Tipperary edge past Kilkenny in game so wild even the scoreboard could not keep up
And then, when the final whistle blew, nobody could swear to the score. The giant scoreboard in Croke Park read
Tipperary
4-21,
Kilkenny
0-30, but before the match officials left the field they stood in a huddle for three or four minutes, doing their sums or getting their story straight.
Word of the uncertainty spread quickly. In their live coverage, the BBC attributed 4-20 to Tipp. If the scoreboard had been wrong, then Kilkenny had spent the last couple of minutes of stoppage time pounding the Tipp square for a goal they didn't need. Two points would have saved them; they had chances for two points and tried to spin each of them into a goal.
The disputed score was Noel McGrath's point in the final minute from a wide angle. The green flag umpire tried to catch the ball as it came down from the netting, but the umpire in control of the white flag waved his hands immediately, and emphatically, indicating a wide. On the scoreboard, though, Tipp had gone four points up.
READ MORE
If the umpire was wrong, Hawk-Eye would surely have had a word in the referee's earpiece. Over the years, those interventions have not been uncommon. If the referee stops play and makes the shape of a TV screen, it invariably means that the umpires have made a mistake. Play resumed.
[
Kilkenny 0-30 Tipperary 4-20 FT: Superb Oisín O'Donoghue goal wins it for Tipp – As it happened
Opens in new window
]
Tipperary's Noel McGrath celebrates with his brother John McGrath. Photograph: James Crombie/Inpho
In answer to questions after the game, a GAA spokesman said that 4-21 for Tipp was the 'official score'. That's what appeared on the GAA's website. However, that story changed within an hour. Contacted by a reporter, the referee James Owens said that Tipp had scored 4-20.
At 7.40pm, nearly two hours after the game had finished, the GAA confirmed that 4-20 had been Tipp's total. 'The GAA acknowledges there was confusion over the final score,' read a brief statement. 'The CCCC is awaiting the full referees report in order to establish how the initial mistake occurred.'
The only score that matters is the one that appears in the referee's report. An error had clearly been made by the scoreboard operator.
Did it make a material difference to the outcome? It made a material difference to Kilkenny's real-time assessment of their needs. Everything else is conjecture.
In his post-match press conference, before Owens had offered his clarification on the final score, the Kilkenny manager Derek Lyng made nothing of it. He said he thought there were three points between the teams. That was the sum of his answer.
Referee James Owens red cards Darragh McCarthy of Tipperary. Photograph: James Crombie/Inpho
And still Kilkenny nearly saved themselves. John Donnelly beat Rhys Shelly with a rocket in stoppage time only for Robert Doyle to block the shot on the goal-line with an outrageous piece of scramble defence. Doyle followed the ball out until it was cleared and then dutifully ran back to take up his station next to TJ Reid, who was standing a yard from the Tipp goal-line, frozen to the spot.
It was a mesmerising match and by distance Tipperary's best performance since the 2019 All-Ireland final. Reduced to 14 men when Darragh McCarthy was sent off for a second yellow card offence 12 minutes from the end of normal time, Tipp explored the depths of their bloody-mindedness. With terrific clarity, they kept going.
In a blistering cameo, Andrew Ormond and Jason Forde combined for three scores in as many minutes, to put Tipp a point up with 68 minutes on the clock. Ormond was fouled twice for frees that Forde converted from long distance with unerring conviction, and then Ormond fed a pass to Forde under pressure for another towering score from under the Hogan Stand.
Is that the goal that decides it? More sloppiness from the Kilkenny defence and Oisín O'Donoghue scores.
📺Watch
📻Listen
📱 Follow
— The Sunday Game (@TheSundayGame)
The game, though, was blown apart by Tipperary's fourth goal in the last minute of normal time. In the Kilkenny D the ball changed hands two or three times, frantically. Paddy Deegan looked like he would clear it and lost it. Finally, the ball was poked into Oisín O'Donoghue's path and the young sub fired a thunderbolt into the top corner of the Kilkenny net. It was a goal fit to win any match.
