Tougher rules needed for utility firms digging up roads, MPs say
Transport Committee chairwoman Ruth Cadbury said a pattern of repeated works can feel like a 'recurring nightmare' for road users.
Under current rules, utility firms are responsible for the quality of the road surfaces they have reinstated for two years after works have completed, or three years in the case of deeper excavations.
The committee called for that period to be extended to five years so council tax payers do not have to pick up the bill for repairing potholes caused by shoddy remediation work.
Other recommendations from the committee included:
– Tighter use of immediate permits enabling companies to dig up roads with little or no notice given to the local authority.
– A new streetworks commissioner, similar to the Scottish roadworks tsar, to monitor performance and resolve disputes.
– The wider use of lane rental schemes, charging firms up to £2,500 a day to incentivise quicker completion of works.
– Better co-operation so utility firms and housing developers can work on the same bit of road at the same time rather than have repeated closures.
Labour MP Ms Cadbury acknowledged that ageing infrastructure under the roads needed to be maintained and upgraded and extra cables and pipes were required for new homes.
'But as every road user knows, street works can feel like a recurring nightmare,' she said.
The committee's recommendations would make a huge difference if they were implemented, she said.
'Upping the quality of reinstatement works will help stem the never-ending plague of potholes on local roads.
'Lane rental schemes should provide a financial incentive to complete works on time.
'And longer-term planning and earlier notification should help councils prevent the infuriating occurrence of multiple roads being closed in one locality, or the same road being dug up multiple times in one year.'
A Department for Transport spokesman said: 'We wholeheartedly agree that streetworks are far too disruptive for drivers and that is why we have taken action to prevent the impact on drivers.
'We've cracked down on streetwork companies overrunning or leaving roads poorly repaired by ramping up fines and giving local authorities new powers to coordinate roadworks more efficiently and will put measures in place so 50% of surplus lane rental funds must be invested into highway maintenance.
'We are determined to end the pothole plague, which is why we are already investing £1.6 billion this year to help local authorities resurface local roads and fix the equivalent of up to seven million extra potholes this year.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Scottish Sun
36 minutes ago
- Scottish Sun
Scottish pub granted 9am licence ‘to allow travelling workers early pints'
Click to share on X/Twitter (Opens in new window) Click to share on Facebook (Opens in new window) A SCOTTISH pub is set to start serving alcohol as early as 9am after arguing that it would allow travelling workers to have an early pint. Bosses of Spider's Web in Dyce, Aberdeen, lodged a bid to the local council to have its licensed hours brought back by an hour. Sign up for Scottish Sun newsletter Sign up 2 Spider's Web in Dyce will now serve alcohol an hour earlier Credit: GOOGLE MAPS The boozer is located on Station Road, just meters away from Dyce Railway Station. And it is often frequented by oil and gas offshore workers who arrive back in the city after lengthy trips away. The early visits from the offshore workers prompted owner Mark Milne to apply for the licensing change. He explained that it would let the pub serve them alcohol after a long, tiring journey that gets them home early in the morning. At a recent meeting, licensing consultant David Scott urged the board to give the changes the green light. According to STV News, he said it was 'for the benefit of the oil and gas industry and the city'. Time has a different meaning to these workers, this is a unique situation serving a very specific set of circumstances David Scott And he argued that the beloved pub is a 'stop-off point' where workers go to "debrief for a pint or two' while waiting on their trains, buses or lifts back home. Scott said: "I fully appreciate that the idea of a 9am start for having a drink seems entirely unnecessary, but that is not the situation we are dealing with here. 'These workers are coming off rigs – they've already been up for hours and may work a nightshift before they arrive in Aberdeen. 'Time has a different meaning to these workers, this is a unique situation serving a very specific set of circumstances. I went to the UK's biggest Wetherspoons with rooftop bar overlooking the beach 'The location means it's the only and last opportunity that many workers get time to debrief. 'People open up after a pint – concerns can be raised, conversations take place that wouldn't be possible in the offshore environment, problems are solved and friendships are made.' Milne also appealed to the planning committee and urged them to allow him to change his operating plan. At the moment, children and young people are not allowed into the public bar in Spider's Web. I fully appreciate that the idea of a 9am start for having a drink seems entirely unnecessary, but that is not the situation we are dealing with here David Scott But Milne, who has run the boozer for 35 years, said that this has often left customers, who want somewhere to go while on a train, frustrated. As a result, he has asked councillors to allow kids and youngsters into the pub, stressing that it would only be when they are accompanied by an adult at all times. He added that it would let them carry out innocent tasks like playing at the pub's pool table, which is located close to the bar. He said: 'I'm not a fan of kids in the public bar, but occasionally folk waiting for a train say, 'Can I take my son through for a quick game of pool?'. 