Parents aim to rally for OCDSB's alternative schools
3 hours ago
Duration 2:14
Social Sharing
Parents of children who attend alternative schools are putting their heads together to try to save the program.
As part of a proposed restructuring, the Ottawa-Carleton District School Board's trustees could soon vote to eliminate all five of its alternative schools. Many parents say the schools focus on individual learning needs in ways regular community schools do not.
At an OCDSB Alternative Schools Advisory Committee meeting Monday night, community members and parents shared their thoughts on the plan in an online forum.
Emily Addison, a parent and co-chair of the committee, was among parents who voiced frustration over the process.
Parents voice concerns about OCDSB's plan to integrate specialized programs
She said parents believe OCDSB administrators had already decided that alternative schools would be cut before hosting consultations, based on a radio interview the board's director of education, Pino Buffone, gave to CBC on Monday morning.
"What, therefore, is the point of having community consultations if there's not opportunities for a plan to be altered or changed?" she asked.
Disagreement over value
On Monday, Buffone told CBC's Ottawa Morning that the alternative school program was being cut because it hasn't been "adding value enough."
"Our students in the alternative program, on balance, each and every year perform under the district average," he said.
Students in alternative schools did perform under the district average on the provincial assessment test (EQAO) in Grade 3 and Grade 6, and on report cards in the last three years, according to an OCDSB report released last fall. The report shows students in regular English programs also performed below average.
Between the regular and alternative programs, alternative students outperformed regular students by between two and eight per cent, in every EQAO subject except Jr-Math. The elementary and middle school French immersion programs performed above district average on the EQAO and report cards in the same time frames.
In the radio interview, Buffone also cited "chronic absenteeism" among alternative students. The OCDSB defines absenteeism as a student missing 10 per cent or more of class days.
The report shows that rates of chronic absenteeism were "higher" in both alternative and regular programs, and "lower" in French immersion programs.
Despite this, Buffone said the board determined alternative programs weren't adding enough value to justify expenses like transporting kids from their home neighbourhoods.
"We're not seeing the return on achievement and well-being that I think is aspired to," he said, adding that the savings could be returned to classrooms. He said they expect $1 million per year in transportation savings — the equivalent of 20 support staff.
Sarah Boardman, a parent of a child at an alternative school, emailed CBC and the school board about several of Buffone's statements. She felt the board's director misrepresented the impact alternative school programs have had on kids — complaints echoed by parents in the meeting.
Boardman feared any savings might only be temporary, should the Ministry of Education reduce future funding for the school board if it doesn't utilize all of the funding it receives for transportation.
The Ministry's funding framework allocates funding based on expenditures reported by school boards.
Getting voices out
One student of an alternative school, Miles White, joined his mother, Jenn Wallner, at the meeting Monday to voice his disappointment at the prospect of losing his school.
He said in the public school system "you're basically just forced to stay still and listen. While alternative schools give you a much wider variety of choices, and teachers have a much different way of teaching."
Webb thanked him for sharing.
"How do we get Miles's voice out, and others' [voices]?" Webb asked.
Some parents said they have been writing letters, posting to social media, and collecting videos of the students sharing their stories. Laura MacKenzie suggested parents show up to a meeting on Wednesday, when the OCDSB board will be hearing from delegations.
"I'm bringing my kid, I'm bringing my partner," she said. "A lot of us need to be there. ... We need to tell our stories about why it's important to us."
