Indonesia's new history books spark fears of whitewashing past events
The 10-volume project, commissioned under President Prabowo Subianto, has drawn criticism for potentially glossing over past abuses.
Draft summaries seen by AFP show no dedicated section on the 1998 violence, which saw widespread riots, looting, and allegations of mass rape.
A brief mention of Suharto's resignation cites student protests as a factor, omitting deeper context.
Historian Andi Achdian called the draft 'flawed' and accused it of whitewashing history.
Culture Minister Fadli Zon defended the project, telling lawmakers the May 1998 events were 'small' and did not require detailed coverage.
However, project editor Jajat Burhanudin contradicted this, stating the final version would include the riots, with the draft serving as a discussion starter.
The controversy deepened after Fadli questioned whether mass rapes occurred during the unrest, despite a 1998 fact-finding report documenting at least 52 cases.
Amnesty International Indonesia's Usman Hamid warned the project risks 'erasing uncomfortable truths.'
Critics argue the government should not dictate historical narratives. Former attorney general Marzuki Darusman cautioned that ignoring past abuses acknowledged by previous administrations undermines accountability.
Activist Maria Catarina Sumarsih, whose son died in post-Suharto violence, accused officials of deceiving younger generations.
At least one scholar, archaeologist Harry Truman Simanjuntak, resigned over political interference, citing disputes over terminology.
Opposition lawmakers and civil groups are calling for the project's suspension, urging historians—not the government—to lead historical documentation.
Fadli confirmed the project will proceed, calling it an 'updated version of history' with public debates expected this month. - AFP
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Star
an hour ago
- The Star
Indonesia eyes technocrat as top US diplomat after two-year gap
JAKARTA: Indonesia is poised to appoint a US-educated technocrat as its ambassador to Washington, ending a prolonged vacancy in a key diplomatic post at a time when the nation is recalibrating trade and business ties with the world's largest economy. Lawmakers in Jakarta have approved Dwisuryo Indroyono Soesilo (pic) as envoy to the US following a closed-door vetting process, Deputy Speaker of Parliament Adies Kadir told Bloomberg News. Soesilo, 70, is a former cabinet minister as well as a geologist and veteran marine governance expert. His nomination awaits a formal nod from President Prabowo Subianto, who is also expected unveil a slate of ambassadors on a date to be announced. The appointment also requires a sign-off by the US. A two-year absence of an ambassador in Washington, along with several other extended vacancies, has drawn criticism from former officials and analysts. They say the gaps have weakened Indonesia's diplomatic leverage amid shifting global alliances and economic pressures. Prabowo is pursuing closer ties with countries including China and Russia while also trying to negotiate a tariffs deal with the US, one of its largest export markets. A recent social media post by a former ambassador to the US, Dino Patti Djalal, urging Prabowo to swiftly fill positions has drawn more than half a million views. Foreign Minister Sugiono last month said the delay "was our mistake,' citing challenges in selecting suitable candidates. Soesilo, whose father served as US ambassador in the 1980s under former ruler Suharto, didn't respond to Bloomberg requests for comment. He acknowledged his vetting to local media earlier this month but said the process wasn't finished. Soesilo earned graduate degrees in remote sensing from the University of Michigan and the University of Iowa before dedicating much of his career to marine research and fisheries policy, including within Indonesian government agencies. He briefly served as director of fisheries and aquaculture at the UN's Food and Agriculture Organization, and later as coordinating minister for maritime affairs under former President Joko Widodo. He has not previously held a diplomatic post. The nomination is part of a broader diplomatic rotation involving 24 ambassadorial posts, including to missions in Germany, the United Nations and North Korea. Names are proposed by the president, and the picks mostly indicate Prabowo is favoring political loyalty and technocratic expertise over traditional diplomatic experience for the bigger roles. He has suggested a former campaign team member as envoy to Malaysia, and a one-time adviser for the mission in Singapore, a significant channel for foreign investment into Indonesia. Local media reported that the sister and adviser to Luhut Binsar Pandjaitan, a powerbroker who backed Prabowo's presidential bid, is expected to serve as ambassador to Japan. Career diplomats have instead been nominated to positions considered less politically sensitive, including to Germany, Vietnam and the UN. Foreign policy experts have expressed concern about the shift in diplomatic strategy for the world's fourth-most populous nation, especially given uncertainties around US political dynamics. In the case of representation in Washington, "what matters most now is having access and experience with Trump himself,' said Dedi Dinarto, lead Indonesia analyst and senior associate at strategic advisory firm Global Counsel LLC. "Indonesia risks being left out of key conversations if its top envoy can't navigate that environment.' Since taking office last year, Prabowo has traveled frequently, including visits to China, the Middle East, Southeast Asian neighbors, Russia and Europe. He recently attended the BRICS summit in Brazil - the first since Indonesia joined the bloc earlier this year - and is scheduled for meetings in Brussels and Paris in coming days. "In a command-style government like this, where the president controls all foreign policy decisions, even appointing capable ambassadors becomes difficult,' said Nicky D. Fahrizal, a foreign policy researcher at the Center for Strategic and International Studies in Jakarta. "Even ambassadors with strong diplomatic credentials may find themselves powerless.' - Bloomberg
