‘We want closure': family searches for answers over Kenyan police officer missing in Haiti
Benedict Kuria and some colleagues were ambushed in March by suspected gang members. Haitian media reported that he had died, but Kenya's police service says a search is continuing.
'We've tried many times to get information from the government, but they've refused,' said Kuria's wife, Miriam Watima. 'We don't know what to do any more.'
Hundreds of Kenyan officers have been posted to Haiti as part of a US and UN-backed mission to help police in the Caribbean country get to grips with rampant gang violence. More than a million people have been forced from their homes in a relentless cycle of indiscriminate killings, kidnappings, gang rapes and arson.
Kuria's case has reignited public concern over Kenya's involvement in the multinational security support mission (MSS), which started last year and was the subject of intense domestic public and legal scrutiny from the outset.
In a search for answers, Kuria's family filed a court petition in June that listed the attorney-general, the inspector general of police and various ministers as respondents. A Nairobi court has scheduled a preliminary court appearance for September but the family, who want the matter treated with urgency, have called for the session to be brought forward.
'We entrusted our son with the government,' said Kuria's mother, Jacinta Kabiru. 'They should give us the information.'
Kuria, a 33-year-old administration police officer, joined the MSS last July. On 26 March the MSS said he was 'unaccounted for' after an ambush the day before on a team who had gone to assist the recovery of a Haitian police vehicle stuck in a ditch that it suspected had been dug by gangs.
Later on 26 March, Kenyan police said a search and rescue mission was continuing, while local leaders and police chiefs went to Watima's house in the town of Kikuyu, north-west of Nairobi in Kiambu county, to tell her that her husband was missing.
But the following day, Haitian media outlets reported that Kuria had been killed, quoting Haiti's presidential transitional council as saying that he 'fell … while carrying out his mission' and 'gave his life for a better future for our country'.
In the months since, his family's desperate scramble for clarity has included visits to police – who have told them a search and rescue mission is continuing – and politicians' offices. Through their lawyer, Mbuthi Gathenji, they have petitioned parliament and written letters to Kenya's attorney-general and María Isabel Salvador, the special representative of the UN secretary-general in Haiti.
Their court petition accuses government officials of 'refusing and/or neglecting' to provide the family with information on Kuria's whereabouts 'to ease their agony', and asks judges to assist in 'compelling the respondents to disclose information'.
'You can imagine the pain that the parents and relatives are going through,' said Gathenji. 'We are asking the government to come out with finality.'
The Guardian has approached Kenya's interior cabinet secretary as well as the MSS and the Kenyan police for comment.
Kenya's leading role in the mission stemmed from a desire by the US and the UN to restructure international intervention in Haiti with a multinational mission headed by an African country, after a series of floundering UN missions during which UN troops caused a cholera outbreak and peacekeepers were accused of sexual assault.
Kenya, which has participated in many peacekeeping missions internationally, volunteered to lead the Haiti intervention. For its president, William Ruto, the deployment was a chance to position his country as a reliable international partner and burnish the reputation of its police force, which regularly uses violence against civilians.
The arrival of the Kenyan officers in June 2024 brought some hope to Haiti, but the mission, beset by funding, equipment and personnel issues, has failed to repel the criminal advance.
In April, Salvador said Haiti was approaching a 'point of no return'. And on Wednesday, Ghada Waly, the executive director of the UN office on drugs and crime, told the UN security council that gangs now controlled an estimated 90% of the capital, Port-au-Prince.
Kuria's mother had tried to dissuade him from joining the mission after learning about Haiti's violent reputation, but he was determined to go, motivated in part by the extra pay the job came with, which he planned to use to improve his relatives' lives. 'This is an opportunity we have got as a family,' his brother, Philip Kuria, recalled him saying.
Kuria was due to return this year at the end of his one-year contract. 'It's a struggle,' said Philip. 'What we want is closure.'
Kuria's uncle, Daniel Ndung'u, said the family was open to any news. 'My prayer is that he's going to come back to join us,' he said. 'This suspense is actually torturing us.'
