logo
How did life survive 'Snowball Earth'? In ponds, study suggests

How did life survive 'Snowball Earth'? In ponds, study suggests

eNCA20-06-2025
Earth has not always been so hospitable to live. During several ice ages, the planet's surface was almost completely frozen over, creating what has been dubbed "Snowball Earth".
Liquid water appears to be the most important ingredient for life on any planet, raising the question: how did anything survive such frosty, brutal times?
A group of scientists said Thursday that they had found an astonishing diversity of micro-organisms in tiny pools of melted ice in Antarctica, suggesting that life could have ridden out Snowball Earth in similar ponds.
During the Cryogenian Period between 635 and 720 million years ago, the average global temperature did not rise above -50 degrees Celsius (-58 Fahrenheit). The climate near the equator at the time resembled modern-day Antarctica.
Yet even in such extreme conditions, life found a way to keep evolving.
Fatima Husain, the lead author of a new study published in Nature Communications, told AFP there was evidence of complex life forms "before and after the Cryogenian in the fossil record".
"There are multiple hypotheses regarding possible places life may have persisted," said Husain, a graduate student at the Massachusetts Institute of Technology.
Perhaps it found shelter in patches of open ocean, or in deep-sea hydrothermal vents, or under vast sheets of ice.
The tiny melted ice pools that dotted the equator were another proposed refuge.
These ponds could have been oases for eukaryotes, complex organisms that eventually evolved into multicellular life forms that would rise to dominate Earth, including humans.
- Could aliens be hiding in ponds? -
Melted ice ponds still exist today in Antarctica, at the edges of ice sheets.
In 2018, members of a New Zealand research team visited the McMurdo ice shelf in east Antarctica, home to several such pools, which are only a few metres wide and less a metre deep.
The bottom of the ponds are lined with a mat of microbes that have accumulated over the years to form slimy layers.
"These mats can be a few centimetres thick, colourful, and they can be very clearly layered," Husain said.
They are made up of single-celled organisms called cyanobacteria that are known to be able to survive extreme conditions.
But the researchers also found signs indicating there were eukaryotes such as algae or microscopic animals.
This suggests there was surprising diversity in the ponds, which appears to have been influenced by the amount of salt each contained.
"No two ponds were alike," Husain said. "We found diverse assemblages of eukaryotes from all the major groups in all the ponds studied."
"They demonstrate that these unique environments are capable of sheltering diverse assemblages of life, even in close proximity," she added.
This could have implications in the search for extraterrestrial life.
"Studies of life within these special environments on Earth can help inform our understanding of potential habitable environments on icy worlds, including icy moons in our Solar System," Husain said.
Saturn's moon Enceladus and Jupiter's Europa are covered in ice, but scientists increasingly suspect they could be home to simple forms of life, and several space missions have been launched to find out more about them.
By Bénédicte Rey
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

Durban teen Tristan Maistry joins prestigious 2025 Summit STEM Fellowship
Durban teen Tristan Maistry joins prestigious 2025 Summit STEM Fellowship

