Opposition criticises Jammu and Kashmir government for ‘dragging its feet' on quota revamp
The committee, in turn, submitted it to the Law Department for legal vetting months ago, and it has been bogged down since. Several opposition parties have expressed dismay and demanded that the Cabinet report be made public.
J&K's reservation quota was revised under Central rule after new categories like Paharis, Paddari Tribe, Koli, and Gadda Brahmin, etc., were included in 2024. The open merit category was reduced significantly, to less than 40%.
The ruling National Conference (NC), which promised to rationalise the quota, constituted a Cabinet Sub Committee (CSC), which was to file its report in six months. However, no final decision was taken on the rationalisation and no deadline was set for the Law Department, evoking sharp reactions from Opposition parties and open merit aspirants.
'Despite the six-month deadline, the Cabinet has neither offered clarity nor transparency on the report, only vague assertions and now a reported referral to the Law Department. This ambiguity is not just disappointing but also damaging,' Engineer Ehtisham Khan, a student rights activist, told The Hindu.
Aspirants in the dark
He accused the NC Government of 'keeping the open merit aspirants in the dark yet again.'
Opposition Peoples Democratic Party (PDP) leader and MLA Waheed-ur-Rehmaan Parra said the Cabinet move has left 'thousands of students heartbroken and disillusioned.' 'This is a deliberate denial of justice. These students have already endured violence, lockdowns, and lost opportunities. Now, as they seek fair representation and rationalised reservation, the government is pushing them further to the margins,' Mr. Parra said.
He said the NC Government has the power to strike down the BJP-imposed policy with a single administrative order.
NC insincere
'But the party that promised to reverse the BJP's damage is now complicit in continuing it. If the Kashmiri youth are not offered hope, it will only empower subversive elements, further destabilising a generation and their future. Rationalisation of reservation and proportional representation represents the only fair path forward, and it must be implemented without further delay,' Mr. Parra said. He demanded that the government make the report public.
J&K Peoples Conference chief and MLA Sajad Lone accused the Abdullah Government of being 'clueless on reservations.' 'It has no intention of doing anything. Now, coming to this draft proposal. To the best of my knowledge, anything sent to the Cabinet should be vetted by the Law Department. It is not the other way around. It looks like another round of time-wasting tactics,' Mr. Lone said.
J&K Apni Party (JKAP) president Altaf Bukhari asked the government to set a timeline for addressing the reservation issue. 'Whether the government focus is on revising the CSC report or obtaining legal vetting, it is essential that a clear and fixed timeline be established,' Mr. Bukhari said.
He called for 'a judicious reservation policy.' 'One thing is clear beyond a doubt that the current reservation policy is highly flawed and injudicious. There is broad consensus that we require a more judicious reservation policy to protect merit,' Mr. Bukhari said.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Time of India
18 minutes ago
- Time of India
CM meets guv, discusses ways to strengthen governance
1 2 Bhubaneswar: CM Mohan Charan Majhi met governor Hari Babu Kambhampati at Raj Bhavan on Monday followed by the governor visiting law minister Prithiviraj Harichandan's residence, sparking speculation of an imminent cabinet reshuffle. While the governor's office stated that discussions centred on strengthening governance and public welfare during his meeting with Majhi, the chief minister's office (CMO) termed it a courtesy call. The timing of the meeting, however, has led to intense political speculation. Taking to X about his meeting with the CM, governor Kambhampati wrote, "We had a cordial discussion on Odisha's development roadmap and ways to strengthen governance and public welfare." The CMO similarly confirmed the meeting on social media. Political observers suggested the meeting could be significant in the backdrop of recent controversies, particularly the sexual harassment complaints emerging from various educational institutions across the state. Since the governor serves as the chancellor of state universities, these issues may have featured in their discussions. Sources close to the govt indicated that CM Majhi might be considering a cabinet reorganisation. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Japanese hair growth method Hair's Rich Learn More Undo The current council of ministers, comprising 16 members, can be expanded to 22 as per constitutional provisions. State BJP president Manmohan Samal had recently hinted at such a possibility. "The chief minister may drop a couple of ministers and introduce new faces to give his govt a fresh look as he enters his second year in office," a senior party leader said on condition of anonymity. On possible cabinet expansion, law minister Harichandan said, "That's a prerogative of the chief minister. As our party state president has already said, discussions are on for filling up the vacancies besides appointment of various boards and corporations." Regarding the governor's visit, the law minister said Kambhampati came as a well-wisher of the family and as a friend. "He gave his feedback regarding the functioning of some departments. He also gave his advice on how the govt should function as per PM Narendra Modi's vision," the minister said, adding the discussions were more personal.
