logo
Experts and officials are still assessing what remains of Iran's nuclear program

Experts and officials are still assessing what remains of Iran's nuclear program

VIENNA (AP) — The big question following U.S. and Israeli attacks on Iran's nuclear program is: What remains of it?
U.S. President Donald Trump has said three targets hit by American strikes were 'obliterated.' His defense secretary said they were 'destroyed.'
A preliminary report issued by the U.S. Defense Intelligence Agency, meanwhile, said the strikes did significant damage to the Fordo, Natanz and Isfahan sites, but did not totally destroy the facilities.
The head of the International Atomic Energy Agency said that as a result of Israeli and U.S. strikes, the agency has 'seen extensive damage at several nuclear sites in Iran,' including those three. Israel claims it has set back Iran's nuclear program by 'many years.'
Officials and experts are still assessing the damage, and their evaluation could change.
Two of the major questions they are trying to address are where Iran's stockpile of enriched uranium is and what is the state of the centrifuges that enrich the fuel.
The answer to the first is not clear, but the IAEA believes significant damage was done to centrifuges at the two enrichment facilities in Natanz and Fordo.
The IAEA — and the world — want to know the state of both the uranium and centrifuges because if Iran chooses to make a nuclear weapon, then making the fuel required would be just a short, technical step away.
Iran has always maintained that its nuclear program is peaceful.
But it has enriched significant quantities of uranium beyond the levels required for any civilian use, and Israel launched strikes on nuclear and military targets on June 13, accusing Iran of trying to develop atomic weapons.
The U.S. joined that attack on Sunday, dropping 14 bunker-buster bombs on two sites. Iran retaliated with strikes on Israeli and American targets. Israel and Iran have since agreed to a ceasefire.
Here's what we know — and don't know — about the state of Iran's nuclear program.
It's possible the nuclear fuel was movedAt least some of Iran's highly enriched uranium may have been moved before the U.S. strikes, the assessment from the DIA suggests, according to two people familiar with the evaluation. The people were not authorized to address the matter publicly and spoke on condition of anonymity.
That would mean that some of the stockpile may have survived.
The assessment was preliminary and will be refined as new information becomes available, the agency has said. Its authors also characterized it as 'low confidence,' an acknowledgement that the conclusions could be mistaken.
The White House has called the assessment 'flat-out wrong,' pointing to the power of the bombs to back up the president's characterization that the sites hit had been destroyed.
Iran has previously threatened to hide its enriched uranium if attacked, and reiterated its pledge the day Israel launched its military campaign. Enriched uranium is stored in canisters that can be moved around fairly easy.
In May, the IAEA, which is the U.N. nuclear watchdog, said Iran had amassed 408.6 kilograms (900.8 pounds) of uranium enriched up to 60%. If it is further enriched to 90%, it would be enough to make nine nuclear weapons, according to the U.N.'s yardstick, though a weapon would require other expertise, such as a detonation device.
Before the war, experts believe the stockpile was mainly stored in two places: underground tunnels at a facility in Isfahan, and in a heavily fortified underground enrichment site in Fordo.
U.S. Defense Secretary Pete Hegseth told reporters Thursday that he was 'not aware of any intelligence that I've reviewed that says things were not where they were supposed to be — moved or otherwise.'
Trucks seen at nuclear facility prompt speculationSatellite imagery showed trucks and bulldozers at the Fordo site beginning June 19, three days before the U.S. struck.
Eric Brewer, a former U.S. intelligence analyst and now deputy vice president at the Nuclear Threat Initiative, said it's 'plausible' that Iran used the trucks to take nuclear fuel away.
But Jacob Kirkegaard, senior fellow at the Breugel think tank in Brussels, disagreed: 'I think that that was a decoy more than anything else.'
Subsequent satellite imagery 'revealed that the tunnel entrances into the underground complex had been sealed off with dirt prior to the U.S. airstrikes,' said Stephen Wood, senior director at American satellite imagery and analysis firm Maxar Technologies. 'We believe that some of the trucks seen on 19 June were carrying dirt to be used as part of that operation.'
Trump offered a similar explanation.
In a post on his Truth Social network on Thursday, he wrote: 'The cars and small trucks at the site were those of concrete workers trying to cover up the top of the shafts. Nothing was taken out of facility. Would take too long, too dangerous, and very heavy and hard to move!'
Gen. Dan Caine, chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, told reporters that the bombs were dropped onto the two main ventilation shafts of Fordo.
He said Iran attempted to cover the shafts with concrete before the U.S. attack, but the cap was 'forcibly removed by the main weapon.'
Centrifuges are highly sensitive and vulnerable to damage
Inspectors from the IAEA have remained in Iran throughout the war, but they are currently unable to inspect any nuclear sites due to safety concerns.
But with the 'explosive payload utilized, and the extreme vibration-sensitive nature of centrifuges,' the agency believes 'very significant damage is expected to have occurred' as a result of U.S. airstrikes at Fordo, according to a statement from IAEA Director General Rafael Mariano Grossi to the agency's board earlier this week.
The centrifuges there are 'no longer operational,' Grossi told Radio France Internationale on Thursday.
Centrifuges are used to enrich uranium — and could eventually bring it up to weapons-grade levels, if Iran chooses to do so.
Natanz, Iran's biggest enrichment site, also houses centrifuges.
In its underground plant, the IAEA believes most if not all of the centrifuge cascades — groups of centrifuges working together to more quickly enrich uranium — were destroyed by an Israeli strike that cut off power to the site.
Its aboveground plant has also been 'functionally destroyed,' the agency said.
Strikes also caused 'extensive damage' at Isfahan, according to the IAEA, especially at the uranium conversion facility and the plant for making uranium metal that's vital to producing a nuclear bomb.
What the damage means for Iran's program is disputed
Much like Trump, Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has said Iran's nuclear program has been brought 'to ruin.'
The Israel Atomic Energy Commission believes the recent strikes have set back Tehran's ability to develop an atomic weapon by years. Israeli officials have not said how they reached this assessment.
The DIA assessment, however, suggested that Iran's nuclear program has been set back only a few months, according to the people familiar with it.
U.S. Secretary of State Marco Rubio, speaking in an interview with Politico, limited his own evaluation to saying Iran was 'much further away from a nuclear weapon today than they were before the president took this bold action.'
Iranian Supreme Leader Ayatollah Ali Khamenei has said that Trump 'exaggerated' the impact of the American strikes.
___
Associated Press writers Sam McNeil in Brussels and Michelle L. Price and Mary Clare Jalonick in Washington contributed to this report.
___ The Associated Press receives support for nuclear security coverage from the Carnegie Corporation of New York and Outrider Foundation. The AP is solely responsible for all content.
___ Additional AP coverage of the nuclear landscape: https://apnews.com/projects/the-new-nuclear-landscape/
Orange background

