St. Paul: At Highland Bridge, Weidner Homes, Ryan Cos. win concessions
The amendments — the sixth to the former Ford Motor Co. site's $275 million tax increment financing district since 2016 — do not alter the total spending planned within the TIF district, but they do alter payment schedules. A new 'minimum assessments agreement' shifts some TIF payments from interest to principal and saves the master developer, the Ryan Cos., some costs upfront as the taxable value of particular land parcels are lowered.
'This does not impact the city budget or the general fund,' said Council Member Saura Jost, addressing the city council on Wednesday. 'This reduces the holding cost to the developer, enabling it to move forward as foreseen in the master plan. … We're not changing the public investment at the site.'
Getting county assessors to agree to drop land values took a joint effort from both the city and the Ryan Cos.
At Highland Bridge, Weidner Apartment Homes now plan construction of two market-rate apartment buildings spanning 350 housing units in the near future. Nearby, the Ryan Cos. had once planned to have started work on a series of commercial or mixed-use buildings on the parcel known as 'Block 2' back in 2021.
Neither project has moved forward in recent years, with both developers blaming the city's rent control policies for adding to an already-complicated financing landscape weighed down by high interest rates, rising construction costs and other barriers.
The Ryan Cos. have since redrawn their plans for four one-story commercial buildings, as well as a four-story, mixed-use residential building consisting of 97 market-rate rental units attached to ground-floor commercial space, a rooftop deck, streetscape improvements and a public promenade. Also planned is a 190-stall structured parking facility.
'You would see immediate development at this site,' said Maureen Michalski, a regional senior vice president of development with the Ryan Cos., referring to the TIF agreement.
So far, the developer has secured a letter of intent for a daycare to operate in one of the stand-alone commercial buildings.
Both Council Members HwaJeong Kim and Nelsie Yang voted against the new TIF arrangement and the related agreements.
While 20% of Highland Bridge is set up for affordable housing through a master plan, Yang expressed concern Wednesday that there was little clarity about the specific rents planned in the new residential buildings. The overall number of residential units planned for Highland Bridge has been redrawn at 3,100 units, down from an initial projection of 3,800 units, according to city staff.
Rents at an existing market-rate development — The Collection at Highland Bridge — average about $2,000 per unit, according to a spokesperson for Weidner Apartment Homes, who said he expected the new construction to proceed along the same grounds.
'Is this truly the biggest win that we can get for the city of St. Paul at the negotiation table?' said Yang, noting that Ramsey County had delayed a vote this week on the new minimum assessments agreement. 'I don't know what an alternative agreement could have looked like. … Also, where is the county on this, too? This is something that is going to be impacting them.'
With Weidner refusing to move forward until the company was released from rent control obligations, the city council voted 4-3 last week to relieve all buildings citywide built after 2004 from the city's voter-approved 3% cap on annual rent increases.
Council Member Cheniqua Johnson, who chairs the city's Housing and Redevelopment Authority, said Wednesday she was excited to see new housing move forward, though she was disappointed with Weidner's lack of communication with her office, as well as with the city in general, prior to the council vote on the rent control amendment.
'I want to add you to that discussion,' said Johnson, addressing Weidner development director Nick Nowotarski, who promised better days ahead. 'That was the first time I had ever met you.'
Added Council President Rebecca Noecker, 'I have been on this council for 10 years, and I've never had any contact with Weidner. … It matters to have you show up, and it matters to have this communication.'
The Ryan Cos. now hope to build the stand-alone commercial structures and the mixed-use building on Blocks 2 using both a public business subsidy and some $24 million in additional loan principal, supported by tax increment financing through a pay-as-you-go note. 'TIF' tax incentives allow private developers to complete public-facing aspects of their developments using money that would ordinarily pay off city, county and school district tax obligations.
The city's Housing and Redevelopment Authority hired the tax firm Baker Tilly as a fiscal consultant to evaluate project costs, financing and operations and confirm the need for TIF to move the Ryan Cos.' Block 2 project forward.
A fresh agreement involves lower new tax values for the buildable land.
The original 'minimum assessments agreement … places a tax burden on the properties without an offsetting income source,' reads the city staff report. 'Both the city and the developer have incurred debt to advance the infrastructure and have carefully evaluated adjustments to the minimum values to entice the stalled development to proceed.'
'We have worked with the assessor, who is supportive of adjustments to certain lots,' the report states. 'The resulting … amendment will reduce values for the certain lots in the short term.' The lot values will exceed the original values in 2041 and continue to increase through the year 2047, the final year of the TIF district.
