Sky claims man may have made €450,000 a year from 'dodgy box' service
Sky TV Limited alleges David Dunbar has operated an illegal service providing thousands with access to its copyrighted broadcast material since 2018. Last month, Sky was granted various orders aimed at gathering evidence of Mr Dunbar's alleged infringement, including permission to seize devices belonging to him.
In a sworn statement to the court, a Sky anti-piracy investigator says Mr Dunbar is considered by Sky to be a 'top-level' copyright infringer, and that his activity 'is likely to have been to the very serious detriment' of Sky and broadcasters and legitimate streaming services in Ireland.
Last November, investigators at Sky became aware of a social media account involved in selling an Internet Protocol television service (IPTV). IPTV is the technology behind 'dodgy box' services. This account was later linked to Mr Dunbar, the investigator says.
Separately, Sky investigators were informed of an anonymous tip-off received by An Garda Síochána's Crime Stoppers initiative, alleging Mr Dunbar's operation of the service.
The investigator estimates Mr Dunbar to have up to 5,000 customers paying for his service, generating about €450,000 per year from the operation. Sky's investigation found Mr Dunbar allegedly charged two annual subscription rates for the service, priced at €80 and €100 respectively.
The investigator says he believes Mr Dunbar has at least 1,682 customers, but the true number is likely much higher.
Court orders
On Thursday, barristers for Sky said Mr Dunbar, with an address at Manor Crescent, Roxborough Manor, Co Wexford, had breached a number of the court's orders, and was in contempt of court.
Theo Donnelly BL, appearing for Sky and instructed by Philip Lee solicitors, said statements made by Mr Dunbar in the proceedings contained inaccuracies and inconsistencies, and failed to explain certain breaches of orders.
Mr Donnelly said bank statements exhibited to an unsworn statement, received by his side this week and due to be filed with the court, appeared to show a dissipation of funds, in breach of freezing orders granted by the court.
Mr Donnelly suggested that Mr Dunbar be given a final opportunity to clarify Sky's concerns, brought on by his statements.
Adam Dodd, a solicitor representing Mr Dunbar, said his client had provided a 'fulsome' affidavit, 'warts and all'. He said his client had admitted to his contempt of court, and has indicated that he is seeking to comply with the orders of the court.
Mr Justice Mark Sanfey said he was of the view that Mr Dunbar should 'put his best foot forward' and answer queries raised by Sky regarding his statements to the court. Mr Justice Sanfey warned Mr Dodd that there was a limit to his patience.
The judge adjourned the case to next month.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Examiner
9 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Man charged with stabbing in West Cork remanded in continuing custody
A Dutch man accused in connection with a stabbing in West Cork will be brought before the district court in September. Bas Mulders, who has an address on Western Road, Clonakilty, appeared before a sitting of Bandon District Court on Monday. The 54-year-old appeared on two charges — assault causing harm and producing an article in the course of a dispute. Appearing before Judge Joanna Carroll, Mr Mulders was represented by solicitor Conrad Murphy. The State applied for a continuing remand in custody, by consent, unless he is granted bail in the meantime by the High Court. He is accused of stabbing another man with a knife during an argument at a location in Clonakilty in the early hours of Tuesday, July 22. He was denied bail at district court level last Friday, when gardaí objected on the grounds that they had serious concerns that he could coerce or intimidate a witness and/or the alleged injured party. There was also a risk he could flee the jurisdiction, the court was told on Friday. Judge Joanne Carroll agreed to the State's application for a remand in continuing custody, until August 7, via video link. If granted bail by the High Court, he is to appear in court in person. Mr Murphy applied for free legal aid for his client, which was granted by Judge Carroll.
