Ed Sheeran's copyright lawsuit might actually be over after a decade
Ed Sheeran's Thinking Out Loud lawsuit drama may finally be coming to an end after years of court cases since the bop was released 11 years ago.
The soft rock hit Thinking Out Loud from Sheeran's second studio album X was released in 2014.
If you think you haven't heard it, you're wrong. The song has a stronghold at every wedding to take place in Britain, Ireland, and the US, since its release and was on every mainstream radio station at least once a day for two years after its launch.
The song was such a massive success that when music journalists compared it to Marvin Gaye's Let's Get It On, copyright lawsuits came in guns blazing.
In the latest update on June 16, the Supreme Court announced that it would not be taking on a copyright case, which accused Sheeran's song of infringing upon Gaye's copyright.
The court did not detail why they decided not to take the case, but it could have something to do with the numerous outcomes in other lower courts that Sheeran has won.
The first suit levelled at Sheeran was in 2016 when the daughter of Ed Townsend, the man who co-wrote the Gaye song in 1973.
The case ended in 2017 with Sheeran being cleared and avoiding millions in possible copyright fees, avoiding the fate of Pharrell and Robin Thicke, who paid a hefty fine after their Blurred Lines track was deemed too similar to Gaye's Got To Give It Up.
The second lawsuit came in 2018 from Structured Asset Sales (SAS), which is estimated to have an 11% ownership stake in Gaye's music. The case was heard in 2023 and resulted in Sheeran winning the case again.
Speaking outside the court in 2023, Sheeran commented: 'We spent the past eight years talking about two songs with dramatically different lyrics, melodies and four chords which are also different and used by songwriters every day all over the world.'
He added: 'These chords are common building blocks which were used to create music long before 'Let's Get It On' was written and will be used to make music long after we are all gone.
'They are in a songwriter's alphabet, our toolkit, and should be there for all of us to use. No one owns them or the way they are played, in the same way nobody owns the colour blue.'
The 2023 victory was, of course, appealed, but led to this Supreme Court dismissal in June 2025.
In a fun twist to the relentless story, a separate case SAS may now go to the federal court.
In a statement to Billboard, SAS owner and industry executive David Pullman said that the separate case 'will now go forward'.
'Defendants' fear has always been the sound recording of 'Let's Get It On',' Pullman said. 'The U.S. Supreme Court was aware of this and understands that the case will go forward and may very well be back at the U.S. Supreme Court at a later date.'
However, the idea of yet another case has been firmly rejected by Sheeran's lawyer.
Sheeran's attorney, Donald Zakarin, has dismissed the suggestion that the case can be revived and emphasised that Sheeran and his co-writer Amy Wadge, created the song independently.
'Pullman's completely unauthorised and improper purported registration of the Marvin Gaye recording of 'Let's Get It On,' 50 years after it was created, will not change that fact,' Zakarin told Billboard.
'If he truly believed that the second case he filed was so compelling – which it is not – he would not have spent the last two years pursuing his failed first case.'
Amy Wadge, who co-wrote the song, has spoken about her relief at the decade-long back-and-forth finally, seemingly, coming to an end.
'Ten long years it has been, so to get that ruling is an incredible relief,' she told BBC Radio 4's Today programme. 'It has just rolled on, but yes, it's done.'
The singer was open about how the financial loss of a negative outcome could have ruined her.
'The absolute truth is that song changed my life. I didn't have a hit until I was 37. Then I was able to feel like I'd had a hit for a year and then all of a sudden it felt like the walls were surrounding.
'It was incredibly frightening. Had we lost that case, I could have effectively lost everything. More Trending
'I just knew that had they been successful, it really would have caused a huge issue for creativity in general.'
The music video of Thinking Out Loud was released a decade ago and as of February 2025, has garnered 3.8 billion streams on YouTube.
The song was the first to ever spend an entire year in the UK Top 40 and is one of the most-streamed songs on Spotify.
Despite its incredible success, it is actually Sheeran's second most successful song ever, behind the 2017 hit Shape of You.
Got a story?
