Supreme Court revives FBI 'wrong house' raid lawsuit
The ruling marks a narrow win for Toi Cliatt, his former girlfriend Trina Martina and her son Gabe Watson, who were all present in the house during the October 2017 encounter.
The unanimous decision written by Justice Neil Gorsuch means they can continue to press claims alleging assault, battery and false imprisonment under a law called the Federal Tort Claims Act (FTCA), one of the few avenues to hold federal officials accountable. Litigation will now continue in the Atlanta-based 11th U.S. Circuit Court of Appeals.
"We look forward to continuing this fight with the Martins in the Eleventh Circuit and making it easier for everyday people to hold the government accountable for its mistaken and intentional violations of individual rights," Patrick Jaicomo, a lawyer at the libertarian Institute for Justice who represents the plaintiffs, said in a statement.
The case highlights the problem of law enforcement raiding the wrong house, which has happened in several high-profile cases.
A district court judge and the appeals court ruled for the government.
The legal question touched upon on whether a particular provision of the law, which allows claims concerning the actions of federal law enforcement officers, is trumped in this instance by another provision called 'the discretionary function exception,' which protects certain judgment calls from liability.
The court did not resolve that question, but did remove a barrier to the plaintiffs being able to argue it in lower courts.
"We readily acknowledge that different lower courts have taken different views of the discretionary function exception," Gorsuch wrote. "We acknowledge, too, that important questions surround whether and under what circumstances that exception may ever foreclose a suit like this one."
In a separate concurring opinion, Justice Sonia Sotomayor wrote that "there is a reason to think" that the discretionary function exception should not bar the plaintiffs' claims. Her opinion was joined by Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson.
During the raid in question the agents had guns drawn and used flash-bang grenades as they entered the house.
Cliatt was handcuffed and thrown on the floor. Martin wanted to rush to her son but wasn't allowed to move. Watson, then 7, woke up to see agents with guns in his bedroom.
The agents quickly left the house upon realizing their error and a supervisor returned later to apologize.
The Justice Department in court papers said that a Garmin GPS device that FBI agent Lawrence Guerra used to lead the team to the house had indicated the agents had arrived at the correct location.
The FBI was seeking to arrest a man named Joseph Riley, who lived nearby. After they left the wrong house, the agents raided the correct home. Riley was arrested and later convicted.
This article was originally published on NBCNews.com
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
an hour ago
Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson reflects on life in the public spotlight
Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson discussed the latest Supreme Court rulings with ABC News' Linsey Davis during a wide-ranging conversation at the Global Black Economic Forum.
Business Insider
an hour ago
- Business Insider
Startup founders and others in tech call on Sequoia Capital to act after a partner called Zohran Mamdani an 'Islamist'
Sequoia Capital, one of the largest and oldest global VC firms, is facing pressure over a partner's online remarks. Signatories self-identified as founders, investors, and tech workers have signed an open letter calling for Sequoia Capital to take disciplinary action against one of its high-profile partners after he called New York City mayoral Democratic nominee Zohran Mamdani an "Islamist" on X. As of writing, the letter appeared to have hundreds of signatures, though at least several of them appeared to be trolls using made-up or fake names. The list includes some business leaders who have previously raised capital from Sequoia-linked funds. That includes Hosam Arab, CEO of Dubai-based fintech Tabby; Hisham Al-Falih, CEO of Lean Technologies; and Ahmed Sabbah, cofounder of Egyptian payments company Telda. They did not respond to requests for comment from BI but confirmed to Bloomberg that they had signed the letter. Some tech workers who self-identified as working for prominent companies such as Microsoft, Turo, Google, and Apple also appeared to have signed the petition. "Mamdani comes from a culture that lies about everything," Shaun Maguire, a partner at Sequoia, posted on X on July 4. He included a screenshot referencing The New York Times' reporting about how Mamdani marked his identity on a college application. "It's literally a virtue to lie if it advances his Islamist agenda," Maguire wrote in a post. Maguire's post was met with backlash on X, and the open letter appeared over the weekend. It demands a public apology from Sequoia, a formal investigation into Maguire's conduct, a zero-tolerance policy on hate speech, and the creation of a hotline for reporting discriminatory behavior. The letter gives Sequoia Capital until July 14 to