'You feel bad saying 'No, you can't'. Folk might think we are unreasonable, but that's the rules.' 'I know the reason we are saying no, but the public thinks we are being heavy-handed.' However, some licensing standards officers initially pushed back against the changes. They explained that the 9am opening time would go against policy and also stated that they had a problem with allowing young children inside. LATE LICENSE SPIDER'S Web isn't the only bar that has applied to change its licensing hours. In May last year, over 50 venues in Glasgow submitted applications to stay open later under a new pilot scheme. The new one-year scheme allows boozers to stay open for an extra hour to trial 1am licenses. According to BBC Scotland News, Glasgow Licensing Board approved 54 applications, and the new closing times were introduced with immediate effect. It also meant that the operating times match those in Edinburgh which already allows bars to stay open until 1am. SNP councillors first pushed for the pilot scheme back in November 2023 in a bid to boost the late-night economy in Glasgow. Bailie Thomas Kerr, who chairs the Glasgow Licensing Board, told BBC Scotland News there was "considerable support" for 1am closing times. He said: 'Glasgow city centre is a great place for a night out and we want to ensure people who come to enjoy the centre have the best possible experience. "We think the 01:00 pilot can improve public safety in the city centre and that's something we will be looking at very closely with our partners following the conclusion of the 12-month trial period.' But others argued that the pool table would be supervised by staff and is actually tucked away by a partition wall, meaning it wouldn't be close to the actual bar. To compromise, councillor Neil Copland suggested that Spider's Web would open at 9am every day except a Sunday, when it would open at 10am. And he said that youngsters could be allowed inside the bar and use the pool table up until 8pm . Councillor Marie Boulton agreed with the suggestions, but stressed it was only because of the 'unique circumstances' surrounding the bar. She added: 'Offshore workers will not be hanging about all day, it's only for a short period. 'I wouldn't want there to be a feeling that we are trying to encourage longer drinking.' The board unanimously agreed on the proposal and approved the request.
Powys County Times
3 hours ago
- Powys County Times
Bus improvements 'at expense of Powys council tax rise'
POWYS councillors have narrowly voted in favour of providing the £1.349 million needed to fund the new bus timetable preferred option. But many opposition councillors felt aggrieved that the extraordinary Powys County Council meeting was held on Friday, July 4, the last possible date to sign the paperwork that allows the new seven-year contracts to come into force on September 1. The preferred option will provide for longer distance services connecting the five 'sustainable Powys' hub towns and then travelling on to larger towns and cities that Powys residents need to get to for health, education and other services that are not available in the county. The changes would provide longer hours and weekend services, This option had been backed by the Liberal Democrat/Labour cabinet last month, and need an extra £2.354 million on top of the basic £5.442 million. To help fund this year's contract the council needed to find £1.349 million from several internal budgets, which were transferred as virements which could only be agreed at a full council meeting. Plaid Cymru group leader Cllr Elwyn Vaughan said: 'Why are we having this discussion at such a late stage? 'It's highly unfortunate and some would say unprofessional that we're having such an important discussion on multi-million-pound contracts at the very last minute. 'It's been known for months when the new contracts would be in place. 'We've been railroaded into a take it or leave it situation, and we should have had more time.' Cabinet member for Highways, Transport and Recycling Cllr Jackie Charlton (Liberal Democrat) said: 'I am really disappointed that you think this is unprofessional. 'I think it's been one of the most professional processes I have seen in this authority. 'We've looked at the really extensive contracts we have with local providers, making sure we can extend wherever possible our existing (bus) network and deliver on what people asked for.' Cllr Charlton stressed: 'It's been through the full democratic process, it's been through scrutiny, cabinet and has been out to engagement.' Cllr Gareth E Jones (Powys Independents) believed that funding the bus services from next year onwards could result in a 'two per cent increase in council tax'. Cabinet member for Finance, Cllr David Thomas said: 'It's a premature to suggest that it will be funded from council tax as we don't know what (financial) settlement we'll receive from the Welsh Government.' He explained that departmental savings, and the government funding floor agreed earlier this year could all be considered to help fund the bus contracts in the longer term. While opposition councillors continued to attack the proposal Liberal Democrat councillors came out to defend it. Cllr Glyn Preston (Liberal Democrat) said: 'One of the largest villages in Wales (Trefeglwys) not served by a bus route, is now going to be served by one.' Cabinet member for legal and regulatory services, Cllr Richard Church (Liberal Democrat) pointed out the 'cross party' Economy Residents and Communities scrutiny committee had supported this option after they discussed the report last month. 'We should be shouting from the rooftops the fact that we are bringing back Sunday and evening services,' said Cllr Church. Eventually a vote was held which saw 25 councillors vote in favour of the virement, 21 vote against it and one councillor abstained.
BBC News
6 hours ago
- BBC News
Labour's first year: How has the North East and Cumbria fared?