If you've got a celebrity story, video or pictures get in touch with the Metro.co.uk entertainment team by emailing us celebtips@metro.co.uk, calling 020 3615 2145 or by visiting our Submit Stuff page – we'd love to hear from you.
MORE: Steps narrowly missed out on Glastonbury legends slot for devastating reason
MORE: Liam Gallagher hits back after Oasis fans branded 'fat, drunk and rowdy'
MORE: 'Secret Glastonbury performers' celebrate UK number 1 album weeks before festival
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Herald Scotland
a day ago
- The Herald Scotland
Without birthright citizenship, these celebs might not be Americans
On June 27, the Supreme Court lifted temporary blocks preventing Trump's order from taking effect, but left it to lower courts to consider the constitutionality of Trump's executive order. Whether Trump will ultimately be able to repeal the longstanding legal precedent that grants citizenship to all children born on American soil is unclear. Here are some well-known actors and politicians who would not have been American citizens when they were born if birthright had not existed. Secretary of State Marco Rubio, 54, is the son of Cuban immigrants who did not become naturalized U.S. citizens until 1975, years after their son was born. Rubio has previously said he does not agree with repealing birthright citizenship. Diane Guerrero Actress Diane Guerrero, who starred in the hit television show "Orange is the New Black," was born to undocumented immigrants from Columbia who were deported when she was 14, she told NPR in 2019. In an interview with the outlet, she said, "This is a country of immigrants. People forget - they like to forget that their ancestors came here with the same dream, with the same hopes, with the same fears. And it's unfair to say that because people are coming later that they don't deserve to be here." Nikki Haley, the former South Carolina governor who ran for the Republican nomination for president in 2024, was born in South Carolina to immigrants from the Punjab region of India, according to her autobiography. In 2015, she told The State news outlet that her parents were in the United States legally but did not become naturalized citizens until after her birth, and the non-partisan American Immigration Council considers her a U.S. citizen because of her place of birth. Bruce Lee Bruce Lee, the martial arts icon who starred in films such as "Enter the Dragon" and "Fists of Fury," was born in San Francisco while his parents were traveling with the Chinese Opera. The National Archives notes that under birthright citizenship he was considered a citizen - though he would not be under Trump's revision to the law. "Lee's parents filed for a Return Certificate on his behalf ... enabling him to return to the United States if he later wished to do so. Lee did return at the age of 18 and grew into the iconic martial artist and film star known across the world." Trump's executive order ending birthright citizenship may have been designed explicitly against his November rival for the presidency, former Vice President Kamala Harris. David Bier, of the Libertarian Cato Institute, posted on X the day Trump signed the order: "As I predicted, Trump's birthright citizenship EO includes a Kamala Harris clause, specifically designed to deny the legitimacy of her US citizenship as the child of someone with a temporary status." Trump's order specifies that someone wouldn't be entitled to birthright if their mother was on a temporary visa - like the student visa Harris' mother was on at the time of her birth - and their father wasn't a citizen, as hers wasn't. Vivek Ramaswamy Vivek Ramaswamy, the tech billionaire and 2024 Republican presidential candidate, told NBC News in 2023 that his father never became a U.S. citizen and his mother only naturalized after he was born. Ramaswamy, who Trump endorsed in next year's Ohio gubernatorial race, has repeatedly called for an end to birthright citizenship. Contributing: Maureen Groppe, Eduardo Cuevas, Sara Chernikoff, Ramon Padilla and Bart Jansen, USA TODAY
Daily Mirror
2 days ago
- Daily Mirror
MAFS star Ella Morgan's mental health struggle since trans ruling
