After ditching Spotify for a week, I now understand why readers love YouTube Music
A few weeks ago, I ran an Open Thread asking readers why they prefer using YouTube Music over many available alternatives, including my service of choice, Spotify. It would be an understatement to say that it received a flurry of comments and strong opinions from our community questioning my views. With just under 400 replies at the time of this writing, not to mention the big win for Google's streaming service in the accompanying poll, it's clear that I was perhaps missing a trick by siding with Spotify. So, as I enjoy reevaluating my opinions, I once again signed up for YouTube Music to see what the fuss is all about. A little over a week later, I'm thoroughly impressed by the strides made by Google's offering.
I was a happy Google Play Music user for many years, and regularly defended the service when people recommended alternatives. But when Google announced the end of the service in 2021, I was left disillusioned by its replacement. In its early days, YouTube Music was unintuitive and leaned too heavily on its video-hosting namesake. It often pushed video when I wanted an audio-first service. It was also heavily influenced by my YouTube browsing and viewing habits, and was astonishingly slow in operation. In short, it sucked, and I quickly jumped ship to Spotify.
Which is the best music streaming service?
0 votes
YouTube Music.
NaN %
Spotify.
NaN %
Neither (mention your preference in the comments).
NaN %
I don't use a music streaming service.
NaN %
The green team is where I still find myself now, and I've been pretty comfortable with it ever since. The Duo plan allows my partner and me to have separate and combined playlists, and collaborate in real-time via Spotify Jam if needed. I also appreciate Spotify's recommendations and the ease of finding new artists. It fits into my life perfectly.
A surprisingly positive return
Andy Walker / Android Authority
So when I returned to YouTube Music earlier this month, the experience was a shock to my system. A wave of nostalgia hit me as I reencountered some treasured playlists I thought I had lost, from the pop-heavy Turbulence reel for managing my anxiety in the air to Sunny Days, a curated list of tracks that feel like a cool summer morning.
From a more objective lens, the app has changed so much since its early days. A tighter, cleaner UI greeted me, frontloaded with playlists I've made or artists and albums I'd always tend to pick first. There's an angle towards content already discovered, which was a refreshing change from Spotify, where my mission was always to find new songs, genres, albums, and slot these into carefully designed playlists. There's something comforting about using Google's product, something functional and purposeful.
I'll admit that because of this approach, Spotify can sometimes feel scattered. While YouTube Music keeps new content and known or saved music largely contained within distinct tabs or sensible filters, Spotify lays these cards out everywhere on the home screen. At least this is what it feels like visually. I can't say that I prefer either layout, but I will say YouTube's makes better use of its screen space in almost all areas.
YouTube Music promotes content already discovered, which was a refreshing change from Spotify's constant new content push.
What about the experience of playing music? I quickly realized why many people like the service, especially those who love deep cuts. Songs that I couldn't find on Spotify, I found here, which usually took the form of a video from YouTube. This included many long-lost EDM remixes from the 2011-2012 era, like Vicetone's remix of Zedd's Clarity. Leveraging the music service gives YouTube Music a huge content discovery advantage, and the option for users to upload their content to the service, even if it's a bit of a schlep to do it via the website, makes it incredibly valuable for those who want to carry their bespoke content selections around with them.
Andy Walker / Android Authority
Dare I say, I like YouTube Music's Explore tab far more than Spotify's Search tab, even if both act as portals into new content. While Spotify opts for a genre-categorized layout with themed collections above, YouTube Music tempts me with its more analytical system, which includes new releases from artists I already follow and a breakdown of top tracks in my country. Again, Google's service makes far better use of the available space on this tab, switching between recommendations and genuine trending content. This perhaps surprised me the most during my experiment. I have always regarded Spotify as the best of the two for naturally discovering new music, and, for the most part, I feel that the Swedish app offers a better hands-off experience in this regard. But if you're the type to flip through vinyls on a Saturday morning slowly, I can appreciate YouTube Music's charm here.
In the four years since I last used YouTube Music, I'm surprised by how many elements Google has polished.
My partner also mentioned another important point: some artists still boycott Spotify. She was delighted to participate in this experiment, as Spotify does not host Joanna Newsom's music, while YouTube does. That's essential if you're a fan of more obscure or opinionated artists who don't appreciate the latter's financial model.
All in all, YouTube Music has a lot going for it. In the four years since I last used the service, I'm surprised by how many elements Google has polished. However, this is a Google product after all, and some quirks largely ruin its otherwise positive glow.
