San Francisco police arrest suspected serial shoplifter under Prop. 36
According to officers, Marcel Criner was initially arrested on Dec. 4, 2024 following a petty theft incident at a store on the 1300 block of Castro Street. Officers booked Criner into jail on suspicion of felony theft after he was suspected in four other thefts at the same location, saying he stole $1,294.73 of items in total.
Two days later, a judge issued Criner a stay away order from the store and was released on his own recognizance.
Later that month,
Prop. 36 went into effect
. The measure, which was approved by
68.4% of voters in the November election
, enables prosecutors to charge petty theft incidents as either a misdemeanor or felony if a person has two or more prior theft convictions, police said.
According to officers, Criner had what was described as "numerous" prior convictions for theft.
Last month, investigators with the department's Defend Against Retail Theft (DART) Organized Retail Crime (ORC) Task Force began investigating Criner for five thefts at the same store after being issued a stay-away order. Investigators said they were also able to link Criner to three other thefts at the store in November.
Police said the losses from the new incidents totaled nearly $3,000.
Criner was arrested and booked into San Francisco County Jail on March 25. He has been charged with five felony counts of petty theft with a prior conviction, five counts of committing a felony while on release, five counts of violating a court order, three counts of petty theft and two counts of organized retail theft.
"Our officers will continue to use every tool available to them, including new statutes from Prop 36 passed by voters, to hold suspects accountable. I'd like to thank the investigators who worked tirelessly on these cases and continue to curb organized retail theft in our city,"
Chief Bill Scott said in a statement
.
Jail records show Criner remained in custody Thursday on $25,000 bail. His next court appearance is scheduled for April 10.
Anyone with additional information is asked to contact police at 415-575-4444 or to text TIP411, beginning the message with SFPD.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
23-06-2025
- Yahoo
California Government Report Assesses a Decade of Changes in Retail Crime
California's retail theft rate has ticked up over the course of the past decade as changes to statewide laws, pandemic-era social standards and the retail environment have impacted crime trends. A new study from the Legislative Analyst's Office (LAO) shows that between 2014 and 2023, reports of retail theft increased by about 11 percent. Prop. 47, passed in 2014, has been fingered for much of the upswing in retail-related crime over more than a decade, as it set the felony threshold for most types of retail theft at $950 or more, resulting in mere misdemeanor charges for many instances of shoplifting. More from Sourcing Journal Port of LA Ordered by Federal Judge to Clean Up Contaminated Wastewater Florida AG Announces 44 Arrests in Retail Crime Blitz Families of 'Kidnapped' L.A. Garment Workers Arrested in ICE Raids Plead for Justice The controversial law, which was overwhelmingly passed by voters as a ballot initiative, became a complicating factor for law enforcement agencies and prosecutors, leading to fewer arrests and convictions. Researchers also found that Prop. 47 led to an increase in other types of crime, including larceny (which can include retail theft). During the pandemic, non-residential burglaries increased, too. Some of these trends coincided with changes to the criminal justice system, from early releases from prison and reductions in probation term lengths during Covid. 'Taken together, these changes may have impacted retail theft rates by reducing (1) the likelihood people are apprehended for crime and (2) the number of people incarcerated at a given time who might otherwise commit crime,' the research showed. At the same time, temporary stay-at-home orders and the closure of businesses during the pandemic may have contributed to a decline in the rate of crimes between 2019 and 2020, before it rebounded in 2021. Retail-related crimes grew slightly in 2015, at a rate of 5 percent, before declining through 2021 at a total rate of 20 percent. Between 2021 and 2023, retail theft increased significantly, at a rate of 32 percent. Experts are still trying to understand the recent upswing, with the LAO positing that other factors, like changes to the retail environment, provide a possible clue. 