Irish Times
10 hours ago
- Irish Times
Somali diplomat challenges detention in Dublin jail over alleged people smuggling
A Somali diplomat arrested at Dublin Airport and charged with people-smuggling offences has launched a High Court challenge against his detention in an Irish prison, claiming diplomatic immunity. Mohamed Abdallatif Hussein, who is attached to the Federal Republic of Somalia embassy in Riyadh, Saudi Arabia, was arrested by gardaí at Dublin Airport on November 26th last year. He was brought before Dublin District Court later that day accused of two counts of alleged people smuggling under the Criminal Justice (Smuggling of Persons) Act, 2021, at Dublin Airport's terminal one. On the same date, he was also charged with two further offences under the Act. READ MORE Last January at Cloverhill District Court he was further charged with four counts of alleged people smuggling under the Act at terminal two, Dublin Airport, on November 6th and September 30th last year. He has not yet entered a plea on any of the eight charges. Barry Ward SC, for Mr Hussein, told the High Court on Monday his client has been held here 'unlawfully' since November and was entitled to diplomatic immunity. While only Mr Hussein's side was represented in court, Mr Ward told Ms Justice Marguerite Bolger his client was travelling under a diplomatic passport at the time of his arrest last November. Mr Ward is bringing the High Court application to have his client released from Cloverhill Prison. On Friday, Faisal Sadiq Khan of FSK Solicitors wrote to the prison governor, requesting his client's 'immediate' release under the Constitution's Article 40.4.2, which concerns the lawfulness of a person's detention. The request was refused by the prison, which said the release of Mr Hussein required a High Court order. Mr Hussein's lawyers say he is entitled to diplomatic immunity under the Vienna Convention. In a sworn statement to the court, Mr Khan said his client was a diplomatic agent 'within' the meaning ... the Vienna Convention on Diplomatic Relations, 1961, transposed into Irish law'. Mr Hussein is bringing the High Court application against the Director of Public Prosecutions and the governor of Cloverhill Prison. The matter is back before the High Court later this week.
Irish Times
10 hours ago
- Irish Times
High Court confirms suspension of physiotherapist who gave Botox-like drug to clients
A physiotherapist who administered an unlicensed Botox-like product to a number of clients and was found guilty of poor professional performance has been suspended for three months by the High Court. High Court president Mr Justice David Barniville confirmed the sanction of Coru, the regulatory body of health and social care professionals, to suspend the Dublin physiotherapist from the register of physiotherapists for three months, starting in October. Igor Castro, who operates a practice on O'Connell Street in Dublin, appeared before a fitness-to-practise inquiry earlier this year over his use and promotion of Liztox, a Korean botulinum toxin product similar to Botox which is used for aesthetic treatments. The fitness-to-practise committee found an allegation proven that Mr Castro had administered Liztox to three clients at his practice in October 2023. READ MORE The committee also found it proven that the Brazilian native had posted one or more posts on his Instagram account between October and November 2023 promoting the fact that he was administering the Botox-like product to clients. In the High Court on Monday, Coru solicitor JP McDowell, of Fieldfisher solicitors, said the committee regarded it as a very serious matter 'and it goes to the issue of public safety'. He said mitigating factors were considered including that Mr Castro had 'considerable insight into the error of his ways'. Confirming the suspension to begin in October, Mr Justice Barniville noted that Mr Castro had made a full admission and was very apologetic for what happened. At the Coru fitness-to-practise committee inquiry last January, the inquiry's chairwoman, Geraldine Feeney, said the committee made its findings on the basis of Mr Castro's own admissions and the uncontroverted evidence of a number of witnesses, including an enforcement officer with the Health Products Regulatory Authority (HPRA). She said Mr Castro's actions in administering Liztox when it was outside his scope as a physiotherapist also represented breaches of the profession's code of professional conduct and ethics. The committee observed that an expert witness had pointed out that Mr Castro was not legally qualified to administer an unlicensed product which was a 'potentially harmful substance'. Ms Feeney said the physiotherapist had demonstrated extremely poor judgment and brought the profession into disrepute. She acknowledged that Mr Castro had co-operated fully from the outset with an investigation by the HPRA and subsequently the Coru inquiry and had made complete admissions about his conduct which she said had demonstrated insight into his wrongdoing. She noted that the committee was satisfied that there was little or no risk that Mr Castro would repeat the conduct in future based on his evidence, insight and statement of regret. She acknowledged that he had provided the inquiry with several references which described him as a 'conscientious and good' physiotherapist. Ms Feeney said the committee was also impressed by the fact that Mr Castro was undertaking continuous education for the purpose of improving his skills and providing physiotherapy services.
