NRL downplays judiciary change after Cleary frustration
The Australian Rugby League Commission (ARLC) now has the power to charge players for on-field acts if they are dissatisfied with the sanctions proposed by the previously independent match review committee (MRC).
Rugby League Players Association boss Clint Newton termed the change "unprecedented over-reach" last week, while four-time premiership-winning Penrith coach Cleary said it implied a "disturbing" lack of faith in the MRC from league bosses.
The rule change comes as the NRL continues to search for consistency between on-field penalties and post-match sanctions for illegal tackles.
Speaking at the launch of the NRL's Beanie For Brain Cancer round, NRL CEO Andrew Abdo insisted the change was only an "insurance policy".
"All it really means is that the Commission is able to, on very rare circumstances if ever, apply to the judiciary to review a matter that may have been missed by the match review committee, or may have, in their view, not been graded appropriately," he said.
"There could be an upwards movement of the grading, it could be a downwards movement of the grading.
"This would be in very rare, exceptional circumstances as an insurance policy. It's not a case of us being in a situation where we're going to see this applied regularly, if at all."
Abdo claimed not to have been aware of frustrated comments made by Cleary, who on Tuesday said it would be better for the NRL to rethink the entire system than weigh in sporadically.
But Abdo said if teams were dissatisfied with the ARLC's charges, they could still challenge proposed sanctions at the judiciary as normal.
"The Commission has no powers to make a final decision, those powers will sit with the judiciary," Abdo said.
Cleary pointed to Scott Sorensen's two-game ban as an example that the judiciary system was making mistakes, with the second-rower escaping on-field sanction altogether for his hip-drop style tackle on Dallin Watene-Zelezniak.
"We'll make no apology for wanting to protect players and we'll also put the onus on the defender to take all measures to avoid those indicators (of a hip-drop)," Abdo said.
The NRL's chief executive has downplayed a controversial change to the judiciary system, saying the league may never need to enact the new rule that has angered Ivan Cleary and the players' union.
The Australian Rugby League Commission (ARLC) now has the power to charge players for on-field acts if they are dissatisfied with the sanctions proposed by the previously independent match review committee (MRC).
Rugby League Players Association boss Clint Newton termed the change "unprecedented over-reach" last week, while four-time premiership-winning Penrith coach Cleary said it implied a "disturbing" lack of faith in the MRC from league bosses.
The rule change comes as the NRL continues to search for consistency between on-field penalties and post-match sanctions for illegal tackles.
Speaking at the launch of the NRL's Beanie For Brain Cancer round, NRL CEO Andrew Abdo insisted the change was only an "insurance policy".
"All it really means is that the Commission is able to, on very rare circumstances if ever, apply to the judiciary to review a matter that may have been missed by the match review committee, or may have, in their view, not been graded appropriately," he said.
"There could be an upwards movement of the grading, it could be a downwards movement of the grading.
"This would be in very rare, exceptional circumstances as an insurance policy. It's not a case of us being in a situation where we're going to see this applied regularly, if at all."
Abdo claimed not to have been aware of frustrated comments made by Cleary, who on Tuesday said it would be better for the NRL to rethink the entire system than weigh in sporadically.
But Abdo said if teams were dissatisfied with the ARLC's charges, they could still challenge proposed sanctions at the judiciary as normal.
"The Commission has no powers to make a final decision, those powers will sit with the judiciary," Abdo said.
Cleary pointed to Scott Sorensen's two-game ban as an example that the judiciary system was making mistakes, with the second-rower escaping on-field sanction altogether for his hip-drop style tackle on Dallin Watene-Zelezniak.
"We'll make no apology for wanting to protect players and we'll also put the onus on the defender to take all measures to avoid those indicators (of a hip-drop)," Abdo said.
The NRL's chief executive has downplayed a controversial change to the judiciary system, saying the league may never need to enact the new rule that has angered Ivan Cleary and the players' union.