Google still has work to do
Andy Walker / Android Authority
Remember when I said that YouTube Music uses its namesake to increase its music availability? Well, this does have some side effects. I can't help but notice YouTube Music listing a video playlist of CART/Champ Car races stretching from 1979 to 2007. No tracks are found in this playlist, even though the engine sounds could be considered music to some. So why is a video playlist in my music streaming app? This was one of the core reasons I left YouTube Music in the early 2020s, and it seems that Google still hasn't quite drawn a line between playlists on the two services.
There are some other odd additions that I wish Google would reconsider. While the Comments feature is excellent in theory, usually remarks left by users offer no insight related to the track itself. It feels like a YouTube comment section, which isn't a good look. I'm not a fan of YouTube Music's Samples tab, either. While Spotify is also slowly trending towards music videos, it's far less intrusive. Dedicating an entire tab for music videos on an audio streaming platform feels counterintuitive.
There are some annoyances YouTube Music still haven't shaken, and its silly promotion of video is one of them.
But let's come back to Spotify. There are a handful of features that still sell the service to me. As I mentioned earlier, Spotify Jam is essential in my daily life. My partner and I often listen to music while doing chores, cooking, or driving. So, having an option to add individual songs to a playlist queue seamlessly is invaluable. More importantly, the feature has also rolled out to Android Auto, which makes road trips far more enjoyable and easier to manage. YouTube Music offers no equivalent.
Then there's Spotify's advanced search chops. For a search giant, Google sure doesn't know how to implement smart search in its products. I can search for artist releases in a specific year using syntax in Spotify. YouTube Music does not.
Of course, Spotify Connect is another indispensable feature I use daily on my PS4. I can control music on my phone while enjoying both game audio and my Spotify playlist, and then seamlessly jump that music over to my Nest Mini when I put the controller down. YouTube Music doesn't have this option, so it's either game chat or music for me.
I'm sticking with Spotify… for now
Andy Walker / Android Authority
Although many readers thought I was biased against YouTube Music, I went into this experiment with an open mind. Google's service has genuinely impressed me with its clean UI, innovative use of space, far broader library, and focus on hands-on discovery. However, some of the annoyances that initially turned me off the service still exist today.
There are other practical problems that I haven't yet mentioned, one of which is price. YouTube Music doesn't have a Duo equivalent, so I need to buy the whole Family package to share the service with my partner. Although only marginally more expensive than Spotify Duo, this is still a waste of money.
YouTube Music may make a fan out of me in the future, but Spotify is a better fit... for now.
Of course, Spotify wins on other fronts. As mentioned, Jam and Connect are two unique features that YouTube Music has yet to rival despite Google's expertise in the smart home and service space. The Swedish service is also more broadly available and compatible with the devices I already use and own, while it also offers best-fit plans for my lifestyle.
This isn't to say that YouTube Music is trash. I'll give Google its deserved plaudits: it's an excellent music streaming platform, but it's the small things that Spotify offers that I've grown accustomed to and that I can't quite live without. Nevertheless, I can now understand why YouTube Music has plenty of fans, even if it still falls slightly short for me.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
CBS News
12 minutes ago
- CBS News
Hops and community are on tap at West Sacramento brewery, celebrating California Craft Beer Week
Craft brewers statewide are showing off their brews to recognize California Craft Beer Week through Sunday, July 27. It's an effort to bring community and craft beer together while spotlighting California's best locally made brews. The special edition pint glass, designed by a Sacramento artist, is only $5 and supports the California Craft Brewing Association. Breweries like Jackrabbit Brewing Company are putting their best hop forward, putting a spotlight on their specialty beers and West Sacramento taproom. "You come in, have a pint of beer and get to know your neighbor," said Evey Ramos, the brewery's events coordinator. Jackrabbit's featured "Hop Stomper" beer was an instant best-seller, thanks in part to the familiar face on the can. The A's relocation to West Sacramento this season meant they met the moment by pitching an A's themed can -- with the mascot Stomper featured, it has already been a homerun. "It sold out of the taproom in a week and a half. It was crazy," said Ramos. The Hop Stomper is still sold out, but a new batch will launch in the taproom next week for purchase. With every pour, there's a purpose. The creative process starts in the brewhouse. "Tons of carbonation on this, which is what we go for," said head Brewer Mike Stone, pouring a glass directly from the tap in the cellar. The taste test is part of perfecting each brew. It comes after a lesson in Fahrenheit and fermentation. It's the science before the sip. "Our team just tweaks it one beer at a time," said Stone. The art is in creating something everyone can enjoy. "I worked corporate industry for seven years and found out I wasn't meant for a desk job and found my way into a brewery," said Stone."Watching other people enjoy something I've put a lot of time and effort into, that's the icing on the cake." Despite the dedication and drive, it's an industry in decline. In 2024, nationwide, more craft breweries closed than opened, according to the Brewers Association. In addition, last year the craft beer market also hit an all time low due to rising costs and declining sales. "I think any craft industry is difficult. You're making something with your hands, your heart, your soul and hoping people want to buy it. If you find somebody local who you love and want to support, then please, please do," said Ramos. Drinking and buying craft beer is what keeps the local taps from running dry. This Sunday, Jackrabbit Brewing is finishing off Craft Beer Week with a jazz concert fundraiser supporting local high school musicians. To purchase the West Sacramento-brewed beers, visit their website. Jackrabbit also recently launched a new venture creating custom craft beer cans for corporate of gifting needs. Customers can work with their in-house designer to create the perfect custom label.