This was Tipp's third successive championship victory over their bitterest rivals, the first time they have run up such a sequence in more than 50 years. The prize is another meeting with Cork, the first ever between these counties in an All-Ireland final.
Their recent history is one-sided. Cork beat them by 18 points in last year's championship, by 15 points in this year's championship and by 10 points in the League final to boot.
Now everything returns to zero.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
3 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Kilkenny consider options after scoreboard confusion
Kilkenny were discussing their options on Sunday night after the GAA clarified the final scoreline in Croke Park and RTÉ was incorrect. Croke Park clarified the correct scoreline as Tipperary 4-20 Kilkenny 0-30 in the second of the All-Ireland SHC semi-finals. After Oisín O'Donoghue's 69th-minute goal put Tipperary three points ahead, 4-20 to 0-29, a Noel McGrath point effort was waved wide by an umpire. However, it was recorded as a point on the scoreboard. Following Jordan Molloy's point in the second minute of additional time to bring Kilkenny's total to 30, both managers Derek Lyng and Liam Cahill were of the understanding that the margin was three points when it was in fact two. 'I had three, I thought it was three,' said Lyng afterwards. Kilkenny chased a goal in the dying stages when in fact they could have aimed for points to force extra-time – John Donnelly had a goal attempt denied by Robert Doyle on the goal-line. In the immediate aftermath of the game, GAA sources stated afterwards that the scoreline was 4-21 to 0-30 in Tipperary's favour. However, the GAA later corrected it and gave one point fewer to the winning side. The Association said they are waiting on referee James Owens' report to ascertain exactly where the confusion arose. A statement on the GAA website read: "The GAA can confirm that the official score at the end of the Tipperary v Kilkenny GAA Hurling All-Ireland Senior Championship Semi-Final was 4-20 to 0-30. 'The GAA acknowledges there was confusion over the final score. The CCCC (Central Competitions Control Committee) is awaiting the full referee's report in order to establish how the initial mistake occurred." This is the second time in two years that a scoreline error has been made in Croke Park. In the 2023 Joe McDonagh Cup final, Carlow beat Offaly after extra-time by a point. Referee Thomas Walsh reported the score as 2-29 to 1-31 as did the stadium scoreboards when in fact it was 2-30 to 1-32. The incorrect score was adopted into the records. Broadcasters RTÉ updated their totals to reflect the right scoreline. In 2015, a re-match was ordered for the Christy Ring Cup final between Meath and Antrim in Croke Park after it was miscalculated that Meath had won the game by a point (2-18 to 1-20). It materialised soon after that the actual scoreline was 2-17 to 1-20 yet Meath were awarded the trophy. Antrim requested a second game, which was granted, but Meath won it by a point, 4-21 to 5-17. Read More Brian Gavin: Widegate scoreboard error unfair on Kilkenny but difficult to contest result
The Journal
4 hours ago
- The Journal
GAA to investigate after confusion over final score of Tipperary-Kilkenny game
THE GAA ARE set to investigate after confusion emerged over the final score of today's All-Ireland senior hurling semi-final between Tipperary and Kilkenny. Tonight the GAA confirmed the official score was 4-20 to 0-30 in Tipperary's favour and acknowledged the confusion with the GAA set to await the full report from referee James Owens 'in order to establish how the initial mistake occurred'. The confusion centred around a Noel McGrath shot in the 70th minute into the Hill 16 end which was waved wide by an umpire. The scoreboard in Croke Park increased Tipperary's tally from 4-20 to 4-21, but no white flag was raised. It transpired to be Tipperary's final score of the game with a Jordan Molloy Kilkenny point the only additional score. Advertisement Tipperary boss Liam Cahill and his Kilkenny counterpart Derek Lyng both revealed afterwards that they believed Kilkenny were chasing a three-point deficit towards the end of the game. That position contributed to Kilkenny's approach of chasing a goal with both Eoin Cody and John Donnelly taking shots to try to find the net