Amy Hannah, the superintendent of education for OCDSB, told the advisory committee that the board of trustees will hear from delegations again on March 19 and that a decision is expected by the end of April.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
National Post
7 hours ago
- National Post
Antisemitism envoy says resignation prompted by frustration over 'not connecting' with anti-hate message
OTTAWA — Ottawa's outgoing envoy for tackling antisemitism is accusing Canada's business sector and civil society of failing to call out a rising tide of hate against Jews and other minorities. Article content In an extensive interview with The Canadian Jewish News, Deborah Lyons also said she could not get a meeting with Conservative Leader Pierre Poilievre during her nearly two-year term. Article content Article content Article content In a statement sent to The Canadian Press, the Conservatives said that Lyons was 'powerless' in her job. Article content Article content Lyons resigned early in her term as Canada's special envoy on preserving Holocaust remembrance and combating antisemitism. She said her decision reflected her 'despair' over the growing gulf in society over violence in the Middle East and the failure of many Canadians to find common ground against hate. Article content 'People were listening and hearing on different frequencies, and so we just were not connecting,' said Lyons. 'That was where the big despair comes from.' She said her work wasn't made any easier by the silence of corporate leaders 'whom I asked many times to stand up,' and by faith leaders who seemed to keep quiet on the suffering of people from other religions. Article content 'I was incredibly disappointed with business leaders,' she said. Article content 'We have a tendency to want to blame politicians all the time, but where have the faith leaders been? Where have the priests and ministers and rabbis and imams and so forth (been)?' Article content Article content Lyons said that some community leaders did ask for her help in finding the right words to speak out against hate — because they feared that they would offend one community if they stood up for another. Article content 'I've been really quite amazed — and often become quite despondent and despairing — about the fact that it was hard to get people to speak up. To speak with clarity, to speak with conviction,' she said. 'The mark of a country is not the courage of its military. It is the courage of its bystanders.' Article content The Canadian Press has requested an interview with Lyons but has not yet had a response. Article content Lyons told The Canadian Jewish News that Amira Elghawaby, the federal government's special representative on combating Islamophobia, tried to work with Lyons on fighting hate, citing an apparently shelved plan to visit provincial education ministers together. 'Neither my community, nor her community, were happy all the time to see us in pictures together,' Lyons said. 'There were often people who just simply didn't want me participating in respectful dialogues, or wouldn't come into the room.'
CTV News
8 hours ago
- CTV News
Ottawa mayor opposes pay hike for councillors amid talk of raise proposals
Ottawa Mayor Mark Sutcliffe says he won't back pay raises for city councillors as some members of council mull bringing forward a motion to give them a significant salary increase. CTV News Ottawa has learned councillors are considering several options for pay raises, where proposals could go up as high as $18,000, from $119,654 currently to $138,000 – a 15 per cent increase. Speaking in a media availability following the meeting, Sutcliffe said that while he respects the hard work of councillors, it would not be appropriate to consider a pay raise at this time. 'I think we need to take a look around at what's going on in the community right now. There's an affordability crisis, there's the prospect of significant federal job reductions, there are lineups at food banks,' Sutcliffe said. 'I hear all the time from my colleagues on city council and from members of the community that they want to see more resources being invested in critical areas to support the most vulnerable.' Sutcliffe added that considerations about a pay raise could impact ongoing salary negotiations with public sector unions representing city staff. 'I think it would be imposing a significant burden on the staff who are negotiating those contracts with those unions if we were to introduce for ourselves a larger than cost of living increase for our salaries,' he said. Ottawa's 24 city councillors each earned $119,490 in 2024 and $111,111 in 2023. Elected officials received a 2.5 per cent raise in each year of the three-year collective agreement for 2023, 2024 and 2025, tied to raises for non-unionized managers. In January, councillors received a report conducted by consulting firm MNP that found the current renumeration rates for elected officials in Ottawa aligned with the median market rate. 'Therefore, data-driven results across comparators' research do not indicate that a salary increase is needed presently,' the report said. Toronto councillors voted in March to increase their salaries by 24 per cent from $137,537 to $170,588. The Ford government unfroze Ontario MPP salaries held at 116,500 since 2009 last spring. MPPs saw a nearly $41,000 raise to a total of $157,350. Coun. Riley Brockington tells CTV News Ottawa he believes an independent assessment should be done to come up with the right figure. Brockington says outside of inflationary increases, councillors have not had an in-depth review on pay raises for members in over two decades. 'I've met with the mayor on a number of occasions. I floated six, seven different options for us to consider, while talking about the pros and cons of each,' he said. 'I just want something that is reasonable, that is backed up by an independent study.' Brockington says there are different opinions on council for the process moving forward. 'The timing is also a concern but at the end of the day, what we really need is a process that council agrees with so that this does not come up every term of office for city councillors and council as a whole to deal with,' he said. No motion on councillor pay was put forward at Wednesday's city council meeting and it's unclear if or when one will be. with files from CTV News Ottawa's Josh Pringle
