MSTR vs. MSTY: Growth or Income? A 12-Month Showdown
From April 2024 to April 2025, investors in Strategy (MSTR) and the YieldMax MSTR Option Income Strategy ETF (MSTY) followed two distinctly different investment paths — one seeking capital appreciation through bitcoin (BTC) exposure, the other pursuing monthly income via options-based strategies. Both are linked to the performance of MSTR, but their outcomes and structures diverged significantly.
Strategy, listed on the Nasdaq, has evolved from an enterprise software company into a de facto bitcoin proxy. As of April 15, the company holds 531,644 BTC, making its stock highly sensitive to bitcoin's price movements. Since adopting its bitcoin treasury strategy in August 2020, MSTR shares have surged over 2,500%. However, this growth comes with volatility: Currently, the stock has an implied volatility of 87%, and a 30-day historic volatility of 102%. MSTR is currently 43% below its all-time high set in November 2024, reflecting the sharp swings typical of a bitcoin-correlated asset. The stock pays no dividend.
In contrast, MSTY, launched in April 2024, is an income-focused ETF that does not hold MSTR shares directly. MSTY's portfolio consists primarily of U.S. Treasury bills, cash, and short-term call options on MSTR, allowing it to synthetically replicate exposure without directly owning the stock.
It employs a synthetic covered call strategy, selling options on MSTR to generate monthly income. This strategy limits upside participation but delivers consistent cash flow, appealing to investors seeking regular distributions.
From April 4, 2024 to April 9, 2025, a $1,000 investment in each product produced the following results:
MSTR: Fueled by bitcoin's strong 2024 rally, the investment grew to $1,895, generating a +89% total return.
MSTY: With 13 monthly distributions totaling $36.53 (ranging from $4.13 in April 2024 to $1.33 in April 2025) reinvested on each ex-dividend date, the investment reached $1,591, a +59% total return.
However, MSTY declined 45% over the year due to its full downside exposure to MSTR's price movements, without benefiting fully from MSTR's rallies because of its call-writing strategy. Additionally, consistent high monthly distributions — partly classified as return of capital — reduced the fund's net asset value over time, further weighing on its share price.
MSTY exhibited significant volatility in its own right, often trading at premiums or discounts to net asset value (NAV), introducing additional price risk.
The premium/discount activity in MSTY reflects both investor demand and underlying volatility in MSTR. Early high volatility supported strong option income and trading premiums, but as volatility eased in 2025, premiums narrowed and discounts appeared more often. However, a renewed bitcoin rally and rising volatility in MSTR could reverse this trend, lifting option income, distributions, and investor demand.
While both products are linked to MSTR's price action, they serve distinct purposes: MSTR offers high-risk growth potential tied to bitcoin, while MSTY delivers yield through a derivatives-based income strategy with inherent structural limitations.
Unlike traditional income strategies that focus on low-volatility, stable-yield investments like broad index ETFs or dividend stocks. MSTY is geared toward retail investors seeking exceptionally high income — but who are also willing to accept significantly higher risk and volatility.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
32 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Undervalued and Profitable: This Artificial Intelligence (AI) Stock Has Soared 73% in 2025, and It Could Still Jump Higher
The booming demand for data center storage has supercharged Seagate Technology's growth in recent quarters, leading to tremendous upside for the stock. Seagate is trading at a discount to the broader market right now, and that could pave the way for attractive returns over the next several years. 10 stocks we like better than Seagate Technology Plc › Storage solutions provider Seagate Technology (NASDAQ: STX) has registered an outstanding rally on the stock market in 2025, rising an incredible 73% year to date and beating the Nasdaq Composite index's 7% return by a massive margin. This impressive performance can be attributed to robust growth in the demand for storage in data centers running artificial intelligence (AI) workloads. Let's dig into how AI is fueling Seagate's growth and see how it could pave the way for more upside in this technology stock. Seagate Technology's revenue in the first nine months of its fiscal 2025 increased almost 43% year over year to $6.65 billion. Even better, the company's non-GAAP (adjusted) income from operations has jumped more than fourfold during this period, thanks to higher margins. Management attributes this fantastic growth to the healthy demand for mass capacity storage in the cloud, which has created a tight supply environment and led to an increase in prices. Management remarked on the company's April earnings call that the growing storage demand "aligns with the cloud capex investment cycle and