Family Disputes Official Account of Nevada Inmate's Death, Alleging Excessive Force and a Cover-Up
A lawsuit filed this week in Clark County District Court says Patrick Odale wasn't acting erratically and growling at officers as the coroner's report states, but was suffering from an asthma attack when he approached prison guards in December 2023 at Southern Desert Correctional Center, a mostly medium-security facility near Las Vegas. Instead of helping Odale, the lawsuit alleges officers pepper-sprayed and beat him and restrained him with his face to the ground. The 39-year-old was pronounced dead soon after.
The lawsuit alleges the Nevada Department of Corrections and its director, the prison warden, correctional officers, and other prison staff engaged in a broad conspiracy that it says sought to cover up the extent of Odale's injuries and the officers' use of force. 'Patrick endured a prolonged and painful death,' the lawsuit says. It also names the medical examiner who performed Odale's autopsy and authored the coroner's report, saying the report downplayed Odale's injuries while overstating the role that drugs found in his system played in his death, which was ruled a homicide by the Clark County coroner's office. The county said it doesn't comment on pending litigation. The Associated Press sent emailed requests for comment Wednesday to the state Department of Corrections and its director, James Dzurenda.
The coroner's report, which was finalized in August 2024, said Odale died of 'positional and mechanical asphyxia in the setting of law enforcement restraint.' But it also said he had low levels of methamphetamine and an animal sedative in his system and that the drugs were a major contributor in his death.
The lawsuit raises questions about the medical examiner's decision to list the drugs as contributing to his death but not Odale's other injuries. Autopsy photos included in the lawsuit show purple bruises across Odale's shoulders and upper back, as well as on his wrists, arms, and lips. The coroner's report describes the injuries as 'minor blunt force trauma,' while the lawsuit says they were critical injuries.
Odale, a father of two, was sentenced in early 2023 to up to two years in prison for possessing a stolen credit card and attempting to carry a concealed weapon, court records show. He died weeks before he was set to be released from custody.
'We were counting down the days. Instead of welcoming him home, we mourned his death and had no chance to say goodbye,' his 15-year-old daughter said in a statement provided by Return Strong, a group advocating for people who are incarcerated.
According to the coroner's report, officers said Odale was erratic and growling at them on the night of his death, leading them to pepper-spray him and put him in a storage room with yard tools for several minutes until he began thrashing the room. Then officers pulled him to the ground, restrained him, and took him to the prison infirmary, the report says.
But the lawsuit claims that other inmates who witnessed the incident reported hearing Odale begging for medical staff and saying he couldn't breathe. The inmates, according to the lawsuit, also reported seeing guards smash Odale's head into a steel door frame after pulling him out of the storage room.
Some of the altercation was captured on security video, the coroner's report shows, but it also indicates that there may be a gap in the footage. The footage, as described by the autopsy report, shows Odale groaning as he is taken to the infirmary. He is face-down with his hands shackled behind his back. Then the autopsy says, after a gap, video coverage resumes showing prison staff performing CPR on an unresponsive Odale. 'When the video resumes, the inmate is face-up with hands shackled anteriorly,' the medical examiner wrote, meaning that his hands were no longer shackled behind him but were in front of his body.
The state Department of Corrections has not released any of the video to Odale's family or the law firm representing them, said James Urrutia, their lawyer. Urrutia is also representing the family of another inmate, Christian Walker, who died after he was beaten by guards at High Desert State Prison near Las Vegas. Their ongoing lawsuit disputes the coroner's report in that case and accuses prison staff of trying to cover up the death. Walker's face was swollen and smeared with blood when he died in custody in April 2023, according to an unredacted copy of his autopsy obtained by the AP. He also suffered head trauma and other injuries to his torso, neck, and extremities. The medical examiner in Walker's case concluded it was a natural death caused by heart problems.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Al Arabiya
3 hours ago
- Al Arabiya
One dead, six wounded in Indianapolis shooting
One person was killed and six others wounded in a shooting in the US city of Indianapolis early Saturday, police said, a day after the country celebrated its independence day. The shooting occurred around 1:27 am (0527 GMT) as officers were investigating disturbances, deputy police operations chief Tanya Terry told a news conference. One was pronounced dead at the scene. Five wounded people were taken from the scene to hospital for treatment, while a sixth walked into a medical facility in a stable condition. Three of the victims were juveniles, including the person who died, Terry said, without providing the ages and conditions of the other victims. Police recovered several firearms at the scene and detained around seven people for questioning. Indianapolis police chief Chris Bailey condemned recurring violence in the city's downtown area, particularly involving young people. 'A kid is dead tonight,' Bailey told reporters. 'It's unacceptable.' The police chief said officers made about 20 arrests throughout the night and recovered guns from minors, including 'an assault rifle stuffed in the front of his pants.' Bailey criticized parents for allowing 'hundreds of unsupervised kids' to roam the downtown area at night. 'We are not your children's keeper. You are,' he said. 'Parents and guardians have got to step up.' The chief said thousands of people had come downtown for fireworks and left peacefully, but others stayed and 'caused trouble.' The shooting marked the second weekend of violence in downtown Indianapolis, according to the police chief. Serious gun violence is common across the United States, where many states have few barriers to the purchasing of firearms, despite widespread support for greater gun control. There have been 189 mass shootings in the United States this year, according to the Gun Violence Archive -- which it defines as four or more people shot.
