The sacking of Simon Goodwin was ruthless but the right call for the Demons
Melbourne's decision to sack a premiership-winner is among the most ruthless the AFL has seen in recent years. It has become all too common for head coaches to be given extra time, whether to build a team from the ground up or to turn around an unexpected decline. But in a cut-throat business where there is only one real winner, as well as several other clubs that might take comfort from at least heading in the right direction, Goodwin sails off into the sunset with the Demons' trajectory going the wrong way.
The 2021 flag was secured thanks to just over a half of football as devastating as has been played on the big stage. With a dynamic and game-busting midfield, led by inspirational captain Max Gawn, there was more than enough to suggest that the drought-breaking premiership was merely the first of many to come for a looming dynasty. Less than four years later and the Goodwin era has unravelled amid diminishing returns. It comes to a close without even another finals victory, let alone a second taste of the ultimate success.
The Demons' 13th premiership was followed by a pair of straight-sets finals exits as familiar problems resurfaced. An imbalanced list stacked with midfield talent and an imperious defence had fewer weapons in the forward half. The team took too long to evolve from a safe but stodgy game plan that failed to create enough scoring opportunities. To make matters worse, the side paid the price as much as any for wayward kicking for goal when the stakes rose.
Goodwin was rightfully given a free pass as his side plummeted to 14th last year. The dramatic drop off was in part explained by on-field and off-field concerns around star midfielders Christian Petracca and Clayton Oliver, as well as the premature retirement of Angus Brayshaw. But the coach was back on shaky ground when there were few signs of improvement during five consecutive defeats to start this year. As the Demons' mid-season revival faded away and they fell out of finals contention, it became a matter of 'when' rather than 'if' the axe would fall.
The 48-year-old said all the right words as he took his turn to be part of the awkward AFL tradition of sending a coach packing with a pat on the back and a stage-managed press conference. Just two weeks ago, Goodwin was adamant that he felt 'incredibly supported by the board' even after a humiliating final-term capitulation against St Kilda. As he fronted the media while seated next to Melbourne president and former player Brad Green on Tuesday, Goodwin allowed himself a smile as he conceded he 'obviously got that wrong'.
The record-breaking defeat to the Saints – when even one of the greatest Demons lost his head in the centre square and Goodwin had little to offer beyond standing on the sidelines and looking perplexed – was followed by an emphatic triumph over West Coast last week. A win over the bottom-placed side is hardly one to save a coaching career but it does make the timing of the call to sack Goodwin with a year left on his contract all the more curious.
Sign up to From the Pocket: AFL Weekly
Jonathan Horn brings expert analysis on the week's biggest AFL stories
after newsletter promotion
With three rounds remaining, Goodwin has declined the offer to coach out the season. He has baulked at the opportunity to enjoy the sort of send-off that a premiership coach typically deserves. The farewell tour would even have begun with a reminder of the glory days when Melbourne face their 2021 grand final opponents Western Bulldogs on Sunday. Instead, the Demons will tiptoe into their next era with clear air and a head start on finding Goodwin's successor.
