Department of Social Protection fined €550k for unlawful database of millions of Irish people's faces
The Data Protection Commission (DPC) inquiry, launched in July 2021, examined the DSP's 'SAFE 2′ registration process, which requires applicants to submit biometric facial data used for facial matching as part of their card application.
The Public Services Card is needed for accessing many welfare and public services, including applications for Child Benefit, Jobseeker's Benefit and driving licences.
A sample Public Services Card.
Department of Social Protection
Department of Social Protection
'SAFE 2′ registration has led to the Department of Social Protection holding biometric facial templates for about 70% of Ireland's population, making it one of the largest biometric data collections in the country.
The DPC inquiry found that the Department did not have a valid legal reason to collect or keep this sensitive facial data.
According to the DPC, the Department also failed to clearly inform people about how their data would be used, and the Department's privacy risk assessment was 'incomplete'.
As well as the €550,000 fine, the data watchdog ordered the department to cease processing biometric data for 'SAFE 2′ registration by March next year, unless a lawful basis is identified.
Deputy Commissioner Graham Doyle said that the DPC decision 'does not challenge the principle of SAFE 2 registration itself'.
'The technical and security measures in place for handling biometric data are sound,' Doyle said in a statement.
Advertisement
'Our concerns relate to whether the legal framework and the way the Department of Social Protection operates the system meet the requirements of data protection law. We found clear gaps in that regard.'
The DPC emphasised the need for a clear and precise legal basis when processing such sensitive data, as required by European privacy laws (GDPR), to protect individuals from arbitrary interference with their privacy rights.
The DPC's decision was made by Data Protection Commissioner Dale Sunderland, and was notified to the Department of Social Protection this week.
The Department of Social Protection has yet to comment on the ruling.
'More than a decade late'
The Irish Council for Civil Liberties (ICCL), which has campaigned against the use of facial recognition in the Public Services Card for more than 15 years, welcomed the decision but described it as 'more than a decade late and inadequate.'
Joe O'Brien, ICCL's Executive Director, said the ruling 'vindicates the actions taken by ICCL and Digital Rights Ireland against the Department of Employment and Social Protection'.
He said the ruling also confirmed what they had long argued – that the Department unlawfully collected facial records from millions without proper legal grounds or clear explanation.
'The Public Services Card, which was estimated to have cost the State €100 million, trespassed upon human rights and infringed EU and Irish law,' O'Brien said.
'The Department effectively created a de facto national biometric ID system by stealth over 15-plus years without a proper legal foundation. This illegal database of millions of Irish people's biometric data must be deleted.'
Olga Cronin, Senior Policy Officer at ICCL, criticised the mandatory nature of the facial recognition process.
'The Department unlawfully forced vulnerable people to give it their biometric data before it would help them,' Cronin said.
'It demanded data from people who needed its help to put food on the table. We should not have to trade our biometric data to access essential services to which we are already legally entitled.'
Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone...
A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article.
Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation.
Learn More
Support The Journal
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Irish Sun
5 days ago
- The Irish Sun
Donohoe in grim Budget ‘challenge' alert after €400 social welfare & €560 Child Benefit decision amid tariff job fears
BUDGET 2026 will cut €1,000 from each Irish workers pocket - with the government ruling out €400 once-off lump sums, €250 energy credits and €560 extra Child Benefit-eligible households. The Minister for Finance played down October's budget spending as he admitted Ireland is facing into a "challenge" with Trump's threatened tariffs possibly making an impact in just a few weeks. 3 Finance Minister Paschal Donohoe is hoping for a successful negotiation between the US and the EU on tariffs Credit: EPA/OLIVIER MATTHYS 3 Taoiseach Micheal Martin said uncertainty around tariffs is 'problematic' for Budget preparations Credit: Cillian Sherlock/PA Wire Minister Paschal Donhoe said the US slapping a 30 per cent tariff on the EU would impact job creation and result in worse levels of employment within the economy. He said Ireland's finances are in "good condition" and he is confident the country can rise to the Speaking to RTE's Morning Ireland, he said a trade agreement between the EU and US could be reached before tariffs take effect. But he warned that although the cost of living is "so hard for so many", the current level of spending growth within the economy will have to bet cut. READ MORE IN MONEY He explained that current spending at eight per cent and nine per cent was when inflation was between five per cent and 10 per cent, adding the rate of increase of prices is now at around two per cent. The Fine Gael TD made the admission after revealing Budget 2026 will more "more normal" than last years, which contained a He said the €2.2billion spent on these measures last year may be needed to protect public services and keep public finances safe. It is understood that boosts worth up to €1,000 per worker have been dropped from plans for Budget 2026. MOST READ ON THE IRISH SUN Government leaders have agreed on the complete elimination of one-off payments such as energy credits, double welfare and Child Benefit double boosts. The one-off cash boosts have benefited the average worker by about €1,000 each. In their general election manifesto, promised to increase all core welfare payments by €12 annually while committed to increasing the to €350 over the lifetime of the government. But promises may not go ahead, depending on the impact of severe tariffs. Taoiseach Micheal Martin yesterday said uncertainty around tariffs is 'problematic' for Budget preparations and medium-term fiscal planning. He said: "We're keeping everything under review, but in context of this year, we have fair ideas to where revenue will land and where expenditure will land. 