The Australian Rugby League Commission (ARLC) now has the power to charge players for on-field acts if they are dissatisfied with the sanctions proposed by the previously independent match review committee (MRC).
Rugby League Players Association boss Clint Newton termed the change "unprecedented over-reach" last week, while four-time premiership-winning Penrith coach Cleary said it implied a "disturbing" lack of faith in the MRC from league bosses.
The rule change comes as the NRL continues to search for consistency between on-field penalties and post-match sanctions for illegal tackles.
Speaking at the launch of the NRL's Beanie For Brain Cancer round, NRL CEO Andrew Abdo insisted the change was only an "insurance policy".
"All it really means is that the Commission is able to, on very rare circumstances if ever, apply to the judiciary to review a matter that may have been missed by the match review committee, or may have, in their view, not been graded appropriately," he said.
"There could be an upwards movement of the grading, it could be a downwards movement of the grading.
"This would be in very rare, exceptional circumstances as an insurance policy. It's not a case of us being in a situation where we're going to see this applied regularly, if at all."
Abdo claimed not to have been aware of frustrated comments made by Cleary, who on Tuesday said it would be better for the NRL to rethink the entire system than weigh in sporadically.
But Abdo said if teams were dissatisfied with the ARLC's charges, they could still challenge proposed sanctions at the judiciary as normal.
"The Commission has no powers to make a final decision, those powers will sit with the judiciary," Abdo said.
Cleary pointed to Scott Sorensen's two-game ban as an example that the judiciary system was making mistakes, with the second-rower escaping on-field sanction altogether for his hip-drop style tackle on Dallin Watene-Zelezniak.
"We'll make no apology for wanting to protect players and we'll also put the onus on the defender to take all measures to avoid those indicators (of a hip-drop)," Abdo said.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
ABC News
an hour ago
- ABC News
Michael Maguire: "Welcome to Coaching!"
Brisbane made it 4 straight wins in the NRL in dramatic fashion to kick off round 18 fighting back from 18-0 down to win 22-18. This is right after 4 straight losses piled the pressure on coach Michael Maguire (25:16) But in response to being asked what he's done differently all Madge told Andrew Moore and the team was "Welcome to Coaching!". However he did say he's welcomed the return of Ezra Mam and still has more quality players to inject into his side. Also on Saturday NRL Luke Lewis and Billy Moore go head to head to discuss Origin 3 (2.46:04). You can also check in on the NSW Origin camp with Hudson Young (1.20:34) who explained that the Blues are getting even closer as a group on and off the field. From the Queensland camp Tom Dearden (1.36:58) explained what it like to prepare for a match when the series is on the line. And as part of the series looking back over the decades in Origin - Noel Cleal (2:15:59) joins Andrew to discuss the 1985 Blues win. You can also get all the latest Rugby League News - and speculation - in MC's Hammertime (46:48)
ABC News
4 hours ago
- ABC News
NRL live updates: Canberra Raiders vs St George Illawarra Dragons, North Queensland Cowboys vs Melbourne Storm
The Canberra Raiders look to firm their grip at the top of the NRL ladder against St George Illawarra in the nation's capital. Follow the live blog below, keep up to date with all the latest stats in our ScoreCentre, and tune in to our live radio coverage.