Try Our AI Features

Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:

Comments

No comments yet...

Related Articles

More people disapprove of Trump than less in latest polls for California, US
More people disapprove of Trump than less in latest polls for California, US

Yahoo

time3 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

More people disapprove of Trump than less in latest polls for California, US

Recent efforts by the Trump administration are shaping the future of California, from the effects of the 'Big, Beautiful Bill' on residents to how federal immigration enforcement policies could impact the state's economy. In July, California saw federal officials visit Alcatraz as part of President Donald Trump's interest in reopening the prison. More recently, efforts to redistrict Texas in favor of Republicans — championed by the president, as USA TODAY reported — have Gov. Gavin Newsom looking to countermaneuver it through California's maps. At the state level, Attorney General Rob Bonta said he's filed 37 lawsuits against the Trump administration, some of which pertain to education, public health, and FEMA-related funding. At the local level, numerous Californians attended one of dozens of local demonstrations held in mid-July to protest the Trump administration. Of course, not all Californians and state officials perceive Trump and his administration negatively. But based on two recent polls, the president's favorability can certainly improve in the blue states. In California, the president holds a net approval rating of -31.6 percentage points, according to The Economist. A Civiqs poll found that in California, 29% approve of Trump, 68% disapprove, and 3% neither approve nor disapprove as of Monday, Aug. 4. Back in late May, a Public Policy Institute of California survey found that 70% of Californians disapproved of Trump's handling of his job, just a single percentage point increase from a February survey. Here are several other recent polls to get a wider view of how people view the president's job performance. Trump approval rating: Gallup, New York Times and more The Economist/YouGov poll: 40% approve of Trump, 55% disapprove of Trump and 4% are not sure, according to figures retrieved on Tuesday, Aug. 5. Emerson College poll: A poll of U.S. voters conducted from July 21-22 found Trump's approval rating was at 46% while 47% disapproved. The credibility interval, similar to a margin of error, was plus or minus 2.5 percentage points. Fox News poll: A poll conducted from July 18-21 under the direction of Beacon Research and Shaw & Company research found that 46% approval of Trump's job performance while 54% disapprove. Gallup poll: Trump has a 37% approval rating in a poll from July 7-21, down several percentage points from his second term average of 42% so far. It's his lowest job approval rating to date in his second term. New York Times poll: New York Times tracks the 'daily average of polls conducted by dozens of different organizations,' showing that as of Tuesday, Aug. 5, the president's approval rating is at 44% while his disapproval rating is at 53%. Quinnipiac University poll: A poll from July 10-14 of self-identified registered voters nationwide found that 40% approved of Trump's handling of his job while 54% disapproved. The margin of effort was plus or minus 2.7 percentage points. Reuters/Ipsos poll: A poll from July 25-27 that surveyed 1,023 U.S. adults nationwide found 40% approved of Trump's performance while 56% disapproved. The poll had a margin of error of 3 percentage points. Paris Barraza is a trending reporter covering California news at The Desert Sun. Reach her at pbarraza@ This article originally appeared on Palm Springs Desert Sun: Trump approval rating: What polls show for California, the U.S.

