Kerrville didn't have weather sirens used by other cities
'We didn't know this flood was coming,' Kelly told reporters. 'Rest assured, no one knew this kind of flood was coming. We have floods all the time. This is the most dangerous river valley in the United States and we deal with floods on a regular basis. When it rains, we get water. We had no reason to believe that this was going to be anything like what's happened here. None whatsoever.'
Nicole Wilson, 42, watched the news conference from her home in San Antonio and was 'blown away.' Wilson told KXAN two of her friends have daughters that were at Camp Mystic and one had a son at Camp La Junta. All three children are accounted for. One of the girl's cousins, however, is still missing, she said.
'Just not having those plans in place is crazy to think about,' she said. 'That they wouldn't have risk mitigation in place when you're surrounded by water.'
Conflicting officials, social posts leave evacuation delay questions in Kerr County flooding
While the National Weather Service issued flash flood warnings and the city of Kerrville's Facebook paged warned to 'move to higher ground immediately,' the young campers at Camp Mystic likely wouldn't have seen that since cell phones, smart watches, iPads and anything with Wi-Fi capability were considered 'unacceptable electronic devices' to bring and 'not allowed,' according to a recent list of instructions sent to parents.
Camp Mystic is located less than 20 miles west of Kerrville in Hunt, which is in Kerr County.
Wilson was born and raised in Kentucky, where she said outdoor weather sirens – primarily used for tornadoes – were common. On July 5, she started a Change.org online petition 'urgently' calling for Kerrville and Kerr County to implement an outdoor early warning siren system for life-threatening emergencies, like flooding. So far, she said she's received 'a lot of positive feedback on that.'
'The tragic events at Camp Mystic and the devastating flooding along the Guadalupe River that happened in July are stark reminders that severe weather can strike with little notice,' Wilson wrote. 'A well-placed siren system will provide critical extra minutes for families, schools, camps, businesses, and visitors to seek shelter and evacuate when needed. This is not just a wish – it is a necessary investment in public safety.'
Indeed, outdoor weather alert systems are not required by any federal or state law. The choice is left up to local leaders. On Friday morning, less than 20 miles from Kerrville, emergency sirens blasted in the unincorporated Kendall County community of Comfort, according to a published report, signaling 'emergency conditions and a mandatory evacuation' as the Guadalupe River continued to rise. Sirens are typically activated by city or county officials, according to the NWS.
'I just think if they had five minutes [of warning time from a siren] longer, five to 10 minutes longer, and that's what those sirens give you …. and you know the counselors would have led them uphill …I don't believe we'd be in the scenario right now where we're searching for those girls,' said Wilson.
Cities that use sirens, like San Marcos — which has 14 outdoor weather sirens to warn of floods, tornadoes and wildfires — have previously touted the outdoor warning system as a 'vital tool' for emergency preparedness. The sirens, called an Outdoor Warning System, are designed to quickly and loudly notify a community of threats to public safety, including severe weather. San Marcos notes its sirens emit unique sound patterns for different emergencies. Critics say they can be expensive, require regular maintenance, are primarily designed to be heard outdoors and aren't as effective as weather radios and mobile alerts. A single siren can cost an estimated $10,000 to $50,000 and multiple are sometimes needed.
Austin doesn't have a city-wide outdoor weather siren system. In 2022, a city spokesperson told KXAN the fastest way to get information out is with 'the technology we have today' and there was a concern that sirens could 'cause confusion.'
This past legislative session, lawmakers filed a bill that would have created a council to operate a grant program assisting local governments with acquiring emergency communications equipment. One of its tasks, if the bill had passed, would have been to develop a statewide strategic plan that included 'the use of outdoor warning sirens.' The council would have also been asked to 'develop and implement, as advisable, emergency alert systems and incorporate as necessary communication technologies into the emergency communications network of this state.'
In 2018, Kerr County, along with the Upper Guadalupe River Authority, applied for a $1 million grant for a flood warning system.
'That application was not selected, okay. That's the bad news,' a commissioner said, according to Kerr County commissioner meeting minutes at the time.
Two years later, in 2020, according to Kerr County meeting minutes, that same commissioner said: 'We've been trying to get a new flood warning system here.'
The 2020 commissioner meeting is when Kerr County implemented IPAWS, or Integrated Public Alert & Warning System through FEMA, which is a free program offered through Kerr County's existing contract with CodeRed, a system it currently uses for mass emergency pre-recorded emergency telephone messages, according to Kerr County's website. The CodeRed system is also used in Kerrville with the caveat that it relies on White Pages data and residents should not 'assume their number is included.'
