Scots - more than 860,000 people - are waiting for NHS operations, appointments and tests, including more 100,000 waiting more than a year. Figures released last week showed one in 12 operations were cancelled in May last year. The SNP promised to eradicate delayed discharge in 2015, but an average 1,852 hospital beds a day were occupied by people who didn't need them in May, down just 12 on April. A lack of home and community care remains a key factor in patients being stuck on wards. Almost a third of people wait more than the four-hour target to be seen in A&E each week. In education, the attainment gap between well-off and poorer pupils, which the SNP promised to close, continues to widen. The proportion of pupils in the poorest areas getting Higher passes last year was 17.2 percentage points lower than in the most affluent - and even worse for Maths and English, where the gaps were 20.6 and 20.8 points respectively. Scottish Lib Dem MP Christine Jardine said: 'Even with a record funding settlement for the Scottish Government to spend, taxpayers will be feeling apprehensive. 'The SNP love to waste taxpayers' money on poorly managed projects like their wildly over budget ferries or their bungled centralisation of social care and then insist they need to pick people's pockets for more. 'With record funding for health, my constituents will expect to finally see some progress on long waits for care. Health and care are the top priority..' Scottish Labour Deputy Leader Jackie Baillie added: 'John Swinney is presiding over an out of control billion-pound prison project, spending hundreds of millions on a never-ending ferry fiasco and we've got more quangos than MSPs. 'After nearly two decades of the SNP wasting the public's money, Scotland has record NHS waiting lists, 10,000 children with nowhere to call home, a drug deaths crisis, overcrowded prisons and falling education standards. 'They have the money, they have the powers - if they had a plan to fix any of the mess they've created we'd have surely seen it by now.' Finance Secretary Shona Robison said: 'The UK Spending Review document sets out in black and white that our funding for day-to-day spending is set to grow by only 0.8 per cent over the next three years, compared with 1.2 per cent average growth for UK Government departments. This will short-change us by £1.1 billion pounds. 'What's more, we face an estimated £400 million shortfall from the UK Government's failure to fully fund their employer National Insurance increase.'
