Scholten introduces bill to open Musk and DOGE to FOIA provisions
U.S. Rep. Hillary Scholten (D-Grand Rapids) on Thursday introduced legislation she says will provide accountability about the actions of billionaire Elon Musk and his Department of Government Efficiency, or DOGE.
According to a press release from Scholten's office, the Consistent Legal Expectations and Access to Records (CLEAR) Act, clarifies that temporary organizations like DOGE are subject to the Freedom of Information Act (FOIA).
'Given the breadth of power these organizations wield, they should be subject to the same standard of scrutiny and public information sharing that other agencies are beholden to,' stated the release.
DOGE was created by President Donald Trump through an executive order using an authority that allows the president to set up 'temporary organizations.' Scholten introduced the legislation to make it clear that any organization created in that manner is automatically subject to FOIA requests.
'In the first two weeks of Trump's second term, chaos has reigned and has many asking… what is happening? An unelected businessman with numerous conflicts of interest has been given unprecedented access to government data and Americans' personal information,' said Scholten. 'These are taxpayer dollars he's controlling, and the American people deserve to know what's happening. Knowledge is power, and in America, that power belongs to the people. My bill will make sure that no president, Republican or Democrat, can hide their actions from the American people.'
Democrats and transparency advocates have raised the alarm over the actions of DOGE, most especially the access its members have been granted to the Treasury Department's payment system, which handles trillions of dollars in payments, including income taxes, Social Security benefits and veterans pay.
The bill would apply retroactively, meaning all of DOGE's records since it was formed would become public if the legislation is signed into law.
U.S. Sen. Elissa Slotkin has also expressed concerns about accountability for Musk and the actions of DOGE.
'The targeting across our federal govt of law enforcement, to flight safety inspectors, to weather forecasters or those who test our drinking water, to doctors conducting clinical trials for children with cancer, is not just wrong – it will result in Americans being less safe,' wrote Slotkin on X, the social media platform owned by Musk. 'Elon Musk, an unelected billionaire, now has access to Americans' private and personal information, including sensitive tax documents. This raises all kinds of questions about the use and abuse of that information for targeting of citizens, to use for legal or financial gain.'
Samuel Bagenstos is the Frank G. Millard Professor of Law at the University of Michigan who specializes in civil rights, labor and employment law, health law and governance, told the Advance this week that 'there's a value to the legal process.
'Even if at the end of the day, that process doesn't result in an injunction stopping Trump from doing what he's doing, lawsuits and the process around lawsuits help to bring to light information about what's going on. They both help to publicize what's going on, because the fact of a lawsuit and legal proceedings will get reported by journalists and become a focal point for public discussion, but also in the process of a lawsuit, you have opportunities for courts to order the defendants to provide information to the plaintiffs,' he said.
Bagenstos has frequently testified before Congress, argued four cases before the U.S. Supreme Court, served as principal deputy assistant attorney general for civil rights in the U.S. Department of Justice during the Obama administration, and most recently was general counsel to the Department of Health and Human Services (HHS) in the Biden administration. He was also nominated by the Democratic Party to run for Michigan Supreme Court in 2018.
'Right now, we don't know exactly what Elon Musk is doing within the executive branch, although there are lots of reasons to worry a lot about what he's doing based on his own statements. But a court can order him to provide information about what he's doing or can order the government to provide information about has Elon Musk been granted access to the federal payment system? What is the scope of that access? Who authorized that access? Does Elon Musk or someone working with him have the authority now to stop payments made by the federal government? Who authorized that and what is the basis on which those individuals were appointed to the government?' Bagenstos said.
'These are all questions that are really important for us to know the answer to, but we might not be able to trust answers that are given by White House press officials. But a court might be able to get more authoritative information on that, so there are lots of reasons why even if at the end of the day courts aren't gonna stop everything Trump's gonna do, there are lots of reasons why we might want to continue to be out there making the case that what Trump is doing is an abuse of his legal authority.'
