Shubman Gill lacked Kohli-like aura. Shastri kept saying...: Nasser flags 'Jadeja' blunder as 'Hardik' talk returns
Speaking on Sky Cricket after England easily chased down 371, their second-highest chase at home, four years after their highest of 378, which also came against India, Nasser gave his verdict on Gill's captaincy.
The Leeds Test marked his debut, as Gill took over the role after Rohit Sharma's retirement. However, Gill reckoned he did not have the same aura as his predecessors, including Kohli, whom he is often compared to. ALSO READ: Virat Kohli would have said, 'I'll get England all out before Tea': Shubman Gill's defensive captaincy under fire
"I thought I saw someone just finding his way, honestly. You've got to be very careful in the first Test match, the people he's taken over from, Kohli, and then Rohit Sharma. I thought he didn't quite have that on-field aura as the names I mentioned there. You look down on those two previous names, and you immediately see who was in charge of India. I looked down from the press box, the commentary position, there were a lot of captains; it was a bit captaincy by committee, which can happen in your early days as a leader because you're still senior players like Rishabh Pant and KL Rahul want to try and help you out as much as possible. I thought he followed the ball a lot. I thought he was reactive as opposed to proactive," he said.
Nasser admitted he was left quite surprised that neither Gill, nor any of the senior players have a word with Ravindra Jadeja, who did not bowl into the rough on the Day 5 track at Headingley, which allowed the England batters to race away to the big target with ease. Despite the track having the perfect ingredient to aid the spinner, which could have turned the game in India's favour, he only had one wicket to show, conceding 104 runs.
The veteran England batter revealed that Shastri kept talking about Jadeja's blunder in the commentary after visuals showed that he was not pitching his deliveries anywhere near the rough area.
"A word with Jadeja, maybe as a young captain, to go to such an experienced spinner, and go, you do know the rough is out there. Ravi Shastri and Mark Butcher are up there, going, show us where that ball is pitching, and it was pitching nowhere near the rough. Ravi was saying, a bit slow, a bit wide, bowl in the rough. I was surprised that not one of the senior players or captains went to Jadeja and said, Can we go a little bit wider. But Ravi's right, they lost the game for two things that he couldn't control," he added. 'India need a Hardik Pandya'
As Nasser went deeper with his assessment of India's loss in the first Test, he sparked the familar talks around the team still missing a seam bowling all-rounder of Hardik's calibre.
The team management experimented with Nitish Reddy in Australia before handing over the duty to Shardul Thakur in Leeds, but both failed to give India that perfect balance yet.
Nasser's words stem from India's lower-order collapse in both innings in Leeds, which was among the factors that resulted in the five-wicket loss despite the side witnessing five centuries during the match.
"The slip cordon and the catching were poor, something that India have done well in the last two or three years and the collapses. And that concerns me because India has a lower order with spin bowling all-rounders and has had for the last decade, which are magnificent. Ashwin, Jadeja, Axar Patel. In England, they are still looking, I think, for that seam bowling all-rounder, you know, someone like a Hardik Pandya, going back to Ravi's times, Kapil Dev or whatever, they are still looking for that lower-order bowler who can bat. And if they keep going for, what, seven for 41 and six for 30 or whatever, then this could be a quick series. They need to run down the order."