'For example, expansion of self-checkout lines and store policies that direct staff not to physically confront shoplifters may have made some people feel that they have a higher chance of avoiding apprehension,' the study said. Technological changes have also made it easier for bad actors to conspire to commit crimes, a la flash mob or smash-and-grab. Social media has been broadly used to organize such retail theft schemes and share tactics, while online marketplaces are routinely used to fence stolen property—a phenomenon that's also been addressed through targeted legislation. There have been also changes in the broader social context, researchers wrote, including rates of homelessness and drug addiction in California—potential motivating factors for retail theft. Amid these evolving societal challenges and changes to the retail landscape, lawmakers and voters have enacted new laws, with 2024 being a landmark year for retail crime legislation in California. These laws change both the likelihood of apprehension for retail theft perpetrators, as well as the likelihood that they will face incarceration for their crimes. For example, Prop. 36, passed by 70 percent of California voters in November, effectively rolls back the most contentious sticking point of Prop. 47 by allowing the dollar value of thefts committed by the same defendant to be aggregated to achieve a felony conviction, even if the thefts are not similar and don't occur within a 90-day period. Under the law, those who have two are more convictions for theft-related crimes like burglary, shoplifting or carjacking can be charged with a felony, which can be punishable with three years of incarceration depending on a person's criminal history. According to LAO researchers, elevating certain misdemeanor crimes to felonies in this way could reduce opportunities to commit crimes, as more of the population likely to participate in retail theft activity would be incarcerated. Meanwhile, another historic package of 11 retail crime-related bills was signed into law by Governor Gavin Newsom last fall, and took effect on Jan. 1. Under Chapter 168 of AB 2943, law enforcement's authority to arrest shoplifters expanded. 'This could help deter people from committing shoplifting if it causes them to perceive a higher likelihood of apprehension,' LAO analysts wrote. 'Additionally, any time they spend in jail following arrest reduces their opportunity to commit more crime.' Notably, Chapter 803 of AB 1065, passed in 2018, established organized retail theft as a specific crime involving working with other perpetrators to steal merchandise with the intent to sell it. The law also criminalized receiving or purchasing stolen goods knowingly, or organizing with others to do so. If the value of stolen retail goods exceeds $950 within a year, thieves can be charged with a felony. According to LAO, within the criminal justice system, available research points to two key mechanisms that impact retail crime rates—namely, the likelihood of apprehension for a crime and the number of people incarcerated who might otherwise commit crimes. One measure of the likelihood of being apprehended for crime is the share of reported crimes for which police make an arrest and are able to resolve the case, or send the detained person for prosecution, also known as a 'clearance rate.' California's clearance rate for property crimes declined from 14 percent in 2014 to about 8 percent in 2023, ticking up during the pandemic era. According to LAO, pandemic era early releases and shorter probationary periods, along with a rise in activities like smash-and-grabs, could have reduced clearance rates. Prop. 47 narrowed officers' ability to make arrests for shoplifting, since many were treated as misdemeanors even when there were repeat offenses. Per LAO, the California Legislature should be paying attention to a number of factors as it evaluates the success of new retail theft and retail crime laws moving forward. The office compiled several questions that lawmakers should ask as it conducts oversight of the recent changes made to address retail theft, including whether practitioners, stakeholders and the public are aware of the changes, whether the new tools are being implemented (and leveraged correctly), whether promising practices are being captured and shared, and whether the laws robust enough to account for technological change. Other areas that should be examined include whether reports of retail crime decrease, whether clearance rates improve, whether there are increased costs to the justice system and whether there are unintended consequences to the changes in the laws. 'Collecting answers to these questions will allow the Legislature to both monitor the implementation of the law changes and help it assess whether they are successful in reducing retail theft,' LAO wrote. On Tuesday, Governor Gavin Newsom's office offered up some evidence that lawmakers' efforts to derail retail crime are already making a dent. According to an analysis of Real Time Crime Index data by the Public Policy Institute of California, property crimes decreased by 8.5 percent in 2024, compared to the year prior. This decrease took place before laws like Prop. 36 took effect, but after the governor opted to allocate an unprecedented $267 million to 55 cities and counties to bolster retail crime-fighting operations and boost prosecutions for organized retail crime. That order took place in fall of 2023, and grant funds were dispersed over the course of the following months. Over the course of 2025—since the 2024 theft package and Prop. 36 were enacted—Newsom said the state's law enforcement agencies have recovered 113,245 stolen items worth nearly $6.5 million. During the month of May alone, arrests were up almost 130 percent, while stolen assets recovered grew by 65 percent, and the value of the items recovered was up nearly 49 percent from the month prior.