Forbes
12 minutes ago
- Forbes
Top 10 Podcasts for Managers and Mid-Level Leaders
Brené Brown's "Dare to Lead" is one of the best podcasts for managers and mid-level leaders. Managers and mid-level leaders may have the hardest jobs in the workforce. They are tasked not with setting an agenda but with following one, motivating their employees to stay on task, focusing on the road ahead, and supporting the vision of leadership at the top. These managers are leaders in their own right but often limited in how much they can effect change, while also hearing complaints from above and below. Balancing all this can be a challenge, and so it helps to know that there are others experiencing the same difficulties and also reaping the many rewards that come with middle-management. This list of podcasts for new and seasoned managers and mid-level leaders can help you find inspiration, new approaches and joy in your job. The 10 Best Podcasts For Managers And Mid-Level Leaders This list was compiled based on podcast ratings on iTunes and other sites, social media presence of the podcast, expertise of the hosts, and quality and diversity of guests. Read on to find your next five-star listen. Hosted by renowned academic and storyteller Brené Brown and based on her book of the same name, Dare to Lead challenges listeners to innovate and create new approaches to leadership. Brown interviews celebrities, cultural tastemakers and thought leaders who give insights into finding your own leadership style and perfecting that approach. Some of her most popular episodes have focused on impostor syndrome, armored vs. daring leadership, creating brave spaces and defining daring leadership. Guests range from the incredibly famous, like Former President Barack Obama, to gifted communicators like author Ruchika T. Malhotra. This podcast is best for managers trying to define and hone their leadership styles. You can listen to Dare to Lead on iTunes, Amazon Music, iHeartRadio and Spotify. From Harvard Business Review, HBR IdeaCast features interviews with business leaders and managers and is hosted by HBR Executive Editor Alison Beard and Senior Editor Curt Nickisch. Each episode provides actionable tips for making day-to-day decisions easier and maximizing time. Topics range from finding ways to utilize artificial intelligence (AI) for training and project management to the wisdom of immigrant entrepreneurs. Guests include Moms Demand Action founder Shannon Watts, Harvard University President Emeritus Lawrence H. Summers and Amazon CEO Andy Jassy. This podcast is best for up-and-coming managers looking to establish their footing. You can listen to HBR IdeaCast on iTunes, YouTube, Amazon Music, iHeartRadio and Spotify. Host Adrion Porter started Gen X Amplified with Adrion Porter to give voice to the generation stuck between the Baby Boomers and Millennials. He focuses on mid-career leaders who have learned from both experience and observing those above and below them, offering unique insights into everyday leadership. Topics include reaching your full potential at work, creating a purposeful career path, recovering from burnout and how to cultivate empathy. Guests tend less toward celebrities and more toward authors, journalists and creators, such as CNBC's Jon Fortt, equity strategist and author Tara Jaye Frank and Ian Schafer, president of Issa Rae's Ensemble. This podcast is best for mid-career managers looking for inspiration as they aim even higher. You can listen to Gen X Amplified with Adrion Porter on iTunes, Audible, YouTube, Amazon Music and Spotify. Adam Grant, an organizational psychologist, delves into workplaces that have incorporated innovative strategies to make every day more productive and actually fun. His message on WorkLife with Adam Grant: Work doesn't have to suck, and anyone can play a role in changing the culture. Topics include improving meetings (oh hallelujah!), the pitfalls of charisma and how to avoid that trap, navigating bureaucracy, and how to stop chasing perfectionism. The guests include a mix of everyday people and workplace experts as well as the occasional A-list celebrity like Dolly Parton. This podcast is best for managers looking to encourage changes in their work culture but uncertain where to begin. You can listen to WorkLife With Adam Grant on iTunes, TED, Amazon Music, YouTube, iHeartRadio and Spotify. Radical candor is the idea of stating your honest opinion, the positive and negative, while exhibiting empathy for the other person. Kim Scott's book Radical Candor inspired this podcast, where Scott and Radical Candor co-founder Jason Rosoff speak to lead Radical Candor coach Amy Sandler about the concept and how to deploy it. Topics include deep dives on employee one-on-one sessions and how to improve them, the problem with vanishing vacations, how to become a boss, and how to give feedback to employees about their tone. Not every episode has a guest, but notable ones