As of 2023, Kerr County Commissioners' Court meeting minutes show the county was still discussing grant options for flood mitigation assistance to include research on engineering and infrastructure for flood prevention measures.
In an interview with the New York Times, Kelly said one reason Kerr County doesn't have a flood warning system is due to the cost.
'Taxpayers won't pay for it,' Kelly is quoted as saying.
Asked if residents might reconsider now, he responded: 'I don't know.'
Copyright 2025 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.
Hashtags
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Yahoo
19 minutes ago
- Yahoo
Search for missing in Texas floods grows desperate as more storms loom: Live updates
Rescue teams on Monday were traversing storm-ravaged terrain and scouring for signs of life as a search for those missing in central Texas grew more desperate and a threat of more flooding loomed. Hundreds of local, state and federal authorities as well as scores of local volunteers were involved as the search entered its fourth day. At least 81 people have died in the flooding since Friday, including at least 28 children in Kerr County alone – the epicenter of the deadly flash floods that came as many were sleeping, officials said. Across the state, 41 known people remained unaccounted for, said Texas Gov. Greg Abbott, noting that the number of missing people is higher as thousands were in the Texas Hill Country celebrating Independence Day weekend when the floods broke out. The missing include 10 children and a counselor from Camp Mystic, a beloved all girls Christian camp near the Guadalupe River, which became a mass torrent of water as it surged over 26 feet in less than an hour on Friday. As rescuers search for people by air, land and water, officials are warning those in central Texas that the flooding threat is not over. Abbott on Sunday said that expected storms "pose life-threatening danger" especially in parts of the state such as Kerrville that have been inundated with heavy rain. 'If you're in any of those regions, you need to realize, for one, you're in an area that is already saturated with water,' he said. "When more water comes down, it could lead to rapid flash flooding events." The National Weather Service extended a flood watch through 7 p.m. local time as downpours were expected through Monday, including in hard-hit parts of the state. Federal forecasters said it's difficult to pinpoint exact locations where the heaviest rain will fall, noting that an uptick in intensity is possible over the Hill Country, where the worst of deadly floods have occurred. Widespread rainfall amounts of 2 to 4 inches were expected, forecasters said, warning that some areas could receive 10 inches of rain. "The thunderstorms should become more organized and move westward possibly across the flood-ravaged portion of Texas during the day today," the weather service said Monday. Trump said he expects to visit Texas later this week after catastrophic flooding caused extensive death and destruction in the state. "Probably on Friday," Trump told reporters on Sunday when asked about visiting the state. "We wanted to leave a little time. I would've done it today, but we'd just be in their way." Earlier on Sunday, Trump signed a major disaster declaration for hard-hit Kerr County, unlocking federal funding for first responders on the ground and offering FEMA assistance to victims of the flooding. — Zac Anderson This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Texas flooding live updates: Rain poses threat amid search for missing
Newsweek
37 minutes ago
- Newsweek
Texas Floods: Celebrities Speak Out as Death Toll Rises
Based on facts, either observed and verified firsthand by the reporter, or reported and verified from knowledgeable sources. Several celebrities have spoken out about the devastating floods in central Texas as the death toll continues to rise. At least 82 people have been confirmed dead at the time of publication—including 28 children, The Associated Press reported. The Context Camp Mystic, a Christian girls' camp in Kerr County, was hit by devastating flash flooding on Friday. The Guadalupe River, which sits next to the campsite, reached 26 feet in just 45 minutes, per AP, and washed away homes in the area as well. Ten girls and a counselor are still missing. The flooding comes just weeks after torrential rain hit San Antonio. Kerr County is located approximately 65 miles northwest of the city. What To Know Texas actor Matthew McConaugheylamented the "pain" and "chaos" caused by the flooding and called for those who can to "lend a helping hand." Khloé Kardashian said she couldn't "stop thinking about the families in Texas and the overwhelming pain they're going through." The National Weather Service issued warnings on Thursday and Friday ahead of the catastrophic floods. Avery Tomasco, Emmy-winning meteorologist at CBS Austin, posted to X, formerly Twitter, on Friday: "FLASH FLOOD EMERGENCY now for western Kerr county 'This is a PARTICULARLY DANGEROUS SITUATION. SEEK HIGHER GROUND NOW! Life threatening flash flooding of low water crossings, small creeks and streams, urban areas, highways, streets and underpasses.' #txwx" He added: "The Guadalupe River is rising rapidly west of Kerrville. Major flooding now expected near Hunt, TX. Moderate to major flooding of the Guadalupe likely in Kerrville." That same day, Tomasco said he "reached out to Camp Mystic" but "their phone lines are either down or busy. No word yet on their status." Meteorologist Cary Burgess told Newsweek the Camp Mystic disaster was eerily similar to a 1987 Guadalupe River flood that killed 10 Christian campers. A search and