Rogue trader tried to con elderly couple with garden work
Arrowsmith's offending came to light when an employee at the Co-operative Bank contacted the police on June 14, 2023, said Thomas Stanway, appearing for Caerphilly council's Trading Standards.
The employee was concerned the 74-year-old victim was being scammed when she attempted to withdraw 'a large amount of cash'.
Police attended the victim's home, and it was confirmed Arrowsmith had invoiced her £18,500 for gardening and landscaping works.
The defendant 'made a number of false claims', including the identity of the builders' merchants he used and claiming that they only accepted cash.
The officer advised the victim not to continue with the work, and told Arrowsmith to collect his equipment and leave the address.
The incident was reported to Caerphilly council's Trading Standards team.
Mr Stanway said the victim agreed to speak with Arrowsmith about proposed gardening works after one of his associates knocked on her door on June 9.
He initially quoted her £19,000. She said this was too high, and a price of £18,500 was agreed.
The victim was provided with an invoice which said he would complete rubbish removal and clearance, cutting trees down, removing tree stumps, and landscaping works.
Arrowsmith started the work 'almost immediately'. On the third day he brought a digger to the property, but the victim became concerned as, instead of removing the excess soil, Arrowsmith spread it over the rest of her garden.
Mr Stanway said Arrowsmith demanded £4,000 from the victim on the 'fourth or fifth day' for the work that had already been completed.
That led to the victim going to the bank and the police being contacted.
On the invoice Arrowsmith gave the victim, the 'No' box next to a statement outlining her cancellation rights had already been ticked. The victim said she was never told by Arrowsmith or his employees about her cancelation rights.
Arrowsmith's business cards had two telephone numbers and didn't include an address. He also claimed to be an approved waste carrier – but subsequent checks with the Environmental Agency and Natural Resources Wales confirmed he wasn't.
Even after the police attended, Arrowsmith continued to pressure the victim to pay £1,830 for 'rubbish collection' – despite the fact the rubbish remained at the site.
A chartered builder and surveyor visited the victim's home and said the work 'did not achieve an acceptable level' and 'was overpriced'.
He described the invoice as 'inappropriate' and 'short of content and descriptions of the work'.
The court heard 35-year-old Arrowsmith, of Kings Meadow in Llanfaes, Brecon, had one previous conviction for one unrelated offence.
Ieuan Bennett, appearing for Arrowsmith, said the defendant was remorseful about the offence and had stopped working following this incident.
He said Arrowsmith did not receive any money from the victim, and that the work had cost him an estimated £1,600 – although he acknowledged 'people would perhaps have little sympathy with that'.
Judge Jeremy Jenkins sentenced Arrowsmith to a 12-month community order. He must complete 120 hours of unpaid work and pay £2,500 in costs.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
South Wales Argus
4 hours ago
- South Wales Argus
Grade II Listed Magor guest house up for sale for £995,000
The Brick House Country Guest House, listed by Christie & Co, is a Grade II Listed property dating back to 1790. The charming residence, which has been owned by the current occupant for an astounding 76 years, is on the market for a guide price of £995,000. According to the estate agent, the guest house was originally built by William Phillips of nearby Whitson Court. (Image: Christie and Co via Rightmove) It has only changed hands twice since then. Originally a farm house, it began offering bed and breakfast services in 1974, a tradition that has continued to this day. The estate agent noted that the property has remained an incredibly popular bed and breakfast, attracting both regular and new guests. Its semi-rural location, just three miles from the M4, has contributed to its enduring success. In addition to the main house, there is a detached bungalow in the grounds which is currently let out on an assured shorthold tenancy (AST), providing further rental income. There is also a partly converted two-storey barn attached to the main house. Once finished, this could offer two bedrooms, a sitting room, and a kitchen. The property is located in Redwick, a peaceful village on the outskirts of Magor, Monmouthshire. It is approximately three miles from Junction 23A of the M4 motorway, providing easy access to Newport, Cardiff, and Bristol. (Image: Christie and Co via Rightmove) The area offers a tranquil rural setting with access to both countryside and urban attractions. These include Magor Square, the Procurator's House, St Mary's Church, Redwick Village, Caldicot Castle & Country Park, and the Gwent Levels. (Image: Christie and Co via Rightmove) The Welsh Coast Path and National Cycle Route also pass close by, providing easy access to the guest house. Inside the property, you enter via a timber-framed, glazed porch into an open plan hall featuring the main staircase. (Image: Christie and Co via Rightmove) This leads to the guest lounge, which boasts a bar area with exposed beams and a feature stone fireplace. There is also a formal sitting room, a guest dining room, a kitchen/breakfast room, a garden room, and an office. (Image: Christie and Co via Rightmove) The main staircase leads to a dual landing housing three ensuite double bedrooms. The second floor offers four bedrooms, two doubles and two singles, with the double bedrooms offering ensuite bathrooms. (Image: Christie and Co via Rightmove) Further accommodation can be accessed from the first floor landing or a separate staircase from the main kitchen. This includes two bedrooms with built-in storage and a separate bathroom. (Image: Christie and Co via Rightmove) Externally, there is off-road parking for numerous vehicles, mature gardens and grounds, and an adjoining three-acre paddock, available via separate negotiation. The gardens, mostly laid to lawn with mature shrub, hedge, and flower borders, wrap around the property. (Image: Christie and Co via Rightmove) An outside terrace makes it perfect for alfresco dining, with views of the countryside and beyond. Included within the freehold sale are two further properties. The first is an attached barn, which is fully wired, plumbed, and plastered, but now requires the second fix for completion. The other is a cottage, which has been let to the current tenant for the last six years on an AST basis. The cottage features a sitting room with central electric fire, a kitchen, a garden room, two bedrooms, and a bathroom. According to the estate agent, this is a fantastic opportunity to be the next custodian of a truly beautiful farmhouse. They noted that the property has a multitude of uses, from continuing the current B&B trade to creating a special family home. With the option to provide extra income via the rental properties or offering multigenerational living opportunities, it's a safe bet for years to come, they added. Coupled with the idyllic countryside location, proximity to major cities and road networks, and having the option to acquire further land, it's a property not to be missed.
Daily Mirror
13 hours ago
- Daily Mirror
'Money dysmorphia' is crippling Brits across the UK - but many don't know they have it
Money dysmorphia is a condition that can lead people to feel anxious, guilty, and stressed. Now, a money expert has explained the ways to recognise and overcome it. Have you ever caught yourself scrolling endlessly through Instagram late at night, envying the extravagant lifestyles your followers showcase on social media? You're certainly not alone. The urge to "keep up with the Joneses" can trigger money dysmorphia – where our understanding of financial reality becomes warped, leading to overwhelming feelings of anxiety, guilt, and stress around spending and saving. Matthew Parden, CEO of money management app Marygold & Co, explains precisely what money dysmorphia involves, the elements that contribute to it, and practical approaches to help tackle and conquer it. What exactly is 'money dysmorphia'? Parden explains: "Money dysmorphia is effectively when the distorted perception of one's financial health, how you feel about your money, doesn't necessarily reflect the reality. This can be emotionally driven, shaped by irregular patterns or social pressures to keep up." READ MORE: 'I live in London for £480 a month including bills and there's just one rule' Money dysmorphia can trigger both overspending and excessive saving, depending on how the individual perceives their situation. "We've worked with anxious savers, avoidant savers and people who like to spend, so there's lots of different types of personality and money dysmorphia can manifest in all of them," shares Parden. Warning signs of money dysmorphia So, what are some warning signs or red flags that someone might be experiencing money dysmorphia? Parden reveals: "Feeling uncertain or anxious about money, even though there is no apparent or immediate shortfall in money, could be a sign of money dysmorphia. It could be that you avoid checking your bank statements or balances and this could be because of stress, or it could be because of a fear of what you might see in there." The money expert continues: "Another sign could be fluctuating between periods where you're spending a lot and reining it back and spending a little, so you kind of vacillate between overspending and underspending. Money dysmorphia could be when you are playing down your success, payments or debts and you feel that you've fallen short, that what you have isn't not enough – even though it might be sufficient." Social media and society's contribution Do social media and