A year ago Labour won all but two of north-east England and Cumbria's 32 constituencies in a landslide election that swept Sir Keir Starmer into Downing after a bumpy 12 months is Labour's rose still proud, or a little wilted?Time to see whether July 2025 marks a happy or unhappy anniversary. Giving us more power Happy anniversary: One of Labour's strongest areas. Within days of taking office, Sir Keir Starmer invited the country's elected regional mayors into 10 Downing Street, including the North East's Kim McGuinness and the one Conservative mayor, Tees Valley's Lord PM was keen to enlist them in his plan for economic growth and so far Labour has largely been good to its word, with regular meetings between ministers and has offered more powers and more freedom, while more money is also on the way. The test will be if it is sustained, but even Ben Houchen says he cannot find fault in the approach to anniversary: A lack of devolution has seen Cumbria miss out on any available pots of money. But that could change next year when the county is due to get an elected mayor, which will unlock its own devolution deal. Getting us moving Happy anniversary: The biggest boost to that devolution process was the release of almost £2.8bn for the mayors to spend on local projects (£1bn for Tees Valley, £1.8bn for the rest of the North East).And that means Kim McGuinness can now promise a long-awaited extension of the Tyne & Wear Metro to Washington. Other investments planned include trams in Teesside and work on Middlesbrough only problem for Labour is that travellers won't see the results of some of this investment until well after the next election. Unhappy anniversary: Labour has been less keen on big road projects. A scheme to dual a 13-mile section of the A1 in Northumberland was scrapped in Rachel Reeves' first Budget, even though the previous government had spent £68.4m preparing the over "budget" alternatives have started, but it is not the first time a plan for the A1 has failed to come to campaigners are also still waiting to find out the fate of the £1.4bn plan to upgrade the remaining single carriageway sections of the A66 between Scotch Corner and Penrith. It has been officially paused with a decision apparently imminent. Making us healthier Happy anniversary: The latest waiting list figures had some encouraging news. Since Labour came to power the numbers on the list in the North East and Yorkshire regional NHS area have fallen by more than 19, anniversary: There is a long way to go if Labour is to meet its election target of 92% of patients waiting no more than 18 weeks. It is a target that has not been reached since 2015 and none of our hospital trusts managed to reach it in the latest is performing the best with 79.5% waiting no more than 18 weeks, but North Cumbria performs below the national average with only 56.5% treated within that time. Labour has pledged to meet the target by March 2029. Making us wealthier Happy anniversary: In terms of tackling poverty, a 6.7% increase in the National Living Wage paid to over-21s stands to benefit a significant number of people in a region which has the lowest pay in the UK. Thousands of children will also benefit from a decision to broaden the entitlement to free school meals to all families claiming Universal Credit, though that will not kick in until next year. Breakfast clubs in some of the area's schools will come sooner and new nurseries will help parents with anniversary: There is still a great deal of uncertainty about the government's plans to reform Personal Independence Payments and reduce the entitlement for some. Nothing now looks likely to change until after a review concludes next year but, as the region with the highest take up of the disability benefit, any change could have a significant impact. The U-turn on winter fuel payments for older people will mean more now qualify, but of course thousands lost out in the first winter of this government.A decision on whether to scrap the two-child cap on some benefits has yet to come. It is something campaigners in the North East say could make the biggest difference to child poverty, but with the government now searching for money to replace the savings sacrificed with the winter fuel and welfare change rethinks, it may have made the change less likely. Boosting our businesses Happy anniversary: There was a welcome in the North East business community for the government's recently-published 10-year industrial strategy. It offers the potential of support and investment in sectors where the region is strong, from manufacturing and green energy to the creative will be moves to help businesses like Nissan and the chemical industry with high energy bills, though not till 2027. A promise to invest in nuclear power will be of interest in Cumbria and was a big boost for Hitachi in County Durham, with new work to build trains delivering on the prime minister's pre-election pledge to secure its future. Unhappy anniversary: Some businesses have faced extra costs because of Labour's decision to raise their National Insurance Cumbria there has been concern that tourism and hospitality did not feature in the industrial the recent decision by a major investor to pull out of plans to develop a film studio in Sunderland was a reminder that no amount of strategy can cover every the protests over changes to inheritance tax, it is probably best not to ask our farmers whether they have enjoyed Labour's first year! Electoral prospects Happy anniversary: Just before July's General Election, Labour's Kim McGuinness became the first North East Mayor and her presence in the region offered a chance for a politician from the party to deliver in lockstep with the government and champion the least Labour scraping home in the North Tyneside mayoral election this May shows it can still win here. And they do not have to call another general election until 2029. Unhappy anniversary: The continuing rise of Reform UK since the party polled well in the region last July poses a big political threat. Its sweeping victory in this year's Durham County Council election shows just how serious the challenge even if the Conservatives are still struggling, the Liberal Democrats and Greens have also been looking to pick off the party's voters. Next year's local elections offer fresh challenges and, on current polling, Labour's longstanding command of the councils in Newcastle, Sunderland, South Tyneside and Gateshead could well be over. Follow BBC North East on X and Facebook and BBC Cumbria on X and Facebook and both on Nextdoor and Instagram.