recovery worker shines his flashlight through through waters near Camp Mystic on July 6, 2025 in Hunt, Texas. (L) Matthew McConaughey attends the premiere of "Sing 2" on December 12, 2021 in... A search and recovery worker shines his flashlight through through waters near Camp Mystic on July 6, 2025 in Hunt, Texas. (L) Matthew McConaughey attends the premiere of "Sing 2" on December 12, 2021 in Los Angeles, California. (R) Jennifer Garner attends the premiere of Netflix's "Family Switch" at AMC The Grove 14 on November 29, 2023 in Los Angeles, California. More;;What People Are Saying President Donald Trump spoke out about the flooding, writing via Truth Social on Sunday: "I just signed a Major Disaster Declaration for Kerr County, Texas, to ensure that our Brave First Responders immediately have the resources they need. These families are enduring an unimaginable tragedy, with many lives lost, and many still missing. The Trump Administration continues to work closely with State and Local Leaders. Secretary of Homeland Security Kristi Noem was on the ground yesterday with Governor Greg Abbott, who is working hard to help the people of his Great State. Our incredible U.S. Coast Guard, together with State First Responders, have saved more than 850 lives. GOD BLESS THE FAMILIES, AND GOD BLESS TEXAS!" Texas Governor Greg Abbott praised the National Guard on X: "The Texas National Guard has done an amazing job rescuing people in peril. They truly are Texans helping Texans. @TexasGuard" Singer Shakira said on X: "Dear San Antonio, Our hearts and prayers are with those affected by the flood in Central Texas. We are donating a portion of tonight's show proceeds to Catholic Charities of San Antonio, who are providing disaster relief to the families impacted." Dear San Antonio, Our hearts and prayers are with those affected by the flood in Central Texas. We are donating a portion of tonight's show proceeds to Catholic Charities of San Antonio, who are providing disaster relief to the families impacted. If you would like to join me in... — Shakira (@shakira) July 5, 2025 Khloé Kardashian posted via her Instagram Stories: "I can't stop thinking about the families in Texas and the overwhelming pain they're going through right now. As a mother, this kind of tragedy hits in a place words can't reach. The loss of those sweet, innocent children is something I can't fully process, there are just no words for this. My heart is so deeply aching for every parent, every family member, and every community. Please know that so many of us are carrying you in our hearts right now and I'm praying with everything I have in me for those still missing. Texas, we are holding you close." Her mother, Kris Jenner, wrote on her Instagram Stories: "My heart is absolutely shattered by the devastating floods in Texas and the unimaginable loss of those precious children. It's a tragedy that's impossible to comprehend and heartbreaking beyond measure. No family should ever have to experience such sorrow. Life is so fragile, and at times unbearably unfair. To the families living this nightmare, we are holding you in our hearts, praying for strength, and grieving alongside you. I am so deeply sorry for your loss, and praying with all my heart that those still missing are found safe." Matthew McConaughey said on Instagram: "At least 70 lives have been lost, many more unaccounted for, and countless Texans are hurting—inside and out. If you're able, please lend a helping hand where and how you can. It's gonna be a long road ahead, but right now the shock, the pain, and the chaos need the steady hand of a neighbor. Texans are some of the most resilient and generous people on the planet." Singer Maren Morris posted to Instagram: "thinking of my home state right now. the floods are devastating and people are still missing. there are several places to donate but i'll be donating to an incredibly impactful fund called the Texas Hill Country Community Foundation. they've set up a specific fund to support local efforts (nonprofits, local government, first responders and local shelters). link in my stories + bio." Country singer Miranda Lambert shared a video to Instagram and captioned it: "Texas needs our help. As always @muttnation Foundation is jumping in to support, and if you'd like to join us please support our fundraiser." Actress Jamie Lee Curtis reshared a post to her Instagram Stories by radio host Anne Hudson of a group of girls at Camp Mystic: "This entire cabin of sweet girls and their two counselors washed away... Several bodies have been recovered, several are still missing. Praying hard that they find survivors and praying extra hard for the families who are living a parent's worst nightmare." Actress Jennifer Garner wrote on her Instagram Stories: "Texas. God, be near." John Rich, one half of the country music duo Big & Rich, stated on X: "Thinking of our neighbors in Texas. In 1987, this exact same thing happened. What a horrific situation." Former first lady of California Maria Shriver took to her Instagram, writing: "Today my prayers are with the families in Texas impacted by the flooding on the Guadalupe River in Central Texas. Right now they need us all to hold them in a circle of love. Let's unite to hold them, pray for them, and pray for the safe return of the more than 2 dozen girls from Camp Mystic in Kerr County, northeast of San Antonio, who were still unaccounted for by late Saturday morning. As a parent myself, my heart is with absolutely everyone who is feeling this loss. #abovethenoise" What Happens Next Search and rescue operations entered a fourth day on Monday as authorities continue to look for those who are still unaccounted for in the floods.