The Advertiser
4 hours ago
- The Advertiser
The day NSW's star of the future blew Cleary away
NSW have earmarked Isaiya Katoa as Nathan Cleary's successor by calling him into camp for State of Origin III, but the incumbent still remembers the day eight years ago when he first realised just how elite the young gun would become. It comes as Brian To'o and Payne Haas once again trained separately from their teammates on Saturday, the final day of NSW's Blue Mountains camp for the decider on July 9. Monday's session at Accor Stadium looms as judgement day for To'o, who needed ice and a brace on his knee after hurting himself playing for Penrith in round 17. But NSW teammates are confident Haas (back) and To'o will both play after they overcame previous injuries to respectively star in Origin I and II. "'Bizza' showed he didn't do much training last game and you've seen the performance he put in," said winger Zac Lomax. "I don't think there are too many questions around that (his recovery) because he's done it and he's performed for us." Long before he was the Dolphins halfback setting the NRL alight, a 13-year-old Katoa accompanied his brother to Penrith headquarters during the off-season. A hooker who played 75 NRL games, Sione Katoa was reporting for an informal training session with Cleary and a handful of other Panthers teammates. The younger Katoa, barely a teenager much less an adult, ran rings around the group of NRL pros, which included Dallin Watene-Zelezniak and Viliame Kikau. "We were doing 3 on 2 drills and he was carving it up. I was like, I've never seen someone at this age do that sort of stuff," said Blues halfback Cleary. "I'd already heard of him, there were raps on him since he was real young. But then just to see him, I was like, it's not normal for a 13-year-old kid to be doing this." It's a fair appraisal from Cleary, a generational talent who grew up playing alongside current NSW five-eighth Jarome Luai - himself rated a top-tier junior talent. Katoa received his first call into NSW camp last week, spending two days around the Blues at their Leura hideaway ahead of the decider in Sydney on July 9. Luai's estimations of Katoa only rose for reuniting with the young superstar, who had been in Penrith's junior system while Luai was at the club. Four-time premiership winner Luai admits he's a little intimidated by the thought of facing Katoa at Wests Tigers, and felt he was "definitely" an Origin star of the future. "It's scary, you're going to have to go up against that in clubland soon. Hopefully he doesn't go that well against you," Luai said. "Obviously his ability to play, his potential and all that, but just the way he speaks, the way he carries himself, the way he interacts with the boys as well. "It's just like, how mature is this guy and how high is his ceiling?" Cleary has been pondering that question for the last eight years. He has been floored by what Katoa has achieved lifting the Dolphins into finals calculations, with the expansion side averaging a tick under 46 points across their last five games. "He's probably my favourite player to watch in the comp at the moment, just what he's able to do," Cleary said. "Just his subtlety is incredible, especially for such a young guy. "People at the top of their game would be happy with what he's doing but he's only 21. It's quite incredible what he's doing." NSW have earmarked Isaiya Katoa as Nathan Cleary's successor by calling him into camp for State of Origin III, but the incumbent still remembers the day eight years ago when he first realised just how elite the young gun would become. It comes as Brian To'o and Payne Haas once again trained separately from their teammates on Saturday, the final day of NSW's Blue Mountains camp for the decider on July 9. Monday's session at Accor Stadium looms as judgement day for To'o, who needed ice and a brace on his knee after hurting himself playing for Penrith in round 17. But NSW teammates are confident Haas (back) and To'o will both play after they overcame previous injuries to respectively star in Origin I and II. "'Bizza' showed he didn't do much training last game and you've seen the performance he put in," said winger Zac Lomax. "I don't think there are too many questions around that (his recovery) because he's done it and he's performed for us." Long before he was the Dolphins halfback setting the NRL alight, a 13-year-old Katoa accompanied his brother to Penrith headquarters during the off-season. A hooker who played 75 NRL games, Sione Katoa was reporting for an informal training session with Cleary and a handful of other Panthers teammates. The younger Katoa, barely a teenager much less an adult, ran rings around the group of NRL pros, which included Dallin Watene-Zelezniak and Viliame Kikau. "We were doing 3 on 2 drills and he was carving it up. I was like, I've never seen someone at this age do that sort of stuff," said Blues halfback Cleary. "I'd already heard of him, there