Erin Patterson jury begins deliberations as mushroom lunch trial enters 10th week
The jury has started deliberations in the triple murder trial of Erin Patterson at the Latrobe Valley law courts in Morwell.
Justice Christopher Beale completed his charge or directions to the jury on Monday.
Patterson, 50, faces three charges of murder and one charge of attempted murder relating to poisoning four in-laws with beef wellington served for lunch at her house in Leongatha on 29 July 2023.
Patterson has pleaded not guilty to murdering her estranged husband Simon Patterson's parents, Don and Gail Patterson, his aunt Heather Wilkinson, and attempting to murder Ian Wilkinson, Simon's uncle and Heather's husband.
The jury of 12 will have to reach a unanimous verdict on each charge. Two other jury members were balloted off shortly before deliberations started.
Jurors have been told they will be sequestered during their deliberations, meaning they will return to supervised accommodation each night to ensure they have no contact with the outside world.
It is the 10th week of a supreme court trial that had been expected to be completed in five to six weeks.
Beale started his charge on Tuesday, saying he expected it would take two days. His charge had three parts: directions regarding the principles of law that apply to the case; the evidence in the case and details about the requirement for the verdicts to be unanimous; and the procedure that would be followed to reach these verdicts.
He also told the jury to put aside any sympathy they may feel for Patterson's lunch guests and continue to ignore the unprecedented media attention surrounding the case.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
BBC News
32 minutes ago
- BBC News
Coventry charity's 'heartbroken' tribute to Reanne Coulson
A charity has paid tribute to Reanne Coulson after police searching for the missing woman found a body and charged a man with her body was discovered in Binley Woods, on the outskirts of Coventry, on Friday afternoon. Formal identification has yet to take place but police said they believed the body to be that of Ms Coulson, who had been missing for a a short tribute on Facebook, Haven Women's Aid said: "We are deeply sorry and heartbroken to hear this devastating news. Our thoughts and condolences are with Reanne Coulson's loved ones, and with all who are affected by this unbearable loss." On Thursday, before the body was found, the charity urged people to "never become desensitised" to male violence against women and girls."We must keep saying their names and we must never stop fighting to end violence against women and girls."Mohammed Durnion, 42, appeared at Coventry Magistrates' Court on Saturday charged with 34-year-old Ms Coulson's man, Adam Moore, 38, was charged with assisting an men were remanded in custody with Mr Durnion due to appear at Warwick Crown Court on 1 July and Mr Moore at the same court on 24 Coulson's family had made appeals for help in the older brother Ashley thanked the public for their help and asked for the family to be left alone to grieve. Follow BBC Coventry & Warwickshire on BBC Sounds, Facebook, X and Instagram.
The Independent
42 minutes ago
- The Independent
Three villagers arrested after mass poisoning of family of tigers in India
Indian forest authorities have arrested three people over the poisoning of five tigers in southern India 's Karnataka, an incident that makes up the highest death toll for big cats in one day in the state. Five tigers were found dead inside a wildlife sanctuary in southern India's Male Mahadeshwara Hills Wildlife Sanctuary. With the bodies of the tigers – a mother and her four cubs – all found close to each other in the wildlife sanctuary in Chamarajanagar district on Thursday. Wildlife officials say they also discovered a dead cow nearby, and that a subsequent investigation has revealed that villagers in the nearby Koppa village laced the cow's carcass with a locally available fertiliser in order to poison the tiger and her cubs. Three villagers, identified by officials as Konappa, Madaraja and Nagaraj, from Koppa village have been arrested over their alleged direct involvement in poisoning the tigers. The case is an example of a 'retaliatory killing' by villagers who killed the tigers for hunting their cattle, said Kumar Pushkar, the additional principal chief conservator of forests (administration and coordination), according to The Hindu. Forest authorities have arrested the three men under the sections of the Wildlife Protection Act 1972 and Indian Forest Act 1969, and the three accused have been produced before a magistrate. Joseph Hoover, a former member of the State Board for Wildlife and an activist in Karnataka, said the methodology in this case appeared to be a textbook example of a targeted wildlife poisoning. Tigers are most often the targets, he told The Independent, although other large animals such as leopards and elephants have been known to be killed in this way too. Villagers in such cases typically deploy a poisoned cow or goat carcass to target tigers for preying on their livestock, or even posing a threat to the farmers and villagers themselves. 'These five tigers were poisoned and killed barely 871 metres away from the anti-poaching camp and main road. It manifests the degree of negligence from the forest officials,' he said. The Independent has reached out to the MM Hills deputy conservator of forests, Chakrapani Y, for comment on the incident. During the investigation, the cattle owner was found to be in the possession of the same pesticide – typically used in marigold cultivation – that was used to kill the tigers, reported Indian daily The Hindu. Officials have sent samples collected by the forest veterinarians to forensic laboratories in Bengaluru and Mysuru for an independent verification of the kind of poison used, the report added. Another set of samples has been sent to a zoo in Mysuru for further analysis. 'Killing tigers by poisoning the carcass of their kill is increasingly the biggest reason behind the unnatural deaths of tigers in Karnataka. It is followed by setting up snares, used to capture deer and wild boar but in the bargain, even leopards and tigers are captured and killed,' Mr Joseph told The Independent. Pesticides used in farming are available cheaply, he said, and typically results in the immediate death of the tigers that consume it. There are also cases of villagers killing tigers by shooting them, he added, as was seen in Shivamogga in Karnataka in February this year where a postmortem of a dead tiger revealed a pellet lodged in its neck. Such incidents appear to show cases of human-animal conflict are on the rise in the state, Mr Hoover warned. 'It is extremely alarming and the conflict has escalated to an extent where forest authorities are unable to manage the situation,' he said. India has lost a total of 103 tigers this year, according to India's National Tiger Conservation Authority, though the net population of the big cats is steadily rising.
BBC News
an hour ago
- BBC News
Edward Stanton: Former children's home manager jailed for abuse
A former children's home manager has been jailed for 15 years after being convicted of historical abuse. Edward Stanton, 73, was found guilty of 11 offences against 10 victims, including the rape of a young girl. The abuse happened at three children's homes in Lanarkshire, which cannot be named for legal the verdicts, it was revealed that Stanton had been jailed for 13 years in 1996 for historical abuse of boys at a children's home in Merseyside. He was also convicted in 2021 of attacks on two other youngsters at the same addition to those offences, Stanton had previously been jailed for possessing indecent images of children and breaching a Sexual Offences Prevention was sentenced at the High Court in Aberdeen following the latest convictions. 'Brushed under the carpet' The trial last month was told Stanton carried out sex attacks on a teenage girl, including at a campsite in preyed on another victim while she was initially resident who was molested in a tent had reported the abuse to a staff member at the time, but he was "not believed", the court the trial, the victim said he and others were "vulnerable children" that were "meant to be in a place of safety". But he said reports of the abuse appeared to be "brushed under the carpet".Another victim told the court that Stanton gave him money to effectively buy his silence.A further victim remembered speaking to staff, but said "nothing was done".The court also heard that the former care home manager was violent towards victim recalled being repeatedly punched and was convicted of charges of rape, numerous indecent assaults, lewd and libidinous behaviour as well as physical attacks.