'But certainly we're waiting in terms of the midterm framework, the five year programme that has to be submitted to Europe, it is problematic. 'We can't abolish the Budgetary process, we still have to go and prepare the budget, and we have to prepare estimates, and there has to be negotiations and so on. 'And there are very significant downside risks given what's happening and in terms of the tariff threat. 'Potentially, if we've got it resolved it could be an upside, we'll have to wait and see." Yes, the cost of living is still high. I know it's a huge challenge for so many, but we don't have the inflation levels that we had for so many years that necessitated spending billions of euro." Finance Minister Paschal Donohoe Last year's Budget package included two double payments handed out before Christmas, €400 extra for carers, €300 for those on . It also included an additional October cost-of-living double payment as well as the usual social welfare Christmas bonus. In Budget 2024, a €250 energy credit paid out over two instalments was handed to every household across Ireland - but a similar payment looks set to be cut from October's budget. previously told the Irish Sun : "We have said we're going to move away from one off temporary measures. WHAT WAS BUDGET 2025'S COST OF 'LIVING PACKAGE'? THE last budget, which was announced in October, saw thousands of families across the country benefit from cost-of-living measures. The package, which was worth €2.6 billion in total, was the largest social welfare package in the history of the State. It was made up of a mixture of increased payments and once-off lump sums for Other measures in Budget 2025 included an expenditure of €6.9billion and €1.4billion in tax changes. Energy credits were also agreed as part of a €2.2 billion cost-of-living package included in 'I think when we're making decisions we have to consider them in the context of the overall fiscal parameters that we've set out. 'And in that context, there are lots of ways we can support families in the context of fuel poverty or higher energy bills and that will be considered in the round in addition to the overall capital investment in our energy system some of which will be central to the National Development Plan process that will help mitigate some of the otherwise increasing costs as part of any increase in energy bills.' Calls have been made for a to monthly Child Benefit cash in Budget 2025 - but the government have ruled out a payment rise for every single parent. The State have also ruled out a repeat of last year's one-off €280 cash boosts handed out to those eligible for Child Benefit. Instead, Minister for Social Protection Dara Calleary said that his department is "working on" a targeted form of the payment which would allow those who are most vulnerable to top-up on the existing €140-a-month cash. The €140 flat payment would still be paid to everyone, regardless of income. Last year, 1.4 million people benefited from It included €400 for those on the Disability Support Grant or Working Payment, and a €300 lump sum payment for Fuel Allowance-eligible households. WHO BENEFITED FROM DOUBLE PAYMENT? THE double payment was given to those receiving the Back to Education Allowance, Back to Work Enterprise Allowance and the Back to Work Family Dividend. Carers and those with who receive social welfare benefits such as the Blind Pension, Carer's Allowance and Carer's Benefit also got the double boost. But Minister Donohoe warned that the record Social Protection package including 10 lump sum payments He said: "Yes, the cost of living is still high. I know it's a huge challenge for so many, but we don't have the inflation levels - the five per cent and 10 per cent - that we had for so many years that necessitated spending billions of euro to help offset prices going up. "And it is correct, therefore, to say at this point in time that we can't repeat those kind of measures again and we will need to make sure that we have the enhanced strength in our economy and in our public finances to deal with the kind of risks that we're outlining." JOB LOSS FEARS Speaking to RTE this morning, Minister Donohoe said the amount of investment and jobs within Ireland's economy continues to be "very positive". But he said employers and investors are "pausing" decisions due to the level economic uncertainty currently facing the country. The minister said the forecast excluding the impact of 30 per cent tariffs still shows a high level of employment growth within the economy but he said the number of jobs being created are growing at a small pace. If Ireland is slapped with the 30 per cent tariffs, Donohoe said it is important to be honest that the impact on job creation and levels of employment will be worse. He said: "This is a big challenge, we need to have a moment of recognition of that, but we have faced challenges before and we will get through this one too." SOCIAL WELFARE CASH FREEZE Social Justice Ireland has called for the payment rate of jobseekers aged 18 to 24 to be increased to the full adult rate. But Tanaiste ndicated that the Government may at its current level instead of including it in any social welfare increases in the upcoming budget. Warning that there is "only so much money in the pot", he previously told us: "I do always think there is merit in not looking at social welfare payments with uniformity across the board. 'We've been talking a lot about college fees the last couple of days unexpectedly perhaps but roughly speaking the equivalent of €1.20 or €1.25 on every social welfare payment is roughly the equivalent of reducing the college fees by €1,000. Business group IBEC earlier this week urged the government to take a "measured and strategic" approach to the budget later this year. It said a €3 billion package - including €1.3 billion in additional infrastructure spending under the National Development Plan - is "appropriate for Budget 2026". The lobby group warned that tariffs "post a serious threat to Irish business" and said the economic model Ireland has relied on for the past five decades is under serious strain. 3 US President Donald Trump threatened to impose a 30 per cent tariff on EU imports from August 1 Credit: REUTERS/Umit Bektas/File Photo
The Journal
5 days ago
- The Journal
Where is the Government at with plans to abolish means testing of the carer's allowance?