respond. "As founders building the future of technology, we cannot accept leadership from a firm whose partners engage in hate speech and spread bigotry," the letter states. "Maguire's conduct not only tarnishes Sequoia's reputation, it also undermines your ability to serve a global, diverse founder ecosystem." Sequoia Capital declined to comment when reached by Business Insider on Monday. Maguire, when reached by BI, also declined to comment but noted several follow-up posts he made in response to the backlash, including a 28-minute video he posted early Sunday morning defending calling Mamdani an Islamist. Maguire said that his criticism was political, not religious or racial, adding that "Islamist" was a political ideology and not the same as Muslim. He also criticized Mamdani's father, Columbia University professor Mahmood Mamdani, accusing him of "radical left-wing Islamism." "To any Muslim that is not an Islamist, and to any Indian that took offense to this tweet, I am very, very sorry," he said in the video. Mamdani's team did not respond to a request for comment. The candidate has previously teared up when speaking with CBS News about the comments he gets, being the first Muslim to run for mayor of New York City. "I get messages that say 'the only good Muslim is a dead Muslim,'" he said. "I get threats on my life, on the people that I love." Mamdani's affordability-focused platform does not advance any religious ideals. He seeks to expand protection for the LGBTQ+ community, raise the minimum wage, and implement free childcare, among other initiatives. Maguire has previously been vocal about politics and sparked controversy online. In 2024, he wrote in a lengthy post on X, saying that he donated $300,000 to get Trump elected as president shortly after Trump was convicted of falsifying business records, though he said at the time his political donations were personal and "did not reflect the views of Sequoia." He also said late last year that he donated another $500,000 to the America PAC founded by Tesla CEO Elon Musk. In January, he called diversity, equity, and inclusion policies "structural racism" in another post on X.
Yahoo
an hour ago
- Yahoo
Musk tweaks Trump with Jeffrey Epstein post
Tech billionaire Elon Musk trolled President Trump early Monday with a post knocking the administration for making no arrests related to the Jeffrey Epstein case. Musk, Trump's former ally-turned-foe, posted an image to his social platform X of 'The Official Jeffrey Epstein Pedophile Arrest Counter,' set to '0000.' 'What's the time? Oh look, it's no-one-has-been-arrested-o'clock again …,' Musk captioned the photo. 'This is the final straw,' Musk responded to an earlier Monday post, which knocked the Trump administration for initially promising to release the 'Epstein list' before reportedly saying, 'There is no Epstein list.' The post came after Axios reported on a memo Sunday evening revealing the Justice Department and FBI have concluded there is no evidence that Epstein, a convicted sex offender, blackmailed powerful figures or kept a 'client list,' as many conspiracy theories suggest. The memo, according to Axios, also says there's no evidence to suggest Epstein was murdered — supporting a medical examiner's report that he died by suicide in a Manhattan jail in 2019. According to the news outlet, the two-page memo also suggests no one else involved in the Epstein case will be charged. The Hill has reached out to the Justice Department for comment. Trump's feud with Musk came to a head last month, when the Tesla chief executive said it was time to drop 'the really big bomb.' '[Trump] is in the Epstein files. That is the real reason they have not been made public,' Musk wrote on X at the time. 'Mark this post for the future. The truth will come out,' he followed up minutes later. Trump, before he was elected in November, said he would have 'no problem' releasing files related to Epstein, something some lawmakers and many on social media have called for after the financier's death. The president last year denied any connection to Epstein, writing on social media, 'I was never on Epstein's Plane, or at his 'stupid' Island. Strong Laws ought to be developed against A.I. It will be a big and very dangerous problem in the future!' Musk's allegation last month came just minutes after Trump threatened to cancel government contracts with his 2024 campaign's largest contributor's companies. Earlier Sunday, Trump issued a lengthy post attacking Musk for calling for the creation of a third party, saying, 'I am saddened to watch Elon Musk go completely 'off the rails,' essentially becoming a TRAIN WRECK over the past five weeks.' 'He even wants to start a Third Political Party, despite the fact that they have never succeeded in the United States – The System seems not designed for them,' he added. 'The one thing Third Parties are good for is the creation of Complete and Total DISRUPTION & CHAOS, and we have enough of that with the Radical Left Democrats, who have lost their confidence and their minds!' The Hill has contacted the White House for comment on Musk's remarks. Updated at 10:28 a.m. EDT Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