Time of India
an hour ago
- Time of India
Will stick to '14 cutoff to identify illegal migrants, says Tripura CM
1 2 Agartala: In a decisive move to clarify its stance on the contentious issue of illegal migration, Tripura chief minister Manik Saha reaffirmed on Monday that the state govt will adhere to the Citizenship (Amendment) Act, 2019 (CAA), which designates Dec 31, 2014, as the cut-off date for granting Indian citizenship. This announcement comes amid mounting pressure from the ruling BJP's coalition partner, Tipra Motha, led by royal scion Pradyot Kishore Debbarman. The party has been urging both central and state govts to recognise individuals who entered India post-1971, in line with the Indira-Mujib Accord, as illegal immigrants. Tipra Motha has been actively campaigning for a comprehensive revision of the electoral roll to identify foreign nationals who settled in Tripura after 1971. The Election Commission of India (ECI) has invited the party for a meeting on Wednesday to discuss these demands. Additionally, Tipra Motha has established district-level committees to identify illegal migrants using fraudulent documents. However, Saha emphasised that BJP's approach to infiltration diverges significantly from Tipra Motha's, particularly concerning the citizenship cut-off year. He reiterated that, according to central govt guidelines, only those who fled religious persecution in Afghanistan, Pakistan, or Bangladesh and entered India by Dec 31, 2014, are eligible for citizenship under the CAA. Those arriving after this date will be classified as illegal migrants. To address the issue, the state govt has formed a Special Task Force (STF) to identify illegal infiltrators. District magistrates and police officials have been directed to enhance surveillance and take swift action when necessary. Saha said collaboration with security and border forces has led to a reduction in illegal entries into Tripura in recent months. The illegal immigration debate has intensified following Prime Minister Narendra Modi's recent comments at a rally in Durgapur, West Bengal. In response, BJP-led states, including Tripura, have bolstered their anti-infiltration strategies. In West Tripura district, a 15-member task force, led by the SP, has been deployed to identify Bangladeshis living illegally. The govt is reportedly developing a separate mechanism to manage those identified as illegal immigrants, though the use of detention centers, like those in Assam, remains uncertain. West Bengal CM Mamata Banerjee has accused BJP of labelling Bengali migrant workers as Bangladeshis and deporting them, sparking an outcry and a renewed assertion of Bengali identity by Trinamool Congress.
The Hindu
2 hours ago
- The Hindu
‘People of Tamil Nadu expect only single-party rule in 2026'
Amid repeated assertions by BJP strategist and Union Home Minister Amit Shah that his party and the All India Anna Dravida Munnetra Kazhagam, constituents of the National Democratic Alliance, would form a coalition government in Tamil Nadu after the 2026 Assembly election, AIADMK general secretary Edappadi K. Palaniswami on Monday (July 21, 2025) said the people of Tamil Nadu expected only a 'single-party rule' in the State. At the same time, he insisted that attempts to break the alliance of the two parties would not materialise. In an interview with The Hindu in Tiruvarur, Mr. Palaniswami, who is on a Statewide tour as part of his 'Makkalai Kappom, Thamizhagathai Meetpom (Will save people, retrieve Tamil Nadu)' campaign, said the next government would be formed in line with the people's sentiment. The people of Tamil Nadu favoured a single-party rule. 'We also wish for the same. The AIADMK will certainly form the next government on its own with an absolute majority and fulfill the people's expectations,' he said. Mr. Palaniswami downplayed the BJP's pre-poll assertion about forming a coalition government, stating that such claims were merely meant 'to enthuse their cadres'. While contending that the AIADMK has not held any talks so far with actor Vijay's Tamizhaga Vettri Kazhagam, he said his appeal to all like-minded parties to join hands with the AIADMK to defeat the DMK applied for the actor-politician too. The same was applicable to the Naam Tamilar Katchi, headed by Tamil nationalist Seeman. 'There are eight more months for the election. A clear picture will emerge at an appropriate time,' he said. The Leader of Opposition accused Chief Minister M.K. Stalin of not understanding the sufferings of the people. A fortnight into his roadshow, Mr. Palaniswami said there had been an overwhelming response from the people to his tour. He felt contradictions within the DMK alliance were getting more pronounced and expressed optimism that the AIADMK will form the next government in Tamil Nadu. Edited excerpts from the interview: What is your assessment of the response to your ongoing State-wide roadshow, which you had launched in Mettupalayam on July 7? There is an overwhelming response from the people. We see huge turnouts wherever I go. You had dubbed M.K. Stalin as a 'Coat Suit' Chief Minister, who did nothing concrete for the development and welfare of the people except for stage-managing shows through media appearances. However, he says his 'Dravidian model' government is the best in the country... I have only reflected the people's assessment of his failure as Chief Minister. Without understanding the suffering of the people under his regime, he projects himself as the best Chief Minister due to arrogance of power. Of late, smaller parties are driving a hard bargain with dominant partners — be it the AIADMK or the DMK. They are seeking more seats. What is your take? It is quite common for parties, depending upon the prevailing circumstances, to make moves for their respective growth. As far as the DMK front is concerned, the party's popularity has taken a hit. So, its allies are asserting themselves. So, it (DMK) will be pushed to allot more seats to allies, as sought by them. So, do you foresee