CTV News
8 hours ago
- CTV News
Report raises questions about First Nations ownership in major projects
People rally against Bill C-5 on Parliament Hill in Ottawa on Tuesday, June 17, 2025. THE CANADIAN PRESS/Justin Tang OTTAWA — A new think tank report is questioning how the federal and provincial governments' sprint to build major infrastructure projects might affect Indigenous Peoples' rights — and warns that it could end up pitting Indigenous communities against each other. The report by the Yellowhead Institute, 'Buried Burdens,' takes a look at major projects through a case study of the Prince Rupert Gas Transmission Project and the Ksi Lisims facility in B.C., which are expected to transport millions of tonnes of gas per year. Owned in part by the Nisga'a Nation, the project has seen staunch opposition from other First Nations communities that did not approve or consent to it. The Yellowhead report, released this week, comes amid a countrywide push to rapidly launch major projects, including pipelines, to shore up the economy against U.S. President Donald Trump's trade war. The recently passed One Canadian Economy Act gives Ottawa the power to fast-track projects it deems to be in the national interest by sidestepping environmental protections and other legislation. Governments have been encouraging First Nations leaders to support such projects through loan guarantees and promises of financial incentives. But many First Nations leaders fear their ways of life could be irreparably harmed if governments evade environmental standards. 'Right now, the narrative is full speed ahead on resource development,' said Hayden King, a member of Beausoliel First Nation who serves as Yellowhead's executive director. 'Increasingly, that includes Indigenous partners, but there's not a lot of discussion on the dynamics of investing in projects like these, and there's a risk that has to be considered … 'First Nations are not necessarily the ones merely impacted by these developments, but they're being encouraged to invest in these projects, to be partners in these projects and grant social licence to enable these projects.' Some provinces have enacted laws similar to the One Canadian Economy Act, including Bill 5 in Ontario, now the subject of a court challenge by nine First Nations. And in B.C., Premier David Eby's government passed Bills 14 and 15 — pieces of legislation meant to ramp up energy and infrastructure development that have come under fire from First Nations. Prime Minister Mark Carney has frequently pointed to Indigenous participation in major projects as a means to ensure their success and prevent delays. He has pointed to the $10 billion Indigenous Loan Guarantee Program as proof of Ottawa's commitment to ensuring Indigenous communities have a meaningful stake. The report challenges that argument altogether, calling it an 'industry-driven narrative.' 'While there are potential benefits from participating in equity ownership when compared to shorter-term impact benefit agreements and service contracts, there are also greater risks,' the report says. 'This particular philosophy of 'economic reconciliation' imagines Indigenous communities regaining control of their economies, aiming for self-sufficiency, sustainability, and self-determination. This is an industry-driven narrative that presents resource extraction as the singular pathway to achieve these ends.' That narrative, the report says, could also cause rifts between Indigenous communities that support specific projects and those that do not. 'While uncomfortable, conflict and disagreement are part of Nation-to-Nation relationships — and always have been. However, it is equally important to recognize that in true Nation-to-Nation relationships, the self-determining rights of one Nation cannot supersede the inherent rights of another,' the report says. King said potential conflicts between pro-development communities and those more hesitant lends itself to conversations about the kinds of development that align with their values. But that conversation is also about rights, King said, and how courts will strike a balance among First Nations who don't see eye-to-eye on project proposals. 'Let's not have the courts decide the answers to those questions, but let's actually work through diplomacy and figure those out on our own terms, using our own Indigenous law,' he said. King said that discussion should 'feed back into the conversation about what kind of economy … we want,' pointing to the pre-contact economies that once sustained Indigenous Peoples. 'We had these economies, and still do to a degree. So what would it look like to reimagine those, and rearticulate them in the face of the narrative that we only have one option, which is resource development?' he said. This report by The Canadian Press was first published July 23, 2025. Alessia Passafiume, The Canadian Press
