A joined-up response to climate crisis
What will it take for governments around the world to take real action on climate change? The science is very clear on the causes and consequences of climate change, and the solutions and pathways to get to net zero emissions have also been well-documented by the Intergovernmental Panel on Climate Change (IPCC). Sometimes people think that the "I" in IPCC stands for "International", but in fact it is "Intergovernmental"; in other words, the governments of the world have requested the many reports that the IPCC has put out. Those same governments have then failed to act collectively in a way that is consistent with the IPCC reports. Why?
As a physicist, I cannot answer those two questions, because they require expertise in social sciences and humanities, using multi- and cross-disciplinary approaches. However, the University of Otago has academic staff and research students in politics, management, philosophy, ethics and other disciplines researching topics related to those questions. Regular readers of the Otago Daily Times ' "Resilient" column in "The Weekend Mix" or online may have noticed columns on climate change from University of Otago staff members or research students affiliated with He Kaupapa Hononga: Otago's Climate Change Research Network. So what is He Kaupapa Hononga, and how is it helping to address those two key questions?
The name "He Kaupapa Hononga" was gifted by Dr Lyn Carter when she was a senior lecturer at Te Tumu School of Māori, Pacific and Indigenous Studies, at the University of Otago. The name points to the process of joining together with shared objectives, aims and values. He Kaupapa Hononga is a revitalised (2019) and reshaped (2020) network that started out as the Otago Climate Change Network (OCCNet). OCCNet was established in 2011 by Colin Campbell-Hunt, then a professor in the department of management, and Prof Ceri Warnock in the School of Law. OCCNet was initially comprised of academic staff from commerce and humanities who were concerned about climate change's societal consequences and wanted to provide research-informed responses. OCCNet members established the undergraduate paper called "Interdisciplinary Aspects of Climate Change" (ENVI312).
For the 2019 revitalisation work, kaitiaki kaupapa assistant research fellow Kate Turner reached out and connected 60 climate change researchers from the sciences, commerce, health sciences and humanities divisions of the University of Otago and 60 members of the public and external organisations. He Kaupapa Hononga was funded equally by the four divisions from 2020 onwards in recognition of the multi-disciplinary nature of the network. He Kaupapa Hononga now connects more than 130 University of Otago researchers and more than 150 members of the public and external organisations. This reflects the increased growth in concern about climate change over the past few years as well as our efforts to connect with people.
In addition to building relationships within the University of Otago, and our regular contributions to the ODT , the Science Media Centre and other print media, He Kaupapa Hononga also communicates the latest in climate change research via our YouTube channel. This channel has 50 videos (and counting) of talks and workshops from 15 minutes to two hours in length from our seminar series, symposium and policy school events.
In 2024, He Kaupapa Hononga put a great deal of effort into multidisciplinary, research-informed policy submissions to government. Our most comprehensive submission was on the Second Emissions Reduction Plan: https://tinyurl.com/mrhz6s5.
We made nine main recommendations: (1) set clear decarbonisation targets (with timelines, and for all sectors); (2) reform the Emissions Trading Scheme (in particular, dealing with cheap and free credits); (3) enhance public transport and lower-carbon freight modes (e.g., rail and maritime freight transport); (4) support the agricultural sector to transition to low emissions farming models; (5) address the big issues in the energy transition (e.g., intermittency, dry year risks, incoming large demand sources such as data centres); (6) align technology availability (e.g., realistic timelines for emissions-reducing agricultural technology); (7) reassess forestry policies (especially to shift the focus from carbon offsetting through exotic conifers to protection of biodiversity and more sustainable forestry practices); (8) update assessment of conservation value prior to permitting forestry activities on Crown land (only permitting native afforestation on Crown land); (9) fund detailed regional and local measurement of carbon storage (for soils, wetlands and riparian margins).
Our past members and postgraduate students have gone on to do great things; for example, our original kaitiaki kaupapa assistant research fellow Kate Turner went to work for the Deep South National Science Challenge as a climate change knowledge broker, and is now principal adviser, climate change adaptation for the Wellington City Council.
I am one of the co-directors of He Kaupapa Hononga, but on Monday, I officially hand over my position to Dr Christine Winter (Ngāti Kahungunu ki te Wairoa) from the University of Otago's politics programme. Prof Janice Lord, from the department of botany, took over the other co-director position from Prof Sara Walton, from the department of management, last year. Along with assistant research fellow Andrea Foley (Kāi Tahu), the new co-directors and their team have exciting plans ahead for He Kaupapa Hononga, so keep an eye out for more on multi- and cross-disciplinary, research-informed action on climate change.