Yahoo
42 minutes ago
- Yahoo
National Weather Service defends its flood warnings amid fresh scrutiny of Trump staff cuts
Fatal floods in Texas that left thousands scrambling for safety with little warning have sparked a fresh round of scrutiny of Trump administration cuts to the National Weather Service. At least 81 people were dead and many others were missing Sunday evening after floodwaters surged through Texas Hill Country, an area known as 'flash flood alley.' Within hours of the deluge early Friday, some Texas officials were critical of the NWS, saying forecasts underestimated the rainfall. Sunday, President Donald Trump rejected the idea of investigating whether NWS cuts had left key vacancies, and the White House said claims that NWS cuts had anything to do with the tragedy were 'disgusting.' Independent meteorologists and a former NWS official said warnings issued in the run-up to the flooding were about as timely and accurate as could be expected with the weather data available in real time. Predicting extreme rain and flash flooding beyond several hours is challenging, they said, and it is also not easy to ensure urgent warnings reach those most at risk. 'The forecasting was good. The warnings were good. It's always about getting people to receive the message,' said Chris Vagasky, a meteorologist based in Wisconsin. 'It appears that is one of the biggest contributors — that last mile.' The meteorologists said they did not think understaffed offices were a primary factor in the tragic outcome, even though the NWS has leadership gaps after a rash of staffing cuts. Tom Fahy, the legislative director for the National Weather Service Employees Organization, a union that represents government employees, said the San Antonio weather forecasting office did not have two of its top positions filled — a permanent science officer (a role that conducts training and is in charge of implementing new technology) or a warning coordination meteorologist (who coordinates with the media and is the public face of the office), though there are employees acting in those leadership roles. Overall, Fahy said, the offices had enough meteorologists to respond to the event. 'The WFOs [weather forecasting offices] had adequate staffing and resources as they issued timely forecasts and warnings leading up to the storm,' Fahy said Saturday, but he added that he was concerned about the unfilled senior positions and vacuums of leadership. In a statement, the NWS said it was 'heartbroken by the tragic loss of life in Kerr County.' It did not address questions about staffing but provided a detailed timeline of the warnings it sent out. Some Texas officials have suggested the National Weather Center forecast did not convey the storm's threat, while others said they were grateful for timely alerts from the agency. 'The original forecast that we received on Wednesday from the National Weather Service predicted 3 to 6 inches of rain in the Concho Valley and 4 to 8 inches of rain in the Hill Country,' Texas Emergency Management Chief W. Nim Kidd said at a news conference Friday. 'The amount of rain that fell in this specific location was never in any of those forecasts nonetheless.' The National Weather Center indicated Kerrville, Texas, and its surrounding areas could be at risk of flash flooding Thursday, according to the National Weather Service timeline. Then, NWS Austin/San Antonio issued a flood watch at 1:18 p.m. Thursday into Friday morning. It issued its urgent flash flood warnings for Kerr County at 1:14 a.m. Andy Brown, the Travis County judge, or chief executive, thanked the NWS for its alerts. Eric Carter, the county's chief emergency management coordinator, described the weather service as being 'very proactive in their warnings.' The agency noted that it sent out a flash flood warning with tags of 'considerable' or 'catastrophic' at 1:14 a.m. CT Friday, which would trigger wireless emergency alerts on enabled mobile devices. 'Flash Flood Warnings were issued on the night of July 3 and in the early morning of July 4, giving preliminary lead times of more than three hours,' the statement said. The Trump administration this spring laid off NWS employees and also offered buyouts and early retirements. By early June, the weather service had lost about 600 employees. Many veteran workers left, along with employees on probation and those recently hired or promoted. Some NWS offices have experienced staffing reductions of more than 40%, and the agency has scrambled to fill critical roles at some forecasting offices. At least eight offices stopped operating 24 hours a day this spring as a result, and some have suspended weather balloon launches. In May, more than 40% of the country's weather forecasting offices had staffing vacancy rates above 20%. The cuts prompted all of the living former directors of the NWS to write a letter expressing concern over staffing levels and future budget cuts. 