Yahoo
12-06-2025
- Yahoo
California looters now face 'hard-charging' consequences after blue state abandoned soft-on-crime approach
Amid the continuing unrest and flash mob-style looting incidents in Los Angeles, California is making a significant pivot toward tougher criminal enforcement. Criminal defense attorney David Wohl told Fox News Digital that the legal consequences are no longer a slap on the wrist for looters following the reversal of Proposition 47, which notably did not criminalize theft under $950. "Now we have a very conservative, hard-charging DA in Los Angeles," Wohl said. "He's adding up what is stolen by each individual co-defendant, and if that's over $950, everybody's getting charged with felonies." In a city once known for turning a blind eye to petty theft and soft prosecution, looters who are taking advantage of protests over federal immigration operations now face stricter penalties. California's Soros-backed Progressive Experiment Collapses After A Decade In 2014, California voters approved Proposition 47, a ballot initiative that reclassified several nonviolent felonies, including shoplifting, theft and drug possession, as misdemeanors if the value involved was $950 or less. Read On The Fox News App Supporters argued the measure would reduce prison overcrowding and redirect state funds to additional programming. Critics argued that it contributed to a noticeable increase in retail theft and emboldened looters. In 2024, voters voiced their concerns and overwhelmingly chose a sharp course correction from the progressive reforms that Proposition 47 implemented and voted in favor of Proposition 36. Prop 36 restored the ability to file felony charges against repeat offenders, regardless of whether their latest crime falls under the $950 limit. It also enhances penalties for group theft and organized looting, which had previously fallen into legal gray zones under Prop 47. The shift stems from a growing rejection of the previous criminal justice model championed by former District Attorney George Gascon, who Wohl described as "more liberal than a lot of public defenders." Under Gascon's leadership, prosecution was often delayed or diminished, with an emphasis on giving offenders "second, third, fourth, fifth chances," Wohl said. Los Angeles Officials Still On 'Progressive Warpath' Despite Overwhelming Voter Rebuke Of Leftist Policies William Jacobson, a law professor at Cornell University and founder of offered a sharp critique of California's criminal justice policies in light of the emergence of looters during the ongoing L.A. protests against immigration enforcement. "Looting and violence have always been illegal, even in California," Jacobson told Fox News Digital. "Unfortunately, California's lax enforcement of the criminal laws, including the former decriminalization of shoplifting, has created a culture of criminality that has played out in numerous riots over the years." "The current riots against immigration enforcement and violence targeting both ICE and the community are part of the California political ecosystem," he said. Several stores across downtown Los Angeles were hit by looters in the early morning hours as anti-ICE riots continued. On Monday night, looters took to the streets and ransacked a series of storefronts, the Los Angeles Police Department confirmed with Fox News Digital. Apple and Adidas were among the stores hit by thieves, as well as several mom-and-pop shops. "What have they done to my business? I don't know," one local business owner shared with Fox News affiliate KKTV. "I have to go inside and see what's going on. I don't know what they have done with the business." WATCH: One video, taken by Brendan Gutenschwager, captured looters ransacking an Apple storefront on Monday night. The video captured a slew of individuals dashing up to the technology storefront and grabbing goods before dispersing as police arrived. The footage captured the store's glass windows spray-painted with "F--- ICE." Other photos showed ransackers disappearing into the night with stolen goods after a smash-and-grab in Compton, a city south of Los Angeles. It was unclear if the thieves were participating in the ongoing anti-ICE protests or if they were being opportunistic of the city's unrest. "Let me be clear: ANYONE who vandalized Downtown or looted stores does not care about our immigrant communities," Mayor Karen Bass said in a post to X. "You will be held accountable." On Tuesday and Wednesday, after continued protests, other businesses set out to protect their stores. Fox News Digital saw a T-Mobile store on the corner of 3rd Street and Broadway boarding up ahead of likely another night of protests in the city. While a security guard protected the property, a repairer worked on the CVS store on the corner of 7th and Spring streets in downtown Los Angeles after several nights of rioting. Attorney General Pam Bondi offered a blunt message to would-be robbers and looters in the deep-blue city on "Fox & Friends" Tuesday. "If you loot a business in California during this, we're charging you with robbery under the Hobbs Act. No longer are the days of non-prosecution for looting. It's a criminal act," she said. The administration is also determined to crack down on those who inflict harm on law enforcement. "We've all made over 190 arrests, [and] more [are] coming. If you hit a police officer, you assault a police officer, state or federal, we are coming after you."Original article source: California looters now face 'hard-charging' consequences after blue state abandoned soft-on-crime approach
New York Post
12-06-2025
- New York Post
California looters now face ‘hard-charging' consequences after blue state abandoned soft-on-crime approach