Watima recalled her last call with Kuria as they discussed academic plans for their 17-year-old daughter. She tops up credit for her husband's phone so it doesn't get deactivated, hoping that one day he'll call again. In the meantime, she waits for the government. 'They should tell us whether he's alive or not,' she said. 'That's all we want to know.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Independent
28 minutes ago
- The Independent
As US abruptly ends support, Liberia faces empty health clinics and unplanned pregnancies
Five months ago, Roseline Phay, a 32-year-old farmer from the West African nation of Liberia, set off on a quest to find contraceptives. Phay and her partner have two daughters, and they barely make ends meet. Determined not to have more children, she went to a health worker in her village, but contraception pills, implants and condoms had run out. Phay trekked for hours on red clay roads to the nearest clinic, but they had no contraceptives either. She did not know it, but her mission was doomed from the beginning. Just weeks before, U.S. President Donald Trump abruptly suspended most foreign aid through the U.S. Agency for International Development, which paid for medications in Liberia's public clinics. Tenacious and outspoken, Phay repeated the trip four times. Then she got pregnant. 'I'm suffering,' she said, with daughter Pauline crying in her arms. 'I have this little child on my back, and the other child in my stomach is suffering." She must continue farming throughout her pregnancy, she said, or "I will not eat.' After she got pregnant she had to wean Pauline off breastfeeding, she said, and the girl became so badly malnourished that she almost died. The U.S. cuts left no therapeutic food to give her, and she is still ill. Phay is among millions across Africa who have seen their lives upended after the U.S. aid cuts. In Liberia, the American support made up almost 2.6% of the gross national income, the highest percentage anywhere in the world, according to the Center for Global Development. 'The impact of USAID in Liberia cannot be overstated,' said Richlue O. Burphy, who worked for USAID projects for over a decade and manages the National Lottery, a government body. 'Everywhere you go, you see the USAID (signs). And almost all the government institutions ... had some kind of USAID partnership.' A feeling of betrayal The sense of betrayal runs deep in Liberia, established in the early 1800s with the aim of relocating freed slaves and free-born Black people from the United States. The political system is modeled on that of the U.S., along with its flag. Liberians often refer to the U.S. as their 'big brother.' Liberia was one of the first countries to receive USAID support, starting in 1961. Its officials thought they would be spared from Trump's cuts because of the countries' close relationship. Following civil wars and an Ebola epidemic, Liberia's survival has depended largely on foreign aid, mainly from the U.S. and the World Bank. Despite abundant natural wealth, six out of 10 Liberians live in poverty, according to the World Bank, and Liberia is among the world's 10 poorest nations. The aid cuts pose 'a serious challenge,' especially for the healthcare system, Deputy Finance Minister Dehpue Y. Zuo, responsible for drafting the development budget, told The Associated Press. To make sure the system stays afloat, he said, "we have to take a dramatic switch to see where we will be cutting funding for other areas.' Liberia received an average of $527.6 million in aid annually between 2014 and 2023, according to the finance ministry. This year, Liberia was supposed to receive $443 million, but the total estimated impact of the cuts is $290 million — essentially what hadn't been disbursed yet. USAID funding built schools and health clinics, provided training for teachers and doctors and gave scholarships for study in the U.S. It supported small-scale farmers and paid for school meals. But most of the U.S. funding went to Liberia's health system, making up 48% of its budget. It funded malaria control, maternal health programs, HIV/AIDS treatment and community health programs. It financed hundreds of health projects run by aid groups. Now in Bong county, where Phay lives, medicine shelves in health clinics are almost empty. The USAID-funded ambulance cannot function because there is no money for fuel. Hospitals are running out of hand sanitizer and gloves. Training for medical staff has stopped, and community health workers have not been paid in months. An opening for China Moses K. Banyan, head of the nearby CB Dunbar Hospital, described the U.S. cuts as 'beyond a shock.' He worried about the future, especially now that Bong county has begun to see a handful of mpox cases spread from neighboring Sierra Leone. Warning of the cuts could have helped in finding options, he said. 