Major medical associations sue Kennedy, Trump administration health leaders for Covid-19 vaccine changes
Medical associations representing hundreds of thousands of doctors, medical professionals and scientists in the United States are suing the leaders of US health agencies for limiting who can get Covid-19 vaccines and for undermining overall vaccine confidence.
The lawsuit, filed Monday in US District Court in Massachusetts, was brought by the American Academy of Pediatrics, the American College of Physicians, the American Public Health Association, the Infectious Diseases Society of America, the Massachusetts Public Health Association D/B/A the Massachusetts Public Health Alliance, the Society for Maternal-Fetal Medicine and an unnamed doctor who is pregnant and fears that she will be unable to get the Covid-19 vaccine.
'Our clients are not litigious organizations. They don't want to be in court, and certainly we do not like that we're in the position of having to sue the secretary of Health and Human Services, our nation's chief health officer. So this is a position that I don't think they want to be in, but it's necessary,' Richard Hughes, lead counsel for the plaintiffs, said at a news conference Monday, calling the lawsuit 'unprecedented.'
The groups are suing US Health and Human Services Secretary Robert F. Kennedy Jr., US Food and Drug Administration Commissioner Dr. Marty Makary, National Institutes of Health Director Dr. Jay Bhattacharya and Matthew Buzzelli, chief of staff at the US Centers for Disease Control and Prevention, who is serving as its acting director.
'This step is not one we take lightly,' Dr. Susan Kressly, president of the American Academy of Pediatrics, said at the news conference Monday. 'It's not one we ever wanted to take at all, but we can no longer wait for government officials to sort this out. Pediatricians cannot stay silent as the system we rely on to support lifesaving vaccines is chiseled away, piece by piece.'
HHS did not respond to CNN's request for comment about the lawsuit.
In May, Kennedy took the highly unusual step of announcing in a video on social media that the Covid-19 vaccine would no longer be recommended for pregnant people and healthy children on the CDC's immunization schedule.
Experts immediately warned that these changes could create new barriers to vaccines for those who want them, including confusion around who is eligible and higher costs for patients if insurance no longer covers them.
Kennedy, who has a long history of anti-vaccine actions, also fired 17 members of the CDC's Advisory Committee on Immunization Practices and replaced them with seven new members, some of whom have raised questions about safety and efficacy of vaccines. The committee members serve as outside experts who help the CDC make informed decisions about vaccines.
Last month, in the first meeting of the newly appointed committee, its chair said it would study well-established vaccines and guidelines, the childhood and adolescent immunization schedules and the vaccines for measles, mumps, rubella and chickenpox.
The lawsuit argues that Kennedy and the Trump administration acted 'arbitrarily and capriciously' by changing the Covid-19 vaccine recommendations. The lawsuit asks for preliminary and permanent injunctions to enjoin, or legally prohibit, Kennedy's Covid vaccine recommendation changes and a declaratory judgment pronouncing the change in recommendations as unlawful.
Dr. Sindhu Srinivas, president of the Society for Maternal-Fetal Medicine, said the decision about the Covid vaccine is dangerous for her patients. Pregnancy is on the CDC's list of conditions that can raise a person's risk of severe illness.
'The federal directive has no evidentiary basis in obstetrics or infectious disease,' Srinivas said. 'Maternal immunization is really the best way to reduce maternal, fetal and infant complications, particularly Covid-19 but also from other illnesses, other infections.'
Kressly, of the American Academy of Pediatrics, said that the immunization system has been a cornerstone of US public health but that she and several members of her association have been alarmed by recent actions by HHS to alter the routine childhood immunization schedule. She said the moves are 'jeopardizing its success' and will make children and communities more vulnerable to infectious disease.
Kressly cited the high number of measles cases this year as an example: There have been more measles cases in the US in 2025 than in any other year since the disease was declared eliminated a quarter-century ago.
Anti-vaccine actions are not just rhetoric or politics, she said, they put people at risk.
'Every child's health is at stake,' Kressly said.
Several doctors whose organizations are plaintiffs in the lawsuit said Kennedy's actions have led people to question the safety and effectiveness of all vaccines, not just the Covid-19 vaccine. Dr. Jason Goldman, president of the American College of Physicians, said some of his patients have been 'confused and scared.'
'This doesn't just impact one vaccine. It is impacting the entire adult and pediatric vaccine schedule and putting our patients at risk,' he said at Monday's news conference.