Ella Morgan was among the celebrities attending the 2025 Rainbow Honours on Friday Pride Month is in full swing, bringing with it a vibrant lineup of events that spotlight some of the most inspiring and influential figures in the LGBTQIA+ community. Among them is the 2025 Rainbow Honours, an annual celebration that recognises individuals and organisations making significant strides in promoting LGBTQIA+ equality and inclusion. On Friday (June 28), Married at First Sight star Ella Morgan was honoured as Campaigner or Influencer of the Year. As a transgender woman, Ella has used her platform to advocate for trans rights, a mission that has become increasingly challenging in recent months. 'My mental health has not been the best since the ruling,' the reality TV star shares. 'I think I just really struggled with being labelled or identified as legally a man.' Back on April 16, the UK Supreme Court ruled that the legal definition of "woman" under the Equality Act 2010 is based on biological sex, excluding transgender women. 'You know, people call me man and tranny and he all the time online, and it's just a word and it means nothing to me,' Ella says. She further shares: 'So it didn't affect me, but now, because it's legally recognised, it is painful and it's sad, and it's like I've gone through all of this stuff and I've still been penalised, and discriminated against. 'But this time, people justify their anger and their hatred with this ruling; it's like it's given some people an excuse to justify their hatred because it's a ruling made by the government.' Ella, who made history when she became the first transgender person to appear on both MAFS in 2023 and Celebs Go Dating the following year, says that she has faced 'more hate than ever' this year. She explains: 'People are like, 'yeah, but you are a man, you know, legally, you are'. 'What am I meant to say to that? And how am I meant to deal with that?' Jake Graf, notable as Britain's most prominent transgender father, echoes Ella's struggle amid the Supreme Court's ruling. Taking to the Rainbow Honours red carpet, he shares: 'I'm a trans man, married to a trans woman, and we have two daughters, three and five years old, and I fear for my wife every time she leaves the house now.' Jake's wife, Hannah, served as the highest-ranking trans officer in the British Army before she left in 2018 to start a family. The couple made history as Britain's first transgender parents. 'Every time she goes into a public toilet, my wife is scared about taking our two little daughters into the toilet or into the changing room when she takes them to their swimming lessons, and that should not be happening,' Jake continues. 'So it's severely affected our lives and our mental health.' He adds: 'I take our daughters to the toilet a lot more than my wife does anymore because she's worried about someone attacking her in front of our kids, which is terrible.' Despite the recent rise in transphobia across, Jake remains hopeful, particularly inspired by the younger generation. 'The younger generation is more and more diverse and more fluid than we ever imagined,' he says. 'There are more trans people out there than I think we ever knew, and I think once we get over this terrible blip in our history, we'll realise that more and more trans people are going to keep coming out, and it will seem less unusual, and soon, we will find that love and acceptance that we so desperately need.' 25-year-old Noah Adams, known as Noahfinnce, was nominated in the Musician category of the awards and took home a Highly Commended prize in the category. He shares: 'When I was younger, I didn't really feel pride at all. 'I felt pride in my bisexuality, but in terms of being trans, I never felt proud of that until quite recently.' The singer-songwriter and YouTuber, who regularly uses his platform to raise awareness about trans issues to his 979,000 subscribers, often shares commentary critical of figures like J.K. Rowling. Like many other attendees at the Rainbow Honours, Noah remarked that this year's Pride Month feels less like a celebration and more like a protest. This year, he would like to protest against anti-trans legislation, not just in the UK, but around the world. 'I tour the US every single year, and this year I'm not going to be able to, because my passport's going to be counted as fraudulent because it doesn't match the sex assigned at birth,' Noah explains. To become better allies to the trans community, the Asthma Attack emphasised the importance of simply asking. 'It's better to say the wrong thing and find out it's the wrong thing than tiptoe around,' Noah concludes. Ali Bromley, notable for being the first lesbian to win Big Brother UK, shares a similar perspective to Noah, stressing the importance of open dialogue and education. 'Sometimes I do make the decision to protect my peace, but then sometimes if somebody sends me a message and I think, actually, that's a good talking point, I think, why not share that and then share my response?' Ali, who was nominated for in the Rainbow Honours' Media Moment category, says. 