Scrutiny for supervised drug consumption site in Victoria's ‘Downtown Eastside'
VICTORIA — The value of a supervised consumption site in the heart of Victoria's most downtrodden neighbourhood is under debate — is it a life-saving tool, or a magnet for drug dealers victimizing those in an encampment on the site's doorstep?
Victoria Coun. Marg Gardiner said the facility is a draw for both 'those addicted to drugs and for drug dealers, who prey on the weak and ill among those encamped' in the three blocks along Pandora Avenue.
'It's Victoria's Downtown Eastside,' she said in an interview, likening Pandora to the Vancouver neighbourhood plagued by crime, poverty and addiction.
Gardiner tabled a motion that went before council this week asking Victoria to formally request Island Health to close the facility, along with a second nearby facility, by Aug. 31.
The council put off any request and the issue was deferred until Nov. 6. Mayor Marianne Alto said time was needed to gather evidence for a 'well-informed discussion' about a 'very complex' issue like supervised-consumption sites.
Gardiner's motion was prompted by a presentation to council last month from Dr. Reka Gustafson, Island Health's chief medical health officer.
Gustafson said the 'vast majority of people who use substances' are not using the Pandora facility, adding that about 80 people are using inhalation services at the site each day.
'The estimated number of people who use opiates in British Columbia is 225,000,' she said. 'So, I think it's really important that the overwhelming majority of people, who use substances and who are dying from toxic substances aren't the people, who are visible to us, aren't necessarily the individuals, that we often talk about.'
For Gardiner, Gustafson's comments mean that users of the facility 'tend to be regular clientele' while 'most of those encamped on the 900 block of Pandora do not seek' out the facility.
Island Health did not directly respond to a request for an interview about Gustafson's comments but provided a statement describing the value of the consumption site.
Many consider the 800 to 1,000 blocks of Pandora Avenue the epicentre of Victoria's homelessness challenge with multiple tents and other sleeping structures set up along its sidewalks.
Bicycles and shopping carts loaded with belongings are parked nearby. Portable fencing has been set up to separate the encampment from a nearby church and other businesses.
Alto said delaying Gardiner's motion would give the city time to implement its recently approved Community Safety and Wellbeing Plan, which includes several items to address that section of Pandora Ave.
The mayor earlier this month announced the plan that would pour $10.35 million into more police and bylaw officers, temporary housing and cleanup as it tries to reduce crime, homelessness and addiction.
The supervised consumption site, known as The Harbour, first opened its doors in June 2018 as Victoria's first such facility under a federal exemption to the Controlled Drug and Substances Act that is set to expire in 2027.
The facility supervises people who consume drugs through their nose, mouth, injections and inhalation, so that they can receive immediate treatment in case they overdose. It also provides safer drug use supplies, drug testing, harm-reduction supplies and harm-reduction education among other services.
Island Health, which operates the facility in partnership with Lookout Housing and Health Society and Solid Outreach Society, said in its statement that the facility is part of 'evidence-based health services that reduce adverse outcomes and death for people who use substances.'
Island Health said the facility received about 3,000 visits from 445 different people in June. It said three drug poisonings happened inside the facility with no deaths or adverse events last month.
Preliminary information from the BC Centre for Disease Control shows that Island Health's seven overdose prevention and supervised consumption sites have averted an estimated 2,140 deaths between January 2019 and October 2024.
As of June 10, 2025, Greater Victoria has recorded 36 overdose deaths, down from 161 in 2024 and 175 in 2023.
Gardiner said in an interview that she knew the likelihood of council supporting her closure motion was 'quite low,' but defended it by saying that the 'general public has to know what is going on' on Pandora.
She said she believes the consumption sites are not working, and she suggests they should be closed entirely, rather than moved elsewhere.
The supervised consumption sites have failed, Gardiner said, especially against the backdrop of the deadly opioid fentanyl, which she said was a 'game-changer' in Victoria's drug subculture.
'The normalization of illicit drugs is harmful to individuals, who fall victim to drug addiction,' she said. 'It's harmful to their families, and it's harmful to society at large. If this council is committed to a safer city, it must do more than increase enforcement, while supporting illicit drug use behind closed door, because that is what we are doing.'
Alto said during debate that deferral of the motion gives time to discuss the future of the facility, not just with Island Health, but also with the province and other actors in the health field, including public health officials.
She said they'll be able to gather some evidence to have a 'well-informed discussion' and allow them to perhaps adjust the motion.
'I will say that I have already been in conversation with a number of those people, including (B.C. Health Minister) Josie Osborne,' Alto said Thursday, adding that Osborne had signalled a willingness to continue the conversation on improving the situation along Pandora Avenue.