SUPPORT: YOU MAKE OUR WORK POSSIBLE
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
8 minutes ago
- Yahoo
EU-US trade deals buoy stocks while Tesla plummets
Stock markets mostly bumped upwards Thursday as hopes grew that the European Union could strike a trade deal with the United States, while Tesla shares nosedived on poor earnings results. Investors have profited in recent weeks from wagers that governments will eventually hammer out pacts with Donald Trump ahead of the US president's looming August 1 deadline to avoid steeper levies. analyst Patrick O'Hare said Trump's Tuesday trade announcement with Japan had raised hopes about further agreements. "There is underlying enthusiasm for more trade deals being struck before the August 1 deadline," O'Hare said. This was boosted further by "optimism surrounding trade talks between the US and EU", said Joshua Mahony, chief market analyst at Rostro trading group. On Wall Street, both the S&P 500 and tech-heavy Nasdaq edged higher in the morning's trading, although the Dow slid lower as investors digested mixed company earnings. Google parent Alphabet was among the early gainers, rising about three percent after reporting a whopping $28.2 billion in second-quarter profits as it touted its artificial intelligence offerings. But Tesla fell around nine percent as CEO Elon Musk warned investors of a rough patch for earnings after the electric car maker reported a 16-percent drop in quarterly profits. A survey of US manufacturers released Thursday showed business confidence in the world's top economy also deteriorated in July for the second month running. "Companies cite ongoing concerns over the impact of government policies, notably in terms of both tariffs and cuts to federal spending," said Chris Williamson, Chief Business Economist at S&P Global Market Intelligence. In Europe, London's FTSE 100 gained 0.9 percent at the close, lifted by a stream of robust earnings, including from consumer goods group Reckitt, mobile phone giant Vodafone and Lloyds bank. Paris fell, dragged down by a drop in luxury stocks and disappointing profits from fossil fuel giant TotalEnergies. Yet most other European stocks markets including Frankfurt rose, as the European Union and Washington appeared close to a deal that would halve a threatened 30-percent levy on EU goods to 15 percent. A European Commission spokesman said Thursday that he believed a trade deal with the US is "within reach". According to multiple diplomats, the deal could waive tariffs on aircraft, lumber, pharmaceutical products and agricultural goods. The bloc, however, is still forging ahead with contingency plans in case talks fail, with member states approving a 93-billion-euro ($109-billion) package of counter-tariffs on US goods. Meanwhile, the European Central Bank left interest rates unchanged, as widely expected. It warned that the economic environment remained "exceptionally uncertain, especially because of trade disputes" as higher US tariffs hang in the balance. The euro dipped a touch following Thursday's rate decision, but it did perk up after ECB President Christine Lagarde said the central bank was monitoring the dollar-euro exchange rate but had no target. The euro has surged almost 14 percent against the dollar since the start of the year, boosted by investors dumping US assets in the face of Trump's impetuous policymaking and attacks on the US Federal Reserve. The euro's appreciation helps contain inflation but could harm European exports and thus slow already sluggish economic growth. In Asia, stocks advanced with Tokyo adding more than one percent, building on a more than three percent surge Wednesday on the back of the Japan-US trade deal. Hong Kong and Shanghai also rose. - Key figures at around 1530 GMT - New York - Dow: DOWN 0.4 percent at 44,851,07 points New York - S&P 500: UP 0.3 percent at 6,375.34 New York - Nasdaq Composite: UP 0.3 percent at 21,075.70 London - FTSE 100: UP 0.9 percent at 9,138.37 (close) Paris - CAC 40: DOWN 0.4 percent at 7,818.28 (close) Frankfurt - DAX: UP 0.2 percent at 24,295.93 (close) Tokyo - Nikkei 225: UP 1.6 percent at 41,826.34 (close) Hong Kong - Hang Seng Index: UP 0.5 percent at 25,667.18 (close) Shanghai - Composite: UP 0.7 percent at 3,605.73 (close) Dollar/yen: UP at 146.79 yen from 146.47 yen on Wednesday Euro/dollar: DOWN at $1.1774 from $1.1777 Pound/dollar: DOWN at $1.3537 from $1.3579 Euro/pound: UP at 86.98 pence from 86.68 pence West Texas Intermediate: UP 1.3 percent at $66.09 per barrel Brent North Sea Crude: UP 1.1 percent at $69.26 per barrel burs-sbk/rl Sign in to access your portfolio
Washington Post
8 minutes ago
- Washington Post
Democrats demand U.S. investigation of American's death in West Bank
