Insurance brokers accused of ‘inherently unfair' commission structure that favours higher premiums
It claimed that the higher the premium a broker will secure for a consumer from an insurer, the more money the broker will make in commissions. It said broker commissions account for 'an increasing proportion of the overall cost of insurance'.
It said other professions are precluded from charging a fee based on a percentage of the product or services and said this is something that also needs further examination.
In a submission to the Department of Finance, as part of the public consultation on a new Action Plan for Insurance Reform, the Alliance for Insurance Reform said: 'Many brokers now charge a fee based on a percentage of the cost of the policy. This is inherently unfair to consumers as the 'worse' the premium they secure for them, the more money they will make.'
The Alliance called for a detailed examination of the brokerage market in Ireland to be carried out, with strong consumer input.
Commissions paid to brokers for selling motor insurance were 14pc of the premium in 2023, according to the Central Bank of Ireland's 'Private Motor Insurance Report', issued last October.
A separate Central Bank report found the average motor premium is now €616. This means brokers earn €86 on the average motor premium. Both motor and home insurance costs have been rising now for months.
Asked for a response, Brokers Ireland, which represents the sector, said the claim that brokerage charges account for 'an increasing proportion of the overall cost of insurance' lacks a clear evidential basis.
It said the Central Bank's Consumer Protection Code mandates full disclosure of fees and commissions at the point of sale. Brokers Ireland said consumers are fully informed of how brokers are remunerated. 'Furthermore, insurance brokers typically work to reduce overall insurance costs for consumers by sourcing the most competitive and appropriate cover,' it said.
It said the suggestion that percentage-based commissions are 'inherently unfair' misrepresents how insurance intermediation works.
'Commission-based models are a long-standing and internationally accepted form of broker remuneration, aligned with the interests of consumers,' it said.
'Insurance brokers are incentivised to deliver appropriate cover, value for money and ongoing service – all of which drive client retention and trust.'
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Irish Independent
2 hours ago
- Irish Independent
Donegal credit union fined for taking cash from people who were not its members
Swilly Mulroy Credit Union, of Bridgetown, was fined €36,000 after the regulator found it operated a practice of soliciting and accepting cash from depositors who did not hold accounts with the credit union. The 2010 Criminal Justice (Money Laundering and Terrorist Financing) Act requires firms to put in place safeguards against the risk of money laundering. In a statement, the regulator for the sector said: 'The Central Bank's investigation found that Swilly Mulroy operated a practice of soliciting and accepting cash from depositors who did not hold accounts with the Credit Union. 'This money would then be electronically transferred to a branch of a local bank, without first being deposited in an account in the customer's name at Swilly Mulroy.' The Central Bank, which incorporates the Registrar of Credit Unions, said as a result of this action, Swilly Mulroy failed to conduct the necessary Anti-Money Laundering checks on the depositors and the transactions. It said this specific cash intensive practice had been flagged to the credit union sector as presenting a heightened money laundering risk. The investigation found that Swilly Mulroy operated in this way between January 2014 and June 2021. Over that period it processed €8,751,694 in deposits from 2,329 cash lodgements. The Central Bank statement said the 'board of Swilly Mulroy was aware of the risks associated with the practice from 2015 but failed to act on its risk management obligations under the 1997 Act'. A new management team ceased the practice in 2021 and subsequently brought it to the attention of the board. ADVERTISEMENT The issue was not brought to the Central Bank's attention and was discovered in 2022 during an inspection by the Central Bank's Anti-Money Laundering Division, it said. The Central Bank commenced this enforcement investigation in 2023. The investigation yielded multiple examples of cash lodgements, which in the usual course should have triggered additional and careful scrutiny but instead were processed without any Anti-Money Laundering checks. Swilly Mulroy has admitted the prescribed contraventions and has agreed to the undisputed facts in the case. Central Bank's Director of Enforcement Colm Kincaid said where firms allow gaps in their control framework, they create opportunities for criminals and terrorists to use our financial system to pursue their illegal activities. 'This action demonstrates the Central Bank's continued focus on firms' compliance with their legal obligations to safeguard the integrity of our financial system,' he said.
