This is the moment when we find out just how mad a king Donald is
'George III is Abraham Lincoln compared to Trump,' said Rick Atkinson, who is vivifying the Revolutionary War in his mesmerising histories The British are Coming and The Fate of the Day. The latter, the second book in a planned trilogy, has been on the New York Times bestseller list for six weeks and is being devoured by lawmakers on Capitol Hill.
As the 'No Kings' resistance among Democrats bristles, and as
President Trump
continues to defy limits on executive power, it is instructive to examine comparisons of President Trump to George III.
'George isn't the 'royal brute' that Thomas Paine calls him in Common Sense,' Atkinson told me. 'He's not the 'tyrant' that Jefferson calls him in the Declaration of Independence, and he's not the sinister idiot who runs across the stage in Hamilton every night singing You'll Be Back.'
READ MORE
('And when push comes to shove, I will send a fully armed battalion to remind you of my love!')
Yes, George III had manic episodes that scared people – depicted in Alan Bennett's The Madness of George III, a play made into a movie with Nigel Hawthorne and Helen Mirren. Palace aides are unnerved when the king's urine turns blue.
'He was in a straitjacket for a while, that's how deranged he was,' Atkinson said. 'His last 10 years were spent at Windsor, basically in a cell. He went blind and deaf. He had long white hair, white beard.'
This is a poisonous moment for our country, with Trump unleashing our military on American citizens and letting ICE officers rough up Democratic lawmakers
King George was relentless about his runaway child: America.
'He's ruthless,' Atkinson explained, 'because he believes that if the American colonies are permitted to slip away, it will encourage insurrections in Ireland, in Canada, the British Sugar Islands, the West Indies, in India, and it'll be the beginning of the end of the first British empire, which has just been created. And it's not going to happen on his watch.'
Unlike Trump, who loves to wallow in gilt and repost king memes and rhapsodise about God's divine plan for him, George III did not flout the rule of law.
'The stereotype of him as an ogre is not historically true,' Atkinson said. 'He's called Farmer George because he's interested in agronomy and writes essays on manure.'
The historian added: 'You can dislike him, but he's not a reactionary autocrat. He is very attentive to the requirements imposed on him as a consequence of the reforms in the 17th century, where he must be attentive to both houses of parliament.
'He's a child of the Enlightenment. He is a major supporter of both the arts and the sciences.' He plays the harpsichord and the organ and he's a great patron of the theatre.' (And doesn't try to co-opt it or force people to watch Cats.)
Unlike Trump, Atkinson said, George III is not a narcissist: 'He's very committed to the realm, to his family. He marries this obscure, drab German princess, Charlotte, as in Charlottesville, Virginia, and Charlotte, North Carolina. They marry six hours after they meet.
She learns to play God Save the King on the harpsichord on the voyage from Germany to England. He has the marriage bedroom decorated with 700 yards of blue damask and large basins of goldfish. 'Because, as you know, nothing says 'I love you' like a bowl of goldfish. He's devoted to her through 15 kids.'
Atkinson said the only similarity between the pious monarch and the impious monarch manqué is 'the use of the military against their own people to enforce the king's will. There are incidents, the Boston Massacre, the Boston Tea Party.'
He added: 'This proclivity for using armed forces for domestic suppression of dissent. That's a slippery slope in this country. It led to an eight-year war when George did it, and Lord knows where it's going to lead this time.'
This is a poisonous moment for our country, with Trump unleashing our military on American citizens and letting ICE officers rough up Democratic lawmakers. He's still posting, madly, about the 2020 election being 'a total FRAUD,' and now he's calling for a special prosecutor to look into it.
With the juvenile delinquent Pete Hegseth leading our military, Trump is recklessly jousting with Iran and threatening to assassinate the Iranian leader. The former opponent of forever wars in the Middle East is debating dropping bombs in the Middle East without military provocation against the United States – which did not work out well for us in the past – and dragging us into another unpredictable, interminable war.
We find this truth to be self-evident: this is the moment when we find out just how mad a king Donald Trump is.
Atkinson concedes he is as mystified as the rest of us by Trump's affinity for 'those who aren't bound by the rules by which we insist our leaders be bound. The fact that we're looking for a monarch to draw parallels to him is telling in and of itself, because that's not what we do. That's what the whole shooting match was about in the 1770s.'
This article originally
appeared in The New York Times
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Extra.ie
2 hours ago
- Extra.ie
Donald Trump threatens to deport New York mayoral candidate Zohran Mamdani
President Donald Trump has threatened to deport New York state lawmaker Zohran Mamdani. The US president claimed he would arrest the Democratic nominee for New York City mayor if he defies Immigration and Customs Enforcement operations. Trump also branded the 33-year-old a 'communist' while talking to reporters on Tuesday at the new 'Alligator Alcatraz' migrant detention center in Florida. President Donald Trump has threatened to deport New York state lawmaker Zohran Mamdani. Pic:Speaking during his victory speech following the mayoral primaries in NYC, Mamdani said he would 'stop masked ICE agents from deporting our neighbors.' During the press conference this week, Trump was asked how he felt about these comments, simply responding: 'Well then, we'll have to arrest him. 'Look, we don't need a communist in this country, but if we have one, I'm going to be watching over him very carefully on behalf of the nation,' he continued. The US president claimed he would arrest the Democratic nominee for New York City mayor if he defies Immigration and Customs Enforcement operations. Pic: Michael M. Santiago/Getty Images Trump also discussed claims that Mamdani is in the US illegally. 'A lot of people are saying he's here illegally,' Trump said. 'We're going to look at everything. Ideally, he's going to turn out to be much less than a communist. But right now he's a communist. That's not a socialist.' Born in Uganda, Mamdani has lived in the United States since he was 7 years old, becoming a naturalised citizen in 2018. Mamdani responded to Trump in a statement on Tuesday, writing: 'His statements don't just represent an attack on our democracy but an attempt to send a message to every New Yorker who refuses to hide in the shadows: if you speak up, they will come for you. We will not accept this intimidation.'