Separately, the Weidner agreement will require the construction of two buildings resulting in approximately 350 housing units over the next few years, as well as pre-payment to the city of all of their 'Green Infrastructure' assessments. Jost noted that form of binding development agreement was not in place previously.
The two developers have agreed not to apply for additional city or Housing and Redevelopment Authority funds on land they own for any future 'vertical development' at Highland Bridge.
'Highland Bridge is important to Ward 3,' Jost told the council Wednesday. 'It's important to the whole city. … Our city will see one of its vacant spaces replaced with something of purpose. … We're expanding the housing options available to our residents in Highland.'
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
Chicago Tribune
17-07-2025
- Chicago Tribune
Lansing considers TIF district at struggling Torrence Avenue shopping center
Lansing officials are studying whether to create a tax increment financing district at the long-struggling Landings Shopping Center on Torrence Avenue, north of 171st Street, could boost economic development there. The Village Board made way Tuesday for a feasibility study to determine the eligibility of properties within the shopping center for a TIF district. TIF money can be used to pay for public improvements as well as incentives for developers. 'We just have a lot of vacancies up there, and we haven't been able to do anything about it,' Lansing Administrator Dan Podgorski said Thursday. Podgorski said the village considered creating the Landings TIF district about five years ago but decided to wait until more of the strip mall's abandoned properties were off the tax rolls. The village owns one such property, the former Ultra Foods at 16831 Torrence Ave., which Podgorski says has sat empty for about a decade. He said establishing a TIF district could encourage another grocery store or other retailer to move into space that is now tax exempt. 'This would be a TIF that would be project driven — that we would need in order to bring those developments,' Podgorski said. 'We would need the incentive.' In a TIF district, property taxes for all government bodies are frozen at levels at the time it is created and any increase due to higher property values, the increment, is used to pay for improvements or incentives TIF districts typically expire after 23 years but can be extended to up to 35 years Other taxing bodies, such as school districts, don't see increased property tax revenue from any development until after the TIF expires, and don't have a share of any community's sales tax money redevelopment might create. The board agreed to pay adviser SB Friedman, which similarly surveyed the long-vacant Sears store at Orland Square shopping center, an estimated $64,500 to survey the Landings Shopping Center. The area the firm will study includes several vacant retailers, some of which still have their old signs. On the north side of the strip mall, adjacent former clothing stores Factory 2-U and Givona Jolie stand empty, adorned with banners indicating their availability for sale. Cars begin to crop up further south in the parking lot, as Forman Mills and Burlington continue to attract sparse traffic. The area being studied also includes breakfast restaurant Golden Bear Pancakes and Crepery Restaurant, at 16851 Torrence Ave., and Kenny's Ribs and Chicken, at 16825 Torrence Ave. Podgorski said he is excited about the future of Lansing's economy as the village focuses on ushering in businesses on other parts of Torrence Avenue, including the additions of a Starbucks, Chipotle, Taco Bell and Chick-fil-a. 'You've got a dozen or more new businesses in that corridor — we feel we're like just getting started,' Podgorski said. He said there are other properties throughout Lansing the village hopes to acquire and redevelop. 'We're building that momentum,' he said.
Chicago Tribune
07-07-2025
- Chicago Tribune
State grant to fuel improvements at 55th Street and Western Avenue in Clarendon Hills
Clarendon Hills has been approved for a $1 million legislative grant for planned intersection improvements at 55th Street and Western Avenue. The state grant was garnered with support from state Sen. Suzy Glowiak Hilton, D-24th, and state Rep. Martha Deuter, D-45th, according to Clarendon Hills Village President Eric Tech. 'Staff is working diligently with DuPage County to get the residents south of 55th Street safe access to the north side of town,' he said. Village Manager Zach Creer said there is documented desire for improving this intersection, going back to the South of 55th Subarea Plan adopted in November 2017. He said a 2022 development proposal for a Dunkin Donuts, which was voted down by the Village Board after numerous residents expressed opposition, refocused interest in the intersection. He said a tax increment financing district was established last year 'as a way to find a funding source for the intersection improvements.' 'The intersection has a lot of car crashes,' Creer said. 'It is a long distance between pedestrian crossings, and this area should be connected to the rest of the town. It's still easily within walking distance of the train station and downtown.' Creer said there have been 18 vehicle crashes at the intersection between 2019 and 2024. A major component of intersection improvements sought by the village is the addition of a traffic signal. 'The Dunkin Donuts proposal was rejected, in part, due to concerns about children trying to cross there without a signal,' Creer said. He said approval would be needed from DuPage County to add a traffic signal at the intersection. 'The warrants for a stop signal upgrade require a certain amount of traffic and a certain amount of crashes,' Creer said. 'In order to justify the warrants for a signal, additional traffic needs to be anticipated.' He said the $1 million grant from the state could take up to a few years to receive, and the village likely would use TIF funds to make up the difference between the grant money and any additional costs. The total anticipated cost of the project is design dependent, Creer said, with a basic traffic signal expected to cost upward of $1 million. 'However, adding lanes or straightening the road could be extremely expensive,' he said. 'It's somewhat development dependent. In order to justify the warrants for a signal, additional traffic needs to be anticipated from the redevelopment of the Tracy's Tavern site (at the southwest edge of the intersection). The village has continued to seek a developer for the former Tracy's Tavern site. 'The last development proposal for a daycare seems to be on pause,' Creer said. 'No new proposal has come forward. If the intersection improvement was unable to move forward, then the money could be repurposed to another village project. The grant is not dependent on any development.' A new two-townhouse development has been approved by the village for an empty lot at 5740 Concord Lane, about a mile and a half from the 55th Street/Western Avenue intersection. Community Development Director Ed Cage said the property is approximately 0.20 acres and is adjacent to a similar property developed in unincorporated DuPage County. Estimated costs for the completed townhomes will be between $300,000 and $400,000, depending on upgrades and options, he said.
