
Pakistan's public debt spiral
Listen to article
Those who look carefully at Pakistan's 2025-26 budget will not fail to notice a startling detail: the total expenditure on debt servicing and foreign loan repayments amounts to a little less than half – 43% to be precise – of all government expenditure. This is by far the largest single line item in the budget.
Compare this to other major expenditures: federal government expenses are 12%, development expenditure is 6%, and defence and services are 8%. Other vitally important sectors such as education, health care, and social services barely make it out of the low single digits.
Further, the budget plans to take on new debt of Rs11 trillion. This will be added to the already crippling level of existing debt, which stands at Rs76 trillion. So by the time 2026 comes around, Pakistan's total debt would have reached Rs87 trillion.
At current exchange rates, this is approximately $300 billion. Compare this to a GDP of $400 billion, and you get a debt-to-GDP ratio of 75%. This is well above Pakistan's own legal threshold set by the Fiscal Responsibility and Debt Limitation Act of 2005, which limits this ratio to 60%.
So Pakistan's total debt, already over the legal limit, is set to increase even more. This will naturally lead to an inexorable increase in debt servicing costs, which, other things being equal, will squeeze even further the already paltry amounts available for other critical sectors such as health, education, social support, and infrastructure.
All this is worrying by itself. But what is of even greater concern is that there seems to be no appreciation by the government of the danger posed by ever-increasing debt – and no attempt to even outline an escape route from this downward path to inevitable insolvency.
It is clear that, should this addiction to ever-increasing debt continue unabated, the time will come when almost all of the government's revenues will go to debt servicing. Eventually, the sovereign country of Pakistan and its 250 million people will toil not for their own improvement but for the exclusive benefit of their lenders. To be sure, there are ways out of this debt sinkhole. But these require competent leadership at the political level, which unfortunately does not exist – not outside, nor inside Adiala jail. So, a solution will have to wait until such leadership comes into existence.
Pakistan's situation, while serious, is not unique. Many other developing countries are stuck in the same predicament: they have too much debt, much of their income is spent on paying interest on this debt, and not much is left over for the truly important aspects of development. Fortunately, as a consequence of the global nature of the problem, there are international efforts to address this issue.
One of these was initiated – perhaps surprisingly – by the late Pope Francis. The Pontiff was disturbed that poor countries and their people were drowning in a whirlpool of debt from which it seemed there was no escape. He was keen that the problem be addressed by some of the best minds in economics.
To this end, he instructed the Pontifical Academy of Social Sciences to engage the services of the Initiative for Policy Dialogue at Columbia University to prepare a report on the issue, outlining how this global problem could be addressed.
The report, with the somewhat unwieldy title of "A Blueprint for Tackling the Debt and Development Crises and Creating the Financial Foundations for a Sustainable People-Centred Global Economy", was released last week. Its lead author is the Nobel Prize-winning economist Joseph Stiglitz, who is professor of economics at Columbia University.
The report begins with the following sentence: "The developing world is facing dramatic debt and development crises. A debt crisis should not be narrowly defined as a matter of countries defaulting on their obligations to creditors. For many nations, the real default is not a legal or financial one, but a social and development one: They are defaulting on their people, their environment, and their future."
It goes on to say: "To meet obligations to their external creditors, debt-distressed countries are sacrificing investments in education, healthcare, infrastructure, and climate resilience. Core aspects of national sovereignty are put into question as economic policy serves creditors rather than citizens. National politics is delegitimised if fiscal and financial policies are in the service of finance rather than in the service of development."
The 30-page document makes for compelling reading. It assesses the scale and nature of the problem and goes on to analyse the issues from multiple perspectives. These include, for example, structural flaws in the financial system, principles for debt resolution, reforming global governance, and rethinking sovereign debt markets.
It critiques the International Monetary Fund (IMF)'s lending and surcharge policies and calls for the elimination of the Fund's regressive surcharges. It recommends setting up an international bankruptcy court for sovereign debt, or at minimum, a robust mediation mechanism.
Finally, it proposes some urgent actions and concludes that debt crises are not simply technical problems — they are moral and political crises that reflect power imbalances and structural injustices. To end the cycle of debt dependency and underdevelopment, the world must create new financial rules grounded in equity, justice, and sustainability.