Irish Times
5 hours ago
- Irish Times
Republicans advance Trump tax-cut Bill, opening way for debate
Donald Trump 's flagship tax and spending Bill moved closer to final Congressional approval on Thursday after Republican holdouts in the House of Representatives agreed to advance the legislation. The rebellion by a handful of members of Mr Trump's own party held up the Bill's progress for several hours, but the House finally voted 219-213 to take the legislation to a final vote later on Thursday. 'We have the votes,' Mike Johnson, the speaker of the House, told reporters. 'We're still going to meet the deadline.' The legislation, which Mr Trump dubs the 'big, beautiful Bill', extends vast tax cuts from his first administration, paid for in part by steep cuts to Medicaid, the public health insurance scheme for low-income and disabled Americans, and other social welfare programmes. READ MORE The Bill would also roll back Joe Biden -era tax credits for clean energy, while increasing investment in the military and border protection. With a narrow majority in the House, Republicans can only afford to lose three votes on the Bill. Mr Trump, who has set a deadline of July 4th to sign the Bill into law, earlier lashed out at the Republican holdouts on his Truth Social network. 'Largest Tax Cuts in History and a Booming Economy vs. Biggest Tax Increase in History, and a Failed Economy. What are the Republicans waiting for??? What are you trying to prove??? MAGA IS NOT HAPPY, AND IT'S COSTING YOU VOTES!!!,' Mr Trump said. On Wednesday, Mr Trump met privately at the White House with Republican dissidents to prevent them from torpedoing the Bill. Several conservative and centrist Republican lawmakers have raised concerns about the legislation that was approved by the Senate this week. Some are unhappy that the Bill — which implements a big chunk of Mr Trump's domestic agenda — does not go far enough to rein in the US debt, or cut back clean energy subsidies. Others are worried about cuts to healthcare programmes. A version of the sweeping legislation was narrowly passed in the Senate after three Republicans sided with Democrats against the Bill, forcing US vice-president JD Vance to cast a tie-breaking vote. That sent the legislation back to the House, which must approve the Bill before Mr Trump signs it into law. An earlier version of the legislation passed the House by a single vote in May. Fiscally conservative lawmakers, including many Freedom Caucus members, object to the cost of the legislation, which the non-partisan Congressional Budget Office (CBO) says will add $3.4 trillion to the deficit over the next decade. The group has circulated a three-page memo detailing what it described as 'failures' of the Senate Bill. More moderate members have argued that the cuts to Medicaid, which would strip an estimated 12 million people of their health insurance, are too steep. The White House has dismissed the CBO's projections and argued that the Bill would more than pay for itself in the long term by generating stronger economic growth. - Copyright The Financial Times Limited 2025
Irish Times
5 hours ago
- Irish Times
Trump says Federal Reserve chair Jerome Powell should ‘resign immediately'
US President Donald Trump said on Wednesday that Jerome Powell , the chair of the Federal Reserve, should 'resign immediately,' escalating an earlier call less than a week ago encouraging him to do so. The president has repeatedly lambasted Mr Powell recently for not cutting interest rates, saying he was costing the country a 'fortune' in debt-servicing costs. In a social media post on Wednesday, Mr Trump linked to an article about comments from Bill Pulte, the head of the US Housing Finance Agency, who wrote on social platform X that the Fed chair should be investigated for 'his political bias, and his deceptive Senate testimony'. At issue is Mr Powell's insistence that the Fed can afford to be patient about cutting interest rates with the economy still on solid footing and inflation risks rising again because of Mr Trump's tariffs . READ MORE On Tuesday, Mr Powell hinted that the Fed would have been able to lower rates if it were not for those policies. In his statement on X, Mr Pulte, who leads the agency that regulates mortgage firms Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, accused Mr Powell of making false statements at a congressional hearing about the swelling costs of a planned renovation of the Fed's headquarters. [ Fed holds rates unchanged as Donald Trump calls chairman Jerome Powell 'stupid' Opens in new window ] At that hearing, Powell pushed back on media reports that the plans included features like a VIP diningroom and new marble table. The administration's attacks on Mr Powell are not new. Just in the past week, Trump has called Mr Powell a 'stubborn mule' and penned him a handwritten note to apply pressure on the Fed to lower interest rates. How the wealthy are buying up land to avoid inheritance tax Listen | 22:03 The president has also previously threatened to remove Powell from his role as chair before his term expires in 2026, but the Supreme Court recently signalled he is not able to do so. This article originally appeared in The New York Times . 2025 The New York Times Company