the DMK alliance disintegrating in the run-up to the Assembly polls? Allies such as the Congress and the VCK have expressed a desire to share power... I cannot say whether the alliance will break up or not. But of late, contradiction in opinions in the DMK alliance is more pronounced. It is being openly reported in the media. [Congress leader] Rahul Gandhi has strongly criticised the Communists. Likewise, the Communist Party of India (Marxist) State secretary P. Shanmugam, while participating in a protest, has said, '98% of the promises made by the DMK in its election manifesto have not been fulfilled.' Such contradictions exist there. Like you mentioned, allies are seeking a share in power. These incidents indicate fissures. But whether the alliance will crack, we cannot respond hypothetically. After having severed ties with the BJP in 2023, you have now entered into an electoral alliance for the Assembly election. The BJP leadership is repeatedly asserting the party will be a part of the next government (should the alliance win in 2026). But during your roadshow at Thiruthuraipoondi, you said 'AIADMK men are not fools' to share power. Could you clarify your stand? I did not say that [contextually]. The DMK and its allies, to malign the AIADMK-BJP alliance, are orchestrating a campaign that the BJP will 'swallow the AIADMK'. The Thiruthuraipoondi statement was made to scotch this well-planned, sinister campaign of the DMK and its alliance partners. In a State that has not seen a coalition government, what is your clear and direct message to the BJP on this issue? The formation of a government will reflect the people's sentiment. People wish for a single-party rule with an absolute majority in the State. This is what is happening as per their wishes for so many years in Tamil Nadu. This is what people expect in the 2026 election as well. We also wish for the same. The AIADMK will certainly form the next government on its own with an absolute majority and fulfil the people's expectation. Will you talk to the BJP leadership to clear the contradictions? There is no contradiction. Parties express such desire (coalition government) to enthuse their cadre. Many are trying to break the AIADMK-BJP alliance by criticising and creating discord among us. It will not materialise. The AIADMK-BJP alliance will continue intact — 100%. Did the AIADMK hold talks with actor Vijay for an alliance with his Tamilaga Vettri Kazhagam (TVK)? There have been no such talks so far. Would you extend an invitation to him to join your alliance? All like-minded parties that want to defeat the anti-people DMK should join hands with the AIADMK. Is this applicable to the TVK? Mr. Vijay is also vowing to defeat the DMK. It applies to his party as well. What about Seeman's Naam Tamizhar Katchi (NTK)? Our general view is that all like-minded parties must join together. There are eight more months for the election. A clear picture will emerge at an appropriate time. But how would parties opposed to the BJP join hands with you? How did such parties join together in the 1999 Parliamentary election and 2001 Assembly election [BJP-inclusive DMK-led alliance]? Is there grassroots synergy between the AIADMK and the BJP? You can see the enthusiasm among them during my ongoing campaign. The BJP cadre and leaders continue to participate in the roadshows. There is a perception that the AIADMK has lost ground in south Tamil Nadu and delta. No such situation, as portrayed by some, prevails on the ground. The AIADMK enjoys strong support in all districts. The people, who have undergone untold sufferings in the 50-month misrule of the DMK, strongly feel we have the capability to throw the DMK out of power. We had done a lot for the people of the delta region. We enacted a law to make the delta an agriculture protected zone. We ensured Cauvery water reached the tail-end areas. We stood by farmers and fishermen when the region was hit by Cyclone Gaja and ensured the timely distribution of compensation. We introduced three-phase power to the farmers and rolled out kuruvai and samba packages. I am basically a farmer. I know their difficulties. The farmers of the delta region also agree that I will safeguard them. They will stand with us. What is your take on the battle for control of the PMK between its founder S. Ramadoss and his son Anbumani Ramadoss? I trust all will end well. I do not want to interfere in their party affairs. How do you see the DMK government's handling of law and order, its promise to eliminate corruption, and the ED raids on ruling politicians? How could the DMK put an end to corruption? It is the fountainhead of corruption. I hope law will take its course in the ED cases. No DMK Minister, involved in corruption, can is absolutely no law and order in Tamil Nadu. There is no safety and security for women and children. The crime rate is up. When DMK men are involved in crimes, the rulers invariably protect them and some officers too. A time will soon come when they will be subjected to questioning. This government, which came to power proclaiming it will abolish the NEET, must also take moral responsibility for the deaths of 25 medical aspirants. Hasn't the DMK consolidated women voters through various schemes including the Kalaignar Magalir Urimai Thogai scheme? The people have not forgotten the DMK government for scrapping the Thalikku Thangam scheme and marriage assistance scheme of distributing ₹25,000 and ₹50,000. The women will teach a fitting lesson to the DMK. What is your aspiration for the AIADMK and its future? I want the AIADMK to grow further and would love to see the party in the seat of power again. I am always with the grassroots level cadre as one of them, and not as a leader. Due to this, I understand their feelings and expectations. I act as per their wishes, and as a party. we are strong and united to defeat our political enemies in 2026. Prime Minister Narendra Modi is slated to visit Ariyalur later this month. Will you meet him? We will let you know soon.
