Shubman Gill lacked Kohli-like aura. Shastri kept saying...: Nasser flags 'Jadeja' blunder as 'Hardik' talk returns
Speaking on Sky Cricket after England easily chased down 371, their second-highest chase at home, four years after their highest of 378, which also came against India, Nasser gave his verdict on Gill's captaincy.
The Leeds Test marked his debut, as Gill took over the role after Rohit Sharma's retirement. However, Gill reckoned he did not have the same aura as his predecessors, including Kohli, whom he is often compared to. ALSO READ: Virat Kohli would have said, 'I'll get England all out before Tea': Shubman Gill's defensive captaincy under fire
"I thought I saw someone just finding his way, honestly. You've got to be very careful in the first Test match, the people he's taken over from, Kohli, and then Rohit Sharma. I thought he didn't quite have that on-field aura as the names I mentioned there. You look down on those two previous names, and you immediately see who was in charge of India. I looked down from the press box, the commentary position, there were a lot of captains; it was a bit captaincy by committee, which can happen in your early days as a leader because you're still senior players like Rishabh Pant and KL Rahul want to try and help you out as much as possible. I thought he followed the ball a lot. I thought he was reactive as opposed to proactive," he said.
Nasser admitted he was left quite surprised that neither Gill, nor any of the senior players have a word with Ravindra Jadeja, who did not bowl into the rough on the Day 5 track at Headingley, which allowed the England batters to race away to the big target with ease. Despite the track having the perfect ingredient to aid the spinner, which could have turned the game in India's favour, he only had one wicket to show, conceding 104 runs.
The veteran England batter revealed that Shastri kept talking about Jadeja's blunder in the commentary after visuals showed that he was not pitching his deliveries anywhere near the rough area.
"A word with Jadeja, maybe as a young captain, to go to such an experienced spinner, and go, you do know the rough is out there. Ravi Shastri and Mark Butcher are up there, going, show us where that ball is pitching, and it was pitching nowhere near the rough. Ravi was saying, a bit slow, a bit wide, bowl in the rough. I was surprised that not one of the senior players or captains went to Jadeja and said, Can we go a little bit wider. But Ravi's right, they lost the game for two things that he couldn't control," he added. 'India need a Hardik Pandya'
As Nasser went deeper with his assessment of India's loss in the first Test, he sparked the familar talks around the team still missing a seam bowling all-rounder of Hardik's calibre.
The team management experimented with Nitish Reddy in Australia before handing over the duty to Shardul Thakur in Leeds, but both failed to give India that perfect balance yet.
Nasser's words stem from India's lower-order collapse in both innings in Leeds, which was among the factors that resulted in the five-wicket loss despite the side witnessing five centuries during the match.
"The slip cordon and the catching were poor, something that India have done well in the last two or three years and the collapses. And that concerns me because India has a lower order with spin bowling all-rounders and has had for the last decade, which are magnificent. Ashwin, Jadeja, Axar Patel. In England, they are still looking, I think, for that seam bowling all-rounder, you know, someone like a Hardik Pandya, going back to Ravi's times, Kapil Dev or whatever, they are still looking for that lower-order bowler who can bat. And if they keep going for, what, seven for 41 and six for 30 or whatever, then this could be a quick series. They need to run down the order."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
&w=3840&q=100)
First Post
an hour ago
- First Post
Steely determination of Indian batting lineup runs England ragged at Old Trafford, keeps Test series alive
This England side 'don't do draws' – indeed this is the first of the Bazball era that hasn't involved two solid days of rain – but they were forced to at Old Trafford, slowly ground into stalemate by the relentless determination of India's rearguard. read more The Indian and English teams shook hands for a draw soon as Washington Sundar brought up his maiden international hundred on the final day of the fourth Test at Old Trafford, Manchester. Reuters The great escape is complete, the series still live. From a first innings deficit of 311 India have done what was once unthinkable, that right now feels a lot more like a win. This England side 'don't do draws' – indeed this is the first of the Bazball era that hasn't involved two solid days of rain – but they were forced to at Old Trafford, slowly ground into stalemate by the relentless determination of India's rearguard. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD At lunch on Day Four India were so far behind the game that to say they were dead and buried almost felt like understatement. They had conceded 669 – the most runs any side has scored in an innings at Old Trafford – and then for good measure lost two wickets inside the first over of their reply. That though was counting against the steely determination of this India batting lineup that, even shorn of Rishabh Pant, defied the odds to pull off a draw that by the end had them running England ragged. Floodgates remain shut despite Gill and Rahul's early dismissals While the groundwork was laid on Day Four – KL Rahul and Shubman Gill's monumental 174-run partnership moved the needle for the tourists from 'certain defeat' to 'in with a chance of a draw' – India still arrived on the final day with England strong favourites to seal a series-clinching win. For all that Rahul and Gill had resisted the England onslaught there was a sense that should both men be removed then the floodgates might open for a home side boosted by the assistance of a final day pitch. Rahul and Gill did both fall before lunch, an outcome England would gladly have accepted before the start of play, the proverbial floodgates however remained firmly closed. England pacer Jofra Archer celebrates as India captain Shubman Gill departs shortly after completing his century on the final day of the fourth Test in Manchester. Reuters A lot has been made of India's team selection throughout this series, they have opted in every Test to try and have it both ways, bolstering both batting and bowling departments with the deployment of all rounders, instead of perhaps committing more wholeheartedly to the strengthening of one – selecting the wicket taking talents of Kuldeep Yadav for example. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD Here though, at the fourth time of asking, that strategy came good, the batting depth provided by the selection of Washington Sundar – even more so in the absence of Pant – a crucial cog in India's dramatic escape. At lunch on the final day India were 223/4, still over 100 runs behind and with only five batsmen left – or six if you included the one-legged Pant, whose participation was far from guaranteed – a large proportion of which comprised India's somewhat vertiginous tail. Jadeja and Sundar resist everything England throw at them Sundar and Jadeja were however unbowed, able to resist everything England threw at them, as well as any final day unpleasantness from the pitch, to secure a result that had seemed beyond them for most of this Test. England may look back and rue one moment in particular – Jadeja dropped first ball by Joe Root at first slip – agonisingly unable to cling on at first, second or even third attempt, as the left hander flashed at a delivery from Jofra Archer. But that chance aside England struggled to really threaten. Even with the assistance of the pitch Liam Dawson looked largely innocuous – only 11 men have bowled as many overs as him in the fourth innings of a game and conceded more runs – and Ben Stokes aside England's pacemen struggled to create any meaningful jeopardy for the visitors. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD Scored a hundred, saved the Test, farmed ♾ aura! 💁♂#RavindraJadeja didn't hesitate, till the end 👀#ENGvIND 👉 5th TEST | Starts THU, 31st July, 2:30 PM | Streaming on JioHotstar! — Star Sports (@StarSportsIndia) July 27, 2025 Ultimately England were so cowed they attempted to shake hands on a draw at the earliest moment possible, but India with Sundar and Jadeja both looking to notch a Test match hundred batted on – the hosts reduced to bowling Harry Brook as the game drew to a close. Both men would make hundreds, a first in Tests for Washington Sundar, their unbroken partnership of 203 had rescued a draw for India and rendered next week's clash at The Oval all to play for. STORY CONTINUES BELOW THIS AD
News18
2 hours ago
- News18
This team will make its own history: Gautam Gambhir
Agency: PTI Manchester, Jul 27 (PTI) Gautam Gambhir wants his players to make their own history rather than following anyone from the past including the India head coach himself. And, after a memorable comeback in the Manchester Test, they are moving in that direction. A 188-run stand between captain Shubman Gill and K L Rahul kept India in the fourth Test against England before Washington Sundar and Ravindra Jadeja earned a spirited draw for the visitors with an unbeaten 203-run alliance. Asked whether Gambhir gave a pep talk to the players after day four and made a reference to his match-saving 137 in Napier back in 2009, Gambhir responded in the negative. 'Look, the first thing is that I don't remember any of my knocks, that has become history. I think they should make their own history. Honestly, no one in this team will follow anyone or want to follow. They should make their own history. 