All The Gaura Bais
For ten months members of an all-women household in a tribal village in MP – 80-year-old Gaura Bai, her widowed daughter-in-law and her three small grandkids – have lived under a tree, after razing their own kuccha house in village Lohari, Dhar district. They demolished their hut last Sept because, as TOI's July 7 story of the shocking incident ('House Lost, Hope Stalled') reported, their panchayat told them that to claim the amount under PMAY-Rural, she would have to demolish the structure, 'show the computer an image proving' she had no house. This was, of course, a total misreading of the scheme. Tragedy is that most of India's disadvantaged rural groups, like Dalit or tribal women, are so impoverished, they aren't equipped to spot an absurdity or a fraud – far less cross-check or factcheck a sarpanch or officials. And should they dare to question officials, consequences can be severe.
Her application was made using her MNREGA card. But a 'system glitch' stalled her allotment. Till March 2025, in MP, over 37L PMAY-Rural houses had been built. Gaura Bai can be seen as one case that fell through the cracks, unseen in all the govt and thinktank audits on PMAY-R. But that's not the point. She has paid the devastating cost of an overly tech-dependent system, which has no Plan B that can be locally addressed. Given 60% of PMAY-R allotment is meant for SCs and STs, how can govts not see the chasm between tech-enabled systems and beneficiaries of the scheme – a largely digitally unlettered population? The TOI report resulted in govt assuring Gaura Bai accommodation till her allotment is resolved. Who compensates her for the hardship of 10 months? Who is accountable for technical flaws? Gaura Bai's case came to light courtesy TOI's report. How many Gaura Bais may be out there, stranded on a technical error?
Facebook Twitter Linkedin Email
This piece appeared as an editorial opinion in the print edition of The Times of India.
Try Our AI Features
Explore what Daily8 AI can do for you:
Comments
No comments yet...
Related Articles
The Hindu
39 minutes ago
- The Hindu
Government finds MNREGA digital attendance system is riddled with holes
Nearly four years after introducing digital attendance system for MNREGA workers and three years after making it mandatory, the government has discovered a whole range of ways the National Mobile Monitoring System (NMMS) platform used for the purpose is being 'misused' and has now added four layers of analog monitoring to plug the holes. On July 8, the Union Rural Development Ministry issued a 13-page note to the State governments on the issue. As per the Ministry's note, there were at least seven ways that the NMMS is allegedly being gamed, which, the government said, was undermining the credibility of the digital attendance system and leading to 'potential misuse of public funds'. The Ministry also cautioned that 'no relaxation will be given in matters concerning the misuse or manipulation of NMMS'. Under NMMS, geo-tagged photographs of the workers are to be uploaded twice a day. First when they arrive for work and then at the end of their shift. Only exception for the second round of photographing is offered at sites with 20 or below workers. It was found that 'irrelevant or unrelated photographs' were being uploaded. In many cases, 'photo-to-photo capturing instead of live work images' was being done. There was also 'mismatch in actual vs recorded count'. A mismatch in gender composition of workers was found at several work sites. The same photo of workers in multiple muster rolls, mismatch in workers in morning and afternoon photos and non-uploading of photos in the afternoon session are the other discrepancies flagged by the Rural Development Ministry. The Ministry has directed the States to ensure that these photographs and attendance of workers is verified at gram panchayat, block, district and State level. At gram panchayat level, they want 100% verification of the present workers. The percentage of physical verification of the uploaded photographs of workers reducing at different levels. So, while at the block level, 20% of the photos at random need to be verified, at the district level, this number is down to 10%, and at State level to 5%. The other significant change is that the government now allows for editing the muster rolls before making the wage bill. So far, this could be done only at the District Collector's level, who also took action in case of complaints. Such amendments of the muster rolls were rare. Chakradhar Buddha, senior researcher, LibTech India, said that what was meant to be a technology-driven, corruption-resistant system is now entirely dependent on manual checks by frontline workers. 'This defeats the very purpose of introducing a digital attendance system,' he added. The government's directions, he said, will be difficult to comply. 'During the summer months, especially in Adivasi areas where large-scale MGNREGA work takes place, thousands of NMMS photos are generated daily. Verifying these images demands staff capacity and technical infrastructure that simply don't exist on the ground,' Mr. Buddha said.