on separate occasions. ***** The full statement reads: 'The GAA can confirm that the official score at the end of the Tipperary v Kilkenny GAA Hurling All-Ireland Senior Championship Semi-Final was 4-20 to 0-30. The GAA acknowledges there was confusion over the final score. The CCCC is awaiting the full referees report in order to establish how the initial mistake occurred.' Written by Fintan O'Toole and originally published on The 42 whose award-winning team produces original content that you won't find anywhere else: on GAA, League of Ireland, women's sport and boxing, as well as our game-changing rugby coverage, all with an Irish eye. Subscribe here . Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
The 42
4 hours ago
- The 42
Scoreboard malfunction colours the close of remarkable Tipperary victory
WE MIGHT NEVER get to the bottom of The Great Scoreline Mystery of the All-Ireland hurling semi-final of 2025. Shortly after the end of the game, GAA officials were adamant that Tipperary had scored 4-21 to Kilkenny's 0-30. The press box in Croke Park, those that weren't lost in nose-picking distraction, had a late Noel McGrath shot marked down as a wide. No white flag was raised. A few eagle-eyed observers insist that an umpire waved it wide. However, the scoreboard in Croke Park ticked it up. What odds, you might say? But there is a very important principle at play here. Because the margin was three points, that meant Kilkenny had to go looking for a goal in a game in which they barely got a sniff of one. With four minutes added on, Kilkenny could have gone hunting for two points to level the game and bring it to extra-time. As it happens, they did get a sight of goal. A few wriggles here from TJ Reid, a shimmy there and John Donnelly was handed the ball in enough space to get a good slap at it. He caught the ball right on the meat and it flew past Tipperary goalkeeper Rhys Shelly. But not past Robert Doyle of Clonoulty Rossmore, who had retreated to a yard off the line and controlled a rocket of a shot. The whistle blew shortly after. Tipperary's first game in Croke Park in six years brought victory. It's only a little thing, granted, but the panic spread to the press box where reporters desperately beseeched each other on what the Tipperary score was. In the media centre, GAA employee Jamie Ó Tuama confirmed that the score would remain as 4-21 to Tipperary. Advertisement It's an unsatisfactory end to a game that falls slightly short of a classic – there was too much loose play – but one that was typically packed with incident between these two. The shorthand version first; the underdogs, who were priced 13/8 before the ball was thrown in, hadn't played on this pitch since the 2019 All-Ireland final when they beat Kilkenny by 14 points. We dredge up someone else's phrase here, but there has always been something of the Old Testament about Tipperary and Kilkenny that makes those involved nervous of each other. Huw Lawlor catches. Ryan Byrne / INPHO Ryan Byrne / INPHO / INPHO That seemed to spread pitchside prior to the game. As the Artane Band led the teams around in the pre-match parade, Kilkenny's Shane Murphy and Adrian Mullen emerged out of the tunnel to belatedly take up their spots, followed later again by TJ Reid. Given these players are lorrying water into themselves for days prior to a game, we hereby launch a campaign for a comfort break for all players in the space between warm-up and parade. These lads aren't camels. The first three scores arrived from Reid, Billy Ryan and Martin Keogan. It took eight minutes for 0-3; in today's money that's slow scoring. Jake Morris charged through the centre of the Cats defence to offload a shot that was blocked. The ball squirted out to John McGrath who placed it in the roof of the Kilkenny net. That was answered by five Kilkenny points. Tipperary were being pegged back. The full-forward line of Keogan, Reid and Eoin Cody was functioning well against a full-back line that many in Tipp were saying Novenas for. But they got to grips with it. Conor Stakelum got their second score on 14 minutes. He got their third two minutes later. Eoghan Connolly produced a burst of three points from play from full-back. Then, a long ball into the corner evaded Jason Forde and Mikey Carey. It broke for Darragh McCarthy who made for goal with Huw Lawlor flaking away, but he squeezed