Goldman added that changes to CDC guidance about the Covid-19 vaccine may mean his patients' insurance will not cover the cost of the shots, and without coverage, those vaccines would be too expensive, limiting access to good protection.
Dr. Tina Tan, president of the Infectious Disease Society of America, said that some people may argue that Covid-19 is not a serious disease for children but that 'those of us who have dedicated our lives to caring for children know that is not the case.'
'Some people say that only a small number of children die from Covid, but the only acceptable number of dead children from Covid is zero, especially when we have the means to prevent their deaths and the vaccines that we have available are safe and very effective and can protect these children from getting severe disease and from dying,' Tan said at the news conference. 'It is really unconscionable to take away a parent's ability and choice to protect their children through vaccination.'
CNN's Asuka Koda contributed to this report.
Correction: A lawyer for the plaintiffs mischaracterized the anonymous doctor's situation; this story has been updated to reflect the change.
See Full Web Article
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Entrepreneur
17 minutes ago
- Entrepreneur
Starbucks Wants to Remove Seed Oils From Egg Bites
The coffee giant is also launching a new egg bite made with avocado oil. Canola oil, a seed oil made by crushing canola seeds, is used in several Starbucks food items in the U.S., from the popular egg white and roasted red pepper bites to its sandwiches. But that may soon change. Bloomberg is reporting that the coffeehouse is exploring how to remove seed oils, including canola, from its lineup. A Starbucks spokesperson told the outlet that the company is also adding a new egg bite option to its menu made with avocado oil. Related: Starbucks Is Hiring a 'Global Content Creator' to Travel, Drink Coffee, and Get Paid Six Figures Last month, Starbucks CEO Brian Niccol met with the U.S. Health and Human Services Secretary, Robert F. Kennedy Jr., to discuss health and the company's menu. Seed oils are a top talking point for Kennedy, which he says are ultra-processed and linked to chronic diseases. His administration suggests using beef tallow, or rendered beef fat, instead of seed oils. Salad chain Sweetgreen and burger chain Steak 'n Shake have already made the switch. "We have made a commitment to remove seed oils from our restaurants," Steak 'n Shake wrote on its website. "Our fries, onion rings and chicken tenders are now cooked in 100% beef tallow in our restaurants." Yesterday, I met with @Starbucks CEO Brian Niccol, who shared the company's plans to further MAHA its menu. I was pleased to learn that Starbucks' food and beverages already avoid artificial dyes, artificial flavors, high fructose corn syrup, artificial sweeteners, and other… — Secretary Kennedy (@SecKennedy) June 18, 2025 Still, scientists say seed oils are safe for consumption in moderation, and the FDA says that when substituted for fats or oils high in saturated fat, like beef tallow, using canola oil may reduce the risk of coronary heart disease. There have also been a number of analyses that indicate seed oils do not impact inflammation, Bloomberg notes. Related: It's Pay-to-Stay at Starbucks as the Coffeehouse Reverses Open Door Policy
CNN
20 minutes ago
- CNN
Hundreds of thousands of children have type 1 diabetes. Now, there's a Barbie who has it, too
The latest Barbie slays in a chic blue polka-dot crop top, ruffled miniskirt, chunky heels and an insulin pump. She is the brand's first doll with type 1 diabetes. Dollmaker Mattel worked with Breakthrough T1D, formerly known the Juvenile Diabetes Research Foundation, to design the doll, which aims to represent the roughly 304,000 kids and teens living with type 1 diabetes in the United States. The doll launched Tuesday at the Breakthrough T1D Children's Congress, a three-day event in Washington that brings in kids and teens living with the condition to meet with lawmakers. This year, they're asking Congress to renew funding for the Special Diabetes Program, which was first allocated by Congress in 1997. The program's current funding ends after September. The advocacy efforts have taken on new urgency this year. With so many deep cuts to federally funded projects in recent months, Breakthrough T1D said it's anxiously watching to see if this funding will be reupped. Type 1 diabetes is an autoimmune disease, meaning the body mistakenly attacks its own organs and tissues. In this case, rough antibodies go after cells in the pancreas that make insulin, an essential hormone that helps the