'They want to fight for the common man back home. And the important thing is that the way a lot of people had written us off in this Test match, this is the foundation of this team. 'These are characters who are sitting in this dressing room, wanting to fight for the country and they will continue to do that," said the head coach. Managing a draw from the brink of defeat would give India a psychological edge over the hosts in the fifth and final Test in London, felt Gambhir. 'It will. Because when you see, when you're put under the pressure, when you're put under the pump and you end up adding five sessions, I think that's a great character. And anything that you do in these conditions, when you're put under pressure and you come out of those pressure moments, it is always a great feeling. 'And it just ends up giving a lot of confidence in the dressing room as well. And I'm sure, I think going into Oval, I think we will be high on confidence, but we can't take anything for granted," he said. Under new captain Gill, the team is going through a transition but Gambhir doesn't see it that way. Considering the inexperience in the side, the squad has done well especially Gill who racked up his fourth hundred of the series on Sunday. 'Good you used that word transition but I don't see it like that because it is still an Indian team. This is the best 18 that is going to represent. It is only experience and inexperience. 'And that is how we see this. But the most important thing is that these guys got to learn a lot from what they did today. 'Because being under pressure, batting five sessions is never easy on day five of the Test against an attack like England. And then coming out with a draw and only losing four wickets…," he said. PTI BS AH view comments First Published: July 28, 2025, 01:30 IST Disclaimer: Comments reflect users' views, not News18's. Please keep discussions respectful and constructive. Abusive, defamatory, or illegal comments will be removed. News18 may disable any comment at its discretion. By posting, you agree to our Terms of Use and Privacy Policy.
Indian Express
2 hours ago
- Indian Express
Rishabh Pant ruled out of 5th IND vs ENG Test at the Oval due to fractured foot
Swashbuckling India wicketkeeper-batter Rishabh Pant was on Sunday ruled out of the fifth and final Test at the Oval due to the injury he suffered in Manchester earlier in the week. N Jagadeesan was named as his replacement. This comes after India kept the series alive after tons from Ravindra Jadeja and Washington Sundar guided the visitors to a draw in the 4th Test. 'Rishabh Pant ruled out of fifth Test due to injury; N Jagadeesan named replacement,' the BCCI said in an X post on Sunday. 'Rishabh Pant, who sustained a fracture to his right foot during the fourth Test against England in Manchester, has been ruled out of the fifth and final Test of the series. The BCCI Medical Team will continue to monitor his progress and the team wishes him a speedy recovery. The Men's Selection Committee has named Narayan Jagadeesan as replacement for Rishabh Pant for the fifth Test, which begins on July 31, 2025 at Kennington Oval, London,' a statement from the board read. 🚨 𝗦𝗾𝘂𝗮𝗱 𝗨𝗽𝗱𝗮𝘁𝗲 🚨 Rishabh Pant ruled out of fifth Test due to injury; N Jagadeesan named replacement. All The Details 🔽 #TeamIndia | #ENGvIND — BCCI (@BCCI) July 27, 2025 Pant fractured his toe while attempting a reverse sweep on Day 1, which led to him having to retire hurt. He then remarkably continued his innings while batting almost on one foot and scored 54 in 75 balls. Pant was advised six weeks of rest and was expected to not travel to the ground on Day 2. However, he was eventually spotted in the dressing room in full gear and he then hobbled out after Shardul Thakur was dismissed shortly before Lunch. On Day 5, the keeper wasn't required to bat due to Jadeja and Sundar's gritty knocks which ended the 4th Test in a stalemate. Jadeja, Sundar and Shubman Gill struck fine hundreds as India secured the morale-boosting draw. The stalemate was achieved after Gill (103), Rahul (90), Jadeja (107 not out), and Washington (101 not out) fired with the bat on a fifth day pitch after India started their second innings 311 runs in arrears. England lead the series 2-1 heading into the fifth and final Test. For skipper Gill, this was his fourth century of the ongoing rubber as he became the first Asian batter to cross 700 runs in a Test series in England. Earlier in the day, opener Rahul was dismissed by Ben Stokes for a doughty 90, ending a 188-run partnership for the third wicket with Gill. Resuming the day on 174 for two and with a deficit of 137 runs, overnight batter Gill completed his hundred before falling to Jofra Archer just before lunch at Old Trafford.