Al Arabiya
16 hours ago
- Al Arabiya
Human Remains Located After California Fireworks Warehouse Explosion
Investigators have located human remains following an explosion at a Northern California fireworks warehouse, Yolo County said in a statement Friday. Seven were missing after the Tuesday fireworks explosion near Esparto, which gripped the small farming community. It sparked a massive fire that led to other spot fires. Nearby Fourth of July celebrations were called off. The county confirmed that its Coroner's Division was allowed access to the site of the fire incident, and the Coroner's Office has been in contact with the families of those who had been reported missing. 'No positive identifications have been made, and recovery efforts are still underway,' the county said in the statement. Two people were treated for injuries, according to officials. Authorities are still investigating the cause of the blast. The warehouse was managed by Devastating Pyrotechnics, which has more than three decades of experience designing and producing fireworks shows in the Bay Area, according to a screenshot of its website before it was taken down. The company, with headquarters in both San Francisco and Esparto, focuses mainly on display fireworks for big productions instead of those for retail. The company said in a statement it would cooperate fully with officials in their investigation. Further south in the state, authorities said that one man was found dead on the scene after a fireworks-related blaze ripped through four homes in a Los Angeles neighborhood Thursday night. A woman was taken to the hospital in critical condition, four others were given treatment for smoke inhalation on the scene, and several animals were injured, the Los Angeles Fire Department said in a statement. Fireworks were still erupting in the area when firefighters arrived at the blaze, which they brought under control later that night, according to the Los Angeles Fire Department. 'The cause of the fire is still being investigated,' department spokesperson Lyndsey Lantz said.
Asharq Al-Awsat
a day ago
- Asharq Al-Awsat
Justice at Stake as Generative AI Enters the Courtroom
Generative artificial intelligence (GenAI) is making its way into courts despite early stumbles, raising questions about how it will influence the legal system and justice itself. Judges use the technology for research, lawyers utilize it for appeals and parties involved in cases have relied on GenAI to help express themselves in court. "It's probably used more than people expect," said Daniel Linna, a professor at the Northwestern Pritzker School of Law, about GenAI in the US legal system. "Judges don't necessarily raise their hand and talk about this to a whole room of judges, but I have people who come to me afterward and say they are experimenting with it'. In one prominent instance, GenAI enabled murder victim Chris Pelkey to address an Arizona courtroom -- in the form of a video avatar -- at the sentencing of the man convicted of shooting him dead in 2021 during a clash between motorists. "I believe in forgiveness," said a digital proxy of Pelkey created by his sister, Stacey Wales. The judge voiced appreciation for the avatar, saying it seemed authentic. "I knew it would be powerful," Wales told , "that that it would humanize Chris in the eyes of the judge." The AI testimony, a first of its kind, ended the sentencing hearing at which Wales and other members of the slain man's family spoke about the impact of the loss. Since the hearing, examples of GenAI being used in US legal cases have multiplied. "It is a helpful tool and it is time-saving, as long as the accuracy is confirmed," said attorney Stephen Schwartz, who practices in the northeastern state of Maine. "Overall, it's a positive development in jurisprudence." Schwartz described using ChatGPT as well as GenAI legal assistants, such as LexisNexis Protege and CoCounsel from Thomson Reuters, for researching case law and other tasks. "You can't completely rely on it," Schwartz cautioned, recommending that cases proffered by GenAI be read to ensure accuracy. "We are all aware of a horror story where AI comes up with mixed-up case things." The technology has been the culprit behind false legal citations, far-fetched case precedents, and flat-out fabrications. In early May, a federal judge in Los Angeles imposed $31,100 in fines and damages on two law firms for an error-riddled petition drafted with the help of GenAI, blasting it as a "collective debacle." The tech is also being relied on by some who skip lawyers and represent themselves in court, often causing legal errors. And as GenAI makes it easier and cheaper to draft legal complaints, courts already overburdened by caseloads could see them climb higher, said Shay Cleary of the National Center for State Courts. "Courts need to be prepared to handle that," Cleary said. Transformation Law professor Linna sees the potential for GenAI to be part of the solution though, giving more people the ability to seek justice in courts made more efficient. "We have a huge number of people who don't have access to legal services," Linna said. "These tools can be transformative; of course we need to be thoughtful about how we integrate them." Federal judges in the US capitol have written decisions noting their use of ChatGPT in laying out their opinions. "Judges need to be technologically up-to-date and trained in AI," Linna said. GenAI assistants already have the potential to influence the outcome of cases the same way a human law clerk might, reasoned the professor. Facts or case law pointed out by GenAI might sway a judge's decision, and could be different than what a legal clerk would have come up with. But if GenAI lives up to its potential and excels at finding the best information for judges to consider, that could make for well-grounded rulings less likely to be overturned on appeal, according to Linna.