body turn food into energy. As a result, the body doesn't make enough of its own insulin, so people have to take insulin by injection or though a pump to survive. Type 1 diabetes is typically diagnosed in childhood but can be diagnosed in anyone at any age. It differs from type 2 diabetes, in which people are still able to make insulin but their cells stop responding to it. In addition to the insulin pump that attaches to the new Barbie's waist, the chestnut-haired beauty has a continuous glucose monitor on her arm – a button held on by a strip of heart-shaped Barbie-pink tape. Her cell phone displays an app that shows her glucose readings. She also has a light blue purse to hold her supplies and snacks to help her manage her blood sugar throughout the day. It matches her shoes, of course. Emily Mazreku, director of marketing and communications at Breakthrough T1D, lives with type 1 diabetes and worked with Mattel to design the doll. Barbie's phone app displays a snapshot of her actual blood sugar readings from one day during the design process. Barbie's blood glucose reading is 130 milligrams of sugar per deciliter of blood, which is in the normal range. Most people with diabetes try to keep their blood sugar between 70 and 180 mg/ continuous glucose monitor has a graph that shows the highs and lows that can happen during the day. The blue polka dots are nods to the colors and symbols for diabetes awareness. Mazreku spent almost two years holding focus groups to get feedback about the features of the doll and to make sure it was representing the entire type 1 diabetes community. 'Mattel approached us, and they wanted this to be a part of their Fashionista line,' Mazreku said. 'And we jumped on that opportunity right away.' The line has dolls with more than 175 different looks, including a variety of skin tones, eye and hair colors. It includes a Barbie with behind-the-ear hearing aids, a blind doll who uses a cane and another with a prosthetic leg. There's also a doll with vitiligo, a condition in which skin loses its pigment and becomes splotchy. 'We know that increasing the number of people who can see themselves in Barbie continues to resonate,' said Devin Duff, a spokesperson for Mattel, in an email to CNN. The company said the blind Barbie and a doll with Down syndrome were among the most popular Fashionista dolls globally in 2024. The company launched its first doll with a disability — a friend for Barbie called Share-a-smile Becky, who used a wheelchair — in 1997. Customers noted at the time that Becky's wheelchair couldn't fit through the doors of the Barbie Dream House, a situation many people with disabilities encounter in real life. That insight is part of the value of having kids play with dolls that have disabilities, said Dr. Sian Jones, co-founder of the Toy Box Diversity Lab at Queen Margaret University in Edinburgh, Scotland. Jones and her colleague Dr. Clare Uytman study how playing with dolls and toys with a range of physical challenges can reduce systemic inequality for disabled people. It's based on a theory of mirrors and windows by Rudine Sims Bishop, a professor emerita of education at Ohio State University. Bishop realized that having diverse characters in books was good for all kids: It helps children from minority groups see themselves mirrored in the lives of book characters, and it gives kids a window into the lives of others, helping them build empathy. Jones says that when kids play with dolls that have mobility challenges, for example, it helps them identify and understand the struggles of people with disabilities whom they meet in real life. 'Barbie in a wheelchair cannot use the doll's house in their kindergarten classroom, so they have to build a ramp in order for her to be able to access the door to their doll's house, for example,' said Jones, who lives with cerebral palsy. When she started her work incorporating disabled dolls into school curricula, Jones said, there were few available for purchase. She mostly had to make them herself. Now, she can buy them from big companies like Lego and Mattel, 'which is wonderful.' Mazreku says the work to design the doll was well worth it. She recently got to bring one home to give to her 3-year-old daughter. 'I brought Barbie home to her and gave her a chance to interact with her and see her things,' Mazreku said. 'And she looked at me and she said, 'She looks like Mommy.' And that was so special for me.' Her daughter doesn't have type 1 diabetes, she said. 'But she sees me every day, living with it, representing and understanding and showing the world and wearing my devices confidently, and for her to see Barbie doing that was really special.'