Inga Smith is an associate professor and climate scientist in the University of Otago department of physics. Each week in this column writers address issues of sustainability.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Otago Daily Times
17 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
Leader nuclear ‘red button' concerns
PHOTO: GETTY IMAGES When it comes to those who have the power to push "the big red button" and start a nuclear war, it has always been hoped that cool heads will prevail. But a University of Otago study shows there is growing concern about the leaders of nuclear-armed nations around the world, and how their health may be affecting their decision-making. Menachem Begin. The Doomsday Clock now sits at 89 seconds to midnight — the closest it has been to catastrophe since the Cuban Missile Crisis in 1962, when the United States and Russia were brought to the brink of nuclear war. The closer it moves to midnight, the closer humanity is to the end of the world. University of Otago (Wellington) public health researcher Prof Nick Wilson said the world was again perilously close to the edge and, given that many former leaders of the world's nine nuclear-armed nations were impaired by health conditions while in office, there were concerns about their decision-making abilities while they had access to nuclear weapon launch codes. Richard Nixon. Prof Wilson, fellow researcher Associate Prof George Thomson and independent researcher Dr Matt Boyd found many of the leaders had multiple serious health issues while in office, including dementia, personality disorders, depression and drug and alcohol abuse. Their study analysed the health information of 51 deceased leaders of China, France, India, Israel, North Korea, Pakistan, Russia, the United Kingdom and the United States. Prof Wilson said 15 leaders had confirmed or possible health issues which impaired their performance and likely hastened their departure. John F. Kennedy. In one case, Israeli Prime Minister Menachem Begin had severe depression and spent his last year as leader isolated in his home. "Impairment during crises was also seen in the case of Richard Nixon's bouts of heavy drinking, including during a nuclear crisis involving the Middle East." He said there were also cases where health information about leaders had been kept secret, including United States President John F. Kennedy, whose aides concealed that he had Addison's disease; and Ronald Reagan, whose administration hid the extent of his injuries after he was shot in 1981, and the likely signs of his dementia near the end of his term. Francois Mitterrand. Prof Wilson said Mr Kennedy's performance was likely impaired by Addison's disease, back pain and his use of anabolic steroids and amphetamines in 1961 when he authorised the failed CIA-backed Bay of Pigs invasion of Cuba. In turn, Soviet leader Nikita Khrushchev's poor mental health probably contributed to him triggering both the Berlin Crisis and the Cuban Missile Crisis. And long-serving French President Francois Mitterrand clung to power until the end of his term in 1995, despite having advanced prostate cancer and his doctor concluding in late 1994 that he was no longer capable of carrying out his duties. A study of members of the British parliament also found they were 34% more likely to experience mental health problems than other high-income earners due to the stress of the job. Nikita Khrushchev. Following the rise in international instability caused by the Russian invasion of Ukraine in 2022, it had become even more important to ensure there was good leadership and governance in those countries with nuclear weapons, Prof Wilson said. "This is particularly the case for the United States, where a leader can in principle authorise the release of nuclear weapons on their own — a situation referred to as a 'nuclear monarchy'." He said there was a range of measures which could reduce global security risks from leaders whose judgement was in question. Ronald Reagan. They included removing nuclear weapons from "high alert" status, adopting "no first use" policies where nations only used nuclear weapons in retaliation, ensuring any weapon launches needed authorisation by multiple people and progressing nuclear disarmament treaties. Requirements for medical and psychological assessments could be introduced for leaders before and during their terms, and democracies could also consider introducing term limits for their leaders, as well as recall systems, so voters could petition for politicians to step down, he said.