include Google Distinguished Designer Ryan Germick, The Economist's 'Bartleby' columnist Andrew Palmer. This podcast is best for managers looking to improve their communication skills. You can listen to The Radical Candor Podcast on iTunes, YouTube, Amazon Music, iHeartRadio and Spotify. You don't need to be an entrepreneur to benefit from EntreLeadership, from noted financial guru Dave Ramsey's Ramsey Solutions. Ramsey offers business and leadership coaching, with a generous dose of encouragement for those finding their footing in the entrepreneurial world—but these tips are also applicable to middle managers. Topics often touch on current events, such as the impact of tariffs on business, and managers can skip most of those. But the in-depth considerations of issues like when to intervene when someone you supervise is having a problem and when leadership structure becomes a problem are definitely worth your time. Ramsey uploads new episodes several times a week, too. This podcast is best for anyone looking for inspiration. You can listen to EntreLeadership on iTunes, YouTube, Amazon Music, iHeartRadio and Spotify. Hosted by twins identified only as 'The Recruiter' and 'The Expert,' The Career Salon With the HR Twins draws on their more than 38 years of combined experience in human resources and recruiting to advise listeners on critical aspects of business. Their fun rapport and curiosity make this listen fly by. Topics range from in-the-weeds breakdowns of performance improvement plans to hiring dos and don'ts from an attorney. The twins usually have at least one guest, often chief people officers or recruiters, but they also examine general trends in HR and offer insights based on their real-world experience. This podcast is best for managers involved in hiring. You can listen to The Career Salon With The HR Twins on iTunes, Overcast and Spotify. What have seasoned leaders learned over the years and how can managers put those lessons to work for them? That question drives The Global Leadership Podcast, hosted by Global Leadership Network executives Whitney Putnam and David Ashcraft. Whether you want to know how to manage conflict or increase productivity, they have answers. Topics include using science-backed theories that have helped high-level athletes in the workplace, how to focus on high-level work, and applying military strategies to the workplace. Guests are experts in their fields, which may be a Navy pilot, a bestselling author or a scientist, though sometimes it's just Ashcraft sharing his expertise. This podcast is best for managers struggling to focus their work who want to become more productive. You can listen to The Global Leadership Podcast on iTunes, YouTube, iHeartRadio and Spotify. LinkedIn co-founder and Greylock partner Reid Hoffman has experienced business success and knows how others can try to achieve it. His podcast, Masters of Scale, features other successful founders, CEOs and entrepreneurs who share how they overcame challenges and break down how they achieved their biggest triumphs. Topics include how to grow small businesses, navigating global expansion and ways AI can benefit managers. He also tackles timely issues in the news. Hoffman's list of guests is a who's who of the business world, including authors John Green and Suzy Welch, Starbucks CEO Brian Niccol and PBS President and CEO Paula Kerger. This podcast is best for managers looking for outside-the-box ideas. You can listen to Masters of Scale on iTunes, YouTube, Amazon Music, iHeartRadio and Spotify. No matter your identity, you can find inspiration and advice from Latina Leadership Podcast, an insightful show focused on navigating life and work with purpose and progress. Anjelica Cazares founded the podcast during the pandemic to help bring Latina women together. Other co-hosts are Olga Rodriguez, Susie Barrera and Andrea Diaz. Topics include maintaining mental health, the ups and downs of launching a new business, how to navigate working with family (a great niche topic that is hard to find honest coverage on), and finding reliable role models. Guests include a who's who of Latina women in business (plus many others), from IT executives to dietitians to health care providers. This podcast is best for managers looking for support and reassurance. You can listen to Latina Leadership Podcast on iTunes, YouTube, Amazon Music, iHeartRadio and Spotify. Grab your AirPods and plug in to any one of these insightful and often uplifting podcasts for managers and mid-level leaders to help you take your career to the next level.
Bloomberg
12 minutes ago
- Bloomberg
How Companies Can Harness That Meme Energy
By Meme stocks. They're back! This time around it's GoPro, Beyond Meat, Kohl, Krispy Kreme and Opendoor Tech. Think short squeezes, sudden price moves (Opendoor up 300% in a few months and down 50% in a week), lots of Reddit chat and much money made and lost. It's all a lot of fun (bar the losing bit).