There is usually a long and difficult road from a policy document such as this to the goals it seeks to achieve. This report is a valiant and necessary first step to tackle a critical problem that besets many developing countries.
It is important because it holds out the promise that, if the global financial community can get together and set narrow self-interests aside, there is hope to improve the well-being of billions of people whose lives are benighted by a cyclone of ever-increasing debt.
The writer is a Chairman of Mustaqbil Pakistan and holds an MBA from Harvard Business School
Hashtags

Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles


Express Tribune
18-07-2025
- Express Tribune
Passenger train fares jacked up by 2%
The Pakistan Railways has made a 2% increase in the fares of passenger trains in view of a hike in the price of High Speed Diesel (HSD). This increase in fares will take effect from today, July 18. An undated office memorandum seen by The Express Tribune directed the director IT to ensure the announcement of the new fares on the PR website. The railways has also increased the rate of its freight trains transporting coal by 3% and the trains transporting rock phosphates and fertilizers by 2%. These hikes will apply from July 21. The government on Tuesday raised the prices of petroleum products by up to Rs11 per litre for the second half of July in a regressive step that is likely to exacerbate the economic hardships of people. According to a notification issued by the Finance Division on July 15, petrol price went up by Rs5.36 - from Rs266.79 to Rs272.15 per litre, while the price of the HSD rose by Rs11.37 per litre - from Rs272.98 to Rs284.35 for the July 16-31 period. This hike in the HSD price increased the cost of the PR operation by Rs4 million [39,86,500] per day and around R199 million [119,500,000] per month. On an average, the PR consumes around 350,000 litres of HSD on a daily basis.


Express Tribune
16-07-2025
- Express Tribune
Commuters suffer as transporters hike fares
In the wake of a sustained and steep rise in petrol and diesel prices, transport operators across all routes in the twin cities of Rawalpindi and Islamabad implemented significant fare hikes on Wednesday. The increases has affected all modes of transportation in Rawalpindi and Islamabad, including local, intercity, and long-distance travel. A recent Rs11 per litre spike in diesel prices has also inflated the cost of transporting essential food supplies, raising concerns over an impending wave of inflation. Public transport fares have risen by Rs5 to Rs15 per passenger, sparking widespread frustration among commuters. Local rickshaws, taxis, and Qingqi rickshaws have followed suit, increasing per-passenger fares. Motorcycle ride-hailing services such as Bykea have raised their minimum fare to Rs100. Meanwhile, minibuses, wagons, and coasters have begun charging passengers additional fees for carrying luggage. Pakistan Railways has also announced plans to revise its fare structure. In parallel, goods transporters have collectively agreed on a 10% increase in freight charges for both intercity and long-route deliveries. Muhammad Faisal, the vice-president of the Goods Transport Union, explains that transporters refrained from raising fares following the previous fuel price hike on July 1. However, the latest diesel price increase — pushing rates to an all-time high of Rs. 284 per liter — has left them with no viable alternative but to adjust fares. Asif Khan, the vice-president of the Transport Federation, criticised the government's continued price hikes over the past six weeks. He noted that in the open market, the prices of tires, spare parts, and mechanical services have soared by 500% to 800%. Additionally, he highlighted rising traffic fines and penalties, all of which have pushed the transport sector to the verge of collapse. The impact of fare hikes is already visible, with a sharp decline in passenger numbers. "Where families once traveled together for weddings and funerals, now only one or two members make the journey due to rising costs," Khan said. He warned that if fuel prices, spare parts, motorway tolls, and vehicle costs continue to escalate, many small transport businesses will shut down, leading to increased unemployment. Faizan Ali, a Bykea motorcycle operator, echoed these concerns. "Our regular riders were those paying Rs50 to Rs100. With fares nearly doubling, many can no longer afford the service. Now, two passengers often share a single ride to split the cost." He further noted the disparity between international and domestic trends: "Global fuel prices are falling, yet locally, we continue to raise them." Citizens have criticised the government's decision, pointing out that global oil prices have dropped to a historic low of $65 per barrel, yet Pakistan has increased domestic prices. They termed it a cruel move and demanded immediate price reductions. Citizens noted that during the PTI government, global oil prices were around $120 per barrel while petrol in Pakistan was priced between Rs150-155 per litre.