ongoing build-out of data center infrastructure to support AI transformations." Specifically, 90% of the storage in large-scale data centers is done with hard drives because of their cost efficiency and scalability. With the storage requirement in data centers expected to more than double between 2024 and 2028, Seagate estimates this could push annual revenue for the data center storage market to $23 billion by 2028, up from $13 billion last year. Seagate is in a solid position to make the most of this growth opportunity considering its 40% share of the global storage market. Not surprisingly, Seagate's outlook for the recently concluded fiscal fourth quarter was an impressive one. The company guided for $2.4 billion in revenue at the midpoint of its range, along with $2.40 per share in earnings. The top-line guidance is good for a 27% year-over-year increase, while earnings are on track to more than double from the prior-year period's reading of $1.05 per share. For the full fiscal year, Seagate could grow revenue 38%, while its adjusted earnings will jump more than sixfold to $7.91 per share. Importantly, the company should be able to sustain this momentum, thanks to the tailwinds discussed above, and that sets the stage for strong returns. The potential earnings growth combined with Seagate's incredibly attractive valuation makes the stock a no-brainer buy. It is now trading at just 21 times trailing earnings and 16 times forward earnings estimates. The Nasdaq 100 index, meanwhile, has an average forward earnings multiple of 29, which means the stock trades at a significant discount to the tech sector overall. Investors looking for a fast-growing AI stock that's also reasonably priced would do well to buy Seagate before it flies higher. Before you buy stock in Seagate Technology Plc, consider this: The Motley Fool Stock Advisor analyst team just identified what they believe are the for investors to buy now… and Seagate Technology Plc wasn't one of them. The 10 stocks that made the cut could produce monster returns in the coming years. Consider when Netflix made this list on December 17, 2004... if you invested $1,000 at the time of our recommendation, you'd have $699,558!* Or when Nvidia made this list on April 15, 2005... if you invested $1,000 at the time of our recommendation, you'd have $976,677!* Now, it's worth noting Stock Advisor's total average return is 1,060% — a market-crushing outperformance compared to 180% for the S&P 500. Don't miss out on the latest top 10 list, available when you join . See the 10 stocks » *Stock Advisor returns as of June 30, 2025 Harsh Chauhan has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy. Undervalued and Profitable: This Artificial Intelligence (AI) Stock Has Soared 73% in 2025, and It Could Still Jump Higher was originally published by The Motley Fool Error in retrieving data Sign in to access your portfolio Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data Error in retrieving data
Yahoo
44 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Apple Inc. (AAPL): 'What Do We Pay For Apple?' Wonders Jim Cramer
We recently published . Apple Inc. (NASDAQ:AAPL) is one of the stocks Jim Cramer recently discussed. Apple Inc. (NASDAQ:AAPL) has become a regular feature of Cramer's morning show over the past couple of months. The firm's disappointing share performance has caught the CNBC host's attention. Apple Inc. (NASDAQ:AAPL)'s stock has lost 12.4% year-to-date as it struggles to recover from a 23% drop in April after President Trump's Liberation Day tariff announcements. The firm's manufacturing base in China has been a significant pain point as investors have continued to question the impact of tariffs on its income statement. Apple Inc. (NASDAQ:AAPL)'s stock has also struggled due to market perceptions of lacklustre AI initiatives and concerns about slowing iPhone sales. In his previous remarks, Cramer has defended the firm but dismissed its stock buyback as inadequate. He also wondered if Apple Inc. (NASDAQ:AAPL)'s P/E ratio is too high. The valuation continues to remain on his mind as he commented: 'Now the one that we have to watch is Apple. What do we pay for Apple?' Previously, he discussed Apple Inc. (NASDAQ:AAPL)'s share P/E ratio and revenue: 'Apple, which cannot get out of its own way. And I think probably could go down to 25 times earnings. Which is a substantial decline. Apple's a share donor. It's a share donor. A wide view of an Apple store, showing the range of products the company offers. '[On why Apple stock should be bought] No I'm not going to because I think the multiple's too high. While we acknowledge the potential of AAPL as an investment, our conviction lies in the belief that some AI stocks hold greater promise for delivering higher returns and have limited downside risk. If you are looking for an extremely cheap AI stock that is also a major beneficiary of Trump tariffs and onshoring, see our free report on the best short-term AI stock. READ NEXT: 20 Best AI Stocks To Buy Now and 30 Best Stocks to Buy Now According to Billionaires. Disclosure: None. This article is originally published at Insider Monkey.