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Hindustan Times
2 hours ago
- Hindustan Times
Gill's tactics in tailspin as England dominate
Mumbai: Made to grind in the field for the whole of Day 3, there were lessons aplenty for Indians, none bigger than for Shubman Gill whose captaincy has come under the scanner at Old Trafford. India's captain Shubman Gill leads the team off the field after Day 3 of Manchester Test. (AFP) Still in the nascent stage of his captaincy reign, leading just in his fourth game, this day will give Gill an important lesson — as captain of the Indian team, he would need to show more trust in his spin strength. In Jasprit Bumrah and Mohammed Siraj, he has a sharp pace attack but in any India bowling unit, there will be good spinners that will have an equally important role to play. Using them effectively is the key. As India's think-tank sits to analyse what transpired on Friday, which England batted through and ended at 544/7, Gill will accept he missed a trick by not attacking with Washington Sundar earlier than when he eventually brought him on. Despite English batters looking largely untroubled against pace in the morning session, it was baffling to see the delay in introducing spin as late as the 62nd over when Ravindra Jadeja was given the ball for the first time on the day. Washington was India's best spinner in the series with big scalps in the previous Test. His confidence was high after a four-wicket haul in his last spell at Lord's. Inexplicably, there was no sign of him till the 69th over. The England batters were not complaining. Their total had swelled to 305/2 and their pair at the crease were well set — Ollie Pope batting on 61 and Root on 45. As it turned out, Washington looked the best Indian bowler on display and was among the wickets straightaway. The well-set Pope was foxed beautifully to induce his edge to KL Rahul at first slip in his fifth over. Two overs later, he struck again when he lured Harry Brook to his doom by having him stumped with a quicker length ball that drew the batter into stepping out. What has made Washington stand out is the amount of drift (2.6 degree) he is getting in English conditions. Pope was beaten by the drift and it was also a hint of drift that forced Brook into a defensive block down the wrong line. In Gill's defence, it can be said that the drawback of too many bowlers, when you prefer to pack the side with all-rounders, is that one or two of them are bound to be underused. Be that as it may, the advantage had been lost by the time the spinners got the opportunity. Among other lessons for the visiting side, there was a masterclass from Joe Root on how to make the start count in these conditions. In their first innings, India's top three of KL Rahul, Yashavi Jaiswal and Sai Sudarshan got starts, but none could capitalise. Starting the day on 11, the veteran showed how it is done. Root converted the half-century into a century and century into 150. Riding on his 248-ball epic (14 fours), Ollie Pope's 71 and captain Ben Stokes 77*, the hosts took firm control of the game. With England already ahead by 186 runs, the best India can hope for is to save the game. The opening session of the day was going to be decisive for India who are trailing 1-2 in the series. However, along with Pope, Root ensured England completely dominated it. At lunch, England were 266/2, a run-rate of 4.50, with Root firmly entrenched on 35 (78b, 5x4) and Pope on 32 (70b, 5x4). Root then combined with Stokes to help England overcome the early hiccup of losing two quick wickets to add 101 runs in the second session to get them to tea on 433/4, increasing the lead to 75. Root was on 121 and Stokes on 36. A thorn in India's flesh, during his innings the Yorkshireman eclipsed a series of records, becoming the second highest run scorer in the history of the game, and now has most hundreds against them — 12. Apart from their spinners taking four of the seven wickets to fall, there was not much to write home about India's bowling attack. The long series is taking its toll on the players. India had scares when their pace weapons Bumrah and Siraj were affected by niggles. Cramps forced England captain Ben Stokes also to retire hurt at the score of 66. All three returned to action later in the day.
NDTV
2 hours ago
- NDTV
England Star Breaks Silence On Confrontation With India Captain Shubman Gill
The Lord's Test confrontation between India's Shubman Gill and England's Zak Crawley remains one of the most-talked-about topics in the series. Many felt that it was this moment which prompted England to shun their 'nice guys' attitude and step up against a testing Indian side. While the content of the verbal battle between Gill and Crawley wasn't revealed, the England star has finally opened up on the heated confrontation, saying he enjoyed those '8 minutes' of the duel with the India captain. During the day third of the Lord's Test, which India lost by 22 runs, an extremely heated argument took place between skipper Gill and England openers, with the Indian skipper alleging that they had wasted time while arriving and after arriving at the crease, to face as less balls as possible, with day's play coming to close. During this whole confrontation, the whole team had surrounded the batters, trying to get under the skin of the batters in every way possible. While many accused Gill of stepping over the line with his gestures that day, Crawley doesn't think anything was outside the 'spirit of the game'. Speaking at the post-day press conference, Crawley told the media, "I've always enjoyed that part of cricket, to be honest, especially when you're batting. There's two of you against eleven, and they're desperate to get you out, and they're chirping you. Most of the time, I'd probably let it slide, and then other times, I feel like it's a good chance to put it back on them. I loved that little eight-minute passage. No one stepped over the line. I thought everyone was in good spirits. It was just competitive cricket, and I really enjoyed it." The England openers Crawley and Ben Duckett came out to bat 90 seconds late on the field during Day 3 of the Lord's Test. Clarifying that they didn't did it intentionally, the right-hand batter said, "No, no. Not at all. I sit in my spot [in the dressing room] until the umpires go out. I saw the umpires go, and I walked out. I wasn't aware that we were 90 seconds late, but fair enough."