Nearly 30 Senate Democrats are urging the Trump administration to investigate the recent death of an American citizen in the West Bank. In a letter addressed to Secretary of State Marco Rubio and Attorney General Pam Bondi on Thursday, the senators criticized what they labeled a 'culture of impunity when it comes to incidents where civilians have been killed in the West Bank, including Americans.' Sayfollah Kamel Musallet, 20, of Tampa, was killed July 11 while visiting family in the occupied West Bank. Palestinian health authorities and Musallet's family have said Israeli settlers are responsible for his death. Shortly after Musallet was killed, the Israel Defense Forces said it was examining reports of a death during a confrontation between Israelis and Palestinians in the area. Spokespeople for the Israeli embassy in Washington and the Justice Department did not immediately respond to requests for comment. The State Department declined to comment. The senators' letter, a copy of which was obtained by The Washington Post, was signed by 29 lawmakers, accounting for more than half of the chamber's Democrats. No Republicans have joined the effort. Three other Palestinian Americans have died in the West Bank since the Israel-Gaza war began in October 2023. Democratic members of Congress have objected to the wave of settler violence, arguing that American citizens are falling victim. The U.S. government 'has failed in its responsibility to protect American citizens overseas and demand justice for their deaths,' the letter states. Sen. Chris Van Hollen (D-Maryland), the letter's lead author, has called for similar investigations in the past. He has emerged as a vocal critic of settler violence and the Israeli government's response to it. His office shared responses to similar requests made of the Biden administration, which show officials offered little further information about the deaths but committed to speaking with Israel's government about them. At a Senate hearing earlier this month to evaluate President Donald Trump's nomination of Michael Waltz, the former White House national security adviser, to become ambassador to the United Nations, Van Hollen criticized the Trump administration's decision to revoke sanctions imposed by the Biden administration targeting Israeli settlers in the West Bank whom the U.S. government at the time deemed extremists. 'When you withdrew that executive order, you sent a very bad signal,' Van Hollen said then. An April analysis by the Washington Institute, a think tank, found that Israeli settler violence has surged in the last year, rising 30 percent in the first part of the year, compared with the same period the year before. Meanwhile, Palestinian terrorism in the same area has sharply declined, the analysis found. 'The increase in settler violence at a time when Palestinian terrorism is decreasing lends credence to the assessment that settler attacks are not simply a response to terrorism, as some have claimed,' the study's author, Neomi Neumann, wrote. The Trump administration has taken a complicated approach to Israel since entering office in January. At times, it has shown frustration with Israeli President Benjamin Netanyahu for the inability to reach a peace deal in Gaza, which has been afflicted by violence and famine nearly two years into the war. Notwithstanding, top Israeli officials have visited Washington multiple times in the last six months, and Trump authorized the U.S. military to join Israeli forces in an attack on Iran's nuclear program in mid-June, fulfilling one of Netanyahu's core priorities. Heidi Levine, Miriam Berger and Marie-Rose Sheinerman contributed to this report.
UPI
8 minutes ago
- UPI
UnitedHealth Group says it's cooperating with DOJ Medicare probe
Attorney General Pam Bondi speaks during a press briefing in June. UnitedHealth said its facing an investigation from the Department of Justice about its Medicare billing practices. Photo by Yuri Gripas/UPI | License Photo July 24 (UPI) -- UnitedHealth Group said Thursday it is facing Department of Justice investigations over its Medicare billing practices. UnitedHealth Group said in a statement on its website that it reached out to the DOJ after seeing media reports about investigations into its Medicare program. "(UnitedHealth) has now begun complying with formal criminal and civil requests from the Department. The Company has full confidence in its practices and is committed to working cooperatively with the Department throughout this process," the statement said. The insurer said it's launching its own investigation. "To provide our stakeholders transparency and confidence (UnitedHealth) ... has proactively launched its own initiative to conduct third party reviews of policies, practices, and associated processes and performance metrics for risk assessment coding, managed care practices, and pharmacy services." The company told CNBC that it expects to complete that review near the end of the third quarter. The Wall Street Journal reported in May that the Justice Department is conducting a criminal investigation into UHC for Medicare fraud. The company said it stands "by the integrity of our Medicare Advantage program." The Journal reported in July that the DOJ interviewed doctors about UnitedHealth's practices and asked if they felt pressured to submit claims for certain conditions that bolstered payments from the Medicare Advantage program. "(UnitedHealth) is committed to maintaining the integrity of its business practices and serving as reliable stewards of American tax dollars," UnitedHealth said. This is just the latest setback for the country's largest health insurer. Shares are down more than 42%, its CEO Andrew Witty left the company in May, it suffered a ransomware attack in early 2024, and then CEO Brian Thompson was killed in December 2024 by alleged shooter Luigi Mangione, which sparked significant public outrage against the company.
