US Supreme Court rules South Carolina can defund Planned Parenthood, paving the way for other states
The US Supreme Court has paved the way for states to cut off funding to Planned Parenthood, one of the country's largest abortion providers, by ruling South Carolina can effectively defund the service.
Planned Parenthood, which provides a wide range of reproductive health services across the US, is already barred from receiving federal money for abortion care.
This latest ruling, supported by six of the Supreme Court's nine judges, allows South Carolina, and potentially other states who may wish to follow suit, to cut off reimbursements to the healthcare provider for low-income Americans who access care through a US government healthcare scheme known as Medicaid.
The case stems from an executive order issued by South Carolina's Republican governor Henry McMaster in 2018 cutting off Medicaid funding to the two Planned Parenthood clinics in the state.
The Medicaid reimbursements were not abortion-related, but Mr McMaster said providing any funding to Planned Parenthood amounts to a taxpayer "subsidy of abortion", which is banned in South Carolina for women who are more than six weeks pregnant.
Both Planned Parenthood and a South Carolina woman suffering from diabetes later launched a legal challenge, arguing that Medicaid patients have the right to receive care from any qualified provider.
An appeals court later overturned the executive order, before the state escalated the legal fight to the Supreme Court.
Thursday's verdict was split down ideological lines, with conservatives holding a 6-3 majority in the US's most powerful court.
The court ruled that a Medicaid patient cannot sue the state to receive medical care from a provider of their choosing.
Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson, in a dissent joined by the two other liberal justices, disagreed.
"Congress enacted the Medicaid Act's free-choice-of-provider provision to ensure that Medicaid recipients have the right to choose their own doctors," Ms Jackson said.
"Today's decision is likely to result in tangible harm to real people."
The Supreme Court ruling was welcomed by the anti-abortion group SBA Pro-Life America, which called it a "major win for babies and their mothers."
It clears the way for South Carolina and other states "to stop funding big abortion businesses like Planned Parenthood in their Medicaid programs," it said on X.
Paige Johnson, president of Planned Parenthood South Atlantic, called the ruling a "grave injustice" and said it "promises to send South Carolina deeper into a healthcare crisis."
The Supreme Court overturned Roe v Wade, the landmark 1973 case that established federal protections for abortion access, in June 2022.
Since then, more than 20 of the 50 US states have imposed strict limits on abortion, or even outright bans.
AP
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Sydney Morning Herald
an hour ago
- Sydney Morning Herald
The art of the lie: Why Trump is taking issue with Iran's alternative facts
Before Trump did it, with an assist from the Supreme Court on Friday, it was Dick Cheney and Donald Rumsfeld who worked to erode checks and balances and hoover all the power into the executive branch. With the malleable George W. Bush in the Oval Office, Cheney and Rumsfeld were able to create an alternative universe where they were never wrong – because they conjured up information to prove they were right. The two malevolent regents had a fever about getting rid of Saddam Hussein, so they hyped up intelligence, redirecting Americans' vengeful emotions about Osama bin Laden and 9/11 into that pet project. Tony Blair scaremongered that it would take only 45 minutes for Saddam to send his weapons of mass destruction westward. But there were no WMDs. When it comes to the Middle East, presidents can't resist indulging in a gasconade. Unlike Iraq, Iran was actually making progress on its nuclear program. Trump did not need to warp intelligence to justify his decision. But he did anyway, to satisfy his unquenchable ego. He bragged that the strikes had 'OBLITERATED' Iran's nuclear capabilities. Loading 'I just don't think the president was telling the truth,' Senator Chris Murphy, a Democrat from Connecticut, told reporters. He believes Iran still has 'significant remaining capability'. When CNN's Natasha Bertrand and her colleagues broke the story that a preliminary classified US report suggested the strikes had set back Iran by only a few months, Trump, Pete Hegseth and Karoline Leavitt smeared her and The New York Times, which confirmed her scoop, as inaccurate, unpatriotic and disrespectful to our military. On Friday afternoon, CNN revealed that the military did not even use bunker-buster bombs on one of Iran's largest nuclear targets because it was too deep. Though Trump likes to hug the flag – and just raised two huge ones on the White House North and South Lawns – he ignores a basic tenet of patriotism: it is patriotic to tell the public the truth on life-or-death matters, and for the press to challenge power. It is unpatriotic to mislead the public in order to control it and suppress dissent, or as a way of puffing up your own ego. Although he was dubbed the 'daddy' of NATO in The Hague on Wednesday, Trump clearly has daddy issues. (Pass the tissues!) He did not get the affirmation from his father that could have prevented this vainglorious vamping. For Trump, it was not enough for the strikes to damage Iran's nuclear capabilities; they had to 'obliterate' them. It could not simply be an impressive mission; it had to be, as Hegseth said, 'the most complex and secretive military operation in history'. (Move over, D-Day and crossing the Delaware.) The president was so eager to magnify the mission that he eerily compared it to Hiroshima and Nagasaki. Trump has always believed in 'truthful hyperbole', as he called it in The Art of the Deal. But now it's untruthful hyperbole. He has falsely claimed that an election was stolen and falsely claimed that $US1.7 trillion ($2.6 trillion) in cuts to the social safety net in his Big, Unpopular Bill 'won't affect anybody; it is just fraud, waste and abuse.' Loading He's getting help on his alternative universe from all the new partisan reporters in the White House briefing room who are eager to shill for him. 'So many Americans still have questions about the 2020 election,' a reporter told Trump at the news conference on Friday, wondering if he would appoint someone at the Justice Department to investigate judges 'for the political persecution of you, your family and your supporters during the Biden administration'? Trump beamed. 'I love you,' he said to the young woman. 'Who are you?' She was, as it turned out, the reporter for Mike Lindell of MyPillow fame, who has his own 'news' network.