IOL News

time2 days ago

  • IOL News

Durban teen Tristan Maistry joins prestigious 2025 Summit STEM Fellowship

The fellowship connects ambitious young learners with top mentors from Harvard University, Stanford University, Massachusetts Institute of Technology and Princeton University to empower the next generation of leaders in STEM (science, technology, engineering, and math). Maistry joined the programme from June 22. It runs until July 12 and provides an in-depth, sustained learning journey that includes workshops, mentorship sessions, and project work. Out of over 3 000 applicants from 90 countries, Maistry's passion, innovation, and dedication secured him a place among the world's future changemakers. Tristan Maistry, a Grade 10 pupil at Curro Embury, was selected to participate in the 2025 Summit STEM Fellowship Programme. A Durban teenager has been selected for a prestigious international fellowship that empowers the next generation of leaders in science, technology, engineering and maths. Maistry, 15, from Morningside, said he was honoured to have been selected through a stringent process. "Knowing that I am part of a small, passionate group of learners who share a love for STEM is very inspiring. It motivates me to make the most of this opportunity and to contribute meaningfully to the programme," he said. Maistry said from a young age he had an aptitude for maths. He said he applied to be part of the Summit STEM Fellowship because it offers an exciting opportunity to develop STEM skills beyond the classroom, engage in hands-on projects, and learn from industry leaders. "I was eager to challenge myself and grow through this experience. It also helps me to build a strong professional network. I have access to mentors and experts who I can reach out to for guidance and to discuss future STEM developments that I'm passionate about," he said. He said the fellowship covers a wide range of topics, including coding, engineering, data science, and innovation principles. Maistry added that it also focuses on leadership development, problem-solving, and preparing learners for future STEM careers through mentorship and exposure to real-world challenges. "It has been an incredible experience so far. I've particularly enjoyed the collaborative projects and the exposure to new technologies and problem-solving techniques. "One of the most interesting things I've learned is how to approach complex problems by breaking them down into manageable steps, which is a skill that will benefit me in any career," he said. Maistry said they have engaged in science trivias and on weekends have been able to chat to different mentors about anything that they are concerned about and want to know. "It is interesting to hear how people in different fields got to where they are and the challenges they faced. "It is about how you use the information taught and the skills learned to make a difference in your work and get involved in your community," said Maistry. He is considering studying actuarial science, engineering, mathematics or to become a chartered accountant, after matric "I am passionate about technology and innovation. This programme has strengthened my interest in these fields," he said.

'Writing is thinking': Do students who use ChatGPT learn less?
'Writing is thinking': Do students who use ChatGPT learn less?

IOL News

time3 days ago

  • IOL News

'Writing is thinking': Do students who use ChatGPT learn less?

IOL A new study suggests students using ChatGPT to write essays show reduced critical thinking and brain activity. Educators report AI-generated work lacks insight, raising concerns about overreliance on tools that may hinder learning. Picture: Beyzaa Yurtkuran/Pexels When Jocelyn Leitzinger had her university students write about times in their lives they had witnessed discrimination, she noticed that a woman named Sally was the victim in many of the stories. "It was very clear that ChatGPT had decided this is a common woman's name," said Leitzinger, who teaches an undergraduate class on business and society at the University of Illinois in Chicago. "They weren't even coming up with their own anecdotal stories about their own lives," she told AFP. Leitzinger estimated that around half of her 180 students used ChatGPT inappropriately at some point last semester -- including when writing about the ethics of artificial intelligence (AI), which she called both "ironic" and "mind-boggling". So she was not surprised by recent research, which suggested that students who use ChatGPT to write essays engage in less critical thinking. The preprint study, which has not been peer-reviewed, was shared widely online and clearly struck a chord with some frustrated educators. The team of MIT researchers behind the paper has received more than 3,000 emails from teachers of all stripes since it was published online last month, lead author Nataliya Kosmyna told AFP. 'Soulless' AI essays For the small study, 54 adult students from the greater Boston area were split into three groups. One group used ChatGPT to write 20-minute essays, one used a search engine, and the final group had to make do with only their brains. The researchers used EEG devices to measure the brain activity of the students, and two teachers marked the essays. The ChatGPT users scored significantly worse than the brain-only group on all levels. The EEG showed that different areas of their brains connected to each other less often. And more than 80 percent of the ChatGPT group could not quote anything from the essay they had just written, compared to around 10 percent of the other two groups. By the third session, the ChatGPT group appeared to be mostly focused on copying and pasting. The teachers said they could easily spot the "soulless" ChatGPT essays because they had good grammar and structure but lacked creativity, personality, and insight. However, Kosmyna pushed back against media reports claiming the paper showed that using ChatGPT made people lazier or more stupid. She pointed to the fourth session, when the brain-only group used ChatGPT to write their essay and displayed even higher levels of neural connectivity. Kosmyna emphasised it was too early to draw conclusions from the study's small sample size, but called for more research into how AI tools could be used more carefully to help learning. Ashley Juavinett, a neuroscientist at the University of California, San Diego, who was not involved in the research, criticised some "off-base" headlines that wrongly extrapolated from the preprint. "This paper does not contain enough evidence or the methodological rigour to make any claims about the neural impact of using LLMs (large language models such as ChatGPT) on our brains," she told AFP. Thinking outside the box Leitzinger said the research reflected how she had seen student essays change since ChatGPT was released in 2022, as both spelling errors and authentic insight became less common. Sometimes students do not even change the font when they copy and paste from ChatGPT, she said. But Leitzinger called for empathy for students, saying they can get confused when the use of AI is being encouraged by universities in some classes but is banned in others. The usefulness of new AI tools is sometimes compared to the introduction of calculators, which required educators to change their ways. But Leitzinger worried that students do not need to know anything about a subject before pasting their essay question into ChatGPT, skipping several important steps in the process of learning. A student at a British university in his early 20s who wanted to remain anonymous told AFP he found ChatGPT was a useful tool for compiling lecture notes, searching the internet, and generating ideas. "I think that using ChatGPT to write your work for you is not right because it's not what you're supposed to be at university for," he said. The problem goes beyond high school and university students. Academic journals are struggling to cope with a massive influx of AI-generated scientific papers. Book publishing is also not immune, with one startup planning to pump out 8,000 AI-written books a year. "Writing is thinking, thinking is writing, and when we eliminate that process, what does that mean for thinking?" Leitzinger asked. AFP