Goodwin spent 11 years at the Demons including nine seasons as head coach. He was handed a team blessed with top-end talent and ready to rise, as part of a succession plan to take over from coach Paul Roos ahead of the 2017 season. An 11-year finals drought was broken the following year as Melbourne reached a preliminary final ahead of time. The best was still to come as Goodwin led the Demons to heights they had not scaled for 57 years and will live long in their hearts. But the grand old club only has to look to the period before Goodwin took charge, rather than all the way back to the curse of Norm Smith, to recall how a steady decline can quickly turn into something much longer and deeper.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Daily Mail
15 minutes ago
- Daily Mail
Footy legend Jimmy Bartel reveals his abusive father threatened to KILL his mum as he opens up about the holiday with his dad that left him horrified
Footy legend Jimmy Bartel has opened up on his upbringing with his abusive father and how his dad once threatened to kill his mother. In a wide-ranging and honest interview, the Geelong great, who won three premierships with the Cats, revealed that his experiences with his own father have shaped him into becoming a better dad for his two sons. Bartel's parents divorced when he was just one. His dad was Terry Bartel, a sportsman who played cricket and football for several high-profile clubs around Victoria. He opened the batting for Beechworth's senior side at the age of 15. Terry also played as a roving midfielder for the club's footy side, before joining Carlton's reserves in 1968. He would never play first-team football for the Blues, failing to settle in at the club. He died in 2010, aged 60, following a 20-month battle with cancer. Speaking with Sarah Grynberg on her 'A Life of Greatness' podcast, Bartel explained that his perception of his dad changed as he got older. 'He was violent, he had his own issues with his own upbringing,' Jimmy told Grynberg. 'He battled alcoholism, gambling addiction. He was incredibly violent to my mum and others in my family. I didn't understand that as a young kid. I was probably protected and shielded, being the youngest.' He added: 'For a young boy, a teenager growing up who loves sport, your dad is your first superhero. Mum kept all the scrapbooks, incredibly talented sportsperson. I'd see him around his mates. He was incredibly charismatic, great life of the party. 'Not diminishing anything his friends had with him... but that wasn't what I was getting. It became a really tough thing for me to deal with. 'How come I'm not getting that?' or you go around to a friend's house and dad's doing this and that stuff and you get to a point where you ask mum what's going on and she goes: 'He's just different to the others and in time you'll work out why'.' Bartel, 41, no longer chooses to drink in front of his mother or his kids, following the experiences he had with his dad while growing up. He also recounted how he had spent some time with his dad during the school holidays when he was 14 years old. The Geelong 300-gamer lifted the lid on a 'scary' experience where his father had 'gotten pretty physical' with him during the trip. 'I remember coming home and going straight to my bedroom,' he told Grynberg. 'Mum came in and said: 'What's wrong?'. "I just don't think he's the person I think he is"', Jimmy replied. 'I had a pretty average night with him, which was pretty scary for myself. He'd been heavily drinking and he got pretty physical with me.' His mother would go on to place an Apprehended Violence Order (AVO) on his father. But after doing so, Bartel explained that his dad arrived at his mum's house and gave her an ultimatum if she did not lift the order. 'He came around and told her to lift the AVO or else he'd take mum. He did. He took my mum out of the house, and I remember looking out the lounge room window and he was taking my mum,' he said. 'I only found out when I was older. He took my mum out to the back of Geelong and pretty much gave her an ultimatum to remove the AVO or 'this is the end for you'. 'And so it was a tough decision for my mum, do you leave three kids with no mum or you come back home and you remove the AVO and you try and manage things a different way.' Jimmy would go on to enjoy a glittering career in the AFL. The utility player was named in two All-Australian sides, crowned a Brownlow Medallist in 2007 and was named the Norm Smith Medallist following Geelong's victorious 2011 premiership win. During his time at the club, Jimmy revealed that he once received a phone call from his sister about their dad. Jimmy was forced to skip a training session with the Cats, instead driving to meet his father to confront him about his abusive tendencies. Jimmy revealed his sister had phoned him, telling him that Terry had shown up at her house following a heavy drinking session, asking to see her first-born son. She explained he had become 'quite aggressive' with her, which Jimmy said: 'Just flipped the switch for me... I said: 'that's it'. 'I was at Geelong, went to training... I was nearly taking team-mates heads off in training drills. A coach grabbed me and said: 'Get off'. I was really close with this coach and he said: 'What is going on?'. I was blurting it out, I was half teary-eyed. 'He goes: 'Just leave, take all the time you want'. Jimmy explained that he got in the car and drove between three to four hours to see his dad. 'I was pretty irrational in my thinking. I was going to meet him the old-fashioned way. The Hume Highway is a boring road, and it gave you a bit of time to calm down. I spoke to my mum on the phone and she said: 'Don't do something he'd do, promise me that'.' Jimmy met Terry the following day, outside an RSL. 'I checked with my sisters and they were more than happy for me to represent their thoughts. I said to him 'That's it, you've done your dust mate, it's all finished'. 'He said: 'Do you want to fight about it, get it out of your system?' I said: 'No, no, that's where we're different, we're done'. He did step in, and I thought 'there's your opportunity' and then it was 'nup'. 'I got in the car, and it was almost a grieving process then for me. I didn't speak to him ever again, and he passed a few years later.' Bartel later opened up on how the experience had shaped him as a father. He said he feels like he 'overcompensates' now with his own children. He said: 'My boys probably get annoyed I smother them!' ''Give us another kiss and a hug,' things like that, you trick them into believing it's a world-famous hug. Always great words if you need a tip to con your kids! I want to be the dad kicking the football, playing cricket or basketball, or dinosaurs - whatever their interest is. He added: 'But I think it's probably because I never got that experience, so I don't want to leave them short in that way. And I think the other thing is that if I say I'm going to be there or do something for them I'm 100 per cent going to be there. 'I've probably gone the other way - probably the antithesis to it.'