United News of India
5 hours ago
- United News of India
A ‘Viksit Gaon' is an achievable reality: Chandrasekhar
New Delhi, July 14 (UNI) Calling for a renewed focus on grassroots development, Union Minister of State for Rural Development Dr Pemmasani Chandrasekhar has noted that a 'Viksit Gaon' where every family has a pucca house with basic amenities, every youth is employed, and every woman is economically empowered is not a distant dream — it is an achievable reality. Speaking at the first Performance Review Committee meeting of the Ministry of Rural Development here, Dr Chandrasekhar underscored the critical role of the Mahatma Gandhi National Rural Employment Guarantee Scheme (MGNREGS) in building a 'Viksit Gaon' as the foundation for a 'Viksit Bharat' by 2047, according to a statement here today. He said rural development schemes are no longer just welfare measures but essential engines driving the nation's inclusive growth story under the leadership of Prime Minister Narendra Modi and Cabinet Minister Shivraj Singh Chouhan. Among flagship initiatives, MGNREGS stood out prominently in the Minister's address. Describing it as 'the strongest weapon against rural unemployment and distress migration', Dr Chandrasekhar highlighted the scheme's continuing relevance, particularly during agricultural lean seasons. With an annual investment between Rs 90,000 and Rs 1,00,000 crore, MGNREGS has generated over 250 crore person-days of work each year. More than 36 crore job cards have been issued so far, and over 15 crore workers remain active beneficiaries, said the statement. However, the Minister stressed the need to transition beyond mere wage payments. He called for a shift towards meaningful and durable asset creation, diversified work categories to ensure productivity, greater convergence with other developmental schemes, and enhanced community participation in selecting and planning work. 'The true potential of MGNREGS lies in its ability to create productive infrastructure that sustains rural livelihoods over time,' he said. In his review, Dr. Chandrasekhar also provided updates on several other key schemes stating that under PMAY-Gramin, over 3.22 crore pucca houses have been constructed so far. An additional 2 crore houses are targeted by 2029. The Minister called for the use of eco-friendly, region-specific technologies and cost-effective housing designs, he said. Similarly, PMGSY has ensured that more than 7.56 lakh km of rural roads are built. The Minister proposed setting up state-level road maintenance funds and encouraging community-based monitoring for improved sustainability. Under the DAY-NRLM, over 10.05 crore rural women have been mobilised into 91 lakh Self Help Groups (SHGs), with cumulatively achieved bank linkages worth over Rs 11 lakh crore. Under the Lakhpati Didi initiative, 1.5 crore women now earn more than Rs 1 lakh annually — halfway to the government's 3-crore target, said the Minister even as he emphasised that future efforts must aim to scale up credit access, market connectivity, and skill advancement for SHGs and rural youth alike, the statement added. UNI AJ PRS
Time of India
5 hours ago
- Time of India
Magadh University VC presents research paper at South Korea conference
Magadh University VC S P Shahi presented a research paper at the International Political Science Association conference in Seoul, South Africa, focusing on the political empowerment of scheduled castes in Bihar. PATNA: Magadh University vice-chancellor (VC) S P Shahi presented his research paper at the 28th world conference of the International Political Science Association held at Seoul in South Korea on Monday. In his paper entitled "Political empowerment of scheduled castes in Bihar", Shahi made an attempt to showcase the empowerment of the marginalized sections of the society in Bihar by ensuring their social awakening and effective participation in democratic processes. Based on his research findings, Shahi pointed out that political transformation of scheduled caste people in Bihar has been one of the crucial but contradictory developments. Citing evidences from Gaya and West Champaran districts, he said that they have not only been mute spectators to this political change, but also played a participatory role in this change. However, this socio-political change has not been uniform everywhere in the state. The change depended on their regional history, education, landlessness, sex and political consciousness, he said. The VC underlined the birth of new hopes and aspirations among the Dalit women and youths through their ever-increasing political awakening and use of digital platforms. The study shows that scheduled castes in Bihar are getting empowered through the constitutional guarantee of social justice and equality, he added.