societal pressures contribute to money dysmorphia? The short answer is yes. Social media and societal pressures can exacerbate feelings of inadequacy regarding personal finances. Parden explains: "Social media presents a curated version of life, where people are only showing the best side of financial life without providing the context. You don't see the debt, the lack of savings, the stress – that is all hidden. For more stories like this subscribe to our weekly newsletter, The Weekly Gulp, for a curated roundup of trending stories, poignant interviews, and viral lifestyle picks from The Mirror's Audience U35 team delivered straight to your inbox. "It does kind of amplify these 'norms' and create unrealistic expectations. It provokes spending which is really emotionally driven and creates a constant pressure to keep up, so that even if your financial footing is secure, you still feel that you've got some way to go. And that in itself can lead to insecurity and a distorted sense of your own financial situation and reality." What repercussions can money dysmorphia have? "Money dysmorphia can often make people avoid getting involved with money and that means they are avoiding financial planning and organisation of their financial life," Parden explains. "This can lead to missed opportunities like having a safety net reserve of cash," shares Parden. "You don't have any savings because you are constantly spending, you may feel like you haven't ever got enough and will consistently avoid doing it. That in itself can lead to anxiety, a sense of failure and can affect your mental and physical health." How to conquer money dysmorphia? Ignorance isn't bliss, particularly when it comes to your wallet. It's time to take control and get savvy with your finances. Parden advises: "Take a step back and work out what it is that may be impacting your relationship with money," suggests Parden. "Just start with small, repeatable steps, like taking 10 minutes out of every week to look at your finances and understand what you're doing and where your money has gone and what is coming up. "If you recognise an issue there, try not to judge yourself. Just do regular gentle reviews of your finances because that helps you start to engage with it and might help reduce the fear. It might also help you move towards bridging that gap between how you feel about your finances and actually what is true in your finances."
Daily Mirror
a day ago
- Daily Mirror
Man charged in connection with death of woman found in woodland 30 years ago
Shona Stevens died after she was discovered badly injured on a path in woodland near her home in Irvine, North Ayrshire, on November 10, 1994 - a man has now been charged A 67-year-old man has been charged following the death of a mother more than 30 years ago, police have confirmed. Shona Stevens, 31, was discovered badly injured on a path in woodland near her home in Irvine, North Ayrshire, on November 10 1994. She later died in hospital. On Friday, Police Scotland announced that a 67-year-old had been arrested - with an update on Saturday revealing the man has now been charged. It comes more than three decades after Ms Stevens was found injured on a footpath near the rear of Alder Green in the Bourtreehill Park area of Irvine. Senior investigation officer Detective Chief Inspector Stuart Gillies said: "I would like to thank the members of the local community who assisted us in our inquiries. I am grateful for their information and input which greatly contributed to our investigation." The man is now expected to appear at Kilmarnock Sheriff Court on Monday, July 28. The frenzied attack happened just 200 yards from the mum's Ayrshire home, as she walked to the Co-op shop in Bourtreehill shopping centre. Shona was last seen walking alone on Towerlands Road just 10 minutes before she was found, the Daily Record reports. The police investigation was hampered after crucial evidence from the crime scene was feared to have been blown away by the downdraught of the helicopter airlifting Shona to hospital in Glasgow. Five weeks later, her body was laid to rest in her mum's hometown of Portree on Skye. It was the third murder recorded in the town in 1994, leaving many local residents in fear - especially as Shona's killer walked freely. But, Police Scotland announced last year that they were 'determined' that the killer would be caught. Her death was being re-investigated as part of a cold case review. At the time, officers were hopeful that advancements in science could lead to a break through. Shona's case was featured on BBC's Crimewatch Live in 2021. A £10,000 reward was offered for any information leading to the arrest of the killer. As part of the appeal, viewers were told about an unusual object - a novelty keyring - which was recovered at the crime scene. A Police Scotland statement released today read: "A 67-year-old man arrested in connection with the death of Shona Stevens has now been charged."