Gardiner opposed deferral, saying that she does not 'want to wait another two years' before Victoria makes a decision.
Island Health didn't comment on the deferral.
'Island Health is aware of the recent motion before Victoria city council,' it said in its statement.
This report by Wolfgang Depner of The Canadian Press was first published July 12, 2025.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Winnipeg Free Press
2 hours ago
- Winnipeg Free Press
Wildfires show why CBC needs public safety mandate: researcher
OTTAWA – The wildfires that are flaring up across Canada again are one of the reasons public safety should be added to CBC/Radio-Canada's mandate, a new report from a research centre at McGill University argues. The report says other public media around the world are incorporating national emergency preparedness and crisis response into their role, and recommends that aspect of the CBC's mandate be formalized and strengthened. 'For us in Canada, wildfires and floods have sort of crept up on us in the last five years as part of an everyday reality,' said Jessica Johnson, a senior fellow at McGill University's Centre for Media, Technology and Democracy, who co-authored the report released Wednesday. 'They were always a reality if you were living in heavily forested areas. But now the smoke from some parts is affecting the whole country and even our neighbours.' On Monday and Tuesday, special air-quality statements caused by wildfire smoke were in effect in many areas of the country, with the government warning residents to consider limiting time outdoors and watch for symptoms of smoke exposure. Thousands of people in Manitoba, Saskatchewan and Alberta have been forced out of their homes this spring and summer due to the wildfires. The report says previous research that looked at false information during wildfires in Canada found that on social media, 'influential right-wing and anti-establishment groups blamed arson by green terrorists and the government for the fires, which further fuelled a distrust in the media in the moments when accurate information was critically important.' Johnson said in the interview that 'if there's misinformation online that's telling people it's just a hoax, you don't need to evacuate, that puts people's lives at risk.' There are also wider concerns about misinformation. Facebook, a platform many have come to rely on for information, blocks news content in Canada, while some Canadians are increasingly turning to generative AI for information, even though such systems can make mistakes and provide false information. 'We've lost a lot of the healthy sources in addition to the arrival of the unreliable sources of information,' Johnson said. While some countries in recent years have been changing the mandates of their public media in response to the climate crisis, she explained, others have been doing it in response to security concerns — for instance, Baltic countries looking at their proximity to Russia. The head of the recent public inquiry into foreign interference concluded that misinformation and disinformation are an existential threat to Canada's democracy, Johnson noted. 'So you start putting it all together and you realize public media starts to look not like a nice to have. It starts to like a part of your communications infrastructure,' Johnson said. During this year's federal election, the Liberals promised to increase the CBC's funding by an initial $150 million annually, and to make a number of changes to the its mandate. That includes adding 'the clear and consistent transmission of life-saving information during emergencies.' Johnson said it's important to ensure that the CBC isn't just repeating information provided by the government, but that it's able to question and hold the government to account. Another key element is ensuring the public broadcaster has the ability to do the work it's tasked with, especially at the local level. Johnson gave the example of residents in an area facing a wildfire, who should be able to find information about potential evacuations affecting their community, instead of media reports being focused on broadly informing Canadians across the country about the fire. She noted there are parts of the country where, when it comes to media presence, the CBC 'is kind of the only game in town or in the nearest town.' Johnson said one option is for the CBC to partner with local independent journalists, a model which has been implemented in Britain and 'could be a great model for Canada.' Changing technology also means there are technical issues to consider — internet and cellphone networks can go down, and many people don't have traditional TV or radios anymore. 'I think it's a government responsibility to do that work, whether it involves research, and say, are we actually prepared, and who needs to be involved in a conversation about making sure that we're prepared?' The CRTC, Canada's broadcast and telecom regulator, announced Tuesday that it's launching a consultation on how to improve Canada's public alert system. It requires cellphone, cable and satellite providers, and TV and radio broadcasters to distribute emergency alerts. Johnson's report concludes that Canada's emergency preparedness needs are changing, and that means 'CBC-Radio Canada may need to be structured to serve the country in ways it hasn't had to in the past.' This report by The Canadian Press was first published July 16, 2025.