Time of India
3 hours ago
- Time of India
India's day of drift: Flat body language, flatter tactics at Old Trafford
Mohammed Siraj reacts on Day 3 of the fourth Test between England and India at Old Trafford in Manchester. (AP) in Manchester: The last half an hour of the second session aptly summed up India's Day 3 at Old Trafford cricket ground. Jasprit Bumrah and Mohammed Siraj were feeling some discomfort in their left ankle, Shubman Gill was forced to operate with Shardul Thakur - not Gill's choice as it was KL Rahul who handed over the ball to him when the captain was in the change room for a quick break - and Anshul Kamboj with the second new ball and the body language remained very flat. Karun Nair and Abhimanyu Easwaran kept going in and out of the field as substitute fielders and the rest - Prasidh Krishna, Kuldeep Yadav, Arshdeep Singh, Akash Deep - ensured that the drinks were loaded and chilled. In the middle of the hapless period, Arshdeep kept the mahaul (environment) light as he urged teammates to clap every time he returned from drinks duties. The mahaul , however, was anything but light in the middle as India put on a listless show with the ball and operated with questionable tactics throughout the day. Go Beyond The Boundary with our YouTube channel. SUBSCRIBE NOW! From under-bowling Thakur, again, to waiting 68 overs before handing over the ball to Washington Sundar, captain Gill let the game slip away. Even Sundar's drift, which got India two quick wickets of Ollie Pope and Harry Brook, wasn't enough to turn momentum India's way as the rest remained very ordinary. Bumrah ran in hard but his lines remained all over the place, Siraj was erratic & expensive, Anshul Kamboj was a royal disappointment on debut and Thakur wasn't considered. by Taboola by Taboola Sponsored Links Sponsored Links Promoted Links Promoted Links You May Like Indonesia: New Container Houses (Prices May Surprise You) Container House | Search ads Search Now Undo The only period of some control came when the two spinners bowled in tandem and while Ravindra Jadeja too failed to keep it tight, he was in good rhythm with Sundar in that period post the Lunch interval. Joe Root was dismissed after scoring 150 runs on Day 3 of the fourth Test between England and India at Old Trafford in Manchester. (AP) The visitors did delay taking the second new ball due to the control which spinners were enjoying but the moment it was taken in the 91st over and pace was introduced, run-making returned to fluent ways for the hosts who operated in comfortable fashion with the Ben Stokes-Joe Root stand. The right-hander scored another hundred, went past Ricky Ponting's 13,378 Test runs and the Indian shoulders remained down. On a day where there wasn't an overcast cloud in the sky and it remained bright and sunny, India's tactical blunders were exposed as they clearly didn't pick the right attack for the surface. Dry and placid, the 22 yards had some variable bounce on the first two days under clouds but evened out when it baked under the sun. It was then just the case of exhibiting the right temperament and showing patience as enough runs were on offer. India just didn't have the attack to even try a Plan B. Ben Stokes remained unbeaten at close on Day 3 of the fourth Test between England and India at Old Trafford in Manchester. (AP) It was another day of wondering what could have been had the guy wearing a bib - Kuldeep Yadav - was giving the oldish Dukes a rip. It's for days and situations like these that you needed some variation but India's obsession with depth and bits-and-pieces template exposed their trumpet of picking an attack to pick 20 wickets. After the Leeds defeat, where they weren't able to defend 370, India swiftly packed their batting instead of adding a wicket-taking option with the ball. The pitches have remained flat and dry in all four Tests so far but Kuldeep's bib is yet to come off. The preference to batting depth has compromised India's wicket-taking ability and it turned out to be a long day under the sun where the opposition milked runs for fun. When Gill and the rest dragged themselves to the change room, the body language was a true reflection of how the day unfolded for them. The loud sledge from the stand near the stairs did catch a few players' attention but they were too tired to care at the moment. Washington Sundar took two wickets on Day 3 of the fourth Test between England and India at Old Trafford in Manchester. (AP) Head down, they called it a day and even Arshdeep's claps and infectious energy wasn't enough to give the shoulders a lift. India: 358 trail England: 544/7 (Joe Root 150, Ben Duckett 94, Zak Crawley 84, Ben Stokes 77*; Washington Sundar 2/57, Ravindra Jadeja 2/117) by 186 runs. For real-time updates, scores, and highlights, follow our live coverage of the India vs England Test match here. Catch Rani Rampal's inspiring story on Game On, Episode 4. Watch Here!