were raps on him since he was real young. But then just to see him, I was like, it's not normal for a 13-year-old kid to be doing this." It's a fair appraisal from Cleary, a generational talent who grew up playing alongside current NSW five-eighth Jarome Luai - himself rated a top-tier junior talent. Katoa received his first call into NSW camp last week, spending two days around the Blues at their Leura hideaway ahead of the decider in Sydney on July 9. Luai's estimations of Katoa only rose for reuniting with the young superstar, who had been in Penrith's junior system while Luai was at the club. Four-time premiership winner Luai admits he's a little intimidated by the thought of facing Katoa at Wests Tigers, and felt he was "definitely" an Origin star of the future. "It's scary, you're going to have to go up against that in clubland soon. Hopefully he doesn't go that well against you," Luai said. "Obviously his ability to play, his potential and all that, but just the way he speaks, the way he carries himself, the way he interacts with the boys as well. "It's just like, how mature is this guy and how high is his ceiling?" Cleary has been pondering that question for the last eight years. He has been floored by what Katoa has achieved lifting the Dolphins into finals calculations, with the expansion side averaging a tick under 46 points across their last five games. "He's probably my favourite player to watch in the comp at the moment, just what he's able to do," Cleary said. "Just his subtlety is incredible, especially for such a young guy. "People at the top of their game would be happy with what he's doing but he's only 21. It's quite incredible what he's doing." NSW have earmarked Isaiya Katoa as Nathan Cleary's successor by calling him into camp for State of Origin III, but the incumbent still remembers the day eight years ago when he first realised just how elite the young gun would become. It comes as Brian To'o and Payne Haas once again trained separately from their teammates on Saturday, the final day of NSW's Blue Mountains camp for the decider on July 9. Monday's session at Accor Stadium looms as judgement day for To'o, who needed ice and a brace on his knee after hurting himself playing for Penrith in round 17. But NSW teammates are confident Haas (back) and To'o will both play after they overcame previous injuries to respectively star in Origin I and II. "'Bizza' showed he didn't do much training last game and you've seen the performance he put in," said winger Zac Lomax. "I don't think there are too many questions around that (his recovery) because he's done it and he's performed for us." Long before he was the Dolphins halfback setting the NRL alight, a 13-year-old Katoa accompanied his brother to Penrith headquarters during the off-season. A hooker who played 75 NRL games, Sione Katoa was reporting for an informal training session with Cleary and a handful of other Panthers teammates. The younger Katoa, barely a teenager much less an adult, ran rings around the group of NRL pros, which included Dallin Watene-Zelezniak and Viliame Kikau. "We were doing 3 on 2 drills and he was carving it up. I was like, I've never seen someone at this age do that sort of stuff," said Blues halfback Cleary. "I'd already heard of him, there were raps on him since he was real young. But then just to see him, I was like, it's not normal for a 13-year-old kid to be doing this." It's a fair appraisal from Cleary, a generational talent who grew up playing alongside current NSW five-eighth Jarome Luai - himself rated a top-tier junior talent. Katoa received his first call into NSW camp last week, spending two days around the Blues at their Leura hideaway ahead of the decider in Sydney on July 9. Luai's estimations of Katoa only rose for reuniting with the young superstar, who had been in Penrith's junior system while Luai was at the club. Four-time premiership winner Luai admits he's a little intimidated by the thought of facing Katoa at Wests Tigers, and felt he was "definitely" an Origin star of the future. "It's scary, you're going to have to go up against that in clubland soon. Hopefully he doesn't go that well against you," Luai said. "Obviously his ability to play, his potential and all that, but just the way he speaks, the way he carries himself, the way he interacts with the boys as well. "It's just like, how mature is this guy and how high is his ceiling?" Cleary has been pondering that question for the last eight years. He has been floored by what Katoa has achieved lifting the Dolphins into finals calculations, with the expansion side averaging a tick under 46 points across their last five games. "He's probably my favourite player to watch in the comp at the moment, just what he's able to do," Cleary said. "Just his subtlety is incredible, especially for such a young guy. "People at the top of their game would be happy with what he's doing but he's only 21. It's quite incredible what he's doing."