National Post
2 hours ago
- National Post
Opinion: Ottawa is underfunding pharmacare and dental care, exacerbating current inequities
Article content These principles should mean that any Canadian who requires a medicine is able to access it when they need it without being restricted by unnecessary rules and regulations, inhibited by cost or rationed according to where they live. Article content However, diabetes medication coverage is limited to predominantly older, inexpensive drugs. Newer drugs, such tirzepatide (which directly treats Type 2 diabetes) and finerenone (which addresses some of its most serious side effects) are excluded — despite having been shown to reduce the risk of heart attacks, strokes and end-stage kidney disease in diabetics. Article content Furthermore, only British Columbia, Manitoba, Prince Edward Island and the Yukon have so far signed the necessary bilateral agreements with Ottawa for national pharmacare. Alberta and Quebec have indicated that they have no interest in the program, although both want their share of the money dangled by the federal government. Article content When national pharmacare coverage is only available in some jurisdictions and restricted to older, inexpensive drugs, patients living in provinces that refuse to join the program will have better access to medications than those in jurisdictions that have signed on. This will not only perpetuate current differences between provincial drug plans, it will exacerbate them. Article content The situation could become even worse if more drug types are eventually included in national pharmacare and employers see the expansion as a chance to save money by cancelling employees' private drug insurance coverage. Article content As presently implemented, dental care and pharmacare satisfy few Canadians' expectations or needs. Ottawa should be transparent with Canadians about its objectives for the CDCP and national pharmacare. Article content Instead of funding a national pharmacare program that fails to fill the gaps, a better way forward would be for Ottawa to transfer that money to provincial governments. The provinces should then use those funds to level up their coverage to that of the best available provincial plan in the country, and exempt lower-income Canadians from co-payments. Article content Article content Article content
CBC
2 hours ago
- CBC
Equipment failure at Winnipeg clinic caused blood plasma donor's kidney injury, lawsuit alleges
A Winnipeg man who donated blood plasma at a plasma clinic has filed a lawsuit claiming he suffered a serious kidney injury after something went wrong with the machine used in the procedure to withdraw blood. The plaintiff alleges the issue happened at the Grifols plasma collection facility, operated by the Ontario-based Canadian Plasma Resources, on Taylor Avenue in Winnipeg. It gives members of the public an honorarium payment for donating blood plasma, according to his lawsuit, filed July 9 with Manitoba Court of King's Bench. On July 15, 2023, the now 43-year-old donor went to the clinic for what the lawsuit describes as a routine plasma donation through a procedure called plasmapheresis, which involves blood passing through medical equipment to separate the plasma from the red blood cells. The red blood cells are then returned to the donor, along with replacement fluids. The procedure took about 90 minutes, and the donor left the Grifols facility around 10:45 a.m., the lawsuit says. Around noon, he began to feel ill and experienced symptoms such as blood in his urine and flu-like symptoms, it says. He called Canadian Plasma Resources to ask if the symptoms were anything he should be concerned about, but was told they were unaware of any issue that would cause them, his lawsuit says. He was advised to drink fluids and seek medical attention if the symptoms worsened. By shortly after 1 p.m., the donor began having significant abdominal pain, which continued to intensify, his lawsuit says. He was taken by ambulance to St. Boniface Hospital, where medical tests were done, including blood work, an ultrasound, a CT scan and urinalysis, to determine the source of his symptoms, the court document says. At the hospital, the donor got an email from Canadian Plasma Resources informing him that a "machine error" caused some red blood cells removed during the procedure to be "broken" and erroneously returned into his body along with the plasma, the claim says. It says he was advised the error may cause him to experience symptoms such as "blood in the urine, lower flank pain, shortness of breath, fever, weakness, confusion, or yellowing of the skin." Acute kidney injury: lawsuit The medical testing determined the donor had suffered an acute kidney injury as a result of the error, the claim alleges. He is suing Canadian Plasma Resources, which operates as Grifols, as well as three Grifols employees identified as health-care professionals. The allegations have not been tested in court, and the defendants have not filed statements of defence. The lawsuit says the man continued to experience fatigue and low energy that made him unable to return to work for about a month, after which he went back to work gradually. He continued suffering fatigue and low energy for about six months, the claim says. It also alleges he has suffered "non-reversible and permanent injuries" from the acute kidney injury, which may result in chronic kidney disease in his lifetime. The lawsuit seeks damages for pain, suffering, loss of enjoyment of life and lost income, among other damages. It alleges the employees at Grifols working at the time of the machine error failed to ensure the medical equipment was working safely and properly, and failed to recognize the equipment was malfunctioning. The employees also failed to advise the donor in a timely way that there was an error during his procedure and that he might experience complications, the claim alleges. CBC reached out to the plaintiff and his lawyer, as well as the defendants Grifols and Canadian Plasma Resources, but did not receive comment on the lawsuit before deadline. Grifols' website says plasma, the straw-coloured liquid portion of blood in which blood cells are suspended, is "used to manufacture life-saving and life-changing therapies." It says tens of thousands of Canadians benefit from plasma therapies used to treat a range of medical issues, such as immune deficiencies, respiratory disorders, and surgical bleeding, among others.