'What I would hope to model is that maybe change and progression can come with conversation, it doesn't always have to be an argument, because I think sometimes we can get very polarised and start shouting at each other and maybe conversation is okay, and social media is a platform where we can do that.' Being a public queer figure comes with a lot of 'trolls' and online hate, RuPaul's Drag Race UK star Saki Yew Suki says. As a result Saki highlighted the importance of recognising personal progress as key forms of self-care within the queer community. They say: 'Just take a moment sometimes in your own life and just reflect and just you give yourself the chance to go, 'oh, my God, I'm doing so well with whatever I'm doing in my life'.' Jaxon Feeley, who won a highly commended award in the Rainbow Honours' Media Moment of the Year category, reveals: 'You really do have to protect yourself, especially after the Supreme Court ruling, the level of hate online has more than tripled in terms of how much hate there is. When bullies are in power, it gives bullies permission to bully, and unfortunately, that creates a hell of a lot of pain.' Charlie Craggs, a transgender activist, expressed pride in the LGBTQIA+ community for coming together to protest transphobic sentiment. 'For a long time, it's felt like the trans, we're the ones who have been seen as the extremists and we're like the ones making it protesty, but that's because our rights have been the most under fire in recent years,' she says. Strictly Come Dancing star Carlos Gu noted the importance of authentic expression, encouraging men to embrace their femininity. 'Sometimes they want you to dance more masculine, but why can't I dance femininely?' the professional dancer jokes. He adds: 'I want to embrace my femininity, femininity, just brilliant. I think a man should embrace more of their femininity inside of them, because they create more layers of artistry and allow them to really express themselves on a deeper level.' Carlos recognised the LGBTQIA+ community for teaching him to embrace his true self without fear. 'I think gay communities are so inspiring and allow ourselves to be ourselves without any obstacles, without any fear to think that somebody might come to us, I think that's the most important thing I've learned,' he says. Actor Jason Patel revealed that starring in the movie Unicorns taught him a profound understanding of exploring the duality of masculinity and femininity and embracing those different extremes. Reflecting on the significance of this year's Pride Month, Jason concluded with a powerful call to action: 'Protect the dolls', a phrase that champions the protection and trans people. The Rainbow Honours celebration was highlighted by Sister Sledge's Kathy Sledge receiving the Icon Award in recognition of her unwavering allyship to the LGBTQIA+ community, made even more memorable by her powerful performance of the timeless anthem, We Are Family. Rainbow Honours 2025 winners Icon Award Winner - Kathy Sledge Inspirational Role Model of the Year Highly Commended - Greg Turner-Smart Winner - Adelle Barker Campaigner or Influencer of the Year Highly Commended - Lady Phyll Winner - Ella Morgan Community Initiative of the Year Highly Commended - Trans+ History Week Winner - UK Black Pride Musician of the Year Highly Commended - Noahfinnce Charity of the Year Winner - LGBT Foundation Celebrity Ally of the Year Highly Commended - Dame Arlene Phillips DBE Winner - Sally Lindsay Media Moment of the Year Highly Commended - Jaxon Feeley in Hunted Winner - Suki and Eve's wedding in EastEnders Celebrity LGBTQIA+ Champion of the Year Highly Commended - Cynthia Erivo Winner - Yasmin Finney
South Wales Guardian
2 days ago
- South Wales Guardian
Ed Sheeran joins Olivia Rodrigo for surprise duet at BST Hyde Park
Rodrigo, 22, opened the 2025 British Summer Time Hyde Park (BST Hyde Park) series on Friday ahead of her headlining set at Glastonbury on Sunday evening. She took a brief pause from performing some of her biggest hits to introduce Sheeran to the stage for a duet version of the English singer's 2011 song The A Team. A post shared by Ed Sheeran (@teddysphotos) He wrote: 'Both (Rodrigo's) albums (Guts and Sour) are no skips for me, I'm a proper fan. We first met at the rock and roll hall of fame back in 2022, sat next to each other with her mum and my dad and went on to hang and keep in touch from there. 'Was gonna go watch the show anyway but she hit me and asked to sing The A Team with her, which was such a buzz. 'That song turns 15 this year, and I remember playing it to rooms with no one in it in 2010, so to still be playing it to new fans with one of the brightest stars of the next generation is an honour and a privilege. Rock Glasto headline Sunday @oliviarodrigo , UK loves you x.' Other performers scheduled for this year's BST Hyde Park series include Sabrina Carpenter, Neil Young and Stevie Wonder.