DURING LAST YEAR'S general election, disability services and support for carers became a flash point that political parties were keen to capitalise on. All of Ireland's main political parties, including Fianna Fáil and Fine Gael, committed to abolishing the means test for the carer's allowance. After both parties re-entered government with the Regional Independents, they made a commitment in the Programme for Government to 'significantly increase the income disregards for Carer's Allowance in each Budget with a view to phasing out the means test during the lifetime of the Government'. 'Income disregards' refers to the amount of money a person can earn per week while still qualifying for the Carer's Allowance. What is the Carer's Allowance? The Carer's Allowance is a weekly payment from the Department of Social Protection to people who care for someone because of their age; an illness; or a disability. The payment is means-tested, which means that a person's income and assets are taken into account by the Department when determining if they qualify for the payment. In 2025, the expenditure on the Carer's Allowance scheme is estimated to be over €1.2 billion. There are currently 100,853 recipients of Carer's Allowance. Advertisement So, where do things currently stand? As part of last year's Budget, the income disregard was increased from €450 to €625 for a single person and €900 to €1250 for carers with a spouse/partner. This took effect from 3 July 2025. Minister for Social Protection Dara Calleary said this change will make the scheme more accessible to people who previously did not qualify. The increase in the disregard means that 5,280 current recipients will receive a higher payment. As a result of this, the Department says 99% of existing Carer's Allowance recipients will now get the full rate of their entitlement. However, many people who are caring for a loved one say this does not go far enough. Family Carers Ireland is appealing to the government to increase the income disregard to €750 for a single person and €1500 for a couple in this year's Budget. The organisation also wants to see the payment increased from €260 to €325 per week. With approximately three months to go until the Budget, for now, it remains unclear what approach the Social Protection Minister will take. What we do know is that, in line with the Programme for Government commitment, there will be a further increase in the income disregard. Responding to a PQ on the matter last week, Minister Calleary said: 'It is important that we make progress in a way that is sustainable and which does not unduly limit our scope to support other vulnerable groups in society.' Readers like you are keeping these stories free for everyone... A mix of advertising and supporting contributions helps keep paywalls away from valuable information like this article. Over 5,000 readers like you have already stepped up and support us with a monthly payment or a once-off donation. Learn More Support The Journal
Irish Times
5 days ago
- Irish Times
Student housing investors ‘spooked' by ghost of Zoom University
The words 'online university' send a spike of fear into the hearts of many recent graduates. They resurface memories of being refined to quarters, forced to attend college virtually in what became known to many as Zoom University. The impact of online college classes on students, however, paled in comparison to its impact on investors in purpose-built student accommodation who were, an Oireachtas Committee heard on Tuesday, 'spooked' by students attending college online. 'Clearly, investors were spooked by the feature of Covid-19 , which meant that people couldn't attend university for almost two years,' said Paul Lemass, the assistant secretary general of the Department for Further and Higher Education . Investors, he said, completed existing projects during the pandemic but in the immediate aftermath, 'stepped back to see what would stabilise' as the new norm in the higher education space. READ MORE Mr Lemass told the Oireachtas Committee that the construction of purpose-built student accommodation was tracking quite well against the projected growth in demand until 2020, but that in the aftermath of the pandemic, commencements have 'struggled to recover'. Eventually, as investors recovered from the terror of Zoom University and looked to restart building student accommodation, the soaring inflationary impact of the Russian invasion of Ukraine hit, Mr Lemass told the committee, though with far less colour. Demand for student housing, as for all housing, far outstrips demand. The committee was told that the estimate of unmet demand stands at 'circa 25,000 beds based on Department of Education student projections from July 2014' . With seemingly ever-increasing demand for student accommodation, the department is currently 'modelling' where growth is as part of new, longer-term projections for the next decade. While the department did not give an up-to-date figure upon request, it is clear the gap is monumental. It remains to be seen if investors will overcome their fears or if, in the search for housing this September, students will be forced to move into crumbling haunted houses or the even more ghastly option: digs.