Amid the continuing unrest and flash mob-style looting incidents in Los Angeles, California is making a significant pivot toward tougher criminal enforcement. Criminal defense attorney David Wohl told Fox News Digital that the legal consequences are no longer a slap on the wrist for looters following the reversal of Proposition 47, which notably did not criminalize theft under $950. Advertisement 'Now we have a very conservative, hard-charging DA in Los Angeles,' Wohl said. 'He's adding up what is stolen by each individual co-defendant, and if that's over $950, everybody's getting charged with felonies.' In a city once known for turning a blind eye to petty theft and soft prosecution, looters who are taking advantage of protests over federal immigration operations now face stricter penalties. In 2014, California voters approved Proposition 47, a ballot initiative that reclassified several nonviolent felonies, including shoplifting, theft and drug possession, as misdemeanors if the value involved was $950 or less. Supporters argued the measure would reduce prison overcrowding and redirect state funds to additional programming. Advertisement 8 Vulgar graffiti was spray-painted onto an Apple store after it was looted during the riots in Los Angeles on June 10, 2025. REUTERS 8 Protesters loot a gas station convenience store in Paramount, California on June 7, 2025. Getty Images Critics argued that it contributed to a noticeable increase in retail theft and emboldened looters. In 2024, voters voiced their concerns and overwhelmingly chose a sharp course correction from the progressive reforms that Proposition 47 implemented and voted in favor of Proposition 36. Advertisement Prop 36 restored the ability to file felony charges against repeat offenders, regardless of whether their latest crime falls under the $950 limit. It also enhances penalties for group theft and organized looting, which had previously fallen into legal gray zones under Prop 47. 8 Police officers detain a group of protesters in the streets of Los Angeles on June 11, 2025. AFP via Getty Images The shift stems from a growing rejection of the previous criminal justice model championed by former District Attorney George Gascon, who Wohl described as 'more liberal than a lot of public defenders.' Advertisement Under Gascon's leadership, prosecution was often delayed or diminished, with an emphasis on giving offenders 'second, third, fourth, fifth chances,' Wohl said. William Jacobson, a law professor at Cornell University and founder of offered a sharp critique of California's criminal justice policies in light of the emergence of looters during the ongoing L.A. protests against immigration enforcement. 8 Graffiti is sprayed onto the glass windows of an Apple store hit by looters during the Anti-ICE riots in California. REUTERS 8 Apple products are scattered around a store that was looted during the Los Angeles riots on June 9, 2025. REUTERS 'Looting and violence have always been illegal, even in California,' Jacobson told Fox News Digital. 'Unfortunately, California's lax enforcement of the criminal laws, including the former decriminalization of shoplifting, has created a culture of criminality that has played out in numerous riots over the years.' 'The current riots against immigration enforcement and violence targeting both ICE and the community are part of the California political ecosystem,' he said. Looters in LA Several stores across downtown Los Angeles were hit by looters in the early morning hours as anti-ICE riots continued. On Monday night, looters took to the streets and ransacked a series of storefronts, the Los Angeles Police Department confirmed with Fox News Digital. Apple and Adidas were among the stores hit by thieves, as well as several mom-and-pop shops. Advertisement 'What have they done to my business? I don't know,' one local business owner shared with Fox News affiliate KKTV. 'I have to go inside and see what's going on. I don't know what they have done with the business.' 8 A shoe sits on the floor in an empty Adidas store attacked by looters in Los Angeles. ALLISON DINNER/EPA-EFE/Shutterstock 8 Workers board up a CVS pharmacy after it was looted by rioters in Los Angeles on June 10, 2025. REUTERS One video, taken by Brendan Gutenschwager, captured looters ransacking an Apple storefront on Monday night. Advertisement The video captured a slew of individuals dashing up to the technology storefront and grabbing goods before dispersing as police arrived. The footage captured the store's glass windows spray-painted with 'F— ICE.' Other photos showed ransackers disappearing into the night with stolen goods after a smash-and-grab in Compton, a city south of Los Angeles. It was unclear if the thieves were participating in the ongoing anti-ICE protests or if they were being opportunistic of the city's unrest. Advertisement 'Let me be clear: ANYONE who vandalized Downtown or looted stores does not care about our immigrant communities,' Mayor Karen Bass said in a post to X. 'You will be held accountable.' On Tuesday and Wednesday, after continued protests, other businesses set out to protect their stores. Fox News Digital saw a T-Mobile store on the corner of 3rd Street and Broadway boarding up ahead of likely another night of protests in the city. While a security guard protected the property, a repairer worked on the CVS store on the corner of 7th and Spring streets in downtown Los Angeles after several nights of rioting. Attorney General Pam Bondi offered a blunt message to would-be robbers and looters in the deep-blue city on 'Fox & Friends' Tuesday. Advertisement 'If you loot a business in California during this, we're charging you with robbery under the Hobbs Act. No longer are the days of non-prosecution for looting. It's a criminal act,' she said. 8 Police officers detained masked protesters after a demonstration near Los Angeles City Hall on June 11, 2025. AFP via Getty Images The administration is also determined to crack down on those who inflict harm on law enforcement. 'We've all made over 190 arrests, [and] more [are] coming. If you hit a police officer, you assault a police officer, state or federal, we are coming after you.'