'Our worst nightmare is that weather forecast offices will be so understaffed that there will be needless loss of life. We know that's a nightmare shared by those on the forecasting front lines—and by the people who depend on their efforts,' they wrote. Compared with many forecasting offices across the country, the Texas offices remain relatively well-staffed. Fahy said the San Antonio/Austin weather forecasting office is operating with 11 staff meteorologists and is down six employees from its typical full staffing level of 26. He also said the nearby San Angelo office, which issued warnings for parts of central Texas, is short four staff members from its usual staffing level of 23. The meteorologist-in-charge position — the office's top leadership position — is not permanently filled. The office is also without a senior hydrologist. 'In San Angelo, there is no hydrologist, and that's a problem,' Fahy said. Hydrologists analyze stream flow and play a key role in flood response. Kerrville City Manager Dalton Rice said the city will look at whether its own emergency notifications were robust enough to warn residents. 'We know questions are being asked about the emergency notification, and while it is not the time to speculate, local and regional partners are committed to a full review of the events and systems in place,' Rice said at a news conference Sunday. 'At the appropriate time, we will take clear steps to strengthen our future preparedness. We owe that commitment to the families who are suffering and every member of our community.' Prominent independent meteorologists who have been critical of NWS staffing and budget cuts in the past have said federal meteorologists on the ground issued timely warnings. Alan Gerard, the former director of the analysis and understanding branch at the National Severe Storms Laboratory of the National Oceanic and Atmospheric Administration, wrote in a blog post that the Austin/San Antonio forecasting office did a good job communicating the risks as quickly as possible, despite the unfilled leadership positions. 'Obviously, having both of these positions vacant for a prolonged time is not optimal, and certainly could have had negative impacts at some level,' Gerard wrote. 'However, just looking at the actual warning services that NWS provided during the event, they were solid and provided the level of warning and alerts that the public should expect to receive for an event such as this.' Matt Lanza, a Houston-based meteorologist, said there were no initial indications that staffing levels or budget cuts played a role in the tragedy. Vagasky, the Wisconsin meteorologist, said predicting flash flooding and extreme rain is notoriously difficult. 'Quantitative precipitation forecasting, called QPF, is one of the hardest things meteorologists have to do. You have to get the right location, the right amount, the right timing,' he said. 'They were aware this was a significant event, and they were messaging that.' Vagasky said the remnants of Tropical Storm Barry moved into Texas and fed tropical moisture to severe thunderstorms, which stalled out over central Texas and pummeled the region with extreme precipitation. He added that the cadence by which forecasters indicated increasing concern fit with what weather models were showing and what he would expect. The Texas Hill Country is often called 'flash flood alley' because its topography can funnel and quickly swell rivers. Knowing precisely where the rain will fall is key for hydrologic models to understand where flood impacts would be worse. 'The forecasts this week were for 4 to 7, 5 to 9 inches of rain, somewhere in there. And some models were showing higher amounts on top of that. Knowing is that higher amount going to fall 3 miles this way or 3 miles that way has a big impact on what the ultimate results are,' Vagasky said. 'Unfortunately, the science just isn't at that point where you can say, 'OK, I know at this specific latitude and longitude, we're going to get this much rain.'' The overnight timing of the heaviest rain and the floodwaters' beginning to rise is a nightmare scenario for forecasters, Vagasky said. 'Severe weather response in the middle of the night is one of the biggest challenges. That's when we see the most tornado fatalities and the most flooding fatalities. People are asleep. They can't see the tornado or the water rising,' he said. 'Did people have their emergency alerts turned on on their phones?' Vagasky, who has criticized staffing reductions and cuts to weather balloon releases at the NWS, said he did not think better staffing would have prevented the tragedy. 'Those are important positions that do need to be filled,' he said, but he added that it 'probably wasn't a significant contributor to what happened.' Vagasky said there is plenty of room to improve quantitative precipitation forecasting that could help forecasters identify threats earlier. Such research is at risk if the administration cuts NOAA's funding as it has outlined, he said. 'The big concern is the latest budget request. If it goes through Congress the way the administration wants, it shuts down all the NOAA research labs, which are the labs doing the work to improve that forecasting.' This article was originally published on