Chicago Tribune
26-06-2025
- Chicago Tribune
Kaneland School District files lawsuit against Sugar Grove over Crown development's TIF district
Kaneland School District 302 is moving forward with taking legal action against the village of Sugar Grove to challenge the tax increment financing district planned for the controversial Crown Community Development project at Interstate 88 and Route 47, according to a lawsuit filed on June 13 with the 16th Judicial Circuit Court. At its May 12 meeting, Kaneland's school board voted to authorize the district to possibly take legal action over the TIF district for the development project. The lawsuit was filed on June 13 with the Kane County Circuit Court, according to case information on the county circuit clerk's website. The project, called The Grove, is a planned 760-acre mixed-use development, commonly called the Crown development in reference to its developer, Naperville-based Crown Community Development, according to previous reporting. The planned development, which the village OK'd last September, is designed to include nearly 400 acres of residential properties, a walkable town center, more than 120 acres of commercial development and about 240 acres for a business park. The lawsuit filed by Kaneland is over the TIF district for the project. A TIF district is a sort of economic development incentive, in which the value of a property is essentially frozen, and the extra or 'increment' taxes created by developing the property go into a special fund used to pay for costs related to improving the area. According to an original proposal, 10% of the TIF funds were to go to the village for any improvements it needs to make in the area, but, in August, then-Sugar Grove Village President Jennifer Konen said Crown had agreed to give another 10% of the funds to be distributed among the other taxing bodies, of which Kaneland is expected to get $26 million. The original TIF agreement also included payments from TIF district funds to offset the cost of schooling for students living in the new housing at the development. Kaneland was previously in negotiations with Sugar Grove to create an intergovernmental agreement about the TIF district, according to past reporting. But, not satisfied with those terms, the district floated the possibility of taking legal action against the village in February. A spokesperson for Kaneland said the district declined to comment on the lawsuit until the village had been served. As of Thursday morning, Sugar Grove's Village Administrator Scott Koeppel said they had not been served. In the complaint, Kaneland says that the establishment of the TIF 'will deprive the school district of incremental property taxes levied against the Redevelopment Project Area for 23 years.' The lawsuit is arguing that there is an 'actual controversy' over whether the area qualifies for tax increment financing, per the filing. The district is making this argument in a few ways. It is arguing that the project area should not be considered 'blighted,' which was part of the rationale for its qualifying as a TIF district, and that the TIF district is not contiguous. It is also alleging that the village has not provided sufficient proof that development would not have occurred in the area without the creation of the TIF district and providing financial incentives to the developer. Per the lawsuit, the school district is asking Sugar Grove to dissolve the TIF district. The Crown development has seen significant community backlash as the project has progressed, including a majority of voters supporting a non-binding referendum in April asking the village to reverse course on the development entirely. In the same election, incumbent Village President Jennifer Konen, who was in support of the project, was ousted, according to past reporting. Pat Gallagher, the primary proponent of the petition for the advisory referendum, told The Beacon-News he felt the situation with the Kaneland lawsuit was avoidable, but he's supportive of it as 'the most appropriate next step.' Sugar Grove Village President Sue Stillwell said in a statement that 'regardless of the nature of the litigation and any dispute,' she is 'committed to fostering a positive, collaborative relationship with the Kaneland School District as well as the other taxing bodies.' According to a statement from Crown Community Development on Tuesday, construction at The Grove has not yet begun, but Crown is working with the village to secure the required permits to begin development.