Boston Globe
2 hours ago
- Boston Globe
US tariffs on European goods threatens world's largest trade relationship
Get Starting Point A guide through the most important stories of the morning, delivered Monday through Friday. Enter Email Sign Up The EU's executive commission, which handles trade issues for the bloc's 27-member nations, said its leaders hope to strike a deal with the Trump administration. Without one, the EU said it was prepared to retaliate with tariffs on hundreds of American products, ranging from beef and auto parts to beer and Boeing airplanes. Advertisement U.S. Treasury Secretary Scott Bessent told CNN's 'State of the Union' program on Sunday that 'the EU was very slow in coming to the table' but that talks were now making 'very good progress.' Here are important things to know about trade between the United States and the European Union. US-EU trade is enormous The European Commission describes the trade between the U.S. and the EU as 'the most important commercial relationship in the world.' Advertisement The value of EU-U.S. trade in goods and services amounted to 1.7 trillion euros ($2 trillion) in 2024, or an average of 4.6 billion euros a day, according to EU statistics agency Eurostat. The biggest U.S. export to Europe was crude oil, followed by pharmaceuticals, aircraft, automobiles, and medical and diagnostic equipment. Europe's biggest exports to the U.S. were pharmaceuticals, cars, aircraft, chemicals, medical instruments, and wine and spirits. Cars from German car maker Audi destined for export were on freight wagons at the Bremerhaven port in April. Focke Strangmann/Getty EU sells more to the US than vice versa Trump has complained about the EU's 198 billion-euro trade surplus in goods, which shows Americans buy more stuff from European businesses than the other way around. However, American companies fill some of the gap by outselling the EU when it comes to services such as cloud computing, travel bookings, and legal and financial services. The U.S. services surplus took the nation's trade deficit with the EU down to 50 billion euros ($59 billion), which represents less than 3% of overall U.S.-EU trade. What are the issues dividing the two sides? Before Trump returned to office, the U.S. and the EU maintained a generally cooperative trade relationship and low tariff levels on both sides. The U.S. rate averaged 1.47% for European goods, while the EU's averaged 1.35% for American products. But the White House has taken a much less friendly posture toward the longstanding U.S. ally since February. Along with the fluctuating tariff rate on European goods Trump has floated, the EU has been subject to his administration's 50% tariff on steel and aluminum, and a 25% tax on imported automobiles and parts. Trump administration officials have raised a slew of issues they want to see addressed, including agricultural barriers such as EU health regulations that include bans on chlorine-washed chicken and hormone-treated beef. Advertisement Trump has also criticized Europe's value-added taxes, which EU countries levy at the point of sale this year at rates of 17% to 27%. But many economists see VAT as trade-neutral since they apply to domestic goods and services as well as imported ones. Because national governments set the taxes through legislation, the EU has said they aren't on the table during trade negotiations. 'On the thorny issues of regulations, consumer standards and taxes, the EU and its member states cannot give much ground,' Holger Schmieding, chief economist at Germany's Berenberg bank, said. 'They cannot change the way they run the EU's vast internal market according to U.S. demands, which are often rooted in a faulty understanding of how the EU works.' European fashion houses are weighing how they would react to higher US tariffs. Taylor Weidman/Bloomberg 'Consequence for many companies' Economists and companies say higher tariffs will mean higher prices for U.S. consumers on imported goods. Importers must decide how much of the extra tax costs to absorb through lower profits and how much to pass on to customers. Mercedes-Benz dealers in the U.S. have said they are holding the line on 2025 model year prices 'until further notice.' The German automaker has a partial tariff shield because it makes 35% of the Mercedes-Benz vehicles sold in the U.S. in Tuscaloosa, Alabama, but the company said it expects prices to undergo 'significant increases' in coming years. Simon Hunt, CEO of Italian wine and spirits producer Campari Group, told investment analysts that prices could increase for some products or stay the same depending what rival companies do. If competitors raise prices, the company might decide to hold its prices on Skyy vodka or Aperol aperitif to gain market share, Hunt said. Advertisement Trump has argued that making it more difficult for foreign companies to sell in the U.S. is a way to stimulate a revival of American manufacturing. Many companies have dismissed the idea or said it would take years to yield positive economic benefits. However, some corporations have proved willing to shift some production stateside. France-based luxury group LVMH, whose brands include Tiffany & Co., Luis Vuitton, Christian Dior and Moet & Chandon, could move some production to the United States, billionaire CEO Bernaud Arnault said at the company's annual meeting in April. Arnault, who attended Trump's inauguration, has urged Europe to reach a deal based on reciprocal concessions. 'If we end up with high tariffs, ... we will be forced to increase our U.S.-based production to avoid tariffs,' Arnault said. 'And if Europe fails to negotiate intelligently, that will be the consequence for many companies. ... It will be the fault of Brussels, if it comes to that.' 'Road could be rocky' Some forecasts indicate the U.S. economy would be more at risk if the negotiations fail. Without a deal, the EU would lose 0.3% of its gross domestic product and U.S. GDP would fall 0.7%, if Trump slaps imported goods from Europe with tariffs of 10% to 25%, according to a research review by Bruegel, a think tank in Brussels. Given the complexity of some of the issues, the two sides may arrive only at a framework deal before Wednesday's deadline. That would likely leave a 10% base tariff, as well as the auto, steel and aluminum tariffs in place until details of a formal trade agreement are ironed out. The most likely outcome of the trade talks is that 'the U.S. will agree to deals in which it takes back its worst threats of 'retaliatory' tariffs well beyond 10%,' Schmieding said. 'However, the road to get there could be rocky.' Advertisement The U.S. offering exemptions for some goods might smooth the path to a deal. The EU could offer to ease some regulations that the White House views as trade barriers. 'While Trump might be able to sell such an outcome as a 'win' for him, the ultimate victims of his protectionism would, of course, be mostly the U.S. consumers,' Schmieding said.