News.com.au
3 hours ago
- News.com.au
‘Make the deal': Donald Trump shifts focus back on Gaza
US President Donald Trump has seemingly returned his focus to the war in Gaza after his role in broking a ceasefire between Israel and Iran. Mr Trump had spent most of Sunday, AEST, doing a running commentary on events at the Capitol where the US Senate was debating his 'Big, Beautiful Bill'. Then in a later post on his Truth Social account, made at about 1am Washington DC time, the President urged Israel and Hamas to strike an agreement in its ongoing conflict. 'MAKE THE DEAL IN GAZA. GET THE HOSTAGES BACK!!! DJT,' he wrote. Mr Trump, who has closely aligned himself with Israel's leader Benjamin Netanyahu, was referencing the Israeli hostages taken by militant group Hamas during its October 7, 2023 terror attacks. It is believed 50 hostages remain after Hamas released some of its captives during earlier ceasefire agreements. Israel's war in Gaza has resulted in the deaths of more than 50,000 Palestinians, according to local authorities. Speaking on Friday, US time, Mr Trump said he believed a ceasefire between Israel and Hamas was 'close'. 'I just spoke to some of the people involved,' he said. 'We think within the next week we're going to get a ceasefire.' Israel's military on Sunday issued an evacuation order for northern Gaza, warning Palestinians in parts of Gaza City and nearby areas of imminent action there. The warning, which comes more than 20 months into the war with Hamas, foreshadowed 'intense force in these areas'. Israeli Defense Force spokesman Avichay Adraee posted to X that 'these military operations will intensify and expand … to destroy the capabilities of the terrorist organisations'. Mr Adraee's post was accompanied by a map of northern Gaza, telling residents to 'evacuate immediately south to Al-Mawasi'. 'Hamas is harming you and bringing disaster upon you,' he wrote. 'Returning to dangerous combat zones poses a threat to your lives.' There has been increasing global criticism over ongoing civilian deaths in the Palestinian territory, with reports of famine and shootings at food aid sites. Gaza's civil defence agency said Israeli forces killed 37 people on Saturday, including at least nine children who died in strikes. Civil defence spokesman Mahmud Bassal told AFP 35 people were killed in seven Israeli drone and air strikes in various locations, and two others by Israeli fire while waiting for food aid in the Netzarim zone in central Gaza. He said the dead included three children who were killed in an air strike on a home in Jabalia, in northern Gaza. Mr Bassal said at least six more children died in a neighbourhood in the northeast of Gaza City, including some in an air strike near a school where displaced people were sheltering. Israeli news outlet Haaretz this week published a story citing unnamed IDF soldiers who claim they were 'ordered' to open fire at unarmed civilians near aid distribution centres. French Foreign Minister Jean-Noel Barrot said on Saturday that he was concerned at the '500 people who have lost their life' in similar incidents in recent weeks. He said France 'stands ready, Europe as well, to contribute to the safety of food distribution' in Gaza. The Israeli military has strongly denied allegations made in Haaretz, telling the Times of Israel its soldiers operated 'under difficult conditions against a terrorist enemy that operates from within the civilian population'. 'IDF soldiers receive clear orders to avoid harming innocent civilians, and they act accordingly.' Mr Trump also backed Mr Netanyahu in a Truth Social post on Srurday, local time, saying he was 'not going to stand' for an ongoing corruption case being run against the Israel Prime Minister. An Israeli court on Friday rejected Mr Netanyahu's request to postpone giving testimony in his corruption trial, ruling that he had not provided adequate justification for his request. In one case, Netanyahu and his wife Sara are accused of accepting more than US$260,000 worth of luxury goods such as cigars, jewellery and champagne from billionaires in exchange for political favours. Mr Trump called Mr Netanyahu a 'war hero' and likened the court case to his own legal battles in recent years. 'Importantly, he is right now in the process of negotiating a Deal with Hamas, which will include getting the Hostages back,' he wrote. 'How is it possible that the Prime Minister of Israel can be forced to sit in a Courtroom all day long, over NOTHING (Cigars, Bugs Bunny Doll, etc.). 'It is a POLITICAL WITCH HUNT, very similar to the Witch Hunt that I was forced to endure.'