RTÉ News
2 hours ago
- RTÉ News
Central Bank fines Co Donegal credit union for anti-money laundering breaches
The Central Bank has fined a Co Donegal credit union a total of €36,273 for breaching anti-money laundering requirements as well as the Credit Union Act of 1997. The Criminal Justice (Money Laundering and Terrorist Financing) Act 2010 requires firms to put in place safeguards against the risk of money laundering and the 1997 Act requires credit unions to develop and implement risk management systems to monitor and manage risks. The Central Bank said its investigation found that Swilly Mulroy Credit Union operated a practice of soliciting and accepting cash from depositors who did not hold accounts with the Credit Union. This money would then be electronically transferred to a branch of a local bank, without first being deposited in an account in the customer's name at Swilly Mulroy. The Central Bank said that as a result, Swilly Mulroy failed to conduct the necessary anti-money laundering checks on the depositors and the transactions. The probe found that Swilly Mulroy operated in this way between 2 January 2014 and 30 June 2021, during which time it processed €8,751,694 in deposits from 2,329 cash lodgements. The Central Bank said the Board of Swilly Mulroy was aware of the risks associated with the practice from 2015 but failed to act on its risk management obligations under the 1997 Act. A new management team ceased the practice in 2021 and subsequently brought it to the attention of the Board. But the issue was not brought to the Central Bank's attention and was discovered in 2022 during an inspection by the bank's Anti-Money Laundering Division. Swilly Mulroy has admitted the breaches. As part of the settlement dealt, the Central Bank said it had determined that sanctions comprising a reprimand and monetary penalty in the amount of €51,819 were both warranted and proportionate to the size of the firm. The application of a 30% settlement scheme brings the amount to €36,273. The sanctions have been accepted by Swilly Mulroy and are subject to confirmation by the High Court. They will not take effect unless confirmed. This is the Central Bank's 160th enforcement outcome to date, and brings the total fines imposed by it to over €407m. Colm Kincaid, the Central Bank's Director of Enforcement, said that anti-money laundering and counter terrorist financing legislation is designed to prevent the financial system being used to launder the proceeds of crime or fund terrorist activities. "One of its key safeguards is that regulated financial service providers have controls in place to identify their customers and detect potential money laundering or terrorist financing." he said. "Where firms allow gaps in their control framework, they create opportunities for criminals and terrorists to use our financial system to pursue their illegal activities. It is also important that, when firms identify that such control gaps exist, they must report it to the Central Bank, so that appropriate actions can be taken to manage and mitigate the risk," he added. He said today's action demonstrates the Central Bank's continued focus on firms' compliance with their legal obligations to safeguard the integrity of the country's financial system.
Irish Examiner
2 hours ago
- Irish Examiner
Monthly supermarket spending surges by more than €90m
Supermarket spending by Irish households has surged by more than €90m as further data confirms the impact food inflation is having on consumers. Monthly credit and debit card spending tracked by the Central Bank shows consumers spent €1.2bn in supermarkets and grocery stores in May, an increase of €91.5m on the same month last year and an increase of €136m on May 2023. Supermarket spending is the category with the highest value of card spending by Irish consumers each month. The cost of living crisis saw general inflation in Ireland peak at 9.2% in October 2022, largely due to a surge in energy prices. While the inflation rate has fallen to below the 2% mark, food inflation has remained stubbornly high. Data from the CSO, published this week, reports a food inflation rate of 4.3% over the past year. Analyst Kantar, who monitors supermarket prices in Ireland, reported an inflation rate of more than 5%. The card spending data from the Central Bank shows an 8.2% rise in supermarket spending over the past year. Overall card spending in May amounted to €9.34bn, a 9.28% rise on May 2024. The average Irish resident spent €37.70 per transaction in May, up 2.91% on last year and in line with the CSO's Consumer Price Index (CPI) figure of 1.7%. Irish consumers spent €3.67bn online in May and €4.06bn in-store. Spending of €1.61bn was recorded for Irish consumers abroad. The Central Bank noted that the warm weather in May likely impacted the €16m monthly rise in spending in 'Drinking Places' while Irish households increased their spending in restaurants and dining establishments €43m compared to April. Spending on education reached €69m, rising almost 10% compared to April. The sub-category of 'Elementary, Secondary Schools' was largely behind the rise in spending by Irish households, with a €6.1m, or 90.5% increase from the previous month, possibly driven by spending amid Leaving Certificate examinations and tutoring. The Central Bank also monitors monthly cash withdrawals from ATMs. In May, the value of total withdrawals amounted to €1.16bn, up 7.10% on April but falling 7.42% compared to May of last year. The average withdrawal amounted to €145.83 in May.