'But it's like you were sleeping, you woke up and you were told: 'Hey, leave this house.'' The withdrawal of U.S. support is an opportunity for others, especially China, experts and officials said. Chinese companies have been operating Liberia's gold mines, building roads and training aid workers. Chinese beer is sold alongside local brands. Many Liberians who would have sent children to universities in the U.S. are now choosing China. Last month, China opened a cardiology wing in the capital's main hospital, which is named after John F. Kennedy but was commonly referred to as 'Just For Killing' because of its scarce resources, even before the U.S. cuts. 'There are gaps to be filled, and that cannot be covered by the government of Liberia,' said Zuo, the deputy finance minister. 'We are open door to the rest of the world, including the United States.' In Phay's village of Sarworlor, community health worker Alice Togbah still wears her USAID vest though she hasn't been paid in months. She has no more malaria medication for children. She is running out of cough medicine and diarrhea treatment. A 4-year-old resident, Promise, got malaria a few days ago. Her mother, Grace Morris, obtained only a limited number of malaria tablets at the nearest clinic because of the U.S. cuts. Now they are finished, and the child still feels ill. 'Children die from malaria here,' she said. Last year, her neighbor's son died because he did not get medication on time. Morris and other women also seek contraceptives. Liberia in recent years made strides in bringing down teenage pregnancy rates and maternal mortality rates. For women in traditional, conservative communities, access to contraceptives meant reclaiming some control over their lives. 'If ... my man touches me, I cannot say no because I need to satisfy him,' Phay said. 'But if I have no medicine, I will get pregnant.' Her 9-year-old daughter, also named Promise, is living in the capital, Monrovia, with her aunt. Phay wants her to finish school and have a different life from hers. 'I am begging, if you people have the medicine, you people need to help us," she said. 'I don't want her to suffer like me." ___ For more on Africa and development: The Associated Press receives financial support for global health and development coverage in Africa from the Gates Foundation. The AP is solely responsible for all content. Find AP's standards for working with philanthropies, a list of supporters and funded coverage areas at
Daily Mail
3 hours ago
- Daily Mail
Royal Caribbean has woman detained during voyage after outrageous threat
A Royal Caribbean passenger said the cruise line detained her after claiming she had threatened to jump off the ship in the middle of her voyage. Lizzy Moss (@ on TikTok) shared a series of videos online detailing her vacation gone wrong, claiming Royal Caribbean's security detained her for a comment she never made. Moss' girlfriend, Kalie Stevens, filmed an interaction with security guards outside their room on June 28, which has already amassed over 30 million views. In the video, Kalie opened the door to find multiple security guards with her girlfriend. The guard explained that Lizzy was confined and they were there to get fresh clothes and toiletries because she would be spending the night detained. Kalie reacted with anger and confusion, pressing the guards about why her girlfriend was confined. The guard calmly replied that they already explained why Lizzy was detained and asked the women not to make a scene. In a separate video, Lizzy claimed that she was a 'hostage' on the cruise and was wrongfully detained after contacting security when she noticed her safe was robbed. Lizzy said she went to security at 8am to report the theft and was subsequently separated from her girlfriend. She claimed that she was detained on the ship for 48 hours after attempting to report that the safe in her room was robbed She added that security accused her of making 'false allegations' and detained her due to remarks she made about wanting to jump overboard. Lizzy vehemently denied that she made any such threats. Lizzy then accused the Royal Caribbean medical staff of 'falsifying past medical records' after she endured a psychiatric evaluation by the ship's medics. She claimed that she was detained for 48 hours and was 'constantly monitored.' 'I am a computer science major with a 4.0 at Jackson State University and I'm an HBCU scholar,' she added. Lizzy said she doesn't drink or do drugs and accused the ship's staff of stripping her of her human rights. Several other videos posted to Lizzy's account depicted her girlfriend's interactions with ship staff while she was detained. Another video depicted a tense conversation with an official who the women claimed was the ship's head of security. The man explained that Lizzy was under the 'confinement protocol' and instructed her to grab a second set of clothing so that she could be comfortable under detainment. 