Meet the geologist uncovering Earth's secrets in South Africa
Meet the geologist uncovering Earth's secrets in South Africa

IOL News

time3 days ago

  • IOL News

Meet the geologist uncovering Earth's secrets in South Africa

Tebogo Makhubela, a South African geologist recipient of one of the prestigious National Geographic 2025 Wayfinder Awards Image: MARCO LONGARI / AFP In the 1997 action film "Dante's Peak", Pierce Brosnan plays the role of a volcanologist sent to investigate seismic activity beneath a long-dormant volcano. Years after its release, the story inspired South African Tebogo Makhubela to become a geologist, the 35-year-old told AFP in an interview. Recipient of one of the prestigious National Geographic 2025 Wayfinder Awards, Makhubela leads a research team working to uncover ancient clues to human evolution. His turf lies below the surface of the Earth in the limestone caves of South Africa's Cradle of Humankind, a UNESCO World Heritage Site about 50 kilometres (30 miles) northwest of Johannesburg. Speaking from inside The Rising Star cave, one of the numerous caves in the area, Makhubela said he and his colleagues have only "scratched the surface" of the site, which dates back five million years. In an unassuming savannah field, hidden under a rocky patch of grass, the cave is where scientists in 2013 discovered Homo naledi, an ancient human relative that lived about 300,000 years ago. "With this cave we've only studied 30 percent... To do the remaining 70 percent, we need, I would say, 20 years minimum," said Makhubela, wearing a dark green overall and a helmet fixed with a torchlight. And with many other caves to study, Makhubela's research isn't close to an end. "I will actually retire before we finish. Hence, I need to train a lot of students to, of course, take over from me." Chasing dreams Makhubela, who lectures at the University of Johannesburg and supervises four PhD students, hopes more young scientists will join him on his mission -- one he believes is crucial to understanding the history of humankind and its environment. "Geology helps us understand Earth, our planet, how it works, how it was formed, its composition and its processes," he said, sitting on a rock next to his yellow backpack filled with notebooks, pens, measuring instruments and water. His own speciality is geochemistry and geochronology, or more simply, determining the age of fossils and environmental changes over time. One hurdle, he said, is that geology is not well known and some young people would rather "chase what is popular". "Right now we're living in the age of artificial intelligence. (But) you don't have to run and go study computer science or IT because you want to be relevant to the times," said the geologist. "If you're more passionate about natural science, go for it. Because if you do it well, there will be a place for you." First at university Born and raised in Soweto, the sprawling township once home to Nelson Mandela, Makhubela was the first in his family to go to university. His mother never went to school and worked as a street vendor while his father moved away when he was 10, he said. As a bright young student, he was pressured to study engineering and work in South Africa's lucrative gold mining industry. But he decided on another path.

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store