Rachel Maddow Is Not Mincing Words When It Comes To The "Authoritarian" Nature Of The Trump Administration
Rachel Maddow Is Not Mincing Words When It Comes To The "Authoritarian" Nature Of The Trump Administration

Yahoo

time3 minutes ago

  • Yahoo

Rachel Maddow Is Not Mincing Words When It Comes To The "Authoritarian" Nature Of The Trump Administration

MSNBC's Rachel Maddow says Americans no longer have to fear potential authoritarianism in their own country, because 'we are there' already — and cited President Donald Trump's widespread immigration raids, detainments without probable cause, and use of military force. 'We have crossed a line,' she said on The Rachel Maddow Show, Monday. 'We are in a place we did not want to be, but we are there. The thing we were all warning about for the last few years is not coming, it is here. We are in it. This is what [it's] like, it turns out.' Maddow argued that large swaths of the country might easily overlook this downward slide, as movies are still being produced, sports continue to be played, and families are still discussing the same old issues they always have around their kitchen table each night. 'But also, at the same time, life in the United States is profoundly changing,' Maddow added Monday. 'It's profoundly different than it was even six months ago, because we do now live in a country that has an authoritarian leader in charge.' Related: She then put it even more bluntly: 'We have a consolidating dictatorship in our country.' While the MSNBC host went on to acknowledge that this might sound 'melodramatic,' Maddow noted the US now seems to have its own 'secret police,' which is commonplace across dictatorships, in the Immigration and Customs Enforcement agency under Trump. 'A massive, anonymous, unbadged — literally masked — totally unaccountable internal police force that apparently has infinite funding but no identifiable leadership,' said Maddow. 'And they act in ways designed to instill maximum fear and use maximum force.' Related: Maddow continued: 'I mean, when you imagine an authoritarian country, what you imagine is masked secret police breaking people's car windows and snatching people off the streets and out of church parking lots and courtroom hallways and taking them away with no charges, no notice, no paperwork, no explanation, not letting them see lawyers and then moving them secretly to what are effectively black site prisons where they won't tell you who's there and where no one's allowed in to see what's going on.' Experts have already warned that one such prison, Florida's immigrant detention camp that Republicans have dubbed 'Alligator Alcatraz,' is 'a human rights disaster waiting to happen.' Democratic lawmakers initially blocked from visiting were finally granted access last month and confirmed its horrid conditions. Related: The president has justified nationwide crackdowns on undocumented workers, as well as the detainment, arrest, and deportation of college students and professors across the US, as necessary protection against supposedly violent and anti-American immigrants. Maddow argued it won't stop there, however, and that the US military in multiple states has already 'extended the legal boundaries of nearby military bases' by hundreds of miles 'so they can give active duty US troops the power to arrest and search people on US soil.' 'We are not heading toward something like this,' Maddow said Monday. 'We are there. It is here. It is the environment in which we are now living. And so, given that you now live in a country with an authoritarian leader, the question is: What can you do for your country?' Related: Watch the full monologue here: This article originally appeared on HuffPost. Also in In the News: Also in In the News: Also in In the News:

Crucial exemption allows majority of Canadian and Mexican goods to be shipped to US without tariffs
Crucial exemption allows majority of Canadian and Mexican goods to be shipped to US without tariffs