'If you do not want to collect some belongings we'll take you back down right now,' he said. The women pushed back on security and accused the ship's staff of detaining Lizzy without proof of her threats to jump overboard. The passengers have posted multiple other videos of their recorded interactions with the ship's staff and explanations of what happened. Daily Mail has reached out to Royal Caribbean for clarification on the women's claims and further explanation on her detainment. The videos have already received millions of likes and thousands of comments, with social media users sounding off on what they believe happened. 'I will never book with Royal Caribbean after watching videos I've seen,' one comment read. 'This is scary! I can't even imagine being in this position,' another added. 'Definitely have a solid case …. This is so scary…' a third agreed. However, others speculated that there was more to the story and took the security's side. 'I've worked on cruise ships and trust me they don't confine you to your cabin unless you have done something wrong I've been on 6 cruise ships as a passenger and 2 cruises as crew and never been confined to my cabin the staff handled this very well,' one argued. Another slammed the two women, writing, 'U guys made dozens of TikTok videos about one issue on a cruise ship [crying emoji] Maybe u need to think up some new content.' Royal Caribbean hasn't substantiated the women's claims or released statements on the situation. Even though security teams on cruise ships are not police officers, they do have a right to detain passengers. Maritime law is complex, but where the alleged incidents occur can determine what laws apply at sea. If cruise ships are in international waters, passengers are typically expected to follow the laws of the country where the ship is registered. Royal Caribbean is registered in Florida, but was incorporated in the Republic of Liberia, according to the Securities and Exchange Commission.
The Guardian
8 hours ago
- The Guardian
Jurors shown CCTV footage of brothers' alleged assault of police officers at Manchester airport
CCTV footage of the alleged assault of three police officers at Manchester airport has been played to jurors. Mohammed Fahir Amaaz, 20, and his brother, Muhammad Amaad, 26, are said to have struck out after police were called to respond to an incident at the Starbucks cafe in Terminal 2 arrivals on 23 July last year, when Amaaz is said to have butted a customer. Minutes later, three officers – PC Zachary Marsden and PC Ellie Cook, who were armed, and the unarmed PC Lydia Ward – approached the defendants at the pay station in T2's car park. On Monday, a jury at Liverpool crown court watched airport camera footage from opposite angles which captured what the crown says was a 'high level of violence' used by the defendants towards the officers. The prosecution say Amaaz resisted as police tried to move him away from a payment machine to arrest him, and then Amaad intervened. The junior counsel Adam Birkby suggested that Amaaz threw 10 punches, which included one to the face of PC Ward that knocked her to the floor, and that Amaad aimed six punches at the firearms officer PC Marsden. Amaaz is also said to have kicked PC Marsden and twice struck firearms officer PC Cook with his elbow. He is said to have punched PC Marsden from behind and then had hold of him before PC Cook discharged her Taser device. Amaaz had his arm around PC Marsden's neck as both fell to the floor, Birkby said, before the officer got to his feet. Birkby went on: 'Mr Amaaz, while prone, lifts his head towards the officers. PC Marsden kicks Mr Amaaz around the head area. 'PC Marsden stamps his foot towards the crown of Mr Amaaz's head area but doesn't appear to connect with Mr Amaaz.' Footage from the body-worn cameras of the three officers was also played to the jury. Amaaz is alleged to have assaulted PC Marsden and PC Ward, causing them actual bodily harm. He is also accused of the assault of PC Cook and the earlier assault of a member of the public, Abdulkareem Ismaeil, at Starbucks. Amaad, 26, is alleged to have assaulted PC Marsden, causing actual bodily harm. Both men, from Rochdale, Greater Manchester, deny the allegations. Giving evidence, PC Marsden told the court he approached the pay station area with the intention of taking 'immediate control' and escorting the suspect from the crowd and to arrest him outside where he would have radio signal. He said: 'I wanted to prevent his escape or any opportunity to escape, but also to give me control of someone who had allegedly been violent towards a member of the public.' He said he placed his hands on Amaaz's left arm, but said he was 'met with immediate resistance' and that he felt the suspect 'clench his fists'. PC Marsden said: 'I recall leaning in and saying to him words along the lines of 'come on mate, we are not doing that here.'' He said he did not feel it was necessary to tell the suspect he was a police officer because he was wearing full uniform with a cap.