Otago Daily Times
18 hours ago
- Otago Daily Times
Scientist's contributions recognised
Sue Grimmond has been named a Fellow of the Royal Society of London. PHOTO SUPPLIED A leading environmental scientist and University of Otago graduate has been elected to one of the world's most distinguished scientific bodies. University of Reading atmospheric and oceanic sciences Prof Sue Grimmond has been named a Fellow of the Royal Society, for her pioneering research on the interactions between urban environments and the atmosphere, which has significantly advanced the field of urban climatology. She is one of just 90 outstanding researchers from across the world, elected to join the Royal Society — the United Kingdom's national academy of sciences — as recognition for their substantial contributions to the advancement of natural knowledge. Prof Grimmond was humbled by the recognition, but also "very honoured". "It reflects the enormous contributions from my research group and everyone I have collaborated with during my career, and who have supported and inspired this work." After studying physical geography and graduating with a Bachelor of Sciences degree at the University of Otago in 1980, she completed her Master of Sciences and PhD in climatology and hydrology at the University of British Columbia, in Canada, where she studied the movement of water vapour in towns and cities. She then worked at Indiana University, in the United States, and King's College, in London, before joining the University of Reading in 2013. At Reading, she holds the position of Met Office joint chair, building links between academic research and weather forecasters. Prof Grimmond is the author of more than 250 peer-reviewed publications, focusing on urban climate, land-surface modelling and hydroclimatology, and she has pioneered understanding about the exchange of heat and moisture between the atmosphere and urban surfaces, such as buildings and roads. As well as leading research projects, she has served as president of the International Association for Urban Climate, she was awarded a European Meteorological Society (EMS) Silver Medal in 2024 for her work in urban meteorology, and was the first female recipient of the Symons Gold Medal in 2020 for her outstanding work in urban climatology.
Otago Daily Times
2 days ago
- Otago Daily Times
New technique helping save at-risk Hector's, Maui dolphins
Solving a three-billion-piece jigsaw puzzle has given conservationists a fighting chance of saving New Zealand's endangered Hector's and Māui dolphins. University of Otago anatomy researcher Dr Alana Alexander and Otago PhD candidate Sebastian Alvarez-Costes have found a way to create their genomes from degraded DNA samples, which is a hugely important step in managing the threatened species. Dr Alexander said getting small tissue samples from free-swimming and elusive underwater aquatic mammals was "tricky", meaning pulling together a quality genome using their DNA had been challenging up until now. "We're really lucky that in New Zealand, when whales and dolphins get stranded, the Department of Conservation takes a small tissue sample with the permission of iwi, and they send it to the New Zealand Cetacean Tissue Archive, at the University of Auckland. "One of our Maui dolphin samples came from that archive, and our Hector's dolphin sample came from an animal that was sampled while free-swimming at Cloudy Bay, on the South Island. "The way that these samples were stored was really great for genetics back in the day, but now we've got all these fancy genome techniques that have come on board, and they need really high-quality tissue. "They needed to be snap frozen at the point of collection." Unfortunately, these samples were not stored in optimal conditions, leading to DNA degradation, she said. Rather than abandon the valuable, but imperfect samples, Dr Alexander, Mr Alvarez-Costes and colleagues from Otago, the University of Auckland, Massey University, Oregon State University and the University of Munich looked at how they could work with what they had. The researchers used high-quality genomes from closely related whales and dolphins — particularly the bottlenose dolphin and vaquita — to create a reference framework to properly assemble and organise the fragmented DNA pieces from Hector's and Māui dolphins. The result was the development of an innovative genome assembly process (a pipeline) that leveraged ''synteny'' — similarities in the order of genes between related species and the structure of their chromosome, Dr Alexander said. ''The analogy I would use is that doing a genome is like doing a puzzle with three billion pieces and you don't know where any of them go. ''What using these other whales and dolphins did was kind of give us the picture on the front of the jigsaw puzzle box, so that we had a good idea about where those different bits of DNA should be placed, so that we could stitch together genomes for these species.'' The technique is a first and has had proved remarkably successful. More than 99% of the genome has been successfully mapped to chromosomes, despite the team working with degraded DNA samples. Their small size and inshore distribution makes these dolphins very vulnerable to fisheries bycatch, pollution, marine traffic and disease. As a result, the Hector's dolphin is endangered with about 15,000 distributed around the South Island, and the Māui dolphin is critically endangered with only 48 individuals older than 1-year-old. Mr Alvarez-Costes said there were concerns for Māui dolphins because the study indicated the species might now be at risk of inbreeding. ''What's also particularly concerning is their reduced genetic diversity may hamper their ability to adapt to other emerging threats like climate change,'' he said. Despite the great challenges, the new genomic information would give conservationists a deeper understanding of each population's genetic health and evolutionary history. That in turn would allow them to contribute to better-informed decisions about protection measures. Dr Alexander said it had been ''a long journey'' and the team was excited to see the project completed. Scientists around the world were now looking to see if the same technique could be used on other species, she said.