CNN
an hour ago
- CNN
Hundreds of thousands of children have type 1 diabetes. Now, there's a Barbie who has it, too
Chronic diseases Disability issuesFacebookTweetLink Follow The latest Barbie slays in a chic blue polka-dot crop top, ruffled miniskirt, chunky heels and an insulin pump. She is the brand's first doll with type 1 diabetes. Dollmaker Mattel worked with Breakthrough T1D, formerly known the Juvenile Diabetes Research Foundation, to design the doll, which aims to represent the roughly 304,000 kids and teens living with type 1 diabetes in the United States. The doll launched Tuesday at the Breakthrough T1D Children's Congress, a three-day event in Washington that brings in kids and teens living with the condition to meet with lawmakers. This year, they're asking Congress to renew funding for the Special Diabetes Program, which was first allocated by Congress in 1997. The program's current funding ends after September. The advocacy efforts have taken on new urgency this year. With so many deep cuts to federally funded projects in recent months, Breakthrough T1D said it's anxiously watching to see if this funding will be reupped. Type 1 diabetes is an autoimmune disease, meaning the body mistakenly attacks its own organs and tissues. In this case, rough antibodies go after cells in the pancreas that make insulin, an essential hormone that helps the body turn food into energy. As a result, the body doesn't make enough of its own insulin, so people have to take insulin by injection or though a pump to survive. Type 1 diabetes is typically diagnosed in childhood but can be diagnosed in anyone at any age. It differs from type 2 diabetes, in which people are still able to make insulin but their cells stop responding to it. In addition to the insulin pump that attaches to the new Barbie's waist, the chestnut-haired beauty has a continuous glucose monitor on her arm – a button held on by a strip of heart-shaped Barbie-pink tape. Her cell phone displays an app that shows her glucose readings. She also has a light blue purse to hold her supplies and snacks to help her manage her blood sugar throughout the day. It matches her shoes, of course. Emily Mazreku, director of marketing and communications at Breakthrough T1D, lives with type 1 diabetes and worked with Mattel to design the doll. Barbie's phone app displays a snapshot of her actual blood sugar readings from one day during the design process. Barbie's blood glucose reading is 130 milligrams of sugar per deciliter of blood, which is in the normal range. Most people with diabetes try to keep their blood sugar between 70 and 180 mg/ continuous glucose monitor has a graph that shows the highs and lows that can happen during the day. The blue polka dots are nods to the colors and symbols for diabetes awareness. Mazreku spent almost two years holding focus groups to get feedback about the features of the doll and to make sure it was representing the entire type 1 diabetes community. 'Mattel approached us, and they wanted this to be a part of their Fashionista line,' Mazreku said. 'And we jumped on that opportunity right away.' The line has dolls with more than 175 different looks, including a variety of skin tones, eye and hair colors. It includes a Barbie with behind-the-ear hearing aids, a blind doll who uses a cane and another with a prosthetic leg. There's also a doll with vitiligo, a condition in which skin loses its pigment and becomes splotchy. 'We know that increasing the number of people who can see themselves in Barbie continues to resonate,' said Devin Duff, a spokesperson for Mattel, in an email to CNN. The company said the blind Barbie and a doll with Down syndrome were among the most popular Fashionista dolls globally in 2024. The company launched its first doll with a disability — a friend for Barbie called Share-a-smile Becky, who used a wheelchair — in 1997. Customers noted at the time that Becky's wheelchair couldn't fit through the doors of the Barbie Dream House, a situation many people with disabilities encounter in real life. That insight is part of the value of having kids play with dolls that have disabilities, said Dr. Sian Jones, co-founder of the Toy Box Diversity Lab at Queen Margaret University in Edinburgh, Scotland. Jones and her colleague Dr. Clare Uytman study how playing with dolls and toys with a range of physical challenges can reduce systemic inequality for disabled people. It's based on a theory of mirrors and windows by Rudine Sims Bishop, a professor emerita of education at Ohio State University. Bishop realized that having diverse characters in books was good for all kids: It helps children from minority groups see themselves mirrored in the lives of book characters, and it gives kids a window into the lives of others, helping them build empathy. Jones says that when kids play with dolls that have mobility challenges, for example, it helps them identify and understand the struggles of people with disabilities whom they meet in real life. 'Barbie in a wheelchair cannot use the doll's house in their kindergarten classroom, so they have to build a ramp in order for her to be able to access the door to their doll's house, for example,' said Jones, who lives with cerebral palsy. When she started her work incorporating disabled dolls into school curricula, Jones said, there were few available for purchase. She mostly had to make them herself. Now, she can buy them from big companies like Lego and Mattel, 'which is wonderful.' Mazreku says the work to design the doll was well worth it. She recently got to bring one home to give to her 3-year-old daughter. 'I brought Barbie home to her and gave her a chance to interact with her and see her things,' Mazreku said. 'And she looked at me and she said, 'She looks like Mommy.' And that was so special for me.' Her daughter doesn't have type 1 diabetes, she said. 'But she sees me every day, living with it, representing and understanding and showing the world and wearing my devices confidently, and for her to see Barbie doing that was really special.'