Scotsman
25 minutes ago
- Scotsman
Scott Brown and ex Hibs boss in clear Easter Road prediction as Kris Boyd effusive in praise of 'top' star
Former Hibs and Rangers favourites have been discussing the battle for third place in this season's Premiership. Sign up to our Hibs football newsletter Sign up Thank you for signing up! Did you know with a Digital Subscription to Edinburgh News, you can get unlimited access to the website including our premium content, as well as benefiting from fewer ads, loyalty rewards and much more. Learn More Sorry, there seem to be some issues. Please try again later. Submitting... Hibs have been backed to secure third place in the Premiership table once again after they kickstarted their league campaign with a hard earned win at Dundee on Sunday. Just days after their hopes of reaching the league phase of the Europa League were ended by a dramatic late defeat in a second qualifying round tie with FC Midtjylland, David Gray's side ventured to Dens Park for a start to the new Premiership season. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Two goals in the space of three first-half minutes from Scotland striker Kieron Bowie put Hibs in control of the contest - although their lead was halved moments later when Finlay Robertson found the net for the hosts. It was Hibs that claimed the points to set themselves up for the first leg of their UEFA Conference League third qualifying round tie against Partizan later this week. The aim for the new season for Gray and his players appears to be all too obvious as they look to at least replicate last season's impressive third place finish and push for success in a number of competitions at home and abroad. With an already positive summer transfer window in full swing, Hibs are one of the favourites to secure European football once again - but former Rangers and Scotland striker Kris Boyd believes it will be Edinburgh rivals Hearts that will nab third place behind Celtic and Rangers. Boyd told Sky Sports: "I know there's a mistake in there but he knows where the goalkeeper is, the goal is and he just places it. When it comes back out, you see people slash at them but he's composed. He's a top young player and it will be interesting to see the next few months and years play out with him." On who finishes third, Boyd said: "I am going Hearts." Partnership Scott Brown is set to remain as Ayr United manager despite missing out on promotion to the Premiership via the play-offs. (Photo by Craig Foy / SNS Group) | SNS Group However, Scott Brown disagreed with the former Rangers man as he stated the partnership between Sunday's two-goal hero Bowie and Australia international Martin Boyle will play a key factor in Hibs securing third place when the season comes to a close next May. Advertisement Hide Ad Advertisement Hide Ad Former Hibs midfielder Brown responded : "I am going Hibs. I like Bowie and Boyle together, the partnership up top. I think that's been a big hit so far. So I will stick with Hibs' And former Hibs boss Jack Ross, who was the last manager to lead the club to a third place finish before Gray, added: "Given my background I am going Hibs as well. There's no way I can agree with Boydy!"
The Independent
44 minutes ago
- The Independent
England's Ashes series in Australia to be shown by TNT Sports
England 's Ashes series down under against Australia will be shown live on TNT Sports. Following the thrilling 2-2 Test series draw with India, Ben Stokes' side will travel to Australia, starting with the first Test in Perth in November, with the five-Test series concluding in January. TNT Sports have now been confirmed as the broadcast rights holders in a deal that will also include all international fixtures staged in Australia until March 2026. The previous two away Ashes series, in 2017-18 and 2021-22, were shown by BT Sport, which later became TNT Sports following a takeover in 2023. Cricket Australia chief executive Todd Greenberg said: "We're pleased to extend our longstanding partnership with TNT Sports and that they will again be instrumental in showcasing the Australian summer of cricket to UK audiences." The deal includes Australia men's white-ball series against South Africa and India this autumn and the women's team's multi-format series against India in February and March next year. TNT Sports already had the rights to England's white-ball tours of Ireland and New Zealand in September and October respectively, and Sri Lanka in March 2026.