The Age
3 hours ago
- The Age
The art of the lie: Why Trump is taking issue with Iran's alternative facts
Before Trump did it, with an assist from the Supreme Court on Friday, it was Dick Cheney and Donald Rumsfeld who worked to erode checks and balances and hoover all the power into the executive branch. With the malleable George W. Bush in the Oval Office, Cheney and Rumsfeld were able to create an alternative universe where they were never wrong – because they conjured up information to prove they were right. The two malevolent regents had a fever about getting rid of Saddam Hussein, so they hyped up intelligence, redirecting Americans' vengeful emotions about Osama bin Laden and 9/11 into that pet project. Tony Blair scaremongered that it would take only 45 minutes for Saddam to send his weapons of mass destruction westward. But there were no WMDs. When it comes to the Middle East, presidents can't resist indulging in a gasconade. Unlike Iraq, Iran was actually making progress on its nuclear program. Trump did not need to warp intelligence to justify his decision. But he did anyway, to satisfy his unquenchable ego. He bragged that the strikes had 'OBLITERATED' Iran's nuclear capabilities. Loading 'I just don't think the president was telling the truth,' Senator Chris Murphy, a Democrat from Connecticut, told reporters. He believes Iran still has 'significant remaining capability'. When CNN's Natasha Bertrand and her colleagues broke the story that a preliminary classified US report suggested the strikes had set back Iran by only a few months, Trump, Pete Hegseth and Karoline Leavitt smeared her and The New York Times, which confirmed her scoop, as inaccurate, unpatriotic and disrespectful to our military. On Friday afternoon, CNN revealed that the military did not even use bunker-buster bombs on one of Iran's largest nuclear targets because it was too deep. Though Trump likes to hug the flag – and just raised two huge ones on the White House North and South Lawns – he ignores a basic tenet of patriotism: it is patriotic to tell the public the truth on life-or-death matters, and for the press to challenge power. It is unpatriotic to mislead the public in order to control it and suppress dissent, or as a way of puffing up your own ego. Although he was dubbed the 'daddy' of NATO in The Hague on Wednesday, Trump clearly has daddy issues. (Pass the tissues!) He did not get the affirmation from his father that could have prevented this vainglorious vamping. For Trump, it was not enough for the strikes to damage Iran's nuclear capabilities; they had to 'obliterate' them. It could not simply be an impressive mission; it had to be, as Hegseth said, 'the most complex and secretive military operation in history'. (Move over, D-Day and crossing the Delaware.) The president was so eager to magnify the mission that he eerily compared it to Hiroshima and Nagasaki. Trump has always believed in 'truthful hyperbole', as he called it in The Art of the Deal. But now it's untruthful hyperbole. He has falsely claimed that an election was stolen and falsely claimed that $US1.7 trillion ($2.6 trillion) in cuts to the social safety net in his Big, Unpopular Bill 'won't affect anybody; it is just fraud, waste and abuse.' Loading He's getting help on his alternative universe from all the new partisan reporters in the White House briefing room who are eager to shill for him. 'So many Americans still have questions about the 2020 election,' a reporter told Trump at the news conference on Friday, wondering if he would appoint someone at the Justice Department to investigate judges 'for the political persecution of you, your family and your supporters during the Biden administration'? Trump beamed. 'I love you,' he said to the young woman. 'Who are you?' She was, as it turned out, the reporter for Mike Lindell of MyPillow fame, who has his own 'news' network.