Express Tribune
16-07-2025
- Express Tribune
Fuel prices hit new peaks, sending consumers reeling
Listen to article The government on Tuesday hiked the prices of petroleum products by up to Rs11 per litre for the second half of July 2025 in a regressive step that would exacerbate the economic hardships faced by the common man. This is the second consecutive increase in the prices of petrol and diesel since the start of the new fiscal year on July 1. On June 30, the government had increased the fuel prices by up to Rs10 for the first fortnight of the current month that ended on Tuesday. Separately, the Oil and Gas Regulatory Authority (Ogra) announced a reduction in the prices of re-gasified liquefied natural gas (RLNG) for the current month, while the rate of kerosene oil and the light diesel oil also came down slightly. According to a notification issued by the Finance Division, petrol price went up by Rs5.36 — from Rs266.79 to Rs272.15 per litre, while the high-speed diesel (HSD) rose by Rs11.37 per litre — from Rs272.98 to Rs284.35 for the July 16-31 period. This latest adjustment in the petrol and HSD prices reflects persistent volatility in the global oil markets. It also shows the government's fiscal constraints in meeting its ambitious revenue targets as it is already charging highest rate of petroleum levy (PL) on the petroleum products to collect revenue. The government said that it had taken the latest decision on the recommendations of Ogra and the relevant ministries. "The Government has decided to revise the prices of petroleum products for the fortnight starting July 16, based on the recommendations of OGRA & the relevant ministries," it said. Ogra had recommended the increase in the prices of petroleum products based on Rs78.02 per litre PL on petrol and Rs77.01 on HSD. It had also assumed Inland Freight Equalisation Margin (IFEM) at Rs8.89 per litre on petrol and Rs6.04 on HSD. The exchange rate adjustment was calculated at Rs3 per litre on petrol and Rs2 on HSD. Diesel is widely used in agriculture and freight transport, and any price increase directly impacts the cost of goods and services. Petrol, meanwhile, fuels motorcycles and cars, and serves as an alternative to compressed natural gas (CNG), especially in Punjab, where CNG stations rely on imported LNG. The fresh price hike is expected to further widen the gap between stagnant household incomes and the rising cost of living. Analysts have warned that without the fiscal space or targeted subsidies, the brunt of global oil volatility will continue to be passed on to the end users. The government had the space to rescue the consumers from the current hike in oil prices by slashing the rate of PL, but it did not compromise on revenue collection and, hence, passed on the full impact of the increase in oil prices in the global market to the consumers. On July 1, the federal government has increased petrol and HSD prices significantly, attributing the hike to global market volatility amid the Iran-Israel war. Petrol was increased by Rs8.36 to Rs266.79 per litre, and HSD by Rs10.39 to Rs272.98, based on Ogra's recommendation. Pakistan imports petroleum products to meet around 85% of its local consumption, whereas 15% needs are met through locally-produced crude oil. At present, consumers are already paying over Rs77 per litre in PL. The current year's budget also includes a new carbon levy, further pushing the fuel prices. Meanwhile, in the deregulated market, kerosene oil becomes cheaper by Rs3.10 and the price of the LDO came down by Rs1.85, while Ogra, through a notification, announced a reduction in the RLNG prices for the current month on the back of slight decrease in the delivered ex-ship (DES) price. According to the Ogra notification, the RLNG prices for the Sui Northern Gas Pipelines Limited (SNGPL) and the Sui Southern Gas Company (SSGC) had undergone changes in both transmission and distribution segments. For the SNGPL, the new transmission price has been set at $10.8338 per million British thermal units (mmBtu), down from $11.0154, reflecting decrease of $0.1816, or 1.65%. The distribution price has been revised to $11.5787 per mmBtu from $11.7816, marking decrease of $0.2029, or 1.72%. Similarly, the SSGC's transmission price has been decreased from $9.7284 per mmBtu in June to $9.4713 in July, a decline of 2.64%. However, the distribution price has also gone down from $10.8650 per mmBtu to $10.5737, a reduction of $0.2913, or 2.68%.