The Star
an hour ago
- The Star
Philippines asserts arbitral win at Beijing forum
MANILA: Representatives from the Philippine Embassy in China attended a July 10 forum in Beijing where they reaffirmed the 'legal authority' of the 2016 arbitral ruling in favour of the Philippines' exclusive sovereign rights over the West Philippine Sea (South China Sea). In a statement on Sunday (July 13), the embassy said the forum organised by a Chinese think tank was held two days before the ninth anniversary of the landmark ruling by the Permanent Court of Arbitration in The Hague, where the Philippines brought its case against China in 2013. The forum 'claimed to bring together scholars, legal experts, and policymakers to engage in in-depth discussions on the historical and legal dimensions of the South China Sea,' the embassy said. But embassy representatives who attended that gathering noted the 'predominant criticism of the [arbitral] award and of Philippine policy and actions in the [South China Sea] region.' The embassy is headed by Ambassador Jaime FlorCruz, a veteran journalist who had reported extensively on Beijing. During an opportunity for an intervention, the Filipino officials asserted before that audience that the ruling, along with its annexes, 'proves the validity and legality of Philippine claims and they are available for everyone to study and read.' They also rejected the notion that the Philippines was the 'troublemaker' in the South China Sea and was refusing to engage in proper dialogue with China. 'We disagree with the notion that the Philippines is not willing to engage with China. In fact, even with the arbitral award, the Philippines has continued to make efforts to keep lines of communication open, maintain proper dialogue, and engage positively with China as well as other claimant states, both bilaterally and regionally, within the context of our legally settled claims in accordance with the United Nations Convention on the Law of the Sea (Unclos) and international law,' they told the forum. 'We hope China's actions demonstrate genuine willingness to engage and to produce constructive and positive outcomes,' they said. The Hague ruling also dismissed China's nine-dash-line claim as having no legal basis, noting that Unclos 'superseded any maritime entitlements based on historic rights in excess of the limits imposed' by that international treaty. Meanwhile US Secretary of State Marco Rubio issued a statement on July 12, the anniversary of the landmark ruling, urging Beijing 'to abide by the 2016 arbitral ruling and to cease its dangerous and destabilising conduct' in the South China Sea. He also called out China for its continued defiance of the ruling, its assertion of 'unlawful and expansive maritime claims,' and aggression against its neighbours. 'Beijing's expansive claims directly infringe on the sovereign rights and jurisdictions of Vietnam, the Philippines, Malaysia, Brunei, and Indonesia, and undermine peace, stability, and prosperity in the Indo-Pacific,' Rubio said on Saturday. He pointed out that the 2016 arbitral ruling was a 'significant milestone and useful basis' to resolve disputes over the South China Sea. He said the United States supports a 'free and open Indo-Pacific,' as it aims to maintain peace and stability and prioritize freedom from maritime disputes. 'We seek to preserve peace and stability, uphold freedom of navigation and overflight, maintain the free flow of trade, and oppose coercion to settle maritime disputes,' Rubio said. Foreign Secretary Teresa Lazaro on Friday also expressed concern over China's continuing rejection of the ruling, emphasising that it 'persists with illegal, coercive, and aggressive actions under cover of a revisionist, self-serving interpretation and application of international law, particularly Unclos.' She said the government continues to assert the sovereign rights of the Philippines, uphold international law and utilise the bilateral consultation mechanism on the South China Sea as well as the bilateral consular consultations mechanism with China to maintain dialogue and diplomacy at appropriate official levels. - Philippine Daily Inquirer/ANN
The Sun
2 hours ago
- The Sun
Trump's UK state visit dates confirmed for September 17-19
LONDON: US President Donald Trump will make his second state visit to the United Kingdom from September 17 to 19, Buckingham Palace confirmed. Trump and First Lady Melania will be formally welcomed by King Charles III and Queen Camilla at Windsor Castle. The invitation was extended through a personal letter from King Charles, delivered by British Prime Minister Keir Starmer during his Washington visit in February. Trump described the invitation as a 'tremendous honour' at the time. This marks Trump's second state visit to Britain, following his 2019 trip where he was hosted by the late Queen Elizabeth II. Unlike French President Emmanuel Macron, who addressed Parliament during his recent visit, Trump will not speak in the House of Commons as it will be in recess during his stay. - AFP