his shot to the net on 22 minutes. Three minutes later, another break in that corner of the Canal End and Cusack Stand. This time McCarthy was able to scoop a handpass towards Jason Forde on his way to goal and he produced a delicate flick over Eoin Murphy to the net. For the first quarter, there was an element of 'After the Lord Mayor's Show' to the game. Now it was alive. The crowd were invested. A block anywhere near the stands always gets a good reaction, but when Alan Tynan came on for two minutes as a temporary sub for Andrew Ormond, he got a full-length block on Paddy Deegan that put the Premier support delirious. Kilkenny kept chipping away but the Tipp attack still looked lethal. Shelly worked a give and go from a puckout that he landed in front of John McGrath and Lawlor. A good old-fashioned wrestle played out but once McGrath got free he got his head down to drive the ball, but it flew over the bar. Now to Darragh McCarthy. The promising young man from Toomevara is a rare talent and reminiscent of Noel McGrath in his senior infancy. He converted Tipp's first free on 38 minutes. But free-taking is a merciless business and on a wet and windy Croke Park it's brutal. That was becoming apparent as McCarthy, followed by full-back Eoghan Connolly, put frees wide. Putting a free wide is one thing. Doing so with an elaborate free-taking routine such as McCarthy's feels like missing two in one go. Standing side on to the ball, then approaching it face-on. Throwing up a few blades of grass, all that stuff just serves to produce a louder guffaw of mockery from the opposition support if and when it drifts wide. Four wides from Tipp from the 40th to 42nd minutes felt like a mini-meltdown. McCarthy missing another one on 47th minutes was self-harm. After 50 minutes, a Reid free drew Kilkenny level. Another put them ahead. Instant surgery was required and Tipp manager Liam Cahill put Jason Forde on the frees. He knocked over two that were high up on the difficulty scale. But it was Kilkenny in the lead when McCarthy was sent off for his second yellow card on 59 minutes. A tap on the hand of Kilkenny goalkeeper Eoin Murphy. A yellow by the book. But the sort of offence that would cause no alarm in the middle of a crowded midfield. Liam Cahill meets Darragh McCarthy after being sent off. Ryan Byrne / INPHO Ryan Byrne / INPHO / INPHO Tipp would go on to outscored Kilkenny 1-5 to 0-4 for the remainder of the game. Jake Morris hit a special. Forde converted a free that should have brought a second yellow for Paddy Deegan but instead Mikey Carey got it. Another free from Forde after Ormond was fouled brought them level. Oisín O'Donoghue entered the fray on 63 minutes. The Cashel man had a spectacular impact as he disposed Richie Reid who was making a rather, well, 'relaxed' clearance and the play ended with a bullet of a point from Forde to take the lead. It's all subjective whims and thoughts of course. But if it had been Brian Cody on the nearby sideline, you'd be tempted to think that ball might have been launched by Reid. The climax was fitting and maybe unexpected as O'Donoghue picked up a scrap of possession and, despite being surrounded by Kilkenny defenders, got a shot off that hit the top corner of Eoin Murphy's net. Related Reads 'There's a lot of drive in them' - The North Tipperary attacking stars pointing the way Absolute warfare: The return of Kilkenny and Tipperary after six years 'We won't be sitting back admiring them' - Clare plotting Déise downfall to reach semi-finals It wasn't quite a knockout blow. But the next 'score' from Noel McGrath felt it as it was chalked up on the scoreboard. Jordon Molloy got a point for Kilkenny. If the scoreboard at that point was right, then Kilkenny might have gone about things differently. Long after the game, Michael Verney of the Irish Independent texted the referee James Owens to enquire about the scoreline. '4-20 to 30 points' was his reply. Some calls were put through to the GAA media department. The same calls rang out. Eventually, Cian Murphy of the Communications Department appeared to inform all left in the Micheál O'Hehir suite that the scoreline, as suspected, was 4-20 to 0-30. The excitement and fervour of a Cork-Tipperary All-Ireland final will drown out any controversy from today. Lucky for some. * Check out the latest episode of The42′s GAA Weekly podcast here