Chicago Tribune

time4 minutes ago

  • Chicago Tribune

Crucial exemption allows majority of Canadian and Mexican goods to be shipped to US without tariffs

TORONTO — U.S. President Donald Trump raised the tariffs on Canadian goods to 35% last week, but a key exemption for Canada and Mexico shields the vast majority of goods from the punishing duties. Goods that comply with the 2020 United States-Mexico-Canada Agreement trade pact that Trump negotiated during his first term are excluded from the tariffs. Here's a look at Trump's tariffs on the two countries and their exemptions: Canada's central bank says 100% of energy exports and 95% of other exports are USMCA compliant. The Royal Bank estimated that almost 90% of Canadian exports appear to have accessed the U.S. market duty free in April. Canadian Prime Minister Mark Carney said the commitment of the United States to the core of USMCA, reaffirmed again last week, means the U.S. average tariff rate on Canadian goods remains one of its lowest, and over 85% of Canada-U.S. trade continues to be tariff free. 'Canada is better off than any of the trading partners right now because the Americans appear to be relying as a default on USMCA,' said Flavio Volpe, president of the Automotive Parts Manufacturers' Association. 'That gives them the tough tariff headline but also allows them the access to the stuff they need from us. Because of that we're in a relative better position.' Canadian and Mexican companies can claim preferential treatment under the USMCA based on where the products are made. 'The headline news is 35% tariffs but it's somewhat targeted,' said John Manley, Canada's former industry minister, finance minister, foreign affairs minister and deputy prime minister. Manley said Canada is doing okay despite the economic uncertainty. 'There is a lot of resilience I'd say. The Canadian economy has done relatively well, better than most of us expected, and remember that there is no tariffs on any of our energy exports,' he said. Trump said last week he would enter into a 90-day negotiating period with Mexico, also one of America's largest trading partners. The current 25% tariff rates are staying in place, down from the 30% he had threatened earlier. But that 25% only applies to the fraction of Mexico's trade with the U.S. that isn't covered by the USMCA. Shortly after speaking with Trump on Thursday, President Claudia Sheinbaum said that within the 'new commercial world order,' Mexico was still the best positioned nation because of the free trade agreement. 'What's within (USMCA) has no tariff, with the exception of what we already know: autos, steel and aluminum; and what is outside the treaty has 25%,' Sheinbaum said. But Economy Secretary Marcelo Ebrard pointed out that under the USMCA no tariffs were paid on more than 84% of Mexico's trade with the United States. Most imports from Canada and Mexico are still protected by the USMCA, but the deal is up for review next year. U.S. Commerce Secretary Howard Lutnick said last month: 'I think the president is absolutely going to renegotiate USMCA.' Preserving the free trade pact will be critical for Canada and Mexico. 'It would be an incredible disruption to lose it especially if you lost it to the levels of tariffs Trump is imposing, 30%, 25% or even 20%. You can absorb a single digit tariff level across the board but you can't adjust that kind of increase,' Manley said. More than 75% of Canada's exports go to the U.S. while more than 80% of Mexico's exports go there. Manley said that depending on how the trade war plays out the risk to the USMCA is very high. 'Uncertainty in business is the enemy of decision making,' he said. Carney said in a series of recent agreements with other countries that America is, in effect, charging for access to its economy. Manley said the investment thesis for Canada is pretty straightforward as Canada is rich in natural resources, has a skilled labor force, is open to immigration and has unfettered access to the U.S. market, the largest economy in the world. 'If that latter point is no longer the case, we've still got all the others, but we've got to really redevelop the investment thesis for attracting investment to Canada,' Manley said. Trump has some sector specific tariffs, known as 232 tariffs, that are having an impact. There is a 50% tariff on steel and aluminum imports and a 25% tariff on auto imports, though there is a carve-out for Canadian and Mexican made cars. 'Despite our advantages, certain major Canadian industries are being severely impacted by U.S. trade actions. These strategic sectors include autos, steel, aluminum, copper, pharmaceuticals, semiconductors, and of course, softwood lumber,' Carney said Tuesday. 'It is clear we cannot count or fully rely on what has been our most valued trading relationship for our prosperity.'

DOWNLOAD THE APP

Get Started Now: Download the App

Ready to dive into a world of global content with local flavor? Download Daily8 app today from your preferred app store and start